Basic Logic 101: Why people who claim this is a very weak era are wrong.

UnderratedSlam

G.O.A.T.
It's simple.

Bear with me...

Fedfans can't cope with Novak and Rafa chasing down and breaking most of RF's most crucial records.
They try to downplay their achievements. (Because... only purrty BHs count.) So they decide to label NextGen as useless, LostGen as terrible.

That is their way of coping with the supposed "GOAT race" being even and open, a fact they can't deal with.

But what they don't realize is one very basic logic flaw in the claim that this is a very weak era...

Namely, when the Big 3 retire, NextGen will most likely be the dominant force.
Which begs the question: if NextGen are "useless" now, then won't THEIR era be much weaker than the current one? Using Fedfan logic, the answer is yes. If they can only win slams after the Big 3 retire, then by definition they will dominate a very weak era.

I.e. if the NextGen era (let's say, in 5 years) is much weaker than this one, then how can the CURRENT era be very weak too?
Are Fedfans claiming that ALL eras or MOST eras are weak? Is pro tennis then in GENERAL one big joke?

So, from now on when you label this era as very weak, keep in mind that a weaker era - or several weak eras - must be following right after this one, using this flawed logic at least.

We can't declare ALL eras, present and future, as weak, can we? Just because Federer doesn't dominate or is "ancient" doesn't mean an era is useless...

Yes, it's true not all eras are equal. Nothing is perfectly uniform in nature. But can we really have just one strong era and 50 weak ones? I say that makes very little sense.

Of course, this post deals with a certain faction of the Fed Army, not all of them. You know very well which section you belong to...
 
Weak era is when a player 10 years removed from his peak does not have competition and a 38 year old is top 3.

Not sure what all the other noise is about.

If big 3 retire, all the other players are around the same weak level but that does not mean it is a weak era in terms of competitiveness. It will be weak in terms of quality but still great for rivalries.
 
Weak era is when a player 10 years removed from his peak does not have competition and a 38 year old is top 3.

Not sure what all the other noise is about.

If big 3 retire, all the other players are around the same weak level but that does not mean it is a weak era in terms of competitiveness. It will be weak in terms of quality but still great for rivalries.
Go to my GAS threads, which explain that primes, peaks and shmeeps have shifted drastically in the last decade, all across the board...

Surely you must have noticed The GREAT AGE SHIFT even without my help?

Even sports journalists had noticed them. Surely anyone can, then...

 
Last edited:
I agree with your points, OP. I think the error in logic ultimately boils down to this, though:

The current era is coming on the heels of the strongest era ever (we'll say 2008-2013, give or take a year or two), and because the current era is comparatively weak, it gets (incorrectly) designated as weak in an absolute sense. Essentially, fans got spoiled and lost perspective. This is an average era we're in, not a weak one.
 
I agree with your points, OP. I think the error in logic ultimately boils down to this, though:

The current era is coming on the heels of the strongest era ever (we'll say 2007-2013, give or take a year or two), and because the current era is comparatively weak, it gets (incorrectly) designated as weak in an absolute sense. Essentially, fans got spoiled and lost perspective. This is an average era we're in, not a weak one.
Precisely, this is not a super-era by any means, but it isn't weak either. The Big 3 are still playing superb tennis and all three are top 5 players winning slams.

Well... RF was winning slams again until Novak came back from injury.

How can any half-way sane person refer to a Big-3-dominated era as weak?
 
Yes, it seems entirely possible that no strong era will emerge until decades from now on if ever at all. Tennis has taken a turn for the worse. All younger players are fundamentally flawed in various ways. The B3 time may end up being the nightmare that killed the soul of tennis. Sad!
 
Go to my GAS threads, which explain that primes, peaks and shmeeps have shifted drastically in the last decade, all across the board...

Surely you must have noticed The GREAT AGE SHIFT even without my help?

Even sports journalists had noticed them. Surely anyone can, then...

There is no age shift. The only GAS that is there is what is coming from you.

Tell me again who is going to win the majors when big 3 retire.. Not Raonic, Nishikori, Dmitrov, Cilic, Monfils, Fognini - but Zverev, Tsitsipas, Medevedev, Rublev, Khachanov - who are all under 22/23
 
Yes, it seems entirely possible that no strong era will emerge until decades from now on if ever at all. Tennis has taken a turn for the worse. All younger players are fundamentally flawed in various ways. The B3 time may end up being the nightmare that killed the soul of tennis. Sad!
How can three great players kill tennis?

I'd say the opposite...

It's the fanboys that kill tennis, with their obsession with records.

"ONLY RECORDS COUNT!!!!!!!!!" Fundamentalism.
 
There is no age shift. The only GAS that is there is what is coming from you.

Tell me again who is going to win the majors when big 3 retire.. Not Raonic, Nishikori, Dmitrov, Cilic, Monfils, Fognini - but Zverev, Tsitsipas, Medevedev, Rublev, Khachanov - who are all under 22/23
Even my gas has more sense than your solid matter... The grey one...

The average age of top 100 players has gone up DRASTICALLY. You can hate me for telling you the truth, up to you...

The notion that HUMAN DNA has gone BAD in just a decade and that ALL younger players suck is nonsensical.

 
Even my gas has more sense than your solid matter... The grey one...

The average age of top 100 players has gone up DRASTICALLY. You can hate me for telling you the truth, up to you...

The notion that HUMAN DNA has gone BAD in just a decade and that ALL younger players suck is nonsensical.


You didn't answer who is going to win the majors when Big 3 retire...We are not talking about who is making up the numbers.
 
You didn't answer who is going to win the majors when Big 3 retire...We are not talking about who is making up the numbers.
I am not here to play Nostradummus, I leave that to Nostradummies...

It's simply LOGICAL that NextGen will win slams after Big 3 retire. It certainly won't be Fed's kids or Connors...
 
Weak era is when a player 10 years removed from his peak does not have competition and a 38 year old is top 3.

Not sure what all the other noise is about.

If big 3 retire, all the other players are around the same weak level but that does not mean it is a weak era in terms of competitiveness. It will be weak in terms of quality but still great for rivalries.
If Fed can’t play at that level at 38 maybe he was never the GOAT, no?
 
Exactly, they want him to be GOAT, BUT they make excuses for him at every corner...

Would a real GOAT need his fans to DEFEND him all the time? A true GOAT would be unassailable.

He's been "too old" since he was 28...
The weak are began when he was 28. Unfortunately he was hit by a bus that year and we’ve only had Fed at like 10% power all these years. So sad, he’d be on 50 slams by now
 
Weak era is when a player 10 years removed from his peak does not have competition and a 38 year old is top 3.

Not sure what all the other noise is about.

If big 3 retire, all the other players are around the same weak level but that does not mean it is a weak era in terms of competitiveness. It will be weak in terms of quality but still great for rivalries.
So if the Big 3 had never existed that would make this a stronger era? :unsure:
 
On this one, the Federer fans are broadly correct.
Federer is past his best and injured frequently. Nadal's shots are good, but his movement is much slower now, perhaps because of the accumulative effect of knee problems. Thiem is brilliant when red-lining, but has shown poor mentality in his 3 Slam finals so far. The rest of nextgen just can't cut it in the final week of a slam.

So only Djokovic is left. He is playing close to the best tennis of his life, and will cruise to 3-4 Grand Slams this year. By 2021, he will have easily overtaken Fedal in Slam count.

However, the hypocrisy of Federer fans is astounding. For years they have argued that the concept of weak eras don't exist, and you only judge players by numerical success and not who they beat. Now suddenly when Djokovic is destined for 21 Slams against weak opposition, they conveniently realise what myself and others have been saying all along.
 
One of them might. Thiem, for example. Perhaps even Nishikori if he can stop getting injured.

But I really enjoyed your earlier post here how the Big 3 are making this era WEAKER by dominating it.

Very fitting for a thread that deals with bad logic. Thanks for providing another example...

Thiem is 1993. So, a whole generation of players from 1987-1993 - not amounting to anything - what is that an example of ??
 
However, the hypocrisy of Federer fans is astounding. For years they have argued that the concept of weak eras don't exist, and you only judge players by numerical success and not who they beat. Now suddenly when Djokovic is destined for 21 Slams against weak opposition, they conveniently realise what myself and others have been saying all along.

This! This makes so much sense!!
 
Didn’t read all of the OP.

But yes, if the youngest current slam champ is 31.5 years old, it’s a weak era.

And yes, it will be weak when the only ones winning slams, and sharing them between them, are the current young mugs.
 
There's a saying in sports that you can only beat what or who is in front of you (Baghdatis Gonzales, Anderson, Ferrer, Del Potro, Old Fed). It doesn't matter as every win counts. So, all talk of weak eras don't cut it when we get down to the stats after a player's career is done.
 
I agree that it will likely be a weaker field after the Big 3 have deteriorated but that doesn't necessarily mean that this era hasn't been weaker than average. I think the field has actually been improving year over year since 2017 but I think after Stan and Andy murdered each other in RG 17 we've been in a weaker than average era. Here's my view of year strength since 2000.
2000-2003: Weak
2004: Medium
2005-2006: Weak
2007: Medium
2008: Strong
2009-2010: Medium
2011-2013: Strong (Golden Years of Tennis)
2014-2017 AO: Medium
2017 RG-2018: Weak
2019-present: Medium/Weak
I think 2019-present is stronger than 17/18 but weaker than other medium years like 07 and 15. The thing is 11/13 is so strong it kinda breaks the curve because there have been some other really competitive years but they aren't as good and aren't worthy of the same category as 11/13. Maybe 11/13 should be it's own category of like Ultra Strong.
 
Last edited:
I agree that it will likely be a weaker field after the Big 3 have deteriorated but that doesn't necessarily mean that this era hasn't been weaker than average. I think the field has actually been improving year over year since 2017 but I think after Stan and Andy murdered each other in RG 17 we've been in a weaker than average era. Here's my view of year strength since 2000.
2000-2006: Weak
2007: Medium
2008: Strong
2009-2010: Medium
2011-2013: Strong (Golden Years of Tennis)
2014-2017 AO: Medium
2017 RG-2018: Weak
2019-present: Medium/Weak
I think 2019-present is stronger than 17/18 but weaker than other medium years like 07 and 15. The thing is 11/13 is so strong it kinda breaks the curve because there have been some other really competitive years but they aren't as good and aren't worthy of the same category as 11/13. Maybe 11/13 should be it's own category of like Ultra Strong.
Yikes
 
Go to my GAS threads, which explain that primes, peaks and shmeeps have shifted drastically in the last decade, all across the board...

Surely you must have noticed The GREAT AGE SHIFT even without my help?

Even sports journalists had noticed them. Surely anyone can, then...

Yes, Osaka, Andreescu and Kenin agree with your GAS and say that today it is impossible to win GS tournaments under the age of 30.
 
Reminds me of the affliction colloquially referred to as SALT. :unsure:
giphy.gif
 
I agree that it will likely be a weaker field after the Big 3 have deteriorated but that doesn't necessarily mean that this era hasn't been weaker than average. I think the field has actually been improving year over year since 2017 but I think after Stan and Andy murdered each other in RG 17 we've been in a weaker than average era. Here's my view of year strength since 2000.
2000-2003: Weak
2004: Medium
2005-2006: Weak
2007: Medium
2008: Strong
2009-2010: Medium
2011-2013: Strong (Golden Years of Tennis)
2014-2017 AO: Medium
2017 RG-2018: Weak
2019-present: Medium/Weak
I think 2019-present is stronger than 17/18 but weaker than other medium years like 07 and 15. The thing is 11/13 is so strong it kinda breaks the curve because there have been some other really competitive years but they aren't as good and aren't worthy of the same category as 11/13. Maybe 11/13 should be it's own category of like Ultra Strong.
Nailed it.
 
The GAS thread is about men's tennis.

You'd know that if you'd visited the thread...

Lazy.

You shouldn't give in so easily: you are right that there is a great age shift and you should insist that it does apply to the women's game, too. Just because some tournaments are won by younger players, it doesn't follow that the average age hasn't gone up markedly. There was a period of 10 years (40 Slams) in which NO 18 year old girl reached the quarter-final of a major. It's always going to be the case that young adults are more competitive in the women's game than the men's. That doesn't mean that the factors pushing the age up in the men's game aren't also pushing the age up in the women's game. There will be younger major champions in the men's game in the future, too. But the overall trend is markedly on the rise and that's likely to continue for some time.
 
Yes, Osaka, Andreescu and Kenin agree with your GAS and say that today it is impossible to win GS tournaments under the age of 30.

The average age in the women's game is up by A LOT and has been for a long, long time. A few women winning in their very late teens or early 20s doesn't disprove that - actually, it supports it, for none of them was young for a first-time champion by the standards of the late 1980s or early 1990s, not even Andreescu. And there are plenty of other older champions in women's tennis in recent years:

1. Serena Williams won 11 Slams in between her 30th birthday and turning 35 and a half.
2. Flavia Pennetta won her only Slam aged 33.
3. Angelique Kerber won her three Slams at 28, 28, and 30.
4. Li Na won her two Slams at 29 and 31 (a month shy of 32).
5. Caroline Wozniacki won her first Slam at 27.
6. Roberta Vinci made her first Slam final at 32.
7. Francesca Schiavone won her only Slam a few weeks before she turned 30 and made her only other final a few weeks before she turned 31.
8. Marion Bartoli won her only Slam at 28 and a half (slightly older).

And, as I noted in my previous post, we recently went a decade with no woman under 19 reaching even the last 8 of a major.

Actually, the great age shift became apparent in the women's game BEFORE it became apparent in the men's. There's some reversion to the mean now, sure, but the overall trend is definitely up in both games. You can look at the Tennis Abstract rankings list for more detail. The age shift goes all the way down the rankings on BOTH men's and women's tours.
 
That's not helpful. Where and why do you disagree? If you don't wanna discuss that's fine but if you do you have to explain why I'm wrong. Also looking back at it I should probably reclassify 04 as Medium. 04 is on par with the other medium years.
Not the guy you replied to, but my list would actually be more like this (although, to keep it clean, I won't divide it into tournaments):

2000 - 2002: Very Weak
2003: Weak
2004: Medium
2005: Medium (This year and 2007 get underrated around here)
2006: Weak
2007: Medium
2008: Strong
2009: Very Strong
2010: Medium (Somewhat overrated year)
2011: Strong
2012: Very Strong (Perhaps the strongest year, though I personally like 2009)
2013: Strong
2014 - 2015: Medium (2014 a bit stronger, but not enough that I would have to distinguish them)
2016 - 2018: Weak (With a few strong tournaments in the mix)
2019: Medium/Weak (I do feel it was stronger than previous years, but not by an awful lot)
 
Last edited:
Not the guy you replied to, but my list would actually be more like this (although, to keep it clean, I won't divide it into tournaments):

2000 - 2002: Very Weak
2003 - 2004: Weak
2005: Medium (This year and 2007 get underrated around here)
2006: Weak
2007: Medium
2008: Strong
2009: Very Strong
2010: Medium (Somewhat overrated year)
2011: Strong
2012: Very Strong (Perhaps the strongest year, though I personally like 2009)
2013: Strong
2014 - 2015: Medium (2014 a bit stronger, but not enough that I would have to distinguish them)
2016 - 2018: Weak (With a few strong tournaments in the mix)
2019: Medium/Weak (I do feel it was stronger than previous years, but not by an awful lot)
2019 was made stronger because of Thiem/Medvedev/Tsitsipas
 
The greatest players this game has ever seen had to fight against each other for every trophy in the last 10-12 years. Only refugees from logic can claim this is a “weak era”. It is one of the strongest eras in the entire history of tennis game, if not THE strongest era ever.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The greatest players this game has ever seen had to fight against each other for every trophy in the last 10-12 years. Only refugees from logic can claim this is a “weak era”. It is one of the strongest era in the entire history of tennis game, if not THE strongest era ever.

Agree. And behind the Big 3, we've got young tyros like Thiem, Tsitsipas, Auger Alliasime, Zverev, The Mad Lad Medvedev along with a guy who Mcenroe thinks is the most talented player he has ever seen (Kyrgios).

It's still not enough to appease the couch potatoes.
 
Back
Top