I absolutely agree, and this might be the best era in sports, ever. All 3 (or 4) improved each other, and also prevented each other from even greater records, such that it's clear that all 3 are better than any other players in history.
Having said that, it's clear to me that as of now, Roger is the overall GOAT with Novak a close 2nd*, and Nadal is the King of Clay but off it "merely" ATG.
*With the caveat that neither are done and Novak may well finish ahead, or close enough that neither can claim it.
Is it important to me that Fedr = GOAT? Yeah, in all honesty I guess it does, a bit. I'm a fan of his. I'll be a fan of his even if he's not the GOAT, because of style and class, but mainly it annoys me that people cherry pick data and focus on things like H2H that don't mean as much as they think.
So that's my honest rant: I try not to get dragged into goat debates, but I wish everyone else could just leave it alone for a while so we could just be fans of the sport.