2017 - 2019 Five set classic countdown

[Deleted member 77403]

How do you all rank the following five set classics that have happened over the past three seasons

Djokovic v Istomi AO 2017
Nadal v Zverev AO 2017
Federer v Nishikori AO 2017
Nadal v Dimitrov AO 2017
Federer v Wawrinka AO 2017
Federer v Nadal AO 2017
Nadal v Muller W 2017
Murray v Wawrinka RG 2017
Del Potro v Thiem USO 2017
Federer v Cilic AO 2018
Federer v Anderson W 2018
Nadal v Del Potro W 2018
Isner v Anderson W 2018
Djokovic v Nadal W 2018
Nadal v Thiem USO 2018
Tsitsipas v Wawrinka RG 2019
Djokovic v Thiem RG 2019
Djokovic v Federer W 2019

Add any more you feel to the list.

 

[Standaa]

where are all the Kyrgios classics? I read here that him and Fedal have the most popcorn quality matches, this doesn’t add up

my top 10 ranking:

1) Federer v Nadal AO 2017
2) Djokovic v Federer W 2019
3) Djokovic v Nadal W 2018
4) Nadal v Dimitrov AO 2017
5) Nadal v Muller W 2018
6) Nadal v Del Potro W 2017
7) Federer v Nishikori AO 2017
8) Federer v Wawrinka AO 2017
9) Nadal v Thiem USO 2019
10) Federer v Cilic A0 2017

 

[Deleted member 77403]

where are all the Kyrgios classics? I read here that him and Fedal have the most popcorn quality matches, this doesn’t add up

my top 10 ranking:

1) Federer v Nadal AO 2017
2) Djokovic v Federer W 2019
3) Djokovic v Nadal W 2018
4) Nadal v Dimitrov AO 2017
5) Nadal v Muller W 2018
6) Nadal v Del Potro W 2017
7) Federer v Nishikori AO 2017
8) Federer v Wawrinka AO 2017
9) Nadal v Thiem USO 2019
10) Federer v Cilic A0 2017

Nadal's had more classics at Wimbledon and on grass than the other slams or surfaces these past few years.

 

[Djokodalerer31]

1.Djokovic x Nadal WC 2018
2.Nadal x Thiem USO 2018
3.Nadal x Dimitrov AO 2017
4.Nadal x Del Potro WC 2018
5.Djokovic x Federer WC 2019
6.Federer x Wawrinka AO 2017
7.Federer x Nishikori AO 2017
8.Nadal x Zverev AO 2017
9.Federer x Nadal AO 2017
10.Federer x Cilic AO 2018
11.Djokovic x Istomin AO 2017
12.Djokovic x Thiem RG 2019
13.Nadal x Muller WC 2017
14.Federer x Anderson WC 2018
15.Isner x Anderson WC 2018

In THAT order...Isner x Anderson was just a servefest between two serbots! LOL Nothing special!

 

[StrongRule]

Wawrinka vs Murray in RG 2017 was also a good match.

 

[Standaa]

1.Djokovic x Nadal WC 2018
2.Nadal x Thiem USO 2018
3.Nadal x Dimitrov AO 2017
4.Nadal x Del Potro WC 2018
5.Djokovic x Federer WC 2019
6.Federer x Wawrinka AO 2017
7.Federer x Nishikori AO 2017
8.Nadal x Zverev AO 2017
9.Federer x Nadal AO 2017
10.Federer x Cilic AO 2018
11.Djokovic x Istomin AO 2017
12.Djokovic x Thiem RG 2019
13.Nadal x Muller WC 2017
14.Federer x Anderson WC 2018
15.Isner x Anderson WC 2018

In THAT order...Isner x Anderson was just a servefest between two serbots! LOL Nothing special!

WC?

what is WC?

 

[Djokodalerer31]

WC?

what is WC?

Not the Wildcard Championships if THAT is what you thought!...WC stands for Wimbledon Championships!

 

[StrongRule]

Nadal's had more classics at Wimbledon and on grass than the other slams or surfaces these past few years.

In AO too. Sad that he lost all the important ones in both these slams.

 

[Deleted member 77403]

Wawrinka vs Murray in RG 2017 was also a good match.

Yes, I will add that to the list.

 

[Standaa]

Not the Wildcard Championships if THAT is what you thought!...WC stands for Wimbledon Championships!

thought it was water closet

 

[Djokodalerer31]

thought it was water closet

Oh Gawd...

 

[TripleATeam]

Tsitsipas/Wawrinka RG 2019?

 

[Standaa]

Tsitsipas/Wawrinka RG 2019?

how could I forget about that one

shame on me

 

[TheIntrovert]

Delpo Thiem US Open 2017

 

[Deleted member 77403]

Tsitsipas/Wawrinka RG 2019?

Adding it in

Delpo Thiem US Open 2017

Adding it in

 

[Doctor/Lawyer Red Devil]

Djokovic vs Nadal at Wimbledon #1 for me easily when it comes to quality shown.

 

[Atennisone]

Djokovic vs Federer WB 2019
Djokovic vs Nadal WB 2018
Nadal vs Dimitrov AO 2017
Nadal vs Thiem UO 2018
Nadal vs Del Potro WB 2018
Federer vs Nadal AO 2017
Isner vs Anderson WB 2018, sorry but that left-handed forehand tells so much.
Murray vs Wawrinka RG 2017
Nadal vs Muller, WB 2017
Djokovic vs Istomin AO 2017
Djokovic vs Thiem RG 2019
Federer vs Cilic AO 2018
Nadal vs Zverev AO 2017
Federer vs Nishkori AO 2017
Federer vs Wawrinka AO 2017

 

[TheIntrovert]

There’s so many to chose from. I’ll do top 5 because I’m lazy
Fedal AO17
Fedovic W19
Nadalovic W18
Nadal Dimitrov AO17
Nadal Delpo W17

 

[Djokodalerer31]

There’s so many to chose from. I’ll do top 5 because I’m lazy
Fedal AO17
Fedovic W19
Nadalovic W18
Nadal Dimitrov AO17
Nadal Delpo W17

Fedal AO 2017 over Djokodal WC 2018 this is just...LOL i just can't...

 

[DjokoLand]

Djokodal W18 was the best IMO. Had the quality and the drama.

 

[TheIntrovert]

Fedal AO 2017 over Djokodal WC 2018 this is just...LOL i just can't...

I value drama and entertainment higher than quality. Which is why fedovic is also higher.

 

[Djokodalerer31]

I value drama and entertainment higher than quality. Which is why fedovic is also higher.

Ugh...WC semis had like...both?! LOL And ulnike AO 2017 final, the 5th set wasn't lopsided Rafa even served for the match! Djokovic breaking back from that isn't dramatic enough for you? Alright then...

 

[TheIntrovert]

Ugh...WC semis had like...both?! LOL And ulnike AO 2017 final, the 5th set wasn't lopsided Rafa even served for the match! Djokovic breaking back from that isn't dramatic enough for you? Alright then...

And in my opinion, the two matches I ranked higher had more. It’s okay to have differing opinions.

 

[King No1e]

1. Nadal vs Djokovic W18
2. Nadal vs Thiem USO18
3. Djokovic vs Federer W19
4. Nadal vs Muller W17
5. Nadal vs Dimitrov AO17

 

[StrongRule]

Ugh...WC semis had like...both?! LOL And ulnike AO 2017 final, the 5th set wasn't lopsided Rafa even served for the match! Djokovic breaking back from that isn't dramatic enough for you? Alright then...

No, he didn't.

 

[MeatTornado]

Djokovic/Federer Wim 19 for drama

Djokovic/Nadal Wim 18 for quality

I loved all the other matches on this list, but those 2 stand above the rest. Everything else is fighting for the bronze.

 

[rUDin 21]

Top 5

1.Djo/Fed W 2019
2.Djo/Nad W 2018
3.Nad/Dim AO 2017
4.Waw/Tsi RG 2019
5.Fed/Nad AO 2017

 

[Tshooter]

2017 USO, del Possum verse Thiem.

Classic del Possum.