Another Multiple Major Winner Added To The “Weak” Era.

chimpish

Hall of Fame
After tonight’s result, we now have 8 multiple major winners who were playing in the 2018-2023 weak era.

Federer
Nadal
Djokovic
Murray
Wawrinka
Alcaraz
Sinner
Zverev

But the era was just clearly too strong for the likes of Murray, Wawrinka, Sinner and Zverev to win a major in this period! :)
 
After tonight’s result, we now have 8 multiple major winners who were playing in the 2018-2023 weak era.

Federer
Nadal
Djokovic
Murray
Wawrinka
Alcaraz
Sinner
Zverev

But the era was just clearly too strong for the likes of Murray, Wawrinka, Sinner and Zverev to win a major in this period! :)
Why the weak era was '18-23? Why wasn't '17 included?

When Djokovic's elbow was healed, he went on to win 5 of 7 slams! '17 didn't include the best player of the decade!
 
Why the weak era was '18-23? Why wasn't '17 included?

When Djokovic's elbow was healed, he went on to win 5 of 7 slams! '17 didn't include the best player of the decade!
But please don’t use the injury excuse, that is the lifeblood of a Rafa fanboy/girl.
 
I was just quoting what the vulture brigade quote.

I find it embarrassing when other Fed fans do this tbh.
Rafa and Nole's age difference is less than 1 year. How many times did Rafa dare to show up and challenge the king on HC and grass during the whole "weak era"?

When did Sinner enter the top 5 in the "weak era"? Quite a bit older than Murray did in the "strong era"?

You know, quite a few Rafans and Sinnerfans do that too.
 
Rafa and Nole's age difference is less than 1 year. How many times did Rafa dare to show up and challenge the king on HC and grass during the whole "weak era"?

When did Sinner enter the top 5 in the "weak era"? Quite a bit older than Murray did in the "strong era"?

You know, quite a few Rafans and Sinnerfans do that too.

Rafa was very careful when he played off of clay, he tried to choose only when things were most in his favor
 
After tonight’s result, we now have 8 multiple major winners who were playing in the 2018-2023 weak era.

Federer
Nadal
Djokovic
Murray
Wawrinka
Alcaraz
Sinner
Zverev

But the era was just clearly too strong for the likes of Murray, Wawrinka, Sinner and Zverev to win a major in this period! :)

Its the ultra hyper career inflation era.
 
Why the weak era was '18-23? Why wasn't '17 included?

When Djokovic's elbow was healed, he went on to win 5 of 7 slams! '17 didn't include the best player of the decade!
Because that's where one single player vultured half of his career Slams despite being 31-36 in one extended span?

2017 wasn't strong. Neither were 2015-2016. 2018-2023 is one long string when one past his prime player won a gazillion Slams against the Berrettinis of the world.
 
After tonight’s result, we now have 8 multiple major winners who were playing in the 2018-2023 weak era.

Federer
Nadal
Djokovic
Murray
Wawrinka
Alcaraz
Sinner
Zverev
It seems that a multiple Slam champion simply playing in a particular period or season is enough to qualify him as strong competition.

I mean LOL at everyone in that period bar Nadal, but Murray - damn what a player he was in 2018-2023.
 
It seems that a multiple Slam champion simply playing in a particular period or season is enough to qualify him as strong competition.

I mean LOL at everyone in that period bar Nadal, but Murray - damn what a player he was in 2018-2023.
You do realise this thread was in jest don’t you?
 
Because that's where one single player vultured half of his career Slams despite being 31-36 in one extended span?

2017 wasn't strong. Neither were 2015-2016. 2018-2023 is one long string when one past his prime player won a gazillion Slams against the Berrettinis of the world.
Man, the period when big 3 were all strong was insanely tough. Stop acting like that is a standard and anything below is to be despised. Also, Novak won in a weaker era at an age almost everyone else is using as an excuse. Much better than Federer winning more than half of his slams in his absolute prime in a weaker era
 
Man, the period when big 3 were all strong was insanely tough. Stop acting like that is a standard and anything below is to be despised. Also, Novak won in a weaker era at an age almost everyone else is using as an excuse. Much better than Federer winning more than half of his slams in his absolute prime in a weaker era
The genuinely strong period is 2007-2014 where you had all of the big 3 in or close to their primes at the same time. It started when Djokovic joined Fedal and started pushing them in the Slams, winning Masters, scoring wins and it ended with Nadal ending his prime at the 2014 FO when Fed was already getting to old to go toe to toe with him and Djokovic on a regular basis. If you look how many Slams each of the big 3 won in that time you have Fed at 8, Nadal at 12 (but inflated with a lot of FO's obviously) and Djokovic at 7, it's very close to each other adjusting Nadal's FO runs.

I never denied Fed had some weak years too, the only issue is the length of the period. That's the same reason I don't care that much that Zverev finally bagged 2 Slams this year, but imagine him doing this for the next 4-5 years where the younger players are just not good enough and both Alcaraz/Sinner struggle with injuries. There's only so much vulturing someone can handle. If Zverev had 3 more years like this there would be people puttig him in the same category as Lendl, Connors, Mac or Agassi and that's just beyond ludicrous.
 
Zverev is obviously below big 3 and sinneraz but if he manages to win more slams post 30, credit where credit is due. I respect Wilander for his slams and would respect Zverev as well. It would mean he is capable of a very high level, surpassed only by a handful of players and that he was able to keep that level throughout the years. Similarly, I'm commending Fed for winning 2 slams in 2017 when Novak was out of the picture. Big 3 are not standard for atg, they are uncomparable legends.
 
The genuinely strong period is 2007-2014 where you had all of the big 3 in or close to their primes at the same time. It started when Djokovic joined Fedal and started pushing them in the Slams, winning Masters, scoring wins and it ended with Nadal ending his prime at the 2014 FO when Fed was already getting to old to go toe to toe with him and Djokovic on a regular basis. If you look how many Slams each of the big 3 won in that time you have Fed at 8, Nadal at 12 (but inflated with a lot of FO's obviously) and Djokovic at 7, it's very close to each other adjusting Nadal's FO runs.

I never denied Fed had some weak years too, the only issue is the length of the period. That's the same reason I don't care that much that Zverev finally bagged 2 Slams this year, but imagine him doing this for the next 4-5 years where the younger players are just not good enough and both Alcaraz/Sinner struggle with injuries. There's only so much vulturing someone can handle. If Zverev had 3 more years like this there would be people puttig him in the same category as Lendl, Connors, Mac or Agassi and that's just beyond ludicrous.
The main part that I believe is inconsistent is your appraisals of Nadal and Djokovic. You’re tying to claim Djokovic was strong from 2007-2010 but Nadal was significantly weaker from 2017-2022.

However it’s a statistical fact on all result based metrics that the opposite is closer to being true, Djokovic increased much more in strength from 2007-2010 to 2011-2016 than Nadal reduced in strength from 2005-2014 to 2017-2022.
 
The main part that I believe is inconsistent is your appraisals of Nadal and Djokovic. You’re tying to claim Djokovic was strong from 2007-2010 but Nadal was significantly weaker from 2017-2022.

However it’s a statistical fact on all result based metrics that the opposite is closer to being true, Djokovic increased much more in strength from 2007-2010 to 2011-2016 than Nadal reduced in strength from 2005-2014 to 2017-2022.
Where was Federer in 2020-2022 again? And it's not like Djokovic and Nadal were in their primes in 2018-2023 too. Don't get me started on the strength of the field btw, because comparing 2022 to 2009 or 2012 f.e. is hilarious.

2007-2014 where as an average we had all of the big 3 in or close to their primes (obviously it never happened at the same time and all 3 had periods where they underperformed) and the strength of the field was high. It started to fall apart after Nadal fell off a cliff in 2015 and Federer was close to his mid 30s.

So I don't know what you're trying to do here. I never said Djokovic in 2007-2010 was better than Nadal in 2017-2020 f.e. But everything put together - the strength of the big 3 and the field combined 2007-2010 is miles stronger than 2017-2020, you're just focusing on 1 parameter out of 4 and ignoring the other 3.

This is like you saying 2018-2023 was tougher than 2024-2026, because the field was tougher back then. Yeah dude let's ignore the fact that in 2018-2023 you had a mid 30s Djokovic dominating a bunch of tier 2 players while today you have 2 ATGs in their primes (if not peaks) and just the presence of Alcaraz and Sinner catapults the strength of this era as a whole to a higher high than a couple of years ago.
 
Last edited:
Where was Federer in 2020-2022 again? And it's not like Djokovic and Nadal were in their primes in 2018-2023 too.

Don't get me started on the strength of the field btw, because comparing 2022 to 2009 or 2012 f.e. is hilarious.
You didn’t answer my points specific to your appraisals of Djokovic and Nadal. You are prepared to criticise Djokovic in one way but not apply the same logic to Nadal.

Nadal most certainly didn’t have a peak Federer or Djokovic to cope with after Australia 10. Lung infection for Fed and Djokovic was worse in 2010 than he was in 2007. Federer was at his worst in 2013 when Nadal had one of his better seasons. So that’s 2008, 2010, 2013, Nadal’s best 3 seasons off Clay from 07-14 where either Fed, or Novak or both were significantly below their best level.
 
Last edited:
You didn’t answer my points specific to your appraisals of Djokovic and Nadal. You are prepared to criticise Djokovic in one way but not apply the same logic to Nadal.

Nadal most certainly didn’t have a peak Federer or Djokovic to cope with after Australia 10. Lung infection for Fed and Djokovic was worse in 2010 than he was in 2007. Federer was at his worst in 2013 when Nadal had one of his better seasons. So that’s 2008, 2010, 2013, Nadal’s best 3 seasons off Clay where either Fed, or Novak or both were significantly below their best level.
Dude you can count all the little beans or you want - Nadal had an easier tournament here, Fed had an easier tournament there. You cat like Djokovic didn't pre 2018. Fed was injured here, Nadal was injured there, Djokovic played worse in 2009-2010 too. It's bean counting.

Nobody even comes close to 2018-2023, a a continuous six-year period where you had 0 ATGs in their primes, Federer was a fossil, Nadal got back to being a clay courter with some spurts of form on HC (and he had to avoid Djokovic to win too) and Djokovic dominated a bunch of tier 2 players to win TWELVE SLAMS (50% of his career total) at the age of 31-36. He had it way too easy for way too long and the fact that he instantly stopped winning Slams the moment he had to compete with 2 prime ATGs proves this.

Is this clear now? Or you wanna cite another tournament from 2010 or 2013 as proof that Fed or Nadal had it easy that one time and that somehow evens out 6 years of Djokovic beating nobodies for 12 Slams? And it would've been another 2-3 years if not for Alcaraz and Sinner. What a joke.
 
Dude you can count all the little beans or you want - Nadal had an easier tournament here, Fed had an easier tournament there. You cat like Djokovic didn't pre 2018. Fed was injured here, Nadal was injured there, Djokovic played worse in 2009-2010 too. It's bean counting.

Nobody even comes close to 2018-2023, a a continuous six-year period where you had 0 ATGs in their primes, Federer was a fossil, Nadal got back to being a clay courter with some spurts of form on HC (and he had to avoid Djokovic to win too) and Djokovic dominated a bunch of tier 2 players to win TWELVE SLAMS (50% of his career total) at the age of 31-36. He had it way too easy for way too long and the fact that he instantly stopped winning Slams the moment he had to compete with 2 prime ATGs proves this.
It’s not bean counting, it’s called treating players fairly and with consistency. The Federer of the second half of 14 and 15 was MUCH BETTER than the Federer of 2013 and still better than Federer 10 until he recovered from the lung infection.

I hear you say 12 slams all the time regarding Novak. But I never see you write Nadal winning 36% of all his majors and 50% of all his hardcourt majors in the same period. Why is this? And not only that, Nadal didn’t even have Djokovic eligible for 2 of those majors held between 17-22.

So this is my issue with your commentary. It’s fine you think 17-23 was all just very weak, I don’t agree with you, I think it’s much more nuanced than that, but I accept that’s your view, but your application of your view in relation to Djokovic and Nadal is very inconsistent. Apply it to both rather than one or it just comes off very biased against Djokovic.
 
Dude you can count all the little beans or you want - Nadal had an easier tournament here, Fed had an easier tournament there. You cat like Djokovic didn't pre 2018. Fed was injured here, Nadal was injured there, Djokovic played worse in 2009-2010 too. It's bean counting.

Nobody even comes close to 2018-2023, a a continuous six-year period where you had 0 ATGs in their primes, Federer was a fossil, Nadal got back to being a clay courter with some spurts of form on HC (and he had to avoid Djokovic to win too) and Djokovic dominated a bunch of tier 2 players to win TWELVE SLAMS (50% of his career total) at the age of 31-36. He had it way too easy for way too long and the fact that he instantly stopped winning Slams the moment he had to compete with 2 prime ATGs proves this.

Is this clear now? Or you wanna cite another tournament from 2010 or 2013 as proof that Fed or Nadal had it easy that one time and that somehow evens out 6 years of Djokovic beating nobodies for 12 Slams? And it would've been another 2-3 years if not for Alcaraz and Sinner. What a joke.

Am I correct in thinking you feel Djokovic should be no more than a three time slam champion? Maybe two slams?
 
The genuinely strong period is 2007-2014 where you had all of the big 3 in or close to their primes at the same time. It started when Djokovic joined Fedal and started pushing them in the Slams, winning Masters, scoring wins and it ended with Nadal ending his prime at the 2014 FO when Fed was already getting to old to go toe to toe with him and Djokovic on a regular basis. If you look how many Slams each of the big 3 won in that time you have Fed at 8, Nadal at 12 (but inflated with a lot of FO's obviously) and Djokovic at 7, it's very close to each other adjusting Nadal's FO runs.

I never denied Fed had some weak years too, the only issue is the length of the period. That's the same reason I don't care that much that Zverev finally bagged 2 Slams this year, but imagine him doing this for the next 4-5 years where the younger players are just not good enough and both Alcaraz/Sinner struggle with injuries. There's only so much vulturing someone can handle. If Zverev had 3 more years like this there would be people puttig him in the same category as Lendl, Connors, Mac or Agassi and that's just beyond ludicrous.
LOL at 2007 stronger than 2015
 
It’s not bean counting, it’s called treating players fairly and with consistency. The Federer of the second half of 14 and 15 was MUCH BETTER than the Federer of 2013 and still better than Federer 10 until he recovered from the lung infection.

I hear you say 12 slams all the time regarding Novak. But I never see you write Nadal winning 36% of all his majors and 50% of all his hardcourt majors in the same period. Why is this? And not only that, Nadal didn’t even have Djokovic eligible for 2 of those majors held between 17-22.

So this is my issue with your commentary. It’s fine you think 17-23 was all just very weak, I don’t agree with you, I think it’s much more nuanced than that, but I accept that’s your view, but your application of your view in relation to Djokovic and Nadal is very inconsistent. Apply it to both rather than one or it just comes off very biased against Djokovic.
Why would not focus on the biggest beneficiary of the career inflation era when assessing 2018-2023?

Djokovic got home with the cake, so why would you focus on Nadal now?
 
Zverev is obviously below big 3 and sinneraz but if he manages to win more slams post 30, credit where credit is due. I respect Wilander for his slams and would respect Zverev as well. It would mean he is capable of a very high level, surpassed only by a handful of players and that he was able to keep that level throughout the years. Similarly, I'm commending Fed for winning 2 slams in 2017 when Novak was out of the picture. Big 3 are not standard for atg, they are uncomparable legends.
Why pointing out Wilander here? He beat Vilas a an 18 years old at the FO and won slams beating Lendl. He is in another stratosphere than Zverev regarding his slam wins.
 
LOL at 2007 stronger than 2015
Not so much lol. Fed and Nadal both stronger in 2007 than in 2015, the latter by miles. Djokovic obviously better in 2015 but still good in 2007 which was his breakthrough year. Depth is more or less equal I would say, we had Murray and Stan in 2015, but we had more players who could cause an upset in 2007. Who other than Djoko, Fed, Murray and Stan we had in 2015?
 
  • Like
Reactions: RS
2007 - Peak Federer. Peak Nadal on grass/clay. A very good Djokovic on all surfaces.
2015 - Peak Djokovic. 34-year old Fed. Nadal playing his crappiest season ever.

But yeah Murray was tougher than Davydenko, so that obviously tips the scales to 2015 LMAO. Let's just convieniently ignore the rest.
most matches won by Big3 over top10s:

2015 - 53
2013 - 52
2012 - 51
2011 - 47
2009 - 44
2014 - 42
2008 - 35
2007 - 34

All statistics say that 2010 YEC to 2016 AO was the strongest period, and Nole was by far the best in this period (10 Slams, 4 YECs, 21 masters, 4 year end #1, etc.). Get over it.
 
Not so much lol. Fed and Nadal both stronger in 2007 than in 2015, the latter by miles. Djokovic obviously better in 2015 but still good in 2007 which was his breakthrough year. Depth is more or less equal I would say, we had Murray and Stan in 2015, but we had more players who could cause an upset in 2007. Who other than Djoko, Fed, Murray and Stan we had in 2015?
check the last post
 
most matches won by Big3 over top10s:

2015 - 53
2013 - 52
2012 - 51
2011 - 47
2009 - 44
2014 - 42
2008 - 35
2007 - 34

All statistics say that 2010 YEC to 2016 AO was the strongest period, and Nole was by far the best in this period (10 Slams, 4 YECs, 21 masters, 4 year end #1, etc.). Get over it.
What you for whatever reason never understand is that top10 wins cannot be compared at face value. Periods are varying in strength and there are stronger and weaker top tens (not even mentioning that wins over No.1 Fed in 2004-2007 would count the same as wins over whoever was No.10 in that time which in itself is ridiculous).
 
Why would not focus on the biggest beneficiary of the career inflation era when assessing 2018-2023?

Djokovic got home with the cake, so why would you focus on Nadal now?
It’s 2017-2023 the period you would be talking about. I’m not focussing on either as I don’t put entire eras into one weak category.

It’s you that’s focussing on one of them. I’m giving Djokovic and Nadal both credit for still winning majors well into their 30’s even if their opposition was sometimes weaker.

And if like you, that think it’s all a weak inflation era, it still what got Rafa ahead of Fed in the slam race so that’s very significant and as a Fed fan I’d expect you to be commenting on that. But you never do, you only apply it to Novak.
 
most matches won by Big3 over top10s:

2015 - 53
2013 - 52
2012 - 51
2011 - 47
2009 - 44
2014 - 42
2008 - 35
2007 - 34

All statistics say that 2010 YEC to 2016 AO was the strongest period, and Nole was by far the best in this period. Get over it.
And the stast show that Djokovic was better against the field in the Slams in 2024-2026 than in 2011-2014.

Btw by top tenners you mean all the Nishikoris, Berdychs and Ferrers that were consistently cleaning the draws and losing in the quarters and semis all the time? Show me the actual matches that are worth so much instead of doing the same old parade of dry stats that are so misleading it's a farce.

The strength of an era as a whole is mostly defined by the presence of ATGs, not David Ferrer and Jo Wilfred Tsonga. You have a super weak era now, yet Djokovic can't bag a single Slam despite winning 2-3 a year for years until 2023. Why is that?

"Yeah prime Sinner and Alcaraz are tougher than a 35-year old Djokovic, but guys ranked in the 15-50 range were tougher in 2018-2023, so 2018-2023 is stronger in 2024-2026". Yeah and that's why Djokovic can't bag a single Slam despite being in the semis and finals all the time.
 
It’s 2017-2023 the period you would be talking about. I’m not focussing on either as I don’t put entire eras into one weak category.

It’s you that’s focussing on one of them. I’m giving Djokovic and Nadal both credit for still winning majors well into their 30’s even if their opposition was sometimes weaker.

And if like you, that think it’s all a weak inflation era, it still what got Rafa ahead of Fed in the slam race so that’s very significant and as a Fed fan I’d expect you to be commenting on that. But you never do, you only apply it to Novak.
Go back to 2022, I did. But the weak era continued for another 1,5 years, Djokovic bagged 4 more Slams beating Kyrgios, Tsitsipas, Ruud and Medvedev in the finals and Djokovic fans declared he was the GOAT. The GOAT of the paper era maybe.
 
How many?

Because I think I saw a post from you saying something along the lines of two slams. But I could be wrong.
You win the slams you win. Unless there are big bans like FO 1977, the early AOs or the pre-open era, we can of course still put some context to the slams in the sense of "stronger or weaker" slams, but adjusting numbers is going too far imho. Novak deserves all of his 24 slams, but I would still not see him in a different tier than Fedal (primus inter pares if you want).
 
Go back to 2022, I did. But the weak era continued for another 1,5 years, Djokovic bagged 4 more Slams beating Kyrgios, Tsitsipas, Ruud and Medvedev in the finals and Djokovic fans declared he was the GOAT. The GOAT of the paper era maybe.

Why do majority of the tennis greats also call him that, and why are the polls also showing that?
 
Let's put is simple for you: Who do you think was stronger? Nadal 2007 or Nadal 2015? Fed 2007 or Fed 2015?
I let that stat speak for me.

wins over top10:

2015 Djokovic 31 >>>>>>>>>>>>>> 2007 Djokovic 6
2007 Federer 17 > 2015 Federer 15
2007 Nadal 11 >> 2015 Nadal 7

Considering all stats 2010 YEC to 2016 AO is objectively the strongest period by Big3 and Big4, and presumably the toughest.
 
You win the slams you win. Unless there are big bans like FO 1977, the early AOs or the pre-open era, we can of course still put some context to the slams in the sense of "stronger or weaker" slams, but adjusting numbers is going too far imho. Novak deserves all of his 24 slams, but I would still not see him in a different tier than Fedal (primus inter pares if you want).

That's fair.

I basically felt Federer, Nadal and Djokovic were all the same tier after 2019 season.
 
check the last post
Do you honestly think that Djokovic beating Berdych, Ferrer, Tsonga and Nishikori a million times in 2015 somehow proves that it was a stronger year than in 2007?

The big 3 collectively was way stronger in 2007 than in 2015, it's not even close and that's what decided the big titles. In 2015 Djokovic basically had Wawrinka catch fire once a year and outside of that he was dealing with a mid 30s Fed, Nadal who was absolute crapola, Murray who was not on his level (mid 30s Fed owned that Murray himself) and guys like Nishikori, Berdych, Ferrer, Tsonga. I can't believe I have to spell it out.

The same way Djokovic was bagging 2-3 Slams a year for years in his 30s until Alcaraz/Sinner showed up and closed the door on him. And I think that today's field is weaker than in 2018-2023. Who cares? 2-3 players decide who gets 95% of the cake.

But yeah dude, 2015 is better than 2007 because Fed and Djokovic beat Nishikori and Berdych a bunch of times in 2015. That's your proof, LMAO?
 
The strength of an era as a whole is mostly defined by the presence of ATGs, not David Ferrer and Jo Wilfred Tsonga.
Exactly. Give an era three ATGs/almost GOAT candidates to challenge the top guy, you can also have 6 sticks of wood as the rest of top ten. It would still be better than having consistent mediocre opposition all along. For Fed, a prime Nadal and prime Raz alongside 7 Daniel Koellerers would cause more harm than 9 Ferrers or even Roddicks. It does not matter whether on the way to the final you win every match with a triple bagel or lose the random set here or there, if in scenario A Nadal on clay is waiting in the final and in scenario B it is Zverev, then everyone in his right mind would chose scenario B.
 
And the stast show that Djokovic was better against the field in the Slams in 2024-2026 than in 2011-2014.

Btw by top tenners you mean all the Nishikoris, Berdychs and Ferrers that were consistently cleaning the draws and losing in the quarters and semis all the time? Show me the actual matches that are worth so much instead of doing the same old parade of dry stats that are so misleading it's a farce.

The strength of an era as a whole is mostly defined by the presence of ATGs, not David Ferrer and Jo Wilfred Tsonga. You have a super weak era now, yet Djokovic can't bag a single Slam despite winning 2-3 a year for years until 2023. Why is that?

"Yeah prime Sinner and Alcaraz are tougher than a 35-year old Djokovic, but guys ranked in the 15-50 range were tougher in 2018-2023, so 2018-2023 is stronger in 2024-2026". Yeah and that's why Djokovic can't bag a single Slam despite being in the semis and finals all the time.
You are beyond any possibility of saving
 
Why do majority of the tennis greats also call him that, and why are the polls also showing that?
Because they want to answer the question and go home instead of getting in a 2h debate.

It's funny how each time they have to anwer their face drops and they say "The numbers show..." or "Looking at statistcs it has to be Djokovic". It's so sad to watch.
 
2010 YEC to 2016 AO win percentage:

Djokovic 89.8%
Federer 83.3%
Nadal 82.9%
Murray 79.8%

2010 YEC to 2016 AO wins over top10s:

Djokovic 126
Federer 68
Nadal 68
Murray 44

The best period by Big3/Big4. cannot be argued otherwise. And Nole was the best in this period, cannot be argued otherwise.
 
Because they want to answer the question and go home instead of getting in a 2h debate.

It's funny how each time they have to anwer their face drops and they say "The numbers show..." or "Looking at statistcs it has to be Djokovic". It's so sad to watch.

So who do you think they feel is the GOAT? Or do you feel they think the GOAT is BS and there not such a thing?

Would you agree there is no GOAT and no one deserves to be called as such?
 
So who do you think they feel is the GOAT? Or do you feel they think the GOAT is BS and there not such a thing?

Would you agree there is no GOAT and no one deserves to be called as such?
It's more nuanced than that. It's never black and white. Depends on the the surface, depends on form, depends on peak level, depends on competition. There are too many variables. And they are way too close to each other to simply say one is better than the other.

Djokovic just won the most, but I don't think anyone truly believes that he is better than Federer or Nadal pound for pound. He just came in last of the big 3, maintained a high enough level long enough combined with some luck of not facing any new ATGs until 2023/2024. Djokovic just basically outlasted them. Just imagine Sinner and Alcaraz arrive a year later, just this small amendment. You still think Djokovic would be called the GOAT?

It's the exact same reason nobody treats Zverev's 2 Slams and probable year end no 1 ranking seriously. Life isn't linear, not everyone gets the same chances. Sometimes players never truly get an opening. Like take tier 2 players from 10-15 years - you don't think they would be capable of winning the FO or/and USO with Zverev's draws?
 
can you find me a better period by Big3/Big4 than 2010 YEC to 2016 AO?

I'm waiting for the stats
Ladies first. Weasel out of that one first and then I'll answer. Otherwise if we're playing pick and choose then the whole debate is pointless. Or tell us how Federer needed more time to set up his forehand than Del Potro or Nadal. That too.

2015 > 2007, because Djokovic beat Nishikori, Raonic, Berdych and Ferrer twenty thousand times. Yeah bro. Who cares Federer was old and Nadal could barely hang on to a top 10 ranking. Djokovic beat a bunch of tier 2 players several times, so that proves 2015 > 2007.
 
Let's put is simple for you: Who do you think was stronger? Nadal 2007 or Nadal 2015? Fed 2007 or Fed 2015?
Interestingly for Rafa, match for match against none big 3 players, he was weaker on clay from 2017-2022 than 2008-2014 but actually stronger on hard and significantly stronger on grass.

2015-2016 he was weaker everywhere.
 
It's more nuanced than that. It's never black and white. Depends on the the surface, depends on form, depends on peak level, depends on competition. There are too many variables. And they are way too close to each other to simply say one is better than the other.

Djokovic just won the most, but I don't think anyone truly believes that he is better than Federer or Nadal pound for pound. He just came in last of the big 3, maintained a high enough level long enough combined with some luck of not facing any new ATGs until 2023/2024. Djokovic just basically outlasted them. Just imagine Sinner and Alcaraz arrive a year later, just this small amendment. You still think Djokovic would be called the GOAT?

It's the exact same reason nobody treats Zverev's 2 Slams and probable year end no 1 ranking seriously. Life isn't linear, not everyone gets the same chances. Sometimes players never truly get an opening. Like take tier 2 players from 10-15 years - you don't think they would be capable of winning the FO or/and USO with Zverev's draws?

So, do you basically agree there is no such thing as GOAT. No player should have this title because it doesn't work.
 
Back
Top