Best slam winner in each year since big 3 era started?

N

Nadal_King

Hall of Fame
Which has been best slam winning version of each year since big 3 era, I will list down mine. You all can join in for your picks although I could be wrong for pre 2015 ones as I wasn't as big fan then.

2003- Federer (Wimbledon)
2004- Federer (Wimbledon)
2005- Federer (Us open)
2006 - Nadal (Rg)
2007- Nadal( Rg)
2008- Nadal (Rg)
2009- Nadal (Ao)
2010- Nadal( UO)
2011- Djokovic (Ao)
2012- Djokovic (Ao)
2013- Nadal (Rg)
2014- Djokovic ( Wimbledon)
2015- Djokovic (Ao)
2016- Djokovic (Ao)
2017- Nadal(Rg)
2018- Nadal (Rg)
2019- Djokovic (Ao)
2020- Nadal (Rg)
2021- Djokovic (Rg)
 
Nadal_King said:
Which has been best slam winning version of each year since big 3 era, I will list down mine. You all can join in for your picks although I could be wrong for pre 2015 ones as I wasn't as big fan then.

2003- Federer (Wimbledon)
2004- Federer (Wimbledon)
2005- Federer (Us open)
2006 - Nadal (Rg)
2007- Nadal( Rg)
2008- Nadal (Rg)
2009- Nadal (Ao)
2010- Nadal( UO)
2011- Djokovic (Ao)
2012- Djokovic (Ao)
2013- Nadal (Rg)
2014- Djokovic ( Wimbledon)
2015- Djokovic (Ao)
2016- Djokovic (Ao)
2017- Nadal(Rg)
2018- Nadal (Rg)
2019- Djokovic (Ao)
2020- Nadal (Rg)
2021- Djokovic (Rg)
Click to expand...

Level wise:

2003 - Federer at Wimbledon
2004 - Federer at Wimbledon (USO/AO close)
2005 - Federer at Wimbledon
2006 - Federer at Wimbledon/USO - tie
2007 - Nadal at RG (Fed at AO close)
2008 - Nadal at RG
2009 - Nadal at AO/Fed at Wimbledon
2010 - Nadal at RG
2011 - Djokovic at AO
2012 - Nadal at RG
2013 - Djokovic at AO
2014 - all 4 close enough interestingly
2015 - Wawa at RG/Djoko at Wim
2016 - Djokovic at AO
2017 - Nadal at RG
2018 - Nadal at RG
2019 - Djoko at AO
2020 - Nadal at RG
2021 - ehhh
 
Last edited:
2003 - Fed Wim
2004 - Fed Wim
2005 - Safin AO/Fed Wim
2006 - Fed Wim/USO
2007 - Nadal RG
2008 - Nadal RG
2009 - Nadal AO
2010 - Nadal RG /Nadal USO
2011 - Djokovic AO
2012 - Nadal RG
2013 - Djokovic AO/Nadal USO
2014 - Nadal RG
2015 - Stan RG
2016 - Djokovic RG
2017 - Nadal RG
2018 - Nadal RG/Djokovic Wim
2019 - Djokovic AO /Nadal RG
2020 - Nadal RG
2021 - Med USO
 
Last edited:
2003: Fed Wimbledon
2004: Fed US Open, very close between that and his other two Slam wins though
2005: Fed Wimbledon
2006: Fed Wimbledon
2007: Nadal RG
2008: Nadal RG
2009: Nadal AO but it’s honestly close
2010: Nadal RG
2011: Djokovic AO
2012: Nadal RG
2013: Djokovic AO
2014: Cilic US Open
2015: Djokovic Wimbledon
2016: Djokovic AO
2017: Nadal RG
2018: Nadal RG
2019: Djokovic AO
2020: Nadal RG
2021: meh
 
RS said:
2003 - Fed Wim
2004 - Fed Wim
2005 - Safin AO/Fed Wim
2006 - Fed Wim/USO
2007 - Nadal RG 07
2008 - Nadal RG 08
2009 - Nadal AO 09
2010 - Nadal RG /Nadal USO
2011 - Djokovic AO 11
2012 - Nadal RG 12
2013 - Djokovic AO 13/Nadal USO 13
2014 - Nadal RG 14
2015 - Stan RG 15
2016 - Djokovic RG 16
2017 - Nadal RG 17
2018 - Nadal RG 18/Djokovic Wim 18
2019 - Djokovic AO 19/Nadal RG 19
2020 - Nadal RG 20
2021 - Med USO 21
Click to expand...
Nadal RG 07 vs Federer AO 07 series of 10 matches? ;)
 
Non winner

2003 - Roddick Wim
2004 - Agassi AO/Roddick Wim
2005 - Fed AO
2006 - Fed RG/Nadal Wim
2007 - Nadal Wim/Fed RG
2008 - Fed Wim
2009 - Fed AO/Fed USO/Del Potro RG/Dasco AO
2010 - Soderling RG
2011 - Fed USO/Fed RG
2012 - Nadal AO
2013 - Djokovic RG. Edit Stan RG
2014 - Fed Wim Edit Djokovic AO
2015 - Fed Wim/Fed USO/Djokovic RG
2016 - dunno
2017 - Nadal AO
2018 - Nadal Wim
2019 - Fed Wim
2020 - Thiem AO
2021 - Tpas RG
 
Last edited:
‘00 Agassi
‘01 Agassi
‘02 PETE
‘03 Agassi
‘04 Fed
‘05 Safin
‘06 Fed
‘07 Nadal/Fed tie
‘08 Nadal
‘09 Nadal
‘10 Nadal
‘11 Djoko
‘12 Nadal
‘13 Djoko
‘14 lol what if it was Cilic?
‘15 Djokovic
‘16 Djokovic
‘17 Nadal
‘18 Nadal Djoko tie
‘19 Djokovic
‘20 Nadal obviously
‘21 Djokovic
‘22 - hope to god we get something better than Nadal AO 22 lol
 
Fed AO 07 is close but against a wider range of ATG on each surface Nadal does better.

A few players could be said to beat AO 07 Fed like 6 times out of 10 but the same is not happening to Nadal at RG.
 
2003: Fed Wimbledon
2004: Fed AO
2005: Fed Wimbledon
2006: Nadal RG
2007: Nadal RG or Fed AO
2008: Nadal RG
2009: Nadal AO
2010: Nadal USO
2011: Djokovic AO
2012: Nadal RG
2013: Djokovic AO or Nadal USO
2014: Cilic USO
2015: Stan RG
2016: Djokovic AO
2017: Nadal RG
2018: Nadal RG or Djokovic Wimbledon
2019: Djokovic AO
2020: Nadal RG
2021: Djokovic RG I guess
 
Nadal_King said:
Which has been best slam winning version of each year since big 3 era, I will list down mine. You all can join in for your picks although I could be wrong for pre 2015 ones as I wasn't as big fan then.

2003- Federer (Wimbledon)
2004- Federer (Wimbledon)
2005- Federer (Us open)
2006 - Nadal (Rg)
2007- Nadal( Rg)
2008- Nadal (Rg)
2009- Nadal (Ao)
2010- Nadal( UO)
2011- Djokovic (Ao)
2012- Djokovic (Ao)
2013- Nadal (Rg)
2014- Djokovic ( Wimbledon)
2015- Djokovic (Ao)
2016- Djokovic (Ao)
2017- Nadal(Rg)
2018- Nadal (Rg)
2019- Djokovic (Ao)
2020- Nadal (Rg)
2021- Djokovic (Rg)
Click to expand...
That's the ONLY Big 3 slam win from that year, so what are we comparing it to?

Unless Roddick is Big 3 too...
 
RS said:
Fed AO 07 is close but against a wider range of ATG on each surface Nadal does better.

A few players could be said to beat AO 07 Fed like 6 times out of 10 but the same is not happening to Nadal at RG.
Click to expand...

no, just 1.
ditto Nadal at RG 07.
 
Lleytonstation said:
Idiot. We said slams.

Belgrade 2 only one that counts.
Click to expand...
tumblr_inline_p4hvspmx8z1us2qgp_500.gifv
 
abmk said:
who are those few players?
gravinbongagis? cdffousssis?
Click to expand...
Think he was saying in hypotheticals like Djokovic 2011 AO or Djokovic 2016 AO versions can take that Fed on. But I cant fathom anyone other than peak Borg over Nadal RG 2007 and peak Borg is a completely different era
 
zuluzazu said:
Its comparison of slam winners since Big 3 era started not levels of Big3 only per se
Click to expand...

Nadal_King said:
Which has been best slam winning version of each year since big 3 era, I will list down mine. You all can join in for your picks although I could be wrong for pre 2015 ones as I wasn't as big fan then.
Click to expand...
I understand this to mean we compare slam wins within every season to other slam wins from Big 3 only.
 
RS said:
Why do you want to fight over nothing?
Click to expand...

I'm not fighting. I'm disagreeing.

RS said:
Djokovic , Agassi and Nadal and Safin have that case imo.
Click to expand...

only Djokovic.
not for Safin over a 10 match series
not Nadal either. he just about beat lower prime fed in AO 09. This is peak fed.
not Agassi over a 10 match series either
 
abmk said:
I'm not fighting. I'm disagreeing.



only Djokovic.
not for Safin over a 10 match series
not Nadal either. he just about beat lower prime fed in AO 09. This is peak fed.
not Agassi over a 10 match series either
Click to expand...
I said a case not that it would 100% happen.

All of them take at least 4/10 imo and Djokovic the 6 imo.
 
zuluzazu said:
Think he was saying in hypotheticals like Djokovic 2011 AO or Djokovic 2016 AO versions can take that Fed on. But I cant fathom anyone other than peak Borg over Nadal RG 2007 and peak Borg is a completely different era
Click to expand...

see his response. He mentioned like 4 players.
Djoko is the only possibility over a 10 match series.
 
Anyone want to do best non winners at slams each year from 03 to 21?

I gave it a go.
 
RS said:
Okay for your pleasure I will say the other 3 get 4 and Djokovic gets 6.

That's how I see it.
Click to expand...

I'm saying based on reasoning.
Safin's focus is bound to drift over a 10 match series. was a point away from losing to AO 05 fed in 4 sets.
Agassi's focus/mental strength is again less than fed's. peak a little worse IMO. .
Nadal's peak is by some distance behind. matchup makes it closer. Still he barely beat AO 09 lower prime fed.

the possibility of them winning 6/10 isn't realistic.
Think about it instead of just agreeing to placate me (or anyone else)
 
abmk said:
I'm saying based on reasoning.
Safin's focus is bound to drift over a 10 match series. was a point away from losing to AO 05 fed.
Agassi's focus/mental strength is again less than fed's. peak a little worse IMO. .
Nadal's peak is by some distance behind. matchup makes it closer. Still he barely beat AO 09 lower prime fed.

the possibility of them winning 6/10 isn't realistic.
Think about it instead of just agreeing to placate me (or anyone else)
Click to expand...
You know I don't quite rate Fed as high as you do so I think it is not out of reach.

Probably less so for Safin for that reason.
 
dapchai said:
03 Fed WC.
04 Fed WC.
05 Fed WC.
06 Fed WC.
07 Fed WC.
08 Fed USO.
09 Fed WC.
10 Fed AO.
11 Djoko AO.
12 Fed WC.
13 Murray WC.
14 Cilic USO.
15 Stan RG.
16 Murray WC.
17 Fed WC.
18 Fed AO.
19 Djoko AO.
20 Djoko AO.
21 Med USO.
Click to expand...
GIF
 
RS said:
Non winner

2003 - Roddick Wim
2004 - Agassi AO/Roddick Wim
2005 - Fed AO
2006 - Fed RG/Nadal Wim
2007 - Nadal Wim/Fed RG
2008 - Fed Wim
2009 - Fed AO/Fed USO/Del Potro RG/Dasco AO
2010 - Soderling RG
2011 - Fed USO/Fed RG
2012 - Nadal AO
2013 - Djokovic RG
2014 - Fed Wim
2015 - Fed Wim/Fed USO/Djokovic RG
2016 - dunno
2017 - Nadal AO
2018 - Nadal Wim
2019 - Fed Wim
2020 - Thiem AO
2021 - Tpas RG
Click to expand...

Non-winners:

2003 - Roddick at Wim, Nalby at USO. Verkerk deserves a mention for his run minus final, esp QF/SF vs Moya/Coria
2004 - Agassi AO/Roddick Wim/Agassi USO
2005 - Fed AO
2006 - Fed RG (Fed had chances in 3 out of 4 sets in RG 06. Nadal in only 2 in Wim 06)
2007 - Nadal Wim (over Fed RG. this is when gap switch b/w fedal on clay vs fedal on grass)
2008 - Fed Wim
2009 - Fed AO/Fed USO/Del Potro RG/Dasco AO/Roddick Wim
2010 - Sod RG
2011 - Fed USO/RG
2012 - Nadal AO, Djokovic USO (was great before the final, even if he did struggle in wind in final)
2013 - Wawa AO, then Djokovic RG
2014 - Djoko AO, Fed Wim
2015 - Djoko RG, Fed Wim, Fed USO
2016 - can't clearly specify, fed AO/Rao AO/Djoko USO
2017 - Nadal AO
2018 - Nadal Wim
2019 - Fed Wim
2020 - Zverev USO. j/k. Thiem AO
2021 - err
 
  • Like
Reactions: RS
Best non winners:

03 Phillippousis WC.
04 Hewitt USO.
05 Roddick WC.
06 Bagdatis AO.
07 Gonzo AO.
08 Murray USO.
09 Roddick WC.
10 Murray AO.
11 Murray AO.
12 Murray WC.
13 Murray AO.
14 Nishi USO.
15 Murray AO.
16 Murray AO.
17 Cilic WC.
18 Cilic AO.
19 Nadal AO.
20 Zverev USO.
21 Med AO.
 
Look at the 2009 list above @RS
if you need more evidence 2009 is the strongest year of this millenium.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RS
abmk said:
Non-winners:

2003 - Roddick at Wim, Nalby at USO. Verkerk deserves a mention for his run minus final, esp QF/SF vs Moya/Coria
2004 - Agassi AO/Roddick Wim/Agassi USO
2005 - Fed AO
2006 - Fed RG (Fed had chances in 3 out of 4 sets in RG 06. Nadal in only 2 in Wim 06)
2007 - Nadal Wim (over Fed RG. this is when gap switch b/w fedal on clay vs fedal on grass)
2008 - Fed Wim
2009 - Fed AO/Fed USO/Del Potro RG/Dasco AO/Roddick Wim
2010 - Sod RG
2011 - Fed USO/RG
2012 - Nadal AO, Djokovic USO (was great before the final, even if he did struggle in wind in final)
2013 - Wawa AO, then Djokovic RG
2014 - Djoko AO, Fed Wim
2015 - Djoko RG, Fed Wim, Fed USO
2016 - can't clearly specify, fed AO/Rao AO/Djoko USO
2017 - Nadal AO
2018 - Nadal Wim
2019 - Fed Wim
2020 - Zverev USO. j/k. Thiem AO
2021 - err
Click to expand...
Forgot about Djokovic AO 14 and should have put Stan.

Rest is fine I guess not much in it. Think 12 Nadal is ahead because of the final but pre final can be debated.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Lew II
Lew Rating for all Slam winners since 2003
Replies
40
Views
2K
daggerman
daggerman
Lew II
Big3's greatest Slam SF+F performances
2
Replies
79
Views
4K
Crazy Finn
C
Red Rick
Big 3 amount of series of consecutive Slam titles
2
Replies
69
Views
3K
Deleted member 771911
D
Lew II
Last 20 slam winners were over 28 years old
Replies
30
Views
2K
fedfan24
F
Lew II
Sets dropped by Big3 before playing each other
Replies
36
Views
2K
SonnyT
S
Back
Top