Delayed grunting and extended grunting

Status
Not open for further replies.

Long Face

Semi-Pro
I'm watching a little Rogers Cup lately, and noticed two players, Silva and Baurista Agut, employed a type of delayed grunting, which could be very unpleasant to their opponents. They started the loud grunting right AFTER they hit the ball, and the grunt lasted till the ball bounced on the opponent's side of the court (slower shots), or till the opponent hit the ball (faster shots).

And it is very different from the type of grunting from, say, Nadal. Although very loud, Nadal only grunts when he takes a swing at the ball.

I had also noticed extended grunting, in which they player starts a lower grunt when he/she hits the ball, but the grunt goes on, very loudly, long after the ball leaves the racquet. I cannot remember which players do this, though. Ferrer sometimes, but not all the time.

Personally I think such grunting is bad sportsmanship. And I believe players who grunt like these started it when they were young, probably taught or encouraged by their coaches. If it worked well in their matches, they kept on doing it.

The suspicion was confirmed recently when I watched a local coach teaching some kids, and he was showcasing an exaggerated and extended grunting to his students, although I know this coach well enough to know that he never grunts in his own matches.
 

Fabresque

Legend
Radek Stepanek, Roberto Bautista Agut, Rogerio Dutra Silva, Joao Sousã, Jo-Wilfried Tsonga, just to name a few.
 

Bender

G.O.A.T.
Delayed grunting I can kinda get...some people exhale after contact.

Extended grunting I can't quite get, since that actually takes effort
 

guanzishou

G.O.A.T.
All compulsive grunters should be stripped off their titles and banned. Grunting has a performance enhancing effect. It makes your weak shots sound louder than it actually sound.
 

Terenigma

G.O.A.T.
If anyone is grunting in the first set, male or female, its gamesmanship. Lets stop acting like it's not or give them the benefit of the doubt. Delayed or not, it's poor gamesmanship.

I can understand some players get grunty after a couple of sets or long matches. Murray and Ferrer and Djokovic are prone to this but it's fatigue. Its not happening every damn point and especially not when you hit god damn dropshots.

Its disgusting and I wish they would enforce a rule about it because it's getting worse and spreading to the ATP as well as the WTA
 

KINGROGER

G.O.A.T.
If you watch some 05 Nadal matches he didn't even used to grunt as much.

In general Fed is again the best for this. Only very occasionally if he's playing say a clay match vs Rafa and putting loads of effort in will he grunt.
 

NothingButNet

Semi-Pro
C'mon, Nadal is a master of the extended grunt, which he alternates with his regular one during long rallies to prove to Toni and his opponent that he's 'zoning'

"The Bull's Belated Bleat"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top