Djokovic might be the GOAT, but the "single" greatest achievement/record in modern tennis is Nadal's 14 RG

ForehandCross

G.O.A.T.
In GOAT race, Djokovic > Nadal. But I can't wrap my head around how 14 RG's being the single greatest achievement in modern tennis is even a debate. Nadal's 14 RG is equal TO THE SLAM RECORD the previous generation. He won 14 slams in 14 years, is equal to career span of most of the GOAT and ATG candidates. He has more than 2 times the record of highest titles(6), 4 times the record of next number of highest wins at the event(3).

Read that again. Incomprehensible, ridiculous and unbeatable.

Djokovic is GOAT because he has almost every record to his name. And he maybe is the best player of all time. But there should be no doubt that this one record of Nadal is the greatest if we talk of singular records/achievements.
 
24 slams is less than 10% higher than next in count.

3 players have slams in same count and vicinity. Making it clear it isn't an outlier.
That's not how greatness works.

With this logic 13+ semifinals at all four Slams would be Nole's greatest record (the second best only has 8) but no one cares about that record.
 
What a surprise. Really which one do you think is tougher to break. The second best in slams is 22 so very well striking distance. The second best in RG is 6. Even if we talk slams in general, 10 is still light years away from 14.
Hardest to break doesn't mean greatest, otherwise Nole's 13 semifinals at all four Slams would be his greatest record
 
Hardest to break doesn't mean greatest, otherwise Nole's 13 semifinals at all four Slams would be his greatest record
Nobody cares about semifinals everyone cares about slam titles like FO titles. It is maybe not making him greatest but definitely the most impressive record.
 
Nobody cares about semifinals everyone cares about slam titles like FO titles. It is maybe not making him greatest but definitely the most impressive record.
Nobody cares about titles at one Slam, everyone cares about overall Slam titles

Everyone would prefer 24 Slams over 14 RGs

8 year end #1s and 428 weeks at #1 are also greater because they define dominance in all tournaments for 8 years/428 weeks, while 14 RGs is only in 1 tournament
 
Greatness is achieving something that is both unattainable and is valued at a high level.

13 SF across 4 slams each is unattainable but reduces down to less valued achievement as an absolute.

Winning a slam is the most valued achievement in Tennis and winning 14 at a single event is much much more unattainable than winning 25.
 
What a surprise. Really which one do you think is tougher to break. The second best in slams is 22 so very well striking distance. The second best in RG is 6. Even if we talk slams in general, 10 is still light years away from 14.
it has nothing to greatness to do. some things are simple greater and more important than others! isners serve aces in single match is impossible to break. still no body cares!

and lot of records will be dificult to break. but nole holds almost ALL most important main records and surely the most important as slams, YE#1, weeks, CGS, completing tennis and highest ATP points!
 
Greatness is achieving something that is both unattainable and is valued at a high level.

13 SF across 4 slams each is unattainable but reduces down to less valued achievement as an absolute.

Winning a slam is the most valued achievement in Tennis and winning 14 at a single event is much much more unattainable than winning 25.
still no ATG see rafa as the GOAT and everyone see nole. all analytics to and very vast majority of the fans. even in spain!
 
still no ATG see rafa as the GOAT and everyone see nole. all analytics to and very vast majority of the fans. even in spain!

Err, the Novak is the greatest because he did all records. He didn't do one. He did each of 5-10 which were treated like measures for tennis greatness.

Doesn't mean Nadal can't have one record that is greater in isolation. But can't grant him GOAT title given Novak achieved more across the board.
 
Err, the Novak is the greatest because he did all records. He didn't do one. He did each of 5-10 which were treated like measures for tennis greatness.

Doesn't mean Nadal can't have one record that is greater in isolation. But can't grant him GOAT title given Novak achieved more across the board.
it is VERY SIMPLE! rafa holds most single surface and single tournaments records and nole holds all overall main records!

ergo, rafa is indisputed single surface and RG GOAT while nole is indisputed overall GOAT (and another single surface and AO GOAT)!!!
 
Err, the Novak is the greatest because he did all records. He didn't do one. He did each of 5-10 which were treated like measures for tennis greatness.

Doesn't mean Nadal can't have one record that is greater in isolation. But can't grant him GOAT title given Novak achieved more across the board.
Would you prefer to have 24 Slams or 14 RGs?
 
Would you prefer to have 24 Slams or 14 RGs?
everyone would prefer to be the overall GOAT than single surface (out of 3 + indoor) GOAT! no single one would take surface instead of overall GOAThood. and, in overall GOAThood is almost guaranteed a surface GOAThood too. as nole is the GOAT on most frequent surface too! and on indoor! now... rafa is greater on CC than nole on HC but overall GOAThood is still the most important and the greatest thing! and there is #1 stat greatness (arguably the most important thing in tennis is to be #1 and especially Y#1 and thats about all surfaces and conditions)!!!!
 
He is The King. Nadal forever. The best player I ever saw live in full flight. And yes that is the one record set in stone. Scary thinking back to some of the crazy shlt he pulled. We all saw the crowds he commanded when he retired. He was basically a cult hero before he had even finished playing.

I do agree with the OP about Djokovic being considered the GOAT of the Big 3 era, though. I think it's the right thing to say. He is the closest I have ever seen to a player becoming completely immersed and obsessed with the concept of tennis being a sport played by imperfect people that demands perfectionism and pursuing that conundrum to the ends of the earth.
 
In GOAT race, Djokovic > Nadal. But I can't wrap my head around how 14 RG's being the single greatest achievement in modern tennis is even a debate. Nadal's 14 RG is equal TO THE SLAM RECORD the previous generation. He won 14 slams in 14 years, is equal to career span of most of the GOAT and ATG candidates. He has more than 2 times the record of highest titles(6), 4 times the record of next number of highest wins at the event(3).

Read that again. Incomprehensible, ridiculous and unbeatable.

Djokovic is GOAT because he has almost every record to his name. And he maybe is the best player of all time. But there should be no doubt that this one record of Nadal is the greatest if we talk of singular records/achievements.

GhG9ImlWIAAp62T
 
Phenomenal achievement, and the most impressive part is his strike rate, once he made the QF. Incredible. A killing machine.

Won 14/16 once he reached the QF stage. Only 1 man stopped him in his career once he reached the QF stage.

And it’s the same guy who in a most peculiar anomaly has actually made 3 more quarter finals at RG than Rafa. 19/22 compared to 16/19.
 
As nice as it sounds, winning RGs was a means to get to the slam record. And that failed.

It's like building a bigger house than your neighbor, until you realize you have no funds left and the house is left with no roof. Walls are strong, but the rain keeps pouring in.
 
In GOAT race, Djokovic > Nadal. But I can't wrap my head around how 14 RG's being the single greatest achievement in modern tennis is even a debate. Nadal's 14 RG is equal TO THE SLAM RECORD the previous generation. He won 14 slams in 14 years, is equal to career span of most of the GOAT and ATG candidates. He has more than 2 times the record of highest titles(6), 4 times the record of next number of highest wins at the event(3).

Read that again. Incomprehensible, ridiculous and unbeatable.

Djokovic is GOAT because he has almost every record to his name. And he maybe is the best player of all time. But there should be no doubt that this one record of Nadal is the greatest if we talk of singular records/achievements.
Nadal's achievement was unbelievable, but Djokovic's dominance over top 10 was even more so.

The players with 20 or more top10 victories per year:

31 - Djokovic (15)
24 - McEnroe (84), Djokovic (12, 13), Nadal (13)
22 - Borg (78), Lendl (85)
21 - Djokovic (11, 16)
20 - Borg (79)

Djokovic did it 5 times in 6 years, '11-16. Borg did it twice, and McEnroe, Lendl & Nadal once. No Connors, Becker, Sampras, Federer, Alcaraz or Sinner! No one has done it in 10 years!

This is the record harder to break than Nadal: Djokovic led the lists in 13 years, '11-23, save '17, when he was injured, including '16 & '18, when he starred in half a season. To tell you how hard it was to lead, Nadal led or co-led it twice, once in '08 with 17, and once when he shared it with Djokovic in '13 with 24.

BTW, Djokovic had the second highest winning percentage among top10, and won the most matches against top10 by 41, at the end of '25.
 
Last edited:
In GOAT race, Djokovic > Nadal. But I can't wrap my head around how 14 RG's being the single greatest achievement in modern tennis is even a debate. Nadal's 14 RG is equal TO THE SLAM RECORD the previous generation. He won 14 slams in 14 years, is equal to career span of most of the GOAT and ATG candidates. He has more than 2 times the record of highest titles(6), 4 times the record of next number of highest wins at the event(3).

Read that again. Incomprehensible, ridiculous and unbeatable.

Djokovic is GOAT because he has almost every record to his name. And he maybe is the best player of all time. But there should be no doubt that this one record of Nadal is the greatest if we talk of singular records/achievements.
Slay :D

0ef846ed4d1bd505e4dfcac3e5e67ee8e7894b8d.gif
 
Well said OP

Carl Lewis and Paavo Nurmi have more olympic golds/medals than Usian Bolt athletics but Bolt has done records which for generations might not be touched

Thats why Nadal is the Usian Bolt of Tennis, his 14 french opens record is the greatest feat which makes him the greatest athlete.
 
It's the most unbeatable top-tier record, that's for sure. The other top-tier records (total slam count, time at #1, consecutive time at #1, consecutive slams, most titles at each slam) are far easier to break than 14 RGs. Does that make it the greatest? I don't know, I wouldn't say that. But I guess it's not an unreasonable take.
 
As nice as it sounds, winning RGs was a means to get to the slam record. And that failed.

It's like building a bigger house than your neighbor, until you realize you have no funds left and the house is left with no roof. Walls are strong, but the rain keeps pouring in.

Ultimately that was the main purpose.
 
It's the most unbeatable top-tier record, that's for sure. The other top-tier records (total slam count, time at #1, consecutive time at #1, consecutive slams, most titles at each slam) are far easier to break than 14 RGs. Does that make it the greatest? I don't know, I wouldn't say that. But I guess it's not an unreasonable take.
It's not top tier record. Not even top2 tier record

Tier 1 = Slam titles
Tier 2 = #1 weeks and # years
 
This forum demonstrates that this assertion cannot be true. How one weighs tennis stats, data, etc is a subjective game.
You can have Djokovic as the best while agreeing with this even as hinted by the op.
 
I agree.

Though I also find it very difficult for any player in the future to achieve 237 weeks in a row at number 1 and to win at least one title (from ATP 250 to Grand Slam) 21 consecutive years.​
 
I can see someone reaching 14 at a slam someday under the right set of circumstances, but I'm pretty confident in saying 14-0 in finals at a slam without ever needing a 5th set to win will never be matched. Similar to Michael Jordan's 6-0 in finals without ever playing a Game 7, except over more than double the sample size. And this is without considering the quality of the players he was up against in those finals... easily the greatest single achievement in the sport, at least for me.
 
No, 24 Slams is the greatest achievement.

8 year end #1 and 428 weeks at #1 are also greater than 14 RGs.
The greatest number of slams and a history making achievement by Novak.

Both players have extraordinary conversion rates on slam events entered so congrats to both.

It is also important to relate to the number of slams that each player entered and was able to play a match in. This allows for a conversion metric which can provide a different perspective on slam titles relational to opportunities to compete.

I researched the entries of both players on a few different sites, and the stats below are open to challenge, but you could argue that Rafa was the most successful at slams on the basis he won the greatest proportion of events he entered. The data below excludes quali's/walkovers.


MetricRafael NadalNovak Djokovic
Main Draws Played6884
Grand Slam Titles Won2224
Slam Title Conversion Rate32.42%28.62%

I still think that Novak is the Greatest of the modern era due to his all court/surface versatility, but total numbers without narrative do not tell the full story over a players career and are not the only numeric metric that should be used.
 
The greatest number of slams and a history making achievement by Novak.

Both players have extraordinary conversion rates on slam events entered so congrats to both.

It is also important to relate to the number of slams that each player entered and was able to play a match in. This allows for a conversion metric which can provide a different perspective on slam titles relational to opportunities to compete.

I researched the entries of both players on a few different sites, and the stats below are open to challenge, but you could argue that Rafa was the most successful at slams on the basis he won the greatest proportion of events he entered. The data below excludes quali's/walkovers.


MetricRafael NadalNovak Djokovic
Main Draws Played6884
Grand Slam Titles Won2224
Slam Title Conversion Rate32.42%28.62%

I still think that Novak is the Greatest of the modern era due to his all court/surface versatility, but total numbers without narrative do not tell the full story over a players career and are not the only numeric metric that should be used.
Borg 11/27 (40.7%) and Alcaraz 7/21 (33.3%) are greater than Nadal then
 
Federer will always remain the face of Tennis.

Nobody really cares about Djokovic Chamberlain era numbers.
He is the figurehead of The Big 3. He set such a bizarrely high standard for dominance and did it in such a freaky way that everyone had to reconsider what was possible.
 
Back
Top