2016 AO R4 - [1] Novak Djokovic vs. [14] Gilles Simon

Who wins?


  • Total voters
    71
  • Poll closed .

okdude1992

Hall of Fame
Glad this is over. Now I can vote. I say Nole in 5.
th
 

veroniquem

Bionic Poster
Basically. That is the danger of winning everything. You don't take it as seriously as you should. You don't wanna go that extra mile like you did before and you can get overconfident. You could totally see it today. But he pulled it out. How? I don't know.
Well I know how. He's a hell of a lot better than Simon, that's how. Simon feeds on opponents' mistakes. He should not win this way against the best, and thankfully he came up short again
 

joekapa

Legend
Simon played the match of his life. He simply played great. Probably the best tennis he can play. Nobody say's someone in the top 20 cannot beat someone in the top 5. Of course they can !!!
 

maticftw

Semi-Pro
What's with djokovic and recent 4th rounds?it's like he wants a shock to his system to prepare for the quarters(full credit to simon though,it was a battle of wills)
 

Russeljones

Talk Tennis Guru
I was a little puzzled by some of Novak's decision making, to be honest. It appeared to me, for example, that Gilles wasn't too comfortable when faced with the sliced balls coming to his backhand. These resulted, almost invariably, into shorter balls sitting up to be attacked. Novak was lulled into exactly the type of match Gilles needed to be competitive. I am sure his team will examine this and he will come out with much more aggression in his next match.
 
D

Deleted member 716271

Guest
Your boy had best be more efficient next match, otherwise things can get disturbing for him.

Yeah, consolation is 2013 vs Wawa R4 went 5 also and he went on to win tourney. Then again Wawa still looms and Simon shouldn't be giving him this much trouble.
 

veroniquem

Bionic Poster
If he hammers Nishikori I agree, but if he plays another duff match then the accumulation of fatigue heading into the semi-final could be very problematic for him. He'd have two full days off for the final I guess though - is that right? Thursday semi and Sunday final for top half.
Yeah he'll have plenty of time to recover
 
N

Navdeep Srivastava

Guest
Djokovic in current form will prevail,but today match shows that people may not rate Seppi or Simon but they can be very dangerous, people were saying this is easy draw but look good performance by halys,Seppi, with Simon looking good then dangerous Nishi and last either Berdych or Fed in semis, suddenly his draw look more tough than usual first glance.

This is what I Said before the match , lol weak draw , his draw has been quite tough, good young blood Chung, Halys, punching above the weight Seppi and Simon, in form Kei in quaters, either rampaging Berdych or Fed in Semis.
According to some tennis fan this is weak draw.
 

tennisfan2015

Hall of Fame
Everybody is laughing at the 100 UE.

However, what you miss is that even though he made 100 UE, he still pulled through and won the match. Who else could of done that ? Nobody.

Fanboys might be making fun of him, but the coaches and players back in the change rooms, are still scratching their heads.
I have collected my bounty on 100UE from the local betting syndicate. Thanks Djok.
 

NoleFam

Bionic Poster
I was a little puzzled by some of Novak's decision making, to be honest. It appeared to me, for example, that Gilles wasn't too comfortable when faced with the sliced balls coming to his backhand. These resulted, almost invariably, into shorter balls sitting up to be attacked. Novak was lulled into exactly the type of match Gilles needed to be competitive. I am sure his team will examine this and he will come out with much more aggression in his next match.

Novak played this match like he had no brain. He didn't really hit out on his shots consistently until the 5th set when he had no other choice. The drop shots on big points in the tiebreak and at the end of 4th set? :confused:....Being lured into pushfest rallies? He should have blown this guy away in 3 easy sets. He has a weak serve and just pushed every ball until the end of the match. Let's just be happy it's over.
 
Last edited:
Why not both?
Because it's always been like this; even dating all the way back to the 80s - the Borg/McEnroe/Connors/Lendl era. You always had a select few winning everything - and in amongst those select few, there was always one who dominated the rest. The tour has never been a "free-for-all", in terms of big titles, especially grand slams. So, if Federer's was a weak era (which I do not accept that it was) and Djokovic's is a weak era (which I don't accept that it is), then we have only ever had weak eras in tennis. Even look at Sampras' era, few could beat him off clay - regardless of how bad he was playing.

BTW, had Djokovic played a better player today in the way he did, say, Murray, or Federer, or Wawrinka, or Nishikori, or even that mentally solid-as-a-rock champion, Tomas Berdych, (basically, a top tenner), he would have lost.
 
Last edited:
Because it's always been like this; even all the way back to the 80s - the Borg/McEnroe/Connors/Lendl era. You always had a select few winning everything - and in amongst those select few, there was always one who dominated the rest. So, if Federer's was a weak era (which I do not accept that it was) and Djokovic's is a weak era (which I don't accept that it is), then we have only ever had weak eras in tennis. Even look at Sampras' era, few could beat him off clay.
With the current players, Federer dominated a weak era, Djokovic doninated a weak 2015 field. But 2011 was far from weak so Djokovic should get lots of credit for that.

Esentially, to me, a weak era is defined by the quality of tennis from the players. One pwrson dominating doesn't necessarily make a weak era imho.
 

The Green Mile

Bionic Poster
Simon can make you overthink things. I've heard a few players talk about this. Some of Novak's shot selection was really bad tonight. Not to mention endless grueling rallies with him can take it's toll, mentally and physically, which we saw.

And Gilles didn't play his best tennis this match WTF? I would give him a 6/10 and Novak a 5/10 for their performances today.
 
Djokovic found a way. He didn't play great but he showed why he no1 and the champion he is. Simon is never easy to play but I think this will sharpen Djoko up going forward. Hopefully he gets night session against kei and I think he will beat nishi in 4 sets.
 

tennis_pro

Bionic Poster
Djokovic found a way. He didn't play great but he showed why he no1 and the champion he is. Simon is never easy to play but I think this will sharpen Djoko up going forward. Hopefully he gets night session against kei and I think he will beat nishi in 4 sets.

Oh I'm sure a 4,5 h+ match in heat will sharpen him alright.
 
Djokovic found a way. He didn't play great but he showed why he no1 and the champion he is. Simon is never easy to play but I think this will sharpen Djoko up going forward. Hopefully he gets night session against kei and I think he will beat nishi in 4 sets.
With a screen name like "Djokovic is the best#1", should we be surprised you think this?
 

Sentinel

Bionic Poster
The only guy on tour who can probably do anything close to what Simon does is probably Devvarman. It is actually really hard to kill the pace on every incoming ball, float every ball, and hit it with very low pace. It takes incredible patience. Even Murray can't do what Simon does. Even Murray goes for pace on every few shots.

Somdev ??? Why ? Can he hang on that long ? I've only seen him once, and only because he was playing Fedr. Can't remember anything much.
 
D

Deleted member 77403

Guest
Djokovic having his traditional 5 set match at the AO. Credit to Simon there but not a good performance from Novak. He needs to pick his game up if he wants to defend the title.
 
Top