Cash vs Noah vs Gonez

[goldenera]

Three one timers of the 80,who were a tad below the great champions
Very appealing games and looks,nice fellas as sell
Who was better?
In glival terms Gomez had the most complete and long career..he basically won every big cc event while doing ok but not great indoors,grass or hard
RG,Montecarlo,2 Rones,2 Barcelonas

Noah won the DC as did Cash..he basically played on clay,indoor and hard and beat Lendl ,Vilas,Wilander but not Borg,Connors,Mac..other than RG he won Madriz,Hamburg and also Richmond and Palm Springs..but on grass has a much worse record than the other two
Cash of course won Wimbledon as well as Johannesburg and lost two AO finals as well as another W and USO sf
None did well at the Masters or WCT finals
I go with Cash because he was a much better major player and while Becker and Mac destroyed him,he was better many times to Lendl and Wilander
As for Gomez or Noah, Andres was steadier on the long run,so my choice is
Cash
Gomez
Noah

What about you?

 

[Cashman]

IMO as a player Cash was comfortably above the other two. Without his horrific luck with injuries he would almost certainly have a couple of additional major titles. Ignoring injuries, his resume is obviously the weakest.

Gomez v Noah is an interesting discussion though. Most statistics give Noah a slight edge - he has more titles, a higher career-best ranking, and he generally performed better in Slams - but he only won 1 of his 8 meetings with Gomez.

 

[goldenera]

Gomez was better player but not by much
Cash was good but not enough for the real greats

 

[goldenera]

Should have placed Kriek in the lot but he was clearly the most talented of them

 

[BorgCash]

Like Cash most of all ( you guess why ), then Noah, then Gomes.

 

[goldenera]

Cash was a really very nice guy but he was not consistent enough to keep it up yet his major perfs are remarkable.

Noah and Gomez were very laid back..Got to know both personally but Noah had a lot of trouble handling his life while Gomez was more mature.

Gomez had a real problem with Lendl whom Cash and Noah beat at slam events..he solved it as he aged..

 

[goldenera]

The three were pretty good at doubs but only Noah had real sucess..he and Forget could beat anyone when on.

 

[goldenera]

Noah the best server and smasher
Cash the best mover and volleyer
Gomez the best groundies and drops shots

Cash was a better mover by far but he couldn t play on clay while Gomez and Niah had some good results on fast turf..not many,but some

 

[BorgCash]

Cash was a really very nice guy but he was not consistent enough to keep it up yet his major perfs are remarkable.

Noah and Gomez were very laid back..Got to know both personally but Noah had a lot of trouble handling his life while Gomez was more mature.

Gomez had a real problem with Lendl whom Cash and Noah beat at slam events..he solved it as he aged..

You know Noah and Gomez?