time_fly
Hall of Fame
I will admit that poaching is a weaker part of my game, but I don't see how I can poach when the opposing guy is hitting a waist-high ball from the middle of no-man's land. I either have to gamble and leave really early, or I won't have time to move very far. But more than that if the opposing woman is hitting a weak, short serve to me, I get offended if the other guy tries to poach. If he stays I will hit a cross-court approach shot to her almost every time, or maybe lob him. If he starts moving then I will start mixing in the hardest, flattest returns down the line (and possibly through his chest) that I can hit. In my head there's a gentleman's agreement that I won't rip it down the line on a short, high serve if he doesn't try to pick off my "safe" returns. Players that poach on weak serves in general annoy me and help me focus on my returns by giving me a target. My ground strokes are much better than my poaches.
I mentioned this to a teammate and he thought I was crazy. He said, "How can she possibly hold her serve if you aren't poaching like crazy on both sides and trying to disrupt their returns?"
So what do you think: should guys poach on weak, short serves to try to pressure their opponents into mistakes? Do you feel it's poor form to target the opposing guy at point-blank range if his partner's serve is really weak and short, unless he "earns it" by moving during your return?
I mentioned this to a teammate and he thought I was crazy. He said, "How can she possibly hold her serve if you aren't poaching like crazy on both sides and trying to disrupt their returns?"
So what do you think: should guys poach on weak, short serves to try to pressure their opponents into mistakes? Do you feel it's poor form to target the opposing guy at point-blank range if his partner's serve is really weak and short, unless he "earns it" by moving during your return?