I was at a bar the other night and the guy asked me what phone I was using. After I told him the iPhone5, he goes I got the Galaxy S3 and I sell them 4 to 1 over the iPhone5. Why are you Android types so married to your phone? It is creepy and I suggest therapy Mr. Torres.
Not sure that its creepy but its definitely weird that some people set so invested in a phone. I agree that some therapy could be in order. It's certainly weird that people are so attached to their iPhones to the point of denial, but then again, any product that attracts a load of people camping out in front of a store 24 hours before its launch is going to have a higher proportional of, shall we say 'fanatical' types?
Give me an iPhone and I'll happily use it. Give me an S3 and I'll happily use that as well.
But to say widgets/live tiles are not a useful function because one particular person does not use it is just denial to be point of stupidity. It's just a flawed argument. Want 50 widgets on your screen? Go for it. Want 10? Go for it. Want 1? Go for it. Want a load of pumpkin backgrounds on your screen? Knock yourself out. You have a choice. There's not a debate to be had here because they are a useful function which you can adjust, turn on/turn off to your heart's content. It's like baulking at having A/C in cars by saying that you can wind the window down instead.
Want maps that work? Get the S3 or iPhone with TomTom (at cost), because iPhone native maps don't work particularly well. It's a non-argument to say 'Well, I don't use maps'.
A replaceable battery or non-replaceable battery? It's a no brainer. It's a non-argument to say 'Well, I turn the brightness down to min, uninstall everything and limit my usage so that I never run out of battery'.
There are loads of things about the iPhone that could be much better. That is a fact!
As for the S3, the UI could be more user friendly and less geeky. Some of the app integration isn't as tight as it could be but that's the difference between a largely open development system and Apple's walled garden.
Always room for improvement and development in both camps. Just too many people in this thread getting too attached to their metal and plastic devices and going into denial.