Djokovic might be the GOAT, but the "single" greatest achievement/record in modern tennis is Nadal's 14 RG

You know you are talking to a guy who says 1995 and 2009 had the greatest depth of talent I have ever seen, yes?

What do you think I mean by that? :)
True but in most the discussions about greatness you have said multiple times the numbers is what you go off and the other stuff is just subjective like competition and level of play.
 
True but in most the discussions about greatness you have said multiple times the numbers is what you go off and the other stuff is just subjective like competition and level of play.

Yes. Because I always says winning counts the most. The name of the game is winning.

But you will often hear me saying Federer's prime ended at AO 2010, Nadal's at AO 2014 and Djokovic's at RG 2016 also.

I understand no player stays the same throughout their careers.

But I also weigh all titles historically the same way as the official governing bodies who run the sport do. Because ultimately, numbers are the only objective thing. Opinions about competition is subjective, the same way I speak about the depth of 1995, calling it the GOAT season with peak Sampras, peak Agassi on hard and grass and peak Muster on clay, plus prime Becker, Ivanisevic, Chang and others.
 
If you draw the line after the '23 season, Djokovic actually had the higher conversion rate.

Djokovic: slams=24, slams entered=84-12=72, conversion rate=24/72=33.3%.

Nadal: slams=22, slams entered=68-1=67, conversion rate=22/67=32.8%.
Rafa skipped the slams he was not winning anyway. He never skipped any RG in his slam winning years.
 
I agree, the clay field was a lot stronger overall in the 80s and 90s. I think Borg maxes out at 9-10.

But if he could have reached 9-10 then he would have. He was never winning that much given how burned out he was and younger guys had emerged. Even generously 7-8 is the max he reaches if we assume he takes 1-2 more.
 
But if he could have reached 9-10 then he would have. He was never winning that much given how burned out he was and younger guys had emerged. Even generously 7-8 is the max he reaches if we assume he takes 1-2 more.

He didn't win, because he was not mentally ready to continue competing.

He has his six RG slams, because that was all he could win.

But I will still give him another 3 to 4 slams on talent alone had he had the mindset to continue.

These are all hypotheticals/
 
He didn't win, because he was not mentally ready to continue competing.

He has his six RG slams, because that was all he could win.

But I will still give him another 3 to 4 slams on talent alone had he had the mindset to continue.

These are all hypotheticals/

Mindset is important too in sports

Shall we give Federer +10 slams and put him at 30 assuming he had more clutch and tough mindset in life?

Borg was afraid of Mac and the problems happening at that time with administrators, was burned out too as that era was not having the kind of "medicines" which today's players have, like these massage creams, createenas, TUIs and what not... So in a way Borg cannot be given more because he would have won more if he could but he did not.

Jimmy Connors who was 4 yrs older played the full 80s while Borg was too tired and scared of Mac, so we must not give him any pass.
 
Mindset is important too in sports

Shall we give Federer +10 slams and put him at 30 assuming he had more clutch and tough mindset in life?

Borg was afraid of Mac and the problems happening at that time with administrators, was burned out too as that era was not having the kind of "medicines" which today's players have, like these massage creams, createenas, TUIs and what not... So in a way Borg cannot be given more because he would have won more if he could but he did not.

Jimmy Connors who was 4 yrs older played the full 80s while Borg was too tired and scared of Mac, so we must not give him any pass.
awesome avatar!

This thread is a strange one. Outside Djokovic fans nobody considers Djokovic GOAT, and even his own fans dont really, given their obsession with Nadal and Federer.

Borg was the best of his era, his 1980 win over McEnroe at W gives him the edge over Mac really. At that level usually one match or two determines who was greater
 
Rafa skipped the slams he was not winning anyway. He never skipped any RG in his slam winning years.
What? Nadal dominated the USO 2010-2019, comfortably the best player there in that decade. Bur for injury definitely wins 2012, 2014, 2018.

Borg definitely would have had more slams as many on here have said bur for off court issues. Same applies to Nadal and now Alcaraz btw.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DSH
awesome avatar!

This thread is a strange one. Outside Djokovic fans nobody considers Djokovic GOAT, and even his own fans dont really, given their obsession with Nadal and Federer.

Borg was the best of his era, his 1980 win over McEnroe at W gives him the edge over Mac really. At that level usually one match or two determines who was greater

To be fair to Djokovic, we could call him the Goat on Hard Courts, his arguments are probably stronger than Federer and Sampras there.

On Grass however he is a phony, he is just not that good enough.

The people in my AVI are the GOATs on Grass along with Federer.

On Clay there is no argument, we all know who rules there, there never was any debate there.
 
I just can’t given AO goat to Djok considering he peaked lower than Safin, Fred Pete and Agassi there.

If you’re the GOAT at a surface you gotta at least have a higher peak than 2014 Stan roflmao.
 
Last edited:
Mindset is important too in sports

Shall we give Federer +10 slams and put him at 30 assuming he had more clutch and tough mindset in life?

Borg was afraid of Mac and the problems happening at that time with administrators, was burned out too as that era was not having the kind of "medicines" which today's players have, like these massage creams, createenas, TUIs and what not... So in a way Borg cannot be given more because he would have won more if he could but he did not.

Jimmy Connors who was 4 yrs older played the full 80s while Borg was too tired and scared of Mac, so we must not give him any pass.

That is what I am saying. He won what we did because he didn't have the mentality to continue playing.

That doesn't mean I am going pretend he didn't have the talent to win more RG with actual tennis and physical game had he actually been mentally capable.

The truth he, he won what he did.
 
Yes. Because I always says winning counts the most. The name of the game is winning.

But you will often hear me saying Federer's prime ended at AO 2010, Nadal's at AO 2014 and Djokovic's at RG 2016 also.

I understand no player stays the same throughout their careers.

But I also weigh all titles historically the same way as the official governing bodies who run the sport do. Because ultimately, numbers are the only objective thing. Opinions about competition is subjective, the same way I speak about the depth of 1995, calling it the GOAT season with peak Sampras, peak Agassi on hard and grass and peak Muster on clay, plus prime Becker, Ivanisevic, Chang and others.
Fair enough I just think some Djokovic fans don't realize they use the subjective arguments like competition and hypotheicals they dread to more than they admit. :)
 
Fair enough I just think some Djokovic fans don't realize they use the subjective arguments like competition and hypotheicals they dread to more than they admit. :)

Its very simple for me, I only care about the winning. :)
 
What? Nadal dominated the USO 2010-2019, comfortably the best player there in that decade. Bur for injury definitely wins 2012, 2014, 2018.

Borg definitely would have had more slams as many on here have said bur for off court issues. Same applies to Nadal and now Alcaraz btw.
US winning percentages: Djokovic 85.6% (ranking third), Nadal 84.8% (6th).

Djokovic enjoyed a 9-match and 19-set winning streak, on HC, on Nadal that lasted 10/'13 to Nadal's retirement.

Fair enough I just think some Djokovic fans don't realize they use the subjective arguments like competition and hypotheicals they dread to more than they admit. :)
Throughout his career, Djokovic has faced more tough competition than anyone else!

Against top 10: Djokovic, 266-122, 68.6% (2nd) winning percentage (all-time rank), 27.4% of his matches were against top10; Federer, 224-123, 64.6% (4th), 22.7%; and Nadal, 186-105, 63.9% (6th), 22.2%.

The data was at end of '25. Djokovic has played more against top10 than anyone; he was up 42 victories, and down one loss, on Federer.

And he played 27.4% of his matches against top10, whereas Federer and Nadal played 22.7% and 22.2%.

That meant that, if Federer faced one top10, then Djokovic would face (27.4-22.7)/22.7=20.7% or one-fifth more. Or, if Federer faced five top10, then Djokovic would face six.
 
Last edited:
US winning percentages: Djokovic 85.6% (ranking third), Nadal 84.8% (6th).

Djokovic enjoyed a 9-match and 19-set winning streak, on HC, on Nadal that lasted 10/'13 to Nadal's retirement.


Throughout his career, Djokovic has faced more tough competition than anyone else!

Against top 10: Djokovic, 266-122, 68.6% (2nd) winning percentage (all-time rank), 27.4% of his matches were against top10; Federer, 224-123, 64.6% (4th), 22.7%; and Nadal, 186-105, 63.9% (6th), 22.2%.

The data was at end of '25. Djokovic has played more against top10 than anyone; he was up 42 victories, and down one loss, on Federer.

And he played 27.4% of his matches against top10, whereas Federer and Nadal played 22.7% and 22.2%.
That's not quite what I meant lol.
 
images


Come back if/when Djokovic gets his...
What, a flash eating disease?
 
What? Nadal dominated the USO 2010-2019, comfortably the best player there in that decade. Bur for injury definitely wins 2012, 2014, 2018.

Borg definitely would have had more slams as many on here have said bur for off court issues. Same applies to Nadal and now Alcaraz btw.
The “GOAT of the USO” lost to Djokovic, Del Potro, Fognini and Pouille in that period.

He never definitely wins any outdoor hard court event because even in his major winning years, he won 22 of 94 (23%) he entered from 2005-2022. Meanwhile Djokovic won 43 of 76 (57%). from 2011-2019, in the period you are talking about. And Rafa was 13 from 44 (29%) in that period. Fed was (31%) was in the same period.

So absolutely no definite about it, the amount of BS spamming, Rafa fans will try to inflate his achievements and abilities off Clay is absolutely ridiculous.
 
The “GOAT of the USO” lost to Djokovic, Del Potro, Fognini and Pouille in that period.

He never definitely wins any outdoor hard court event because even in his major winning years, he won 22 of 94 (23%) he entered from 2005-2022. Meanwhile Djokovic won 43 of 76 (57%). from 2011-2019, in the period you are talking about. And Rafa was 13 from 44 (29%) in that period. Fed was (31%) was in the same period.

So absolutely no definite about it, the amount of BS spamming, Rafa fans will try to inflate his achievements and abilities off Clay is absolutely ridiculous.
Rafa only dared to challenge the HC GOAT at HC slams 5 times throughout his entire career. 4 of those times came after Nole had played a 5-setter SF, and he still fumbled half of them. The only time Nole didn't have a 5-setter SF, Rafa got destroyed at AO19, and he has hidden from Nole at every slam outside of RG ever since.
 
Haha..so jelly.

No one cares about Djokovic’s 15 asterisk slams, ergo he has no statue.
Federer had more, much more asterisk slams.

Take a look: first 17 of Djokovic's slams were against Federer, Nadal, Murray, Wawrinka, del Potro & Thiem!

Most of Federer's first slams were against Roddick, Hewitt and Davydenko. He was undefeated against those guys, 21-0!

I bet you don't want to see the truth, so you won't check them!
 
In GOAT race, Djokovic > Nadal. But I can't wrap my head around how 14 RG's being the single greatest achievement in modern tennis is even a debate. Nadal's 14 RG is equal TO THE SLAM RECORD the previous generation. He won 14 slams in 14 years, is equal to career span of most of the GOAT and ATG candidates. He has more than 2 times the record of highest titles(6), 4 times the record of next number of highest wins at the event(3).

Read that again. Incomprehensible, ridiculous and unbeatable.

Djokovic is GOAT because he has almost every record to his name. And he maybe is the best player of all time. But there should be no doubt that this one record of Nadal is the greatest if we talk of singular records/achievements.
Longevity & domination wise Nadal 14 RG will stand the test of time , Djokovic holding all 4 slams on 3 different surface is probably the highest peak in tennis history.
The beauty is in the eye of beholder .

images


images
 
I think he could have got more but not to 14.
Minimum 8, maximum 9.
For Borg fans, how many Grand Slam titles could he have won between 1982 and 1986 had he wanted (and been able) to play in the Major tournaments in that time frame?
:unsure:
 
  • Like
Reactions: RS
It might be harder to achieve, but if you ask any tennis player what record would they rather have, the answer would be unanimous, 24>14...
 
Minimum 8, maximum 9.
For Borg fans, how many Grand Slam titles could he have won between 1982 and 1986 had he wanted (and been able) to play in the Major tournaments in that time frame?
:unsure:

Yes I was thinking 8-9. Guess we will never know though.
 
The “GOAT of the USO” lost to Djokovic, Del Potro, Fognini and Pouille in that period.

He never definitely wins any outdoor hard court event because even in his major winning years, he won 22 of 94 (23%) he entered from 2005-2022. Meanwhile Djokovic won 43 of 76 (57%). from 2011-2019, in the period you are talking about. And Rafa was 13 from 44 (29%) in that period. Fed was (31%) was in the same period.

So absolutely no definite about it, the amount of BS spamming, Rafa fans will try to inflate his achievements and abilities off Clay is absolutely ridiculous.
So why did at the USO Nadal dominate Djokovic in 2 of 3 finals? Is Djokovic not considered the greatest hard court player?

Nadals losses to Del Potro were both due to injury as were the losses to Fogini (more accurately lack of match fitness due to previous injuries ) and pouille (recovering from a serious wrist issue).

Apart from Federer who won 5 in a row, nobody has been as dominant at the USO as Nadal when he was able to play fully fit or close to fit since Sampras.
 
To be fair to Djokovic, we could call him the Goat on Hard Courts, his arguments are probably stronger than Federer and Sampras there.

On Grass however he is a phony, he is just not that good enough.

The people in my AVI are the GOATs on Grass along with Federer.

On Clay there is no argument, we all know who rules there, there never was any debate there.
Agree with all that
 
14 RG's is possibly the greatest single achievement in any sport, even more so when taken in context of the injuries over that period.


100%. This while having to battle the two biggest rivals in tennis history. And the actual clay court win/loss record is mind blowing.

This is what defines all-time greats in sports. Pure dominance.
 
So why did at the USO Nadal dominate Djokovic in 2 of 3 finals? Is Djokovic not considered the greatest hard court player?

Nadals losses to Del Potro were both due to injury as were the losses to Fogini (more accurately lack of match fitness due to previous injuries ) and pouille (recovering from a serious wrist issue).

Apart from Federer who won 5 in a row, nobody has been as dominant at the USO as Nadal when he was able to play fully fit or close to fit since Sampras.
I don’t doubt Nadal’s elite capability on HC. But he also got beaten a lot in HC majors before the final stage. That’s what makes his HC legacy a good tier or maybe two below Federer and Djokovic along with his much worse HC tournament strike rate and performance against top 10 players on HC.
 
I don’t doubt Nadal’s elite capability on HC. But he also got beaten a lot in HC majors before the final stage. That’s what makes his HC legacy a good tier or maybe two below Federer and Djokovic along with his much worse HC tournament strike rate and performance against top 10 players on HC.
We are talking the US Open. Nadal was practically unbeatable 2010-2019 there when fit.

Australian Open your point is valid.
 
We are talking the US Open. Nadal was practically unbeatable 2010-2019 there when fit

Australian Open your point is valid.
I’d take huge issue with that statement. Whilst Nadal displayed very impressive top levels, Nadal to my mind could never be classed as “unbeatable” on any hard court period. Fit or not fit, peak or not peak. The differences between his levels at RG 05-22 where he was almost unbeatable and 10-19 US where he wasn’t imo, are huge.

Novak beat him pretty comfortably in US11, he missed 12 and 14. He was off form (for him 15/16) losing to Fognini and Pouille, 17 he doesn’t face a top 10 player, 18 Del Potro is in control before he retires, 19 Meddy is the only top 10 player he plays. So that means the years 12, 14, 15, 16, 17, 19, are 6 out those potential 10 US Opens where he literally faces 1 top 10 player.

And that fact is highly significant when you look at his record at the US and hardcourts in general against top 10 players. Remember, he’s 7-5 against top 10 players in his career at the US Open. And from 08-13 in his peak, he’s only 5-3 versus top 10 players at the US. He has just played so few top 10 players at the US to make your “unbeatable” statement even close to believable.

His overall career record on hard against top 10 players is 75-75. He was never the best player on hardcourt 2 seasons in a row and never the best player at the US open 2 seasons in a row.

Added to the fact he was so regularly beaten in hardcourt masters even during his peak, that I could never label him as unbeatable on a hardcourt, to try and suggest he was over a 10 year period is absurd, despite again giving him full credit for his very high level best performances.
 
Last edited:
We are talking the US Open. Nadal was practically unbeatable 2010-2019 there when fit.

Australian Open your point is valid.
On any HC against his two main rivals:

Rafa could not win a single match against Fed after 2014.

Rafa could not win a single set against Nole after 2013.
 
On any HC against his two main rivals:

Rafa could not win a single match against Fed after 2014.

Rafa could not win a single set against Nole after 2013.
Rafa fan has habit of glorifying Nadal outside of clay court.
Every win against federer and novak is glorified to such heights that sometimes you think RAFA UNDERACHEIVED outside clay but for a player whose bread and butter was clay court he overacheived BIG TIME.
 
14 might not be broken because most ATGs don’t have the interest or stupidity in being so one-dimensional, especially in the least important surface and slam.
 
Djokovic could have easily beaten 14 RGs if that’s what he chose to dedicate his life to. But he simply had much bigger fish to fry.
 
At the Us Open.

Why are you judging Nadal post his peak lol. Desperation
Are you crazy or something.
By your definetion Nadal was past his peak / prime years and still continued for 10 more years and won majors till 2022.
And you will shower praise on Nadal for staying relevant till 2022 and crucify Novak for his 2023 heroics.
By the way when did Novak past his prime ?
 
Back
Top