clout
Hall of Fame
Which matches do you think each member regrets losing the most?
For Federer (in no particular order):
2008 Wimbledon Finals (chance for 6 (possibly 7) straight Wimby's and 3 straight wins vs Rafa)
2009 Australian Open Finals (his post-game reaction says it all)
2019 Wimbledon Finals (doesn't get worse than this)
2009 US Open Finals (could've won the NCYGS; choked away set 2 and 4, and got blown off the court in set 5 against a 20-year old)
2005 Australian Open Semis (could've had 4 straight 3-slam seasons; would've been a massive feat for the GOAT debate)
2014 Wimbledon Finals (had BP to serve for a Nicklaus-like resurgence)
2010/11 US Open Semis (40-15 again...in b2b years, in the same touney, in the same round, against the same player...RIP)
2007/11 French Open Finals (How many BPs did Fed have in '07 and how in the world did he lost set 1 in '11)
2014 US Open Semis (MUGlic decided to GOAT or else Fed would've drew 'Kori in a gimme finals)
2015 US Open Finals (How many squandered BPs again?)
For Nadal (in no particular order):
2012 Australian Open Finals (Up a break in the fifth...)
2017 Australian Open Finals (Up a break in the fifth...again)
2014 Australian Open Finals (Body fell apart against a player who's never took a set off him)
2018 Wimbledon Semis (Had SPs in set 3 and multiple BPs in the fifth)
2007 Wimbledon Finals (Had many BPs in the fifth)
2009 French Open R16 (I know he had to lose there at some point in his career, but damn given the complexion of men's tennis at the time, he could have permanently put Fed to bed with another beating in the eventual finals if Soderling never happened on that fateful day)
For Djokovic (in no particular order):
2013 French Open Semis (Up a break in the fifth...until he touched the net...if only he didn't touch the net)
2015 French Open Finals (Slayed Rafa but got Stanimaled...at the time, it looked like Nole's chances of winning RG was fading)
2011 French Open Semis (Could've won the CYGS)
2014 US Open Semis (How tf did he lose to Nishikori of all ppl...a horrible blown opportunity by Nole here)
2014 Australian Open Quarters (Could've won 6 straight AOs)
2012 US Open Finals (he gave this away to Murray in set 5)
Since Fed is my fav player out of these three, '08 Wimbledon and '09 AO were the worst losses...until '19 Wimbledon of course.
For Federer (in no particular order):
2008 Wimbledon Finals (chance for 6 (possibly 7) straight Wimby's and 3 straight wins vs Rafa)
2009 Australian Open Finals (his post-game reaction says it all)
2019 Wimbledon Finals (doesn't get worse than this)
2009 US Open Finals (could've won the NCYGS; choked away set 2 and 4, and got blown off the court in set 5 against a 20-year old)
2005 Australian Open Semis (could've had 4 straight 3-slam seasons; would've been a massive feat for the GOAT debate)
2014 Wimbledon Finals (had BP to serve for a Nicklaus-like resurgence)
2010/11 US Open Semis (40-15 again...in b2b years, in the same touney, in the same round, against the same player...RIP)
2007/11 French Open Finals (How many BPs did Fed have in '07 and how in the world did he lost set 1 in '11)
2014 US Open Semis (MUGlic decided to GOAT or else Fed would've drew 'Kori in a gimme finals)
2015 US Open Finals (How many squandered BPs again?)
For Nadal (in no particular order):
2012 Australian Open Finals (Up a break in the fifth...)
2017 Australian Open Finals (Up a break in the fifth...again)
2014 Australian Open Finals (Body fell apart against a player who's never took a set off him)
2018 Wimbledon Semis (Had SPs in set 3 and multiple BPs in the fifth)
2007 Wimbledon Finals (Had many BPs in the fifth)
2009 French Open R16 (I know he had to lose there at some point in his career, but damn given the complexion of men's tennis at the time, he could have permanently put Fed to bed with another beating in the eventual finals if Soderling never happened on that fateful day)
For Djokovic (in no particular order):
2013 French Open Semis (Up a break in the fifth...until he touched the net...if only he didn't touch the net)
2015 French Open Finals (Slayed Rafa but got Stanimaled...at the time, it looked like Nole's chances of winning RG was fading)
2011 French Open Semis (Could've won the CYGS)
2014 US Open Semis (How tf did he lose to Nishikori of all ppl...a horrible blown opportunity by Nole here)
2014 Australian Open Quarters (Could've won 6 straight AOs)
2012 US Open Finals (he gave this away to Murray in set 5)
Since Fed is my fav player out of these three, '08 Wimbledon and '09 AO were the worst losses...until '19 Wimbledon of course.
Last edited: