Andy Roddick - Does he get the credit he deserves?

A common mistake on this board is to evaluate the level of play of a player in a final by evaluating his career achievement. That's often because we didn't witnessed these matches live and it is sometimes difficult to look at bad quality videos now that we are accustomed to HD. But it's completely wrong. Cilic level at the USO, Del Potro's, Wawrinka, Nishikori's, etc. There is little link between the level they showed during specific tournaments and their whole (rather poor) careers. Yet in 3-5 years many fans of the then world N°1 will laugh at Djokovic for losing a SF to Nishikori who then lost to Cilic, two players who achieved little and therefor HAVE to been bad during the USO 2014. It's wrong reasoning. Us who saw Nishikori play against Wawrinka and Djokovic we know he was playing very well, higher that what his achievement suggest, and it's even truer for Cilic (hence the winner).
 
A common mistake on this board is to evaluate the level of play of a player in a final by evaluating his career achievement. That's often because we didn't witnessed these matches live and it is sometimes difficult to look at bad quality videos now that we are accustomed to HD. But it's completely wrong. Cilic level at the USO, Del Potro's, Wawrinka, Nishikori's, etc. There is little link between the level they showed during specific tournaments and their whole (rather poor) careers. Yet in 3-5 years many fans of the then world N°1 will laugh at Djokovic for losing a SF to Nishikori who then lost to Cilic, two players who achieved little and therefor HAVE to been bad during the USO 2014. It's wrong reasoning. Us who saw Nishikori play against Wawrinka and Djokovic we know he was playing very well, higher that what his achievement suggest, and it's even truer for Cilic (hence the winner).
Or Gonzalez at AO. Even Baghdatis at AO.
 
Or Gonzalez at AO. Even Baghdatis at AO.

Baghdatis was physically done and couldn't last for a 3 sets matches but he came out blazing, yes. My comment is true for many matches, and only those who saw these matches when they were played (and those who are honest and don't try to belittle a rival's competition) can assess who played how well.
 
Being top 10 for nearly a decade means you are consistent. Sampras in 2001 was playing awful. Please don't reply to this. You clearly don't have a handle on consistency.
Sampras was very poor in 2001 , but in us open he was very much in form like 2002 us open, his match vs Agassi was stuff of legends and my favourite match of us open till date. He defeated Rafter, Safin and Agassi back to back, so don't tell me that he was out of form in us open, whole year yes but us open no.
Ferrer also finished 7 years as top ten , I guess you also consider him as great consistent player.
 
Disagree. USO 2007, YEC 2006 RR, Wimb 2009, Miami 2010. He had his moments of playing agressively, but he just did not maintain the consistency.

Saying that he was never the same again is an overreaction.
I know friend but I said that he was not consistent and other poster said to me that he was top ten for decade, this reply was for him. I still consider his Wimbledon 09 loss as one of the greatest sad moment in tennis history.
 
For his height - that's pretty much as well as you can possibly serve. Great forehand but lost it after 2004. Improved solid backhand in 2009 with Stefanki.

If all 3 things clicked at the same time - Roddick could've been great. Instead, he was just good / very good at times.
 
Being top 10 for nearly a decade means you are consistent. Sampras in 2001 was playing awful. Please don't reply to this. You clearly don't have a handle on consistency.
Safin never did anything remotely like being top ten for a decade. The closest you can say is that he had a peak run where he was either in or near the top ten for about three years, but he saw frequent plunges out of the top ten, twenty, fifty, even 100, between brilliant runs.

He was maddeningly inconsistent and unfocused, especially for a guy with his absurd level of talent.

http://www.atpworldtour.com/en/players/marat-safin/s741/rankings-history
 
Last edited:
Safin never did anything remotely like being top ten for a decade. The closest you can say is that he had a peak run where he was either in or near the top ten for about three years, but he saw frequent plunges out of the top ten, twenty, fifty, even 100, between brilliant runs.

He was maddeningly inconsistent and unfocused, especially for a guy with his absurd level of talent.

http://www.atpworldtour.com/en/players/marat-safin/s741/rankings-history

I never said Safin was in the first place. I said Roddick was a consistent figure in tennis. I do seriously wonder if people actually read the posts being submitted in this place.


Sampras was very poor in 2001 , but in us open he was very much in form like 2002 us open, his match vs Agassi was stuff of legends and my favourite match of us open till date. He defeated Rafter, Safin and Agassi back to back, so don't tell me that he was out of form in us open, whole year yes but us open no.
Ferrer also finished 7 years as top ten , I guess you also consider him as great consistent player.

Yeah, because Ferrer has won a slam, 5 MS titles and has made 4 other grand slam finals. :rolleyes:
 
I never said Safin was in the first place. I said Roddick was a consistent figure in tennis. I do seriously wonder if people actually read the posts being submitted in this place.




Yeah, because Ferrer has won a slam, 5 MS titles and has made 4 other grand slam finals. :rolleyes:
ok how much you want to rate Roddick ? I rate him as a great talent who achieved less.
 
I never said Safin was in the first place. I said Roddick was a consistent figure in tennis. I do seriously wonder if people actually read the posts being submitted in this place.




Yeah, because Ferrer has won a slam, 5 MS titles and has made 4 other grand slam finals. :rolleyes:
what I meant was that being top ten doesn't mean you are great consistently.
 
For his height - that's pretty much as well as you can possibly serve. Great forehand but lost it after 2004. Improved solid backhand in 2009 with Stefanki.

If all 3 things clicked at the same time - Roddick could've been great. Instead, he was just good / very good at times.


I might actually create a twitter account to ask him if he regrets changing his forehand. Surely Dubai 08 and Miami 2010 was telling that he could beat the best if he played the game that brought him a lot of success. Dumb move, and instead, one of the most scary players became the most passive player ever. Roddick from 05+ even made Murray look like an aggressive player.
 
Hewitt is underrated though @NatF

I was thinking about it today. I would put him at 3rd or 4th in the world if he was playing right now

I would say Hewitt is simultaneously underrated and overrated. Many people underrate how good he was at Wimbledon and the U.S. Open, but many people don't realize just how poor he was at the Australian and French Opens. He was a mere 32-20 at his home Slam, and only 26-19 -- with no QF appearances -- outside his run to the final in 2005. Meanwhile, at the French, he was a mere 28-14, with only 2 QF appearances that both ended with straight set losses in which Lleyton only won 7 games (Ferrero in 2001; Gaudio in 2004).
 
Hewitt is underrated though @NatF

I was thinking about it today. I would put him at 3rd or 4th in the world if he was playing right now
So you say Hewitt is underrated and then you underrate Hewitt...beautiful stuff.

Hewitt at his peak form right now would be neck and neck with Murray and would probably give Djokovic (and Federer) a tougher challenge. Hewitt at his peak didn't really prioritize masters and the field was much deeper leading to a higher chance of early round upsets. However, Murray has been more consistent at the slow court slams so I would give him a edge in the rankings but Hewitt would be tougher opposition for the top guys. There is no question he would be above Federer at the moment...4 is out of the question.
 
So you say Hewitt is underrated and then you underrate Hewitt...beautiful stuff.

Hewitt at his peak would be neck and neck, and maybe above Murray as Murray isn't at his peak. There is no question he would be above Federer at the moment
I say Murray is better than Hewitt.

Thats underrating Hewitt is it. Anyway. Yeah he would most likely be ahead of Federer no doubt. But would still slightly put him behind Murray as year end number 2..
 
I would say Hewitt is simultaneously underrated and overrated. Many people underrate how good he was at Wimbledon and the U.S. Open, but many people don't realize just how poor he was at the Australian and French Opens. He was a mere 32-20 at his home Slam, and only 26-19 -- with no QF appearances -- outside his run to the final in 2005. Meanwhile, at the French, he was a mere 28-14, with only 2 QF appearances that both ended with straight set losses in which Lleyton only won 7 games (Ferrero in 2001; Gaudio in 2004).
yeah he didn't like the slow courts but it was odd how he didn't really care about the AO until 04. Although part of that is that he added more punch to game in 05 which made him more able to hit through opponents on slow hard.

That being said he ran into Federer in a 4R at the 04 AO where he was in good form himself and he also lost in the 4R of the French in 06 and 07 to Nadal and still he took a set in 06. That's just luck of the draw...if he is in another section he coulda possibly made it to the finals of the 04 AO and the QF/SF of those FO.
 
I say Murray is better than Hewitt.

Thats underrating Hewitt is it. Anyway. Yeah he would most likely be ahead of Federer no doubt. But would still slightly put him behind Murray as year end number 2..
you said 3 or 4 and while Murray will compile better results Hewitt like I said would assuredly be a bigger threat to Djokovic than this version of Murray would. Murray is definitely not a better player right now than 04-05 Hewitt at the slams.
 
yeah he didn't like the slow courts but it was odd how he didn't really care about the AO until 04. Although part of that is that he added more punch to game in 05 which made him more able to hit through opponents on slow hard.

That being said he ran into Federer in a 4R at the 04 AO where he was in good form himself and he also lost in the 4R of the French in 06 and 07 to Nadal and still he took a set in 06. That's just luck of the draw...if he is in another section he coulda possibly made it to the finals of the 04 AO and the QF/SF of those FO.


Not beating Safin at AO 04.
 
Many fans, especially on this forum, tend to talk about Andy Roddick like he was a poor player. He is also considered a reason why many refer to Federer's era as weak, because Federer happened to beat him in several Grand Slams. But, if we think objectively about Roddick for a change, how good was he? I remember the Wimbledon final in 2004 where Roddick played fantastic against a prime Federer but still lost. And of course the final five years later when he deserved to win the title.

To share a light on his legacy I decided to create a video of his most memorable moments:


What's your fondest memory of Andy Roddick?
look Andy you've gotten a lot of love around here. and here you are trying to drum up even more. sheesh.
 
you said 3 or 4 and while Murray will compile better results Hewitt like I said would assuredly be a bigger threat to Djokovic than this version of Murray would. Murray is definitely not a better player right now than 04-05 Hewitt at the slams.
If 2015-2016 is equivalent to 2004-2005. Murray has had better results and 2016 isnt over yet. In what slam could have Hewitt beaten Djokovic in the last 2 years 15-16??
 
If 2015-2016 is equivalent to 2004-2005. Murray has had better results and 2016 isnt over yet. In what slam could have Hewitt beaten Djokovic in the last 2 years 15-16??
If he got him early at Wimbledon(in 04 he almost took Federer 5 and he was playing quite well in 05 Fed was just in god mode) or at the USO(where in 05 he gave peak Federer a very tough match while DJokovic was losing sets to Agut and Lopez neither of whom played particularly well) it would be possible. I wouldn't put my money on it but he would almost assuredly do better than Murray did considering he did better against peak Fed at slams than Murray did against late and post prime Fed.
 
If he got him early at Wimbledon(in 04 he almost took Federer 5 and he was playing quite well in 05 Fed was just in god mode) or at the USO(where in 05 he gave peak Federer a very tough match while DJokovic was losing sets to Agut and Lopez neither of whom played particularly well) it would be possible. I wouldn't put my money on it but he would almost assuredly do better than Murray did considering he did better against peak Fed at slams than Murray did against late and post prime Fed.
I Dont like comparing Murray to Hewitt by comparing how they played against Fed. Completely different match up
 
We get it; Hewitt is a 15 slam champion in this era!!!

I've never said he was anything of the sort. You've obviously got a bone to pick with the Federer fanbase and good luck with that - but don't bother replying to me if you've got nothing to offer but sarcasm.

At best I think he's a 3-4 calibre champion - at best.
 
He was easily a 3-4 slam player but his inconsistency and Fed stopped him, but he get overrated on this forum.
If anything Hewitt and Safin are underrated.

Not true. both of them are used as weak era evidence ALL the time. Despite both being number 1, both winning multiple majors, hewitt being one of the youngest (if not youngest?) number ones ever.. but they're considered whipping boys and not given the credit they deserve.
 
Not true. both of them are used as weak era evidence ALL the time. Despite both being number 1, both winning multiple majors, hewitt being one of the youngest (if not youngest?) number ones ever.. but they're considered whipping boys and not given the credit they deserve.
who both safin and Hewitt or Roddick and Hewitt?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
My hero from the day I started watching tennis. Federer didn't only break the Roddick serve. He broke much of the fire Roddick had. Awesome on court presence, awesome off court presence, GOAT press conferences. I will always be sad when I look back at Wimbly 2009.
 
For example in 2008 Murray and Federer met 4 times, all on HC, Murray won 3 times, yet lost the USO final 6-2 7-6 6-2. Losing his first slam finals against Federer at the USO is fine, but to 6-2 sets show that he was well below his best level. In 2010 Murray and Federer met 4 times again and shared the wins (2-2) but in their slam finals at the AO he was straight setter again. Federer was in good form and losing to him is no shame, but once again he couldn't bring his best level at the most important match.

Murray recieves no flak for his Wimbledon 2012 loss because everyone consider that he played well and was unlucky to meet a revived Fed.

I would safely put Wimbledon 2012 as one of Federer's best ever performances, and Murray was up for that one. Other than that yes, Murray could have played better in the AO and USO encounters.
 
Murray is spoken of as an ATG in the wrong era. He gets tons of credit - he has plenty of detractors too but so does every player.

Trust me, I would haven't had to spend a quarter of my time on these boards if he had consistently been given the credit he deserves. In fact I go so far as to flatter myself that the situation would still have been dire if I hadn't had to spend so much time on these boards correcting fallacies and inaccuracies and challenging the persistent ignorance of his career that has been so much a feature of his various detractors on here. :cool:
 
Ranking him #4, bit of an underrating. I think adjusted for today's era he'd be fighting for #2



He has plenty of detractors :D 90's Clay for example.
I have no problems with him being number 2. But I would put my money on Murray. He would have better results.
 
Also, I'd say Roddick was very, very talented, but he ended up playing a game he wasn't very talented at.

Dubai 2008 was an amazing run and looking at that, I could never get why he stopped playing like that.
 
Back
Top