Carlos vs Peak Djokovic? Who would win?

Carlos vs Peak Novak? Who would win?

  • Peak Novak

    Votes: 19 47.5%

  • Carlos

    Votes: 15 37.5%

  • Peak Fed

    Votes: 5 12.5%

  • Peak Rafa

    Votes: 7 17.5%
  • Total voters
    40
B

btsjungkook

Professional
I feel Carlos would probably win. He does everything better than Peak Novak. The only thing Peak Novak had was his return and stamina but Carlos has ball striking, net game, and better attacking game than Novak had. He'd probably win against Federer in the Rg semi when Novak couldn't. What do you think?
 
btsjungkook said:
I feel Carlos would probably win. He does everything better than Peak Novak. The only thing Peak Novak had was his return and stamina but Carlos has ball striking, net game, and better attacking game than Novak had. He'd probably win against Federer in the Rg semi when Novak couldn't. What do you think?
Click to expand...
He's too young to be compared to BOAT.
 
Carlos is a better player in basically every regard now. Slightly worse backhand and return but miles better in every other category. I was more impressed with his level at the last US Open more than any of the 22 majors Novak won.

He has character and class. Roger can finally pass the torch to him. Feels great to witness it.
 
2011 and 2015 Djokovic would win over current Carlos! Carlos would have his chances against many other versions though.Carlos is still developing though so he may improve further. We will see.
 
M3aty said:
Carlos is a better player in basically every regard now. Slightly worse backhand and return but miles better in every other category. I was more impressed with his level at the last US Open more than any of the 22 majors Novak won.

He has character and class. Roger can finally pass the torch to him. Feels great to witness it.
Click to expand...
Carlos of course is a miles better server than Novak
 
He hasn’t reached his peak, but what he’s currently shown would not be enough to topple Peak Djokovic with any consistency. No shame in that given his age.
 
Carlos beating weak era players makes everyone thing think he's some kind of goat

Non of the players today can do anything to the big 3, yet people think Carlos is like some kind of tennis god that just descended from heaven. What a joke

Just because he had some exciting games with fcking serial loser Jannik Sinner means he's better than peak GOAT?

What a joke
 
M3aty said:
He has character and class. Roger can finally pass the torch to him. Feels great to witness it.
Click to expand...
It does feel like Carlos is the right player to succeed Fed with this kind of beautiful aggressive all court game.

And he’s captivating folks like no one quite has since Roger.

Don’t know what the future holds, and I don’t think Novak and Rafa will go away quietly, but It is cool to see.
 
We haven't seen Peak Charles yet.

He's better than Federer already, or so we've been recently informed. But let's not get ahead of ourselves.
 
Current novak will beat up on chuck for at least the next year. Peak novak? No chance. That’s not to say Carlos won’t improve…
 
All these threads would look a joke if Djokovic and Nadal beat Alcaraz in clay swing since both no way are in there prime let alone being at peak. So to assume Carlitos having a higher peak than big 3 is just too early day dreaming. Let the kid become 20 and he has a lot of time left to prove these things if you would give him such tags then if he lands up on TTW ,then by reading this may lose motivation :p
 
Current Alcaraz would struggle vs Djokovic when he was that age (they're very similar but Djokovic better):




So he would definitely lose vs peak Djokovic.
 
Carlos could probably barely hang on with peak Djokovic as far as rallies go, but he's thoroughly outclassed in the serve-return complex.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

JohanLiebert
  • Poll Poll
Peak Federer Vs. Peak Djokovic
2 3 4
Replies
190
Views
13K
Federev
Federev
G
  • Poll Poll
Peak Novak Djokovic vs peak Rafael Nadal at US Open, who wins?
2
Replies
99
Views
8K
SonnyT
S
M
  • Poll Poll
2024 Alcaraz vs 2011 Djokovic, 2007 Federer and 2009 Nadal at the AO, but the Big Three start with a 6-1, 6-3, 5-2 lead
Replies
2
Views
532
itrium84
itrium84
Razer
  • Poll Poll
Who Faced the harder challenge to overcome ? (Djokovic vs Fedal) or (Federer vs Djokodal) ?
5 6 7
Replies
315
Views
9K
BorgTheGOAT
BorgTheGOAT
Sport
  • Poll Poll
Nadal vs. Alcaraz. Who possesses a superior peak on hard courts?
2 3 4
Replies
183
Views
6K
iuyhii
I
Back
Top