clout
Hall of Fame
They had similar results: 2 majors, 2 Masters, 9 wins vs top 10 players and 53 wins in total.
However, consistency throughout the season is the tiebreaker and in this case it goes to Rafa. He made all four semis at slams, 3 finals and won two titles. He also won 2 Masters (same as Nole), and made the semis or better in 11/13 tournaments he played in this year. Rafa also has a better win percentage at 88% compared to 83% from Djoker (they won a similar # of matches). Also, despite both losing in the group stages, Rafa went 2-1 (with two great wins vs Daniil and Stefanos) compared to 1-2 from Nole. Rafa also finished the year at number one which meant he earned more points than Novak throughout the duration of the season. I think this one easily goes to Rafa although they both had marvelous seasons and any of their fans that want more than what their favs have already done this year is being greedy
However, consistency throughout the season is the tiebreaker and in this case it goes to Rafa. He made all four semis at slams, 3 finals and won two titles. He also won 2 Masters (same as Nole), and made the semis or better in 11/13 tournaments he played in this year. Rafa also has a better win percentage at 88% compared to 83% from Djoker (they won a similar # of matches). Also, despite both losing in the group stages, Rafa went 2-1 (with two great wins vs Daniil and Stefanos) compared to 1-2 from Nole. Rafa also finished the year at number one which meant he earned more points than Novak throughout the duration of the season. I think this one easily goes to Rafa although they both had marvelous seasons and any of their fans that want more than what their favs have already done this year is being greedy