2024 US Open QF: [1] Jannik Sinner vs [5] Daniil Medvedev

Who will win?


  • Total voters
    102
  • Poll closed .

bw114

Rookie
For those who follow golf, Med has this Rory McIlroy like quality to him for me (even though their respective games don't share similarities). Won when they were (relatively) young; have both had so many opportunities at majors; are always in the mix late in tournaments; are both quite likeable, level-headed, intelligent guys. But something about both of them seems unable to cross the finish line, and it gets harder and harder as they age.

Obviously, for Rory it's been a decade, and for Med its been three years. But the window is smaller in tennis. I like both of them and will always root for them, but the similarity is there.
Bumping my own post here, but with every slam match Med loses, the more accurate this comparison becomes. Each one seems to get progressively harder for Med to win
 
Sinner gets it done in 4 sets.

A weird match with a scoreline of 6-2 1-6 6-1 6-4.

Jannik is into his first ever US Open SF.

Completes the set of slam SFs - beating Alcaraz to that particular stat, given Alcaraz hasn't made the SFs in Australia.

Actually, come to think of it, who was the last person prior to today to complete the set of slam semis? Surely it wasn't Berdych at AO 2014? That's been more than 10 years! But I can't think who else. Ferrer never made the SFs at Wimbledon, nor did Tsonga at the US Open, nor either Del Potro or Soderling at the Australian Open. Wawrinka also never made the Wimbledon SFs. Federer/Nadal/Djokovic/Murray all completed the set well before 2014. Nishikori, Dimitrov, and Raonic didn't complete the set. Nor Medvedev, Zverev, or Tsitsipas - at least not yet.

Ooh - just remembered that Cilic did complete the set at RG 2022! Is he the only player between Berdych and Sinner to do so?
 

nolefam_2024

Bionic Poster
Completes the set of slam SFs - beating Alcaraz to that particular stat, given Alcaraz hasn't made the SFs in Australia.

Actually, come to think of it, who was the last person prior to today to complete the set of slam semis? Surely it wasn't Berdych at AO 2014? That's been more than 10 years! But I can't think who else. Ferrer never made the SFs at Wimbledon, nor did Tsonga at the US Open, nor either Del Potro or Soderling at the Australian Open. Wawrinka also never made the Wimbledon SFs. Federer/Nadal/Djokovic/Murray all completed the set well before 2014. Nishikori, Dimitrov, and Raonic didn't complete the set. Nor Medvedev, Zverev, or Tsitsipas - at least not yet.

Ooh - just remembered that Cilic did complete the set at RG 2022! Is he the only player between Berdych and Sinner to do so?
Yes
Thiem sucked on grass you missed Thiem
 

Aussie Darcy

Bionic Poster
Completes the set of slam SFs - beating Alcaraz to that particular stat, given Alcaraz hasn't made the SFs in Australia.

Actually, come to think of it, who was the last person prior to today to complete the set of slam semis? Surely it wasn't Berdych at AO 2014? That's been more than 10 years! But I can't think who else. Ferrer never made the SFs at Wimbledon, nor did Tsonga at the US Open, nor either Del Potro or Soderling at the Australian Open. Wawrinka also never made the Wimbledon SFs. Federer/Nadal/Djokovic/Murray all completed the set well before 2014. Nishikori, Dimitrov, and Raonic didn't complete the set. Nor Medvedev, Zverev, or Tsitsipas - at least not yet.

Ooh - just remembered that Cilic did complete the set at RG 2022! Is he the only player between Berdych and Sinner to do so?
Ha I just posted this on the main thread!

I think your list is correct. Berrettini is just missing a French Open. His best result was a QF. Thiem missed Wimbledon with his best being 4R there.

I don’t think anyone else has done it since Cilic and Berdych!
 

dking68

Legend
Completes the set of slam SFs - beating Alcaraz to that particular stat, given Alcaraz hasn't made the SFs in Australia.

Actually, come to think of it, who was the last person prior to today to complete the set of slam semis? Surely it wasn't Berdych at AO 2014? That's been more than 10 years! But I can't think who else. Ferrer never made the SFs at Wimbledon, nor did Tsonga at the US Open, nor either Del Potro or Soderling at the Australian Open. Wawrinka also never made the Wimbledon SFs. Federer/Nadal/Djokovic/Murray all completed the set well before 2014. Nishikori, Dimitrov, and Raonic didn't complete the set. Nor Medvedev, Zverev, or Tsitsipas - at least not yet.

Ooh - just remembered that Cilic did complete the set at RG 2022! Is he the only player between Berdych and Sinner to do so?
If Sinner wins his first semifinal against Draper, he will be the first 2000s born player to cross 10,000 points. If it wasn’t for the ban he would’ve already crossed it.
 

dking68

Legend
Medvedev was in such a rush like he had a train to catch. Like chill sometimes and give yourself a bit of time. I get that it's how he wants to do it but god it wouldn't hurt to run down the clock a bit.
Sinner is 20 points away from 10,000. Had he not been banned he would’ve surpassed 10,000 atp points
 

Rovesciarete

Hall of Fame
Enjoyable match, dominating performance of Jannik apart that second set.

First breadstick of the season, can't remember exactly the last time - must be over a year since somebody baked something for the Nr.1.

Updated weekly(ish). Last update: 2024-08-26
Player​
2024: Baked​
6-0​
6-1​
0-6​
1-6​
Last 52: Baked​
6-0​
6-1​
0-6​
1-6​
Career: Baked​
6-0​
6-1​
0-6​
1-6​
W w/0-6​
L w/6-0​
16
5
11
0​
2
23
6
17
0​
2
494
119
375
12
43
5
5
14
3
11
0​
0​
22
5
17
0​
0​
69
11
58
7
10
3
0​
20
2
18
0​
3
21
2
19
0​
5
64
13
51
2
15
2
0​
 

placebo

Rookie
Medvedev was in such a rush like he had a train to catch. Like chill sometimes and give yourself a bit of time. I get that it's how he wants to do it but god it wouldn't hurt to run down the clock a bit.
That's his manual setting. I agree though. When he's not playing well, he does need to give himself a little more to compose himself.
 

Tennis Fan States63

Hall of Fame
Completes the set of slam SFs - beating Alcaraz to that particular stat, given Alcaraz hasn't made the SFs in Australia.

Actually, come to think of it, who was the last person prior to today to complete the set of slam semis? Surely it wasn't Berdych at AO 2014? That's been more than 10 years! But I can't think who else. Ferrer never made the SFs at Wimbledon, nor did Tsonga at the US Open, nor either Del Potro or Soderling at the Australian Open. Wawrinka also never made the Wimbledon SFs. Federer/Nadal/Djokovic/Murray all completed the set well before 2014. Nishikori, Dimitrov, and Raonic didn't complete the set. Nor Medvedev, Zverev, or Tsitsipas - at least not yet.

Ooh - just remembered that Cilic did complete the set at RG 2022! Is he the only player between Berdych and Sinner to do so?

Beat me to it.....

marin-cilic-ball-bounce.gif
 

nolefam_2024

Bionic Poster
Enjoyable match, dominating performance of Jannik apart that second set.

First breadstick of the season, can't remember exactly the last time - must be over a year since somebody baked something for the Nr.1.

Updated weekly(ish). Last update: 2024-08-26
Player​
2024: Baked​
6-0​
6-1​
0-6​
1-6​
Last 52: Baked​
6-0​
6-1​
0-6​
1-6​
Career: Baked​
6-0​
6-1​
0-6​
1-6​
W w/0-6​
L w/6-0​
16
5
11
0​
2
23
6
17
0​
2
494
119
375
12
43
5
5
14
3
11
0​
0​
22
5
17
0​
0​
69
11
58
7
10
3
0​
20
2
18
0​
3
21
2
19
0​
5
64
13
51
2
15
2
0​
Meddy played out of his mind in second and Sinner still could have made it at least 6-2.
 

nolefam_2024

Bionic Poster
He's currently sitting at about 7,400 points for this year. If he got 12,000 by the end of year, then yes, that would be incredible, but he's not on pace to do that. So saying he's much better than Medvedev based on something that could theoretically happen, but is unlikely, isn't a good way of measuring their levels. Bringing up that it hasn't been done very often in "30 years" is extremely misleading. The ATP only changed the point system to make 12,000 points possible in 2009; it was literally impossible to get 12,000 points, even with a perfect season, before then.
7800 now most likely 9000 by end of this week

He is heading towards monster end of the season as well.
 

Drighiz

Rookie
So Sinner with US open and Aussie open... and Alcarez with Wimbledon and French open.....................so Whos' the real #1 ??
Hmmm good question. It's almost as if we should devise a point system where bigger tournaments are worth more than the smaller ones, and players get more points the farther they get into each tournament.
 
Top