Djokovic the least mentally strong of Big 3

Misrepresented "statistics" backing up a flawed idea of what mental strength is.

"Because Nadal is the only 2-time Wimbledon champion in the Open Era to lose before the QFs four straight times to an ace, he has poor mental strength."

See, I can do it, too.
No as techincal deficiency is not mental weakness. Djokovic has the worse conversion rate of SF and F appearances to trophies of the big 3. I just circle back and follow the science to speak
 
Yes, Federer did say it. He was obviously feeling pain. That doesn't make it true, which is how you represented it. Your point about Becker is my point. For a guy like Becker it would be a bad tactic. He missed big and often. He was not a steady player. For more balanced players who can play both offensively and defensively, it is a valid tactic. In fact, to make a general rule, as you have, is to take tennis IQ out of the equation. I've said this before. Tennis is a cat and mouse game where you push and pull. You look to play offensively without redlining and you try to coax your opponent into the redline. In the course of a match I will go through dozens of transitions between attempting to control the point and attempting to force my opponent to hit a bigger shot to win the point than he can consistently manage.
When i play when i get a BP SP or MP i go big. Fortune favours the brave is my motto.
 
What are the chances of blowing 3 overheads in the span of 11 points (Nadal, '21 AO QF 3rd set TB), when you've an excellent overhead? Not more than 1%, I'd guess!

I bet that was the 1st time ever Nadal missed 3 overheads in a span of 11 points in Slam competition!

Djokovic has lost many times in Slam competition to opponents inferior in quality to Murray and Wawrinka, and will continue to do so!
 
As late as summer of 2014, Djoker had a losing record in slam finals. Nadal, Fed, Pete and Borg never had a losing record in slam finals.

Yes, Djoker has done his fair share of choking.

Basically until the beginning of the career inflation era, he had a losing record in slam finals. all the Djokovic boat stuff is just recency bias from those who’ve forgotten or never watched the strong era
 
When i play when i get a BP SP or MP i go big. Fortune favours the brave is my motto.
I wish I could play you. Sounds like a mindless motto. There is certainly nothing "brave" in the game of tennis. Bold, foolish? Yes. What do you think about exploring the idea of a thread for actual competition, challenges among forum participants? Perhaps the first challenge, rather than guns at dawn, brave, we could post videos of us playing tennis and the board could comment on who would beat whom. After that, if no one felt satisfied we could bet a plane ticket and film the competition, to be posted once again. I think it might be fun.
 
No as techincal deficiency is not mental weakness. Djokovic has the worse conversion rate of SF and F appearances to trophies of the big 3. I just circle back and follow the science to speak

You have yet to show how this relates to mental weakness.

You wonder why everyone says Djokovic is mentally tough and Federer isn't? Because everyone else's explanations make sense and yours doesn't.
 
At the '17 AO Final, Nadal led Federer 4-2 in the final set!

In an earlier post, I asked rhetorically what was the probability of Rafa's losing the next 4 games (which he actually did) to lose the match. I was guessing it was about 5%! Now, I'm going to quantify it statistically!

Let's assume that when either Federer or Nadal serve, he has an 80% of winning the service game, and the returner has an 20% of winning (quite reasonable assumption). So the probability of Federer winning both of his, and both of Nadal's service games is .8 x .2 x .8 x .2 = 2.6%!

So Nadal had only a 2.6% probability of losing the next 4 games consecutively, and he did just that!
 
Losing to an underdog doesn't qualify as choking, as everyone does it, and especially when the underdog is a mainstay in the top 10 (such as Murray and Wawrinka).

Losing 3 times to Dustin Brown in Wimbledon may warrant special scrutiny however! Not because it was Dustin Brown, but because of Brown's highest ranking of 64, and it was 3 times!

But choking does occur if you lose from a overwhelmingly winning position (>90%): such as holding double matchpoints, especially on your serve!

Choking is also involved when you find such unlikely circumstances to lose! If Nadal hadn't flubbed 3 overheads in the 3rd set TB against Tsisipas, he most likely would've won the '21 AO QF! How likely was it for Nadal to flub 3 overheads in the span of 11 points (the length of the TB), given that he has such a dependable one? Very unlikely, I could only guess it at 1%!
 
Nadal lost 2 AO finals ('12 Djokovic, '17 Federer) in very similar circumstances. IMO, one was a choke, the other wasn't!

In both, Nadal was serving 4-2 in the 5th, with one break in hand. Probably, at that point, his chances of winning were probably around 70%, a good, but not overwhelming percentage!

In '12, Nadal's match chances never increased, as Djokovic broke back, and went on to win 7-5! This wasn't a choke, since Djokovic's chances of breaking any of Nadal's service games hover around 20%!

In '17, from 2-4 in the 5th, Federer broke Nadal twice, and held twice to win 6-4. What were his chances of doing so?

Federer's chances of breaking any of Nadal's service games were 20%; breaking two consecutive Nadal's games were 4%; breaking 2 consecutive Nadal's games, and holding his 2 service games were 2.6%. This was a choke, because the circumstances with only abysmally small chances of happening, did happen!
 
Last edited:
How can you watch USO15 and W19 and conclude that Novak is the weakest mentally of the 3? :D
 
Back
Top