BBs questions on MTM

5263

G.O.A.T.
5363 said: "You are also right as to the big role accelerating into contact plays, which is why it is one of the bigger points of MTM training.
========================================
more from bb-
With the term MODERN in the title of MTM, we can easily assume that Modern means Modern? lol And since you mentioned MTM and ACCELERATION in the same breath we can also assume you were implying that acceleration is something unique to MTM instruction and no one elses.

However, we both know it is not true. Acceleration has been taught by many different coaches, methods, etc....for years and years and years.

So, if acceleration is a key principle in technique that has been taught by many for years and years, why would you ever associate this with MTM alone?
===========================


Not sure why this is so hard for you? As anyone can see, there is no suggestion of exclusivity in the quote, Nor was their any mention of it being MTM alone. The mention of MTM was relevant due to the fact that it has been formed around the idea of avoiding false data, opposed to what you cite "different coaches, methods, etc" which is sort of a hodge podge mix of ideas.

I'm not PTR, so I can't speak to that detail with them, as I expect you can. While it may be in the mix for PTA, it is clearly not one of the big keys for them and according to you, they don't really have a system as such any way.
You know what happens when you assume and jump to unsupported conclusions.
 
I kinda like the MTM branding (though I see it as mostly that -- branding.) To me, it translates to "teach pro strokes."
 
Weren't there some discussion in the Bailey Method thread where BB spoke his mind about what he thought of how the MTM package was delivered by TeachesTennis? I could have sworn I saw some very heated exchanges and tempers flared between BB and some of the other members, but then those posts kinda disappeared and the thread became toned down a bit the next day. So I just assumed that there were some mutual retractions going on behind the scene after everyone cooled down and maybe some of those posts I saw were mutually deleted.

So now I'm a little surprised to see this thread and this topic of discussion being started up again, that's all...
 
5363 said: "You are also right as to the big role accelerating into contact plays, which is why it is one of the bigger points of MTM training.
========================================
more from bb-
With the term MODERN in the title of MTM, we can easily assume that Modern means Modern? lol And since you mentioned MTM and ACCELERATION in the same breath we can also assume you were implying that acceleration is something unique to MTM instruction and no one elses.

However, we both know it is not true. Acceleration has been taught by many different coaches, methods, etc....for years and years and years.

So, if acceleration is a key principle in technique that has been taught by many for years and years, why would you ever associate this with MTM alone?
===========================


Not sure why this is so hard for you? As anyone can see, there is no suggestion of exclusivity in the quote, Nor was their any mention of it being MTM alone. The mention of MTM was relevant due to the fact that it has been formed around the idea of avoiding false data, opposed to what you cite "different coaches, methods, etc" which is sort of a hodge podge mix of ideas.

I'm not PTR, so I can't speak to that detail with them, as I expect you can. While it may be in the mix for PTA, it is clearly not one of the big keys for them and according to you, they don't really have a system as such any way.
You know what happens when you assume and jump to unsupported conclusions.

No, I don't. I have supported my information with pictures, videos, articles, and everything else I can find.

It is you that hasn't supported a darn thing you have said.

Bottom-line, there is no need to mention in the same breath as if MTM has a unique concept here on whether a player should accelerate the racquet head.

Even Oscar Wegner after an exchange of posts said that he created a method of teaching and a lot of the substance to his teaching was concerning what he felt were best practices. In other words, the ideas and concepts already existed.

And the term MODERN is misleading as well. Although I can accept it after hearing from Wegner, it still needs to be used in check. Acceleration of the racquet, windsheild wiper swings, etc... are not at all modern.

Is there something you are not getting?

You are once again headed down the wrong path. Bring it.
 
Last edited:
Weren't there some discussion in the Bailey Method thread where BB spoke his mind about what he thought of how the MTM package was delivered by TeachesTennis? I could have sworn I saw some very heated exchanges and tempers flared between BB and some of the other members, but then those posts kinda disappeared and the thread became toned down a bit the next day. So I just assumed that there were some mutual retractions going on behind the scene after everyone cooled down and maybe some of those posts I saw were mutually deleted.

So now I'm a little surprised to see this thread and this topic of discussion being started up again, that's all...

It is because I will always challenge these MTM folks as if they have cornered the world on instruction and tennis advice and he is mad. He wants to take me on in this subject, let him. I will bury him like I have before. Give me this one. It will be my pleasure.

And what did I say about it? I said, I didnt like the "marketing" campaign or the propoganda surrounding the hype that promoted MTM as the sole source of wisdom and the "modern" stroke.

I also said that MTM is not modern at all. MTM is being packaged as a method that is far from the old rotten conventional teaching wisdom that exists and certain coaches want to drag you down to hell with.

This is not only BS, it is plain ol stupid. You guys need to understand that although Oscar has packaged many of these existing concepts and practical advice, the only thing he invented was his way of teaching them. That is it. That is all he did.

It is incredibly irritating that someone would side-by-side tell us that a certain concept is an MTM principle as if that is the only place you are going to hear about it.

MTM is a teaching method that has borrowed and copied a lot of the best principles, ideas, advice, and concepts that has been around for a long long time.
 
Last edited:
Weren't there some discussion in the Bailey Method thread where BB spoke his mind about what he thought of how the MTM package was delivered by TeachesTennis? I could have sworn I saw some very heated exchanges and tempers flared between BB and some of the other members, but then those posts kinda disappeared and the thread became toned down a bit the next day. So I just assumed that there were some mutual retractions going on behind the scene after everyone cooled down and maybe some of those posts I saw were mutually deleted.

So now I'm a little surprised to see this thread and this topic of discussion being started up again, that's all...

The retractions were due to his harassment and attacks which are not allowed on the forum. It's pretty clear that when you have to resort to that kind of talk, there must not be much content to support your case.

I just started the thread so he would not hijack the other thread.
 
Last edited:
although Oscar has packaged many of these existing concepts and practical advice, the only thing he invented was his way of teaching them.

It is incredibly irritating that someone would side-by-side tell us that a certain concept is an MTM principle as if that is the only place you are going to hear about it.

MTM is a teaching method that has borrowed and copied a lot of the best principles, ideas, advice, and concepts that has been around for a long long time.

No, actually he didn't invent the way of teaching them either. That, like the rest, was selected as a best practice.

I have never said anything remotely along the lines of MTM being the only place to learn anything. Even the system as a whole has been copied due to it's quality, and so even much it can be learned thru other sources modeled on it.

Sorry you don't like the name.
Any more questions?
 
Last edited:
The retractions were due to his harassment and attacks which are not allowed on the forum. It's pretty clear that when you have to resort to that kind of talk, there must not be much content to support your case.

THE TITLE OF THIS POST IS: BB's QUESTIONS ON MTM.

You deliberatly reposted my comments which had nothing personal in them. However, they were a difference of opinion.

You later said that I had nothing to back my words up which is not true. I am not going to sit back and just watch you imply untrue things regarding MTM.

So, what is it? You can put a post up attacking me and act like a victim?

If you call me out, you best know what you are talking about and in this subject, you have nothing to go with.

TO THE MODERATORS: PLEASE LET THIS POST GO ON FOR A BIT. I WILL NOT POST ANYTHING PERSONAL, HOWEVER, I WILL BE DIRECT, BLUNT, AND TO THE POINT. I WILL PROVIDE DETAIL, ILLUSTRATIONS, AND OTHER EVIDENCE IF I HAVE TO TO PROVE MY POINT ON THIS TOPIC. IF IT GETS FRUSTRATING FOR 5263, YOU WILL NOW KNOW WHY.

IF YOU DO DECIDE TO REMOVE THIS POST, I WON'T COMPLAIN EITHER, THIS IS A DIRECT CALL OUT ON AN OPINION AND DISAGREEMENT ON MTM.
 
Last edited:
THE TITLE OF THIS POST IS: BB's QUESTIONS ON MTM.

You deliberatly reposted my comments which had nothing personal in them. However, they were a difference of opinion.

You later said that I had nothing to back my words up which is not true. I am not going to sit back and just watch you imply untrue things regarding MTM.

So, what is it? You can put a post up attacking me and act like a victim?

TO THE MODERATORS: PLEASE LET THIS POST GO ON FOR A BIT. I WILL NOT POST ANYTHING PERSONAL, HOWEVER, I WILL BE DIRECT, BLUNT, AND TO THE POINT. I WILL PROVIDE DETAIL, ILLUSTRATIONS, AND OTHER EVIDENCE IF I HAVE TO TO PROVE MY POINT ON THIS TOPIC. IF IT GETS FRUSTRATING FOR 5263, YOU WILL NOW KNOW WHY.

IF YOU DO DECIDE TO REMOVE THIS POST, I WON'T COMPLAIN EITHER, THIS IS A DIRECT CALL OUT ON AN OPINION AND DISAGREEMENT ON MTM.

Yes, I am the victim here. I just made a post with helpful intent to the OP and stated my reference.
You then proceed your usual bully tactics, just like the ones above with screaming in all caps.

I just started this thread so you didn't hijack still another post to carry out your personal attacks.
I asked you to start it, but you continued to hijack the other thread.
 
Last edited:
Yes, I am the victim here. I just made a post with helpful intent to the OP and stated my reference.
You then proceed your usual bully tactics, just like the ones above with screaming in all caps.

I just started this thread so you didn't hijack still another post to carry out your personal attacks.
I asked you to start it, but you continued to hijack the other thread.

The whole problem started with one line from you:

"You are also right as to the big role accelerating into contact plays, which is why it is one of the bigger points of MTM training."

Nobody asked you what "MTM training" suggests?

If you have a good idea or you agree with something and you have some sound information to back it up, then that's cool. That shows you have some decent information and you know what you are talking about.

But if you are using whatever your concept of "MTM training" is as proof then who cares? Same if you are a Vic Braden guy, or whatever...

It makes you look cheap and it does kind of make you look like you're some sort of mad cult follower or something.

If you wouldn't of mentioned "MTM training", then Im sure you would of gotten jumped on.

If someone tryed to make a point and say that it's right just because "Vic Braden says so" Id think the same thing, "I learned it and the Dennis VanDeMeer Academy". It's a weak argument and it explains nothing.
 
5363 said: "You are also right as to the big role accelerating into contact plays, which is why it is one of the bigger points of MTM training.
========================================
more from bb-
With the term MODERN in the title of MTM, we can easily assume that Modern means Modern? lol And since you mentioned MTM and ACCELERATION in the same breath we can also assume you were implying that acceleration is something unique to MTM instruction and no one elses.

However, we both know it is not true. Acceleration has been taught by many different coaches, methods, etc....for years and years and years.

So, if acceleration is a key principle in technique that has been taught by many for years and years, why would you ever associate this with MTM alone?
===========================


Not sure why this is so hard for you? As anyone can see, there is no suggestion of exclusivity in the quote, Nor was their any mention of it being MTM alone. The mention of MTM was relevant due to the fact that it has been formed around the idea of avoiding false data, opposed to what you cite "different coaches, methods, etc" which is sort of a hodge podge mix of ideas.

I'm not PTR, so I can't speak to that detail with them, as I expect you can. While it may be in the mix for PTA, it is clearly not one of the big keys for them and according to you, they don't really have a system as such any way.
You know what happens when you assume and jump to unsupported conclusions.

THE TITLE OF THIS POST IS: BB's QUESTIONS ON MTM.

You deliberatly reposted my comments which had nothing personal in them. However, they were a difference of opinion.

You later said that I had nothing to back my words up which is not true. I am not going to sit back and just watch you imply untrue things regarding MTM.

So, what is it? You can put a post up attacking me and act like a victim?

If you call me out, you best know what you are talking about and in this subject, you have nothing to go with.

TO THE MODERATORS: PLEASE LET THIS POST GO ON FOR A BIT. I WILL NOT POST ANYTHING PERSONAL, HOWEVER, I WILL BE DIRECT, BLUNT, AND TO THE POINT. I WILL PROVIDE DETAIL, ILLUSTRATIONS, AND OTHER EVIDENCE IF I HAVE TO TO PROVE MY POINT ON THIS TOPIC. IF IT GETS FRUSTRATING FOR 5263, YOU WILL NOW KNOW WHY.

IF YOU DO DECIDE TO REMOVE THIS POST, I WON'T COMPLAIN EITHER, THIS IS A DIRECT CALL OUT ON AN OPINION AND DISAGREEMENT ON MTM.

Don't get upset Bill. That dude is not even able to spell his own name correctly. :rolleyes: :D
 
Actually, the sentence:

"You are also right as to the big role accelerating into contact plays, which is why it is one of the bigger points of MTM training."

is very interesting to me, even though it doesn't suggest anything about MTM being the first to advocate this.

I have read a number of tennis books, and the only one I've read that talks about accelerating the racquet into the ball is Wegner's book. I was one of those who believed that only the terminal velocity of the racquet mattered, but now I think that acceleration is important. Could somebody point me to any other book or article that talks about this topic, that predates Wegner's work? Thanks.
 
Nobody asked you what "MTM training" suggests?

But if you are using whatever your concept of "MTM training" is as proof then who cares? Same if you are a Vic Braden guy, or whatever...

If someone tryed to make a point and say that it's right just because "Vic Braden says so" Id think the same thing, "I learned it and the Dennis VanDeMeer Academy". It's a weak argument and it explains nothing.

So Nobody asked about MTM? Is that like how nobody asked you about this?

It's not a weak argument, cause it isn't an argument, it's a reference to info, and the rest is just your opinion, which doesn't carry much of a reference, does it? I'm quite interested in where info comes from, as are many people. If you are not, you are free to ignore it.
 
Actually, the sentence:

"You are also right as to the big role accelerating into contact plays, which is why it is one of the bigger points of MTM training."

is very interesting to me, even though it doesn't suggest anything about MTM being the first to advocate this.

I have read a number of tennis books, and the only one I've read that talks about accelerating the racquet into the ball is Wegner's book. I was one of those who believed that only the terminal velocity of the racquet mattered, but now I think that acceleration is important. Could somebody point me to any other book or article that talks about this topic, that predates Wegner's work? Thanks.

thank you for pointing this out.
 
MTM is a teaching method that has borrowed and copied a lot of the best principles, ideas, advice, and concepts that has been around for a long long time.

That sounds like a pretty good endorsement. Bruce Lee created Jeet Kune Do from a myriad of martial arts that already existed. So did the founders of KaJuKenBo, Gracie Jujitsu, Defendo, Krav Maga, American Combatives, etc.
They took elements of existing styles that they felt were the best and made it into their own style. If that's what MTM is doing with tennis, I see nothing wrong with them marketing it as such.
 
I see nothing wrong with them marketing it as such.
I think the issue is whether Wegner has given due credit. That's all.

My impression, though is his emphasis on the last 1/3 of the stroke is unique, in that it seems he makes it kind of a foundation for his teaching.
 
Yes, I am the victim here. I just made a post with helpful intent to the OP and stated my reference.
You then proceed your usual bully tactics, just like the ones above with screaming in all caps.

I just started this thread so you didn't hijack still another post to carry out your personal attacks.
I asked you to start it, but you continued to hijack the other thread.

Bottom-line is acceleration of the racquet has not only been said here but is said by nearly every tennis teaching pro alive and dead. There is no secret here. Acceleration happens through having a elastic wrist, it happens through rotation. It happens through using the non-dominant arm through a braking action of the shoulders which accelerates the arm and hand through the contact zone.

This is such a well known concept that is is ridiculous to imply this is unique to MTM.

I have never ever seen or read anything about MTM and I have posted numerous posts about accelerating the racquet through the ball by using the kinetic chain on many posts including stroke analysis posts on this board.

There is no uniqueness with MTM regarding accelerating a racquet through the contact zone. NONE. If MTM talks about this it is a borrowed well known concept that many teching pros and players understand and advocate.

And because they do, there is no uniqueness in these areas with the exception on the way it is taught. That is it.

Again, I have never read a word about MTM and have always advocated racquet accelreration based on past learnings and studies on tennis. Many teaching pros including Yandell, Braden, Williams, Bolleterri, and on and on teach racquet acceleration. In fact, their instuction to utilize good biomechanics is to help a player increase acceleration.

Improving momentum is also a concept taught by many teaching pros and players.

Racquet acceleration is a basic, and I mean basic instruction to all players and it is not unique to MTM whatsoever.

You have absolutely nothing on this. It is a commonly taught concept that has been advocated for tennis players to do for decades. PERIOD.
 
There is no disagreement. I am just correcting misinformation.

Oh yes there is a disagreement. I am disagreeing that MTM should even be implied for a concept that is taught by many many coaches and players. It is not unique to MTM at all. It is even taught here.
 
That sounds like a pretty good endorsement. Bruce Lee created Jeet Kune Do from a myriad of martial arts that already existed. So did the founders of KaJuKenBo, Gracie Jujitsu, Defendo, Krav Maga, American Combatives, etc.
They took elements of existing styles that they felt were the best and made it into their own style. If that's what MTM is doing with tennis, I see nothing wrong with them marketing it as such.

I dont endorse anything pal. And if you think I do then let me finish and tell you the other side of the coin. I think you read a bit too much in it.

Many other teaching pros and methods tech best practices as well. However, nothing is perfect. Nothing. Concepts provided in MTM can also be challenged like how players prepare for the ball. So please dont put words in my mouth or I will debate you as well.
 
I think the issue is whether Wegner has given due credit. That's all.

My impression, though is his emphasis on the last 1/3 of the stroke is unique, in that it seems he makes it kind of a foundation for his teaching.

Due credit? Well, geee, so we waited all these years with many pros advocating acceleration that we should stop and give MTM or Oscar due credit? Well, let me bring up some of my posts that talks about racquet acceleration. Did I get "DUE" credit? This is such a basic concept that has been taught for decades.

Please dont make me laugh. Everyone from Braden to you name 'em, has taught racquet acceleration not only in groundstrokes but also serves.

All teaching pros and all methods advocate racquet acceleration. This is so basic it is ridiculous.
 
Last edited:
Bottom-line, due credit is not something you give to one individual or method when a concept or instructional advice has been a commodity in learning tennis for decades.

It is absolutely proposterous to even suggest that someone should be given due credit when they were not the first nor the last to teach racquet acceleration through the ball. When they themselves have used COMMON KNOWLEDGE on stroke technique.

If MTM teaches racquet acceleration fine. So does everyone else.
 
Due credit? Well, geee, so we waited all these years with many pros advocating acceleration that we should stop and give MTM or Oscar due credit?
Uhhh I think you misread my quote. I said whether Oscar has given due credit (i.e. Oscar claims the ideas are his) , not been given due credit. :D
 
Oh yes there is a disagreement. I am disagreeing that MTM should even be implied for a concept that is taught by many many coaches and players. It is not unique to MTM at all. It is even taught here.

just correcting mis info like this. you are the only one talking of unique.
Not only is it not implied, but it has been denied.

And since you have never read on MTM, maybe you don't need to make so many judgements of it, but then, maybe commenting when uninformed is your area?
 
Uhhh I think you misread my quote. I said whether Oscar has given due credit (i.e. Oscar claims the ideas are his) , not been given due credit. :D

think bb is going to bother getting it right?

I don't know if you have met or read Oscar, but he is big on giving credit and is glad to share where his info comes from. Maybe not good enough at it for some, but better than many.
 
Last edited:
Can I be the voice of reason and say :


Why is everyone even arguing about this stuff? Shouldn't this be taken off these forums and through e-mail?
 
Can I be the voice of reason and say :


Why is everyone even arguing about this stuff? Shouldn't this be taken off these forums and through e-mail?

Lol, yes, that is a good reasonable comment.

Never would discuss this through email. I jave alread provided my bottom-line and it ends with me there. There is no discussion.

From my perspective, I am tired of these MTM people claiming that common knowledge and common instructional advice is theirs and theirs alone. Or even come close to implying it.

I also laughed when Trickey said "to give them due credit". For what please? For mentioning something in their instruction that is commonly mentioned everywhere else including here?

Racquet acceleration is so basic and so commonly taught that it is not unique to any tennis teaching system and we should never ever give credit to someone or some method for using common knowledge amongst coaches and knowledgable players..
 
Can I be the voice of reason and say :


Why is everyone even arguing about this stuff? Shouldn't this be taken off these forums and through e-mail?

Not sure why you would suggest that? everyone has a choice what threads to read or which to skip. Several are interested in the points made in this thread. Many even bother to post their thoughts.
 
I also laughed when Trickey said "to give them due credit". For what please? For mentioning something in their instruction that is commonly mentioned everywhere else including here?
Like I said, I think you misread my quote. Shrug.

I don't know if you have met or read Oscar, but he is big on giving credit and is glad to share where his info comes from. Maybe not good enough at it for some, but better than many.

Yeah, I don't know either way. It sounded like Oscar was promoting his material as if he had originated many of those ideas. Again, can't say.
 
Last edited:
I also laughed when Trickey said "to give them due credit". For what please? For mentioning something in their instruction that is commonly mentioned everywhere else including here?
.

This says it all doesn't it. Tricky asks if Oscar has given enough credit to others he learned from, and bb goes off cause he can't understand the post. It explains alot.
Now I see why he keeps trying to act as though there have been claims of being unique where none exist.
 
Not sure why you would suggest that? everyone has a choice what threads to read or which to skip. Several are interested in the points made in this thread. Many even bother to post their thoughts.



No, this thread is a flame fest wrapped up in a pretty sparkly and pink giftwrap. Don't try and fool me; this is obviously a personal argument between you and BB, and that should be taken off these forums.
 
No, this thread is a flame fest wrapped up in a pretty sparkly and pink giftwrap. Don't try and fool me; this is obviously a personal argument between you and BB, and that should be taken off these forums.

You can jump to what ever conclusions you want. I started this thread to try and avoid changing the topic of the thread where he wanted to discuss this.
 
You can jump to what ever conclusions you want. I started this thread to try and avoid changing the topic of the thread where he wanted to discuss this.



You started this thread in order to start an argument for no apparent reason. Rather than just ignoring BB (which would have been the better option), you opt to create a thread in order for you two to go at it like you two are Gladiators and this forum is your arena.



Honestly, I'm not saying one person is right or wrong, but there is no point in arguing when it's obvious that this is a personal issue.
 
I dont endorse anything pal. And if you think I do then let me finish and tell you the other side of the coin. I think you read a bit too much in it.

Many other teaching pros and methods tech best practices as well. However, nothing is perfect. Nothing. Concepts provided in MTM can also be challenged like how players prepare for the ball. So please dont put words in my mouth or I will debate you as well.

LOL, I didn't mean endorse in the sense like it's a Nike endorsement. I just thought it was a nice description.

I didn't put words in your mouth. I used your own words. It seems like this MTM thing is a very touchy subject for some. No offense was meant toward you, it actually seemed like you were being nice with that description that I quoted. Things seemed like they were evolving into a more amicable situation.

MTM, and getting certified in it, is still an open book for me. I'm still not sure about it, so I am withholding judgment. It's an interesting subject and one that should be discussed rationally and respectfully by ALL parties involved. It seems when the subject comes up, it turns into a peeing contest and an argument.
 
LOL, I didn't mean endorse in the sense like it's a Nike endorsement. I just thought it was a nice description.

I didn't put words in your mouth. I used your own words. It seems like this MTM thing is a very touchy subject for some. No offense was meant toward you, it actually seemed like you were being nice with that description that I quoted. Things seemed like they were evolving into a more amicable situation.

VABeachTennis - you did put words in my mouth and twisted my meaning. You took it out of context. I don't endorse, promote, or subscribe to any method of teaching. And the "best-practice" comment was made in context of the fact that other methods also incorporate known best-practices. All methods of teaching have known and common elements in their instructional advice. All methods take in their version of best-practices. All of them. All methods will put their spin on things. No other method has gone out and seduced players into thinking that they have cornered the market on "modern" technique than MTM and their followers. Their basis to promote their position as the "true and only" leaders of the modern era is false. They simply have taken known information and repackaged it. Then they sell it as if it is their own.

MTM, and getting certified in it, is still an open book for me. I'm still not sure about it, so I am withholding judgment. It's an interesting subject and one that should be discussed rationally and respectfully by ALL parties involved. It seems when the subject comes up, it turns into a peeing contest and an argument.

Again, I dont care about the method. You can teach whatever you want. However, if anyone comes in here and starts telling others that "MTM" is the one that developed, invented, solely endorsed, was the only one that recognized or even implied anything like that, I will debate it.

Further, the dichotomy of how 5263 and Tennis presents their information is sly and shrude. Subtle hints of "us vs. them" or "modern vs. conventional" or "new vs. old" are spinkled throughout many of their posts concerning this subject. They like to put the USPTA manal and take it out of context. Many people who don't understand the history or the progression of tennis would easily buy into it. Sort of like how people get suckered into buying Dianetics or Scientology. Same tactics. So, when they consistently mention a known tennis principle along with their promotion of MTM, I definetly have an issue with that.

So, why do I have an issue with this? Why bother. I will tell you why. Because it is not based on truthful information. My principles are violated when someone twists the truth for their benefit. Now some people dont care if they are lied to or tricked into thinking something. Unfortunately, I do. And the best part about this is, I know more than they do. That is why they have not been able to win their argument.

All I have to do is post a 1926 player hitting a "modern" forehand and their entire foundation crumbles. They have nothing to say. However, they also will not stop promoting their information and neither will I challenging it.
 
Last edited:
All I have to do is post a 1926 player hitting a "modern" forehand and their entire foundation crumbles. They have nothing to say. However, they also will not stop promoting their information and neither will I challenging it.

Great example of where his point on this crumbles.
Showing a 1926 pic of a modern forehand just gives more evidence of how legitimate the forehand is that Oscar picked to include in the methods he teaches.
If this is bb's case, he just lost it.
 
No, this thread is a flame fest wrapped up in a pretty sparkly and pink giftwrap. Don't try and fool me; this is obviously a personal argument between you and BB, and that should be taken off these forums.

I guess it was just so uninteresting you couldn't stay away? I think if you don't like a thread, you should not read it, and surely not bother to post on it.

Look if that is what you think, of course it is fine, but you can only assume my intentions, especially if you disregard what I have to say about it. Otherwise, I mostly appreciate your post on this forum, so no hard feeling on my end.
 
VABeachTennis - you did put words in my mouth and twisted my meaning. You took it out of context. I don't endorse, promote, or subscribe to any method of teaching. And the "best-practice" comment was made in context of the fact that other methods also incorporate known best-practices. All methods of teaching have known and common elements in their instructional advice. All methods take in their version of best-practices. All of them. All methods will put their spin on things. No other method has gone out and seduced players into thinking that they have cornerned the market on "modern" technique. They have nto done so. They simply have taken known information and repackaged it like anyone else.



Again, I dont care about the method. You can teach whatever you want. However, if anyone comes in here and starts telling others that "MTM" is the one that developed, invented, solely endorsed, was the only one that recognized or even implied anything like that, I will debate it.

Further, the dichotomy of how 5263 and Tennis presents their information is sly and shrude. Subtle hints of "us vs. them" or "modern vs. conventional" or "new vs. old" are spinkled throughout many of their posts concerning this subject. They like to put the USPTA manal and take it out of context. Many people who don't understand the history or the progression of tennis would easily buy into it. Sort of like how people get suckered into buying Dianetics or Scientology. Same tactics. So, when they consistently mention a known tennis principle along with their promotion of MTM, I definetly have an issue with that.

So, why do I have an issue with this? Why bother. I will tell you why. Because it is not based on truthful information. My principles are violated when someone twists the truth for their benefit. Now some people dont care if they are lied to or tricked into thinking something. Unfortunately, I do. And the best part about this is, I know more than they do. That is why they have not been able to win their argument.

All I have to do is post a 1926 player hitting a "modern" forehand and their entire foundation crumbles. They have nothing to say. However, they also will not stop promoting their information and neither will I challenging it.

Hey BB, I think you give excellent advice. It wasn't my intention to twist your words or take them out of context, what's in it for me? I'm not an MTM guy, nor do I want to slam someone who gives excellent tennis tips and insights that I actually agree with (you). The post that I made (and quote from you) was meant to be positive and not a slam on you or anyone else for that matter.

I like those pictures that you posted from the old players from 1926, it led me to go to google books and check out some of the old tennis books there.
 
Maybe thats why NO one does??

Except you of course in this odd way of bring up a point that is not relevant.

So NO one does? You're are kidding right? Well, I do? I have goe over racquet acceleration, arm acceleration, hand acceleration, in great detail many many times. Or is it that you just are selectively reading information to make your claims?????? I also know many many others do!

You are joking about that I assume.

I dont know what you dont understand about the words "commonly taught".
 
Last edited:
So NO one does? You're are kidding right? Well, I do? I have goe over racquet acceleration, arm acceleration, hand acceleration, in great detail many many times. Or is it that you just are selectively reading information to make your claims?????? I also know many many others do!

You are joking about that I assume.

I dont know what you dont understand about the words "commonly taught".

Please read slowly-
you said it was not right to teach as unique- then I said NO ONE does teach it as unique that I am aware of!
 
Please read slowly-
you said it was not right to teach as unique- then I said NO ONE does teach it as unique that I am aware of!

PLEASE READ EVEN SLOWER: MTM is a teaching method that has borrowed and copied a lot of the principles, ideas, advice, and concepts that has been around for a long long time. Other coaches have been the inventors. Other coaches need the credit. MTM is just a method of teaching tennis it does not own or hoard concepts that others have created.

Racquet acceleration is taught by many many teachers, methods, etc... Racquet acceleration is consistently taught here and through others. It is not unique to MTM, it is not unique to Oscar. It is not unique at all. Get it? Do you want me to repeat this until it sinks in?

DO YOU READ?
 
Hey BB, I think you give excellent advice. It wasn't my intention to twist your words or take them out of context, what's in it for me? I'm not an MTM guy, nor do I want to slam someone who gives excellent tennis tips and insights that I actually agree with (you). The post that I made (and quote from you) was meant to be positive and not a slam on you or anyone else for that matter.

I like those pictures that you posted from the old players from 1926, it led me to go to google books and check out some of the old tennis books there.

Thanks for the clarification. I dont mind if you want to use MTM. That is not my argument. Because MTM utilizes good common knowledge (like others) it is a viable method of teaching tennis.

I am more after the promotion and marketing side of this stuff.

Yes, those pictures really tell the story. The story is this, tennis is a largely frgamented industry. There are pockets of knowledge everywhere. Tennis coaching is a maturing group and needs to mature further. People like Oscar, Bolleterri, and others have packaged known information with current ways to play and developed their instructional package or method of learning.

In my opinion, this is the way to go and I am glad people like Oscar is doing that. Someday maybe I will. I will take everything I know and create a lesson on all strokes using my background in instructional design, learning theory, etc...I have some good ideas that I know will be a great improvement on the way we teach tennis and communicate.

However, I personally have a hard time accepting this mantra or propoganda that I continually bump into. I know others think I am nuts or this is a no big deal. However, when I have studied and learned over the years what is true and not true, I have a very hard time just sitting back and watching someone(s) take advantage of people that don't know.

Is this a big deal to others? No. This is a separate topic that deals with the back office of tennis. However, because I spent a lot of time in the back office of tennis, it is a big deal to me. Just let me have this argument.
 
Last edited:
I think 5263 was saying that no one is saying that this is unique to MTM.

Then why link it to MTM? If it is a general teaching technique, I wouldnt post "MTM" this and that knowing Yandell and others say the same thing.

The bottom-line is MTM follwoers believe they have the answers to all tennis players. They do not. They have borrowed concepts - period. There is no reason to mention MTM and imply that some how MTM is the one that "understands" or "discovered" this.

And he doesn't have to say it directly. The implications of his words are there.

The post was on an OP trying to understand and develop racquet acceleration. If it is common knowledge, why link it to MTM? Unless of course, you are steering someone toward or promoting MTM.
 
Last edited:
Apparrently he does not want to acknowlege this fact since it does not help his rant.
Anyone else can see how it is here.

Yeah, you have yet to prove anything with your little rant post here either. Whats the matter 5263, dont you have any proof that this is uniquely taught by MTM? Why even mention MTM on a commonly taught principle unless you are promoting it?

Where is your proof that is only mentioned by MTM also? MTM is simply a packaged teaching method that is based on known principles that many other teach and use. It is just a method and nothing else.
 
why link it to MTM?

Educated people are used to references.

Sort of like when you get in these arguments and try to prove you know something because you were a Vic Braden instructor. Yes, I've seen you
do that over and over, but never complained or tried to cut down Braden as you have Oscar and MTM.
 
Educated people are used to references.

Sort of like when you get in these arguments and try to prove you know something because you were a Vic Braden instructor. Yes, I've seen you
do that over and over, but never complained or tried to cut down Braden as you have Oscar and MTM.

Too bad you are not that edcuated. Otherwise, you would realize that you would also have to include many other references to ensure that the information you provided was fairly represented and proper acknowledgement to others that also promote the same thing. My god. This is getting hilarious.

Geeez, more babble.

I link things to people who actually discovered the information. Vic Braden discovered many things that is largely taken for granted. Oscar has not discovered anything except his own method of teaching tennis.

Get real. You are spinning now. MTM is just repackaged known information.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top