Djokovic's and Federer's h2h against players both faced 10+ times

We know Djokovic leads 27-23 the h2h with Federer, but Fed fans say it was just due to lucky circumstances. So let's also see the h2h against players they both faced 10+ times:

vs Nadal = Djokovic 31-29 (51.7% win rate) > Federer 16-24 (40.0%)
vs Murray = Djokovic 25-11 (69.4%) > Federer 14-11 (56.0%)
vs Berdych = Djokovic 25-3 (89.3%) > Federer 20-6 (76.9%)
vs Wawrinka = Federer 23-3 (88.5%) > Djokovic 21-6 (77.8%)
vs Tsonga = Djokovic 17-6 (73.9%) > Federer 12-6 (66.7%)
vs Cilic = Djokovic 20-2 (90.9%) > Federer 10-1 (90.9%) - same win percentage but Nole has more wins
vs Nishikori = Djokovic 18-2 (90.0%) > Federer 8-3 (72.7%)
vs Ferrer = Federer 17-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 16-5 (76.2%)
vs Del Potro = Djokovic 16-4 (80.0%) > Federer 18-7 (72.0%)
vs Monfils = Djokovic 20-0 (100.0%) > Federer 10-4 (71.4%)
vs Gasquet = Djokovic 13-1 (92.9%) > Federer 19-2 (90.5%)
vs Stepanek = Djokovic 13-1 (92.9%) > Federer 14-2 (87.5%)
vs Kohlschreiber = Federer 14-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 12-2 (85.7%)
vs Raonic = Djokovic 12-0 (100.0%) > Federer 11-3 (78.6%)
vs Seppi = Djokovic 12-0 (100.0%) > Federer 14-1 (93.3%)
vs Youzhny = Federer 17-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 7-3 (70.0%)
vs Lopez = Federer 13-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 9-1 (90.0%)

So out of 17 opponents that both played 10+ times, Djokovic has better h2h than Federer against 12 of them. Add to that the actual h2h between the two, and Djokovic has better h2h in 13 out of 18.

total head to head against players both faced 10+ times including the h2h between them:

Djokovic 314-99 (76.03%)
Federer 273-100 (73.19%)

As you can see, the h2h between Djokovic and Federer is not just about circumstances, Nole also performed better against the opponents they both faced.
 
We know Djokovic leads 27-23 the h2h with Federer, but Fed fans say it was just due to lucky circumstances. So let's also see the h2h against players they both faced 10+ times:

vs Nadal = Djokovic 31-29 (51.7% win rate) > Federer 16-24 (40.0%)
vs Murray = Djokovic 25-11 (69.4%) > Federer 14-11 (56.0%)
vs Berdych = Djokovic 25-3 (89.3%) > Federer 20-6 (76.9%)
vs Wawrinka = Federer 23-3 (88.5%) > Djokovic 21-6 (77.8%)
vs Tsonga = Djokovic 17-6 (73.9%) > Federer 12-6 (66.7%)
vs Cilic = Djokovic 20-2 (90.9%) = Federer 10-1 (90.9%) - same win percentage so this one is a tie
vs Nishikori = Djokovic 18-2 (90.0%) > Federer 8-3 (72.7%)
vs Ferrer = Federer 17-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 16-5 (76.2%)
vs Del Potro = Djokovic 16-4 (80.0%) > Federer 18-7 (72.0%)
vs Monfils = Djokovic 20-0 (100.0%) > Federer 10-4 (71.4%)
vs Gasquet = Djokovic 13-1 (92.9%) > Federer 19-2 (90.5%)
vs Stepanek = Djokovic 13-1 (92.9%) > Federer 14-2 (87.5%)
vs Kohlschreiber = Federer 14-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 12-2 (85.7%)
vs Raonic = Djokovic 12-0 (100.0%) > Federer 11-3 (78.6%)
vs Seppi = Djokovic 12-0 (100.0%) > Federer 14-1 (93.3%)
vs Youzhny = Federer 17-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 7-3 (70.0%)
vs Lopez = Federer 13-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 9-1 (90.0%)

So out of 17 opponents that both played 10+ times, Djokovic has better h2h than Federer against 11 of them, with Federer having a better h2h in 5, and one tied. Add to that the actual h2h between the two, and Djokovic has better h2h in 12 out of 18.

total head to head against players both faced 10+ times including the h2h between them:

Djokovic 314-99 (76.03%)
Federer 273-100 (73.19%)

As you can see, the h2h between Djokovic and Federer is not just about circumstances, Nole also performed better against the opponents they both faced.

Wrong about Cilic. It doesn't do you any good to call a tie a win. It makes it seem like you're cherry picking, which other posters have already accused you of doing. 20-2 = 10-1. Neither is better. You could as easily say 10-1 is better because it involves fewer losses as that 20-2 is better because it involves more wins. Both arguments are equally fallacious.

I fixed your post for you. You should edit it, too, as the case looks solid without you engaging in those shenanigans about Cilic.
 
Wrong about Cilic. It doesn't do you any good to call a tie a win. It makes it seem like you're cherry picking, which other posters have already accused you of doing. 20-2 = 10-1. Neither is better. You could as easily say 10-1 is better because it involves fewer losses as that 20-2 is better because it involves more wins. Both arguments are equally fallacious.

I fixed your post for you. You should edit it, too, as the case looks solid without you engaging in those shenanigans about Cilic.
1-0 and 100-0 both are 100% but....
 
Wrong about Cilic. It doesn't do you any good to call a tie a win. It makes it seem like you're cherry picking, which other posters have already accused you of doing. 20-2 = 10-1. Neither is better. You could as easily say 10-1 is better because it involves fewer losses as that 20-2 is better because it involves more wins. Both arguments are equally fallacious.

I fixed your post for you. You should edit it, too, as the case looks solid without you engaging in those shenanigans about Cilic.
Disagree, a bigger sample size is almost always more impressive. 300 wins/3 losses is more impressive than 100 wins/1 loss. Just because it's usually harder to maintain a great win rate when you play more matches.
 
Disagree, a bigger sample size is almost always more impressive. 300 wins/3 losses is more impressive than 100 wins/1 loss. Just because it's usually harder to maintain a great win rate when you play more matches.

If you are the better player, it is actually statistically easier to win a long series than a short one. (Hence upsets are more common in Bo3 than in Bo5, for example).
 
If you are the better player, it is actually statistically easier to win a long series than a short one. (Hence upsets are more common in Bo3 than in Bo5, for example).
Yes, but a series takes place in a short period of time. Career h2h between contemporary elite players generally spans many years, there are many factors involved (form, health, age, courts, conditions, etc).
Federer > Safin > Djokovic
Djokovic > Zverev > Federer
Djokovic > Thiem > Federer
 
Djokovic > Zverev > Federer
Djokovic > Thiem > Federer

Zverev and Thiem - too much age difference to take their H2H’s with Federer seriously

Age wise Federer to Djokovic is like Djokovic to Safin.
So if Federer Djokovic H2H has any credibility then that means Safins H2H with Djokovic must be credible too. Not to mention Roddicks ;)
 
Yes, but a series takes place in a short period of time. Career h2h between contemporary elite players generally spans many years, there are many factors involved (form, health, age, courts, conditions, etc).

Djokovic > Zverev > Federer
Djokovic > Thiem > Federer

Cilic isn't an elite player to the extent that Djokovic and Federer are, so the more matches the play, the less likely he is to win a high percentage of them. Despite that, him winning 10% against them means that the H2H is equal, regardless of the number of matches played.
 
Wrong about Cilic. It doesn't do you any good to call a tie a win. It makes it seem like you're cherry picking, which other posters have already accused you of doing. 20-2 = 10-1. Neither is better. You could as easily say 10-1 is better because it involves fewer losses as that 20-2 is better because it involves more wins. Both arguments are equally fallacious.

I fixed your post for you. You should edit it, too, as the case looks solid without you engaging in those shenanigans about Cilic.
The bigger sample size the better.

Also, Fed lost a Slam semi to Cilic, while Nole owned Cilic 5-0 at Slams. Cilic definitely damaged Fed more than Nole.
 
Last edited:
Most of these players are younger than fed, and some by a decent amount.

Notice fed has a better record with the older guys?
Why didn't Nole face 10+ times many players from Fed's gen?

Why no Safin, no Roddick, no Hewitt, no Nalbandian, no Davydenko, etc.?

Why were they thrown out of the game so early?

Maybe these words from Roddick give us an answer:

"I remember in the 2012 Olympics, I played Novak 2nd round. I was unseeded but had won a couple weeks before and won two of the last three tournaments I played in so I was feeling great. I felt like Wimbledon was a place where I could still catch lightning in a bottle, make a bit of a run. Felt great in practice that week, went out 2nd round. Novak was someone who I had a decent record against at that point and he beat me like a drum. I was like a child on the court and I didn't play that bad. I lost two and two on grass. I walked off the court and thought I'm going to go out tomorrow and feel like I'm playing well. He just beat me like a drum and that was one of the first times where I thought this game is getting a little bit different than what I've been used to, these guys are from another planet right now. That one kind of hit home for me. The way he was playing in that moment was eye opening."
 
All players from Fed's gen retired early because they could not keep up with the evolution of the game.

The prize money and endorsements got much richer in the Big4 era. Why should have they retired if they were good enough to still be top players?
 
To Novak fans ......They already know Novak is better player than Federer .
If we start tp compare stats
Federer will be losing more than he will win.
To Federer fans..... They all are high aristocratic class who wear TIMELESS Rolex and take their weekly dose of religious experince with Roger .
 
We know Djokovic leads 27-23 the h2h with Federer, but Fed fans say it was just due to lucky circumstances. So let's also see the h2h against players they both faced 10+ times:

vs Nadal = Djokovic 31-29 (51.7% win rate) > Federer 16-24 (40.0%)
vs Murray = Djokovic 25-11 (69.4%) > Federer 14-11 (56.0%)
vs Berdych = Djokovic 25-3 (89.3%) > Federer 20-6 (76.9%)
vs Wawrinka = Federer 23-3 (88.5%) > Djokovic 21-6 (77.8%)
vs Tsonga = Djokovic 17-6 (73.9%) > Federer 12-6 (66.7%)
vs Cilic = Djokovic 20-2 (90.9%) > Federer 10-1 (90.9%) - same win percentage but Nole has more wins
vs Nishikori = Djokovic 18-2 (90.0%) > Federer 8-3 (72.7%)
vs Ferrer = Federer 17-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 16-5 (76.2%)
vs Del Potro = Djokovic 16-4 (80.0%) > Federer 18-7 (72.0%)
vs Monfils = Djokovic 20-0 (100.0%) > Federer 10-4 (71.4%)
vs Gasquet = Djokovic 13-1 (92.9%) > Federer 19-2 (90.5%)
vs Stepanek = Djokovic 13-1 (92.9%) > Federer 14-2 (87.5%)
vs Kohlschreiber = Federer 14-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 12-2 (85.7%)
vs Raonic = Djokovic 12-0 (100.0%) > Federer 11-3 (78.6%)
vs Seppi = Djokovic 12-0 (100.0%) > Federer 14-1 (93.3%)
vs Youzhny = Federer 17-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 7-3 (70.0%)
vs Lopez = Federer 13-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 9-1 (90.0%)

So out of 17 opponents that both played 10+ times, Djokovic has better h2h than Federer against 12 of them. Add to that the actual h2h between the two, and Djokovic has better h2h in 13 out of 18.

total head to head against players both faced 10+ times including the h2h between them:

Djokovic 314-99 (76.03%)
Federer 273-100 (73.19%)

As you can see, the h2h between Djokovic and Federer is not just about circumstances, Nole also performed better against the opponents they both faced.
Federer won more than half the points he played against Djokovic, even though they played many, many matches when Federer was really old.

Federer is the only player who played against Djokovic 10 or more times and had a leading dominance ratio against him until recently when sinner did it.

Even despite the age advantage, the racket technology advantage, the stroke advantage, Djokovic is three points away from trailing the head to head 24-26.

So yes, lucky circumstances.

Also, nice cherry picking to avoid Roddick lol.

Djokovic: 4-5 vs. Roddick, Federer 21-3

Or Haas

Djokovic: 3-6, Federer 13-4
 
Federer won more than half the points he played against Djokovic, even though they played many, many matches when Federer was really old.

Federer is the only player who played against Djokovic 10 or more times and had a leading dominance ratio against him until recently when sinner did it.

Even despite the age advantage, the racket technology advantage, the stroke advantage, Djokovic is three points away from trailing the head to head 24-26.

So yes, lucky circumstances
In tennis you must win matches, not points.

If you win many points but then lose the match you are just a choker.
 
In tennis you must win matches, not points.

If you win many points but then lose the match you are just a choker.
Three points is lucky circumstances which is what you’re arguing against the original post.

It seems kind of strange that the player who had the age advantage, for the majority of the rivalry, has the racket technology advantage, for the entire rivalry, had the stroke advantage, for the entire rivalry could not win more than half the points against Federer and the most lopsided wins between the two belong to the person who had the age disadvantage, the racket technology, disadvantage, and the stroke disadvantage.
 
Three points is lucky circumstances which is what you’re arguing against the original post.

It seems kind of strange that the player who had the age advantage, for the majority of the rivalry, has the racket technology advantage, for the entire rivalry, had the stroke advantage, for the entire rivalry could not win more than half the points against Federer and the most lopsided wins between the two belong to the person who had the age disadvantage, the racket technology, disadvantage, and the stroke disadvantage.
The thread shows that it was not luck, Djokovic was also better against the opponents that both faced.

And also has more Slams, YECs, Masters, weeks at #1, years at #1, career Slams, career Masters, ncygs, wins over top5, over top10s, win percentage, etc.
 
This is for that great mathmetician who in earlier post is saying 20 2 and 10 1 are both equal.
You will better have 20 dollars in pocket and spend 2 rather than having 10 dollars in your pocket and spend 1.
No player will say i am satisfied with 10 wins against opponent when he can win 20 .
 
This is for that great mathmetician who in earlier post is saying 20 2 and 10 1 are both equal.
You will better have 20 dollars in pocket and spend 2 rather than having 10 dollars in your pocket and spend 1.
No player will say i am satisfied with 10 wins against opponent when he can win 20 .
By the way Federer lost a Slam semifinal to Cilic while Djokovic owned Cilic in all the big matches.

If the twice bigger sample size doesn't break the tie, the UO14 loss does.
 
By the way Federer lost a Slam semifinal to Cilic while Djokovic owned Cilic in all the big matches.

If the bigger sample size doesn't break the tie, the UO14 loss does.
I assume we are not going in deep details that which match was more important than others.
Even without any context 20 2 is better than 10 1 .
Because we are discussing playing matches and not doing RATIO
 
Three points is lucky circumstances which is what you’re arguing against the original post.

It seems kind of strange that the player who had the age advantage, for the majority of the rivalry, has the racket technology advantage, for the entire rivalry, had the stroke advantage, for the entire rivalry could not win more than half the points against Federer and the most lopsided wins between the two belong to the person who had the age disadvantage, the racket technology, disadvantage, and the stroke disadvantage.
And by the way Nole has a career history of winning close matches, so it's not luck, it's mental strength.

Djokovic:
matches won saving match points = 17
matches lost wasting match points = 4
Ratio = 4.25

Federer:
matches won saving match points = 22
matches lost wasting match points = 24
Ratio = 0.92
 
And by the way Nole has a career history of winning close matches, so it's not luck, it's mental strength.

Djokovic:
matches won saving match points = 17
matches lost wasting match points = 4
Ratio = 4.25

Federer:
matches won saving match points = 22
matches won wasting match points = 24
Ratio = 0.92

Age advantage, racket tech advantage, stroke advantage, and couldn’t win more than half the points because he’s an inferior talent
 
Cilic isn't an elite player to the extent that Djokovic and Federer are, so the more matches the play, the less likely he is to win a high percentage of them. Despite that, him winning 10% against them means that the H2H is equal, regardless of the number of matches played.
Isn't Cilic better than some of the players that Federer had a worse win rate against? Another thing, if Borg had one loss at RG instead of two, would you consider him better than Nadal there?
Age advantage, racket tech advantage, stroke advantage, and couldn’t win more than half the points because he’s an inferior talent
Not even 6 years difference. The worse version of the two to play in this matchup was young Novak by far. Federer always played with "home crowd". Federer started using poly strings in 2002, Djokovic in 2008, nice try. Djokovic from a modest family in a war torn country, Federer from a rich family in Switzerland. Oh, and Federer winning more than half of the points is nothing more than serve shenanigans, since his serve was better than Novak's for the entirety of the rivalry.
 
Not even 6 years difference. The worse version of the two to play in this matchup was young Novak by far. Federer always played with "home crowd". Federer started using poly strings in 2002, Djokovic in 2008, nice try. Djokovic from a modest family in a war torn country, Federer from a rich family in Switzerland. Oh, and Federer winning more than half of the points is nothing more than serve shenanigans, since his serve was better than Novak's for the entirety of the rivalry.
Everyone from Fed's gen already used a two handed backhand: Safin, Roddick, Hewitt, Ferrero, Nalbandian, Davydenko, Coria, Ferrer, etc.. It's not like the two handed backhand was a secret that was kept away Federer. Federer simply played better with a one handed backhand.

Those he mentioned are all just theories, while those I presented are facts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: vix
Everyone from Fed's gen already used a two handed backhand: Safin, Roddick, Hewitt, Ferrero, Nalbandian, Davydenko, Coria, Ferrer, etc.. It's not like the two handed backhand was a secret that was kept away Federer. Federer simply played better with a one handed backhand.

Those he mentioned are all just theories, while those I presented are facts.
Not to mention Agassi, who had probably the best backhand ever back then. He is way older than Fed, so it is Federer's "fault" for choosing the OHBH. Oh, and Federer probably wouldn't have the same slice and backhand volley if he played with a two handed, so probably it was really better for him to have stuck with the OHBH.
 
All players from Fed's gen retired early because they could not keep up with the evolution of the game.

The prize money and endorsements got much richer in the Big4 era. Why should have they retired if they were good enough to still be top players?
Then nothing has changed, there are zero players older than 31 in top40 except Djokovic.
 
Then nothing has changed, there are zero players older than 31 in top40 except Djokovic.
Fed's gen declined at like age 26-28, except Ferrer. While many players in Nole's gen were strong until their late 20s and early 30s (Stan, Berdych, Tsonga, Gasquet, Monfils, Anderson, Isner, Del Potro, Cilic, Bautista Agut)

Fed's gen was thrown out of the game quickly. They were pretty bad.
 
Fed's gen declined at like age 26-28, except Ferrer. While many players in Nole's gen were strong until their late 20s and early 30s (Stan, Berdych, Tsonga, Gasquet, Monfils, Anderson, etc.)

Fed's gen was thrown out of the game quickly. They were pretty bad.
About the same as Medvedev/Tsitsipas then ;)

85-88 gen was extremely strong, ive never said otherwise. Thats why Federer won so few slams in his 30s despite playing good.
 
About the same as Medvedev/Tsitsipas then ;)

85-88 gen was extremely strong, ive never said otherwise. Thats why Federer won so few slams in his 30s despite playing good.
But what does this have to do with the thread?

This thread is about the h2h against opponents both played 10+ times, and there's no way to know how Nole would have done against players of Fed's gen if they didn't retire early. It's completely hypothetical while this thread is about real matches.

Roddick has expressed how the h2h would have gone if he kept playing, he said Nole and the tour in general upped the level in 2012 so likely Roddick would have been dominated:

"I remember in the 2012 Olympics, I played Novak 2nd round. I was unseeded but had won a couple weeks before and won two of the last three tournaments I played in so I was feeling great. I felt like Wimbledon was a place where I could still catch lightning in a bottle, make a bit of a run. Felt great in practice that week, went out 2nd round. Novak was someone who I had a decent record against at that point and he beat me like a drum. I was like a child on the court and I didn't play that bad. I lost two and two on grass. I walked off the court and thought I'm going to go out tomorrow and feel like I'm playing well. He just beat me like a drum and that was one of the first times where I thought this game is getting a little bit different than what I've been used to, these guys are from another planet right now. That one kind of hit home for me. The way he was playing in that moment was eye opening."
 
But what does this have to do with the thread?

This thread is about the h2h against opponents both played 10+ times, and there's no way to know how Nole would have done against players of Fed's gen if they didn't retire early. It's completely hypothetical while this thread is about real matches.

Roddick has expressed how the h2h would have gone if he kept playing, he said Nole and the tour in general upped the level in 2012 so likely Roddick would have been dominated:

"I remember in the 2012 Olympics, I played Novak 2nd round. I was unseeded but had won a couple weeks before and won two of the last three tournaments I played in so I was feeling great. I felt like Wimbledon was a place where I could still catch lightning in a bottle, make a bit of a run. Felt great in practice that week, went out 2nd round. Novak was someone who I had a decent record against at that point and he beat me like a drum. I was like a child on the court and I didn't play that bad. I lost two and two on grass. I walked off the court and thought I'm going to go out tomorrow and feel like I'm playing well. He just beat me like a drum and that was one of the first times where I thought this game is getting a little bit different than what I've been used to, these guys are from another planet right now. That one kind of hit home for me. The way he was playing in that moment was eye opening."
Lets be honest, almost all your threads are about the same thing, to prove Djokovic > Federer ;)
 
Why didn't Nole face 10+ times many players from Fed's gen?

Why no Safin, no Roddick, no Hewitt, no Nalbandian, no Davydenko, etc.?

Why were they thrown out of the game so early?

Maybe these words from Roddick give us an answer:

"I remember in the 2012 Olympics, I played Novak 2nd round. I was unseeded but had won a couple weeks before and won two of the last three tournaments I played in so I was feeling great. I felt like Wimbledon was a place where I could still catch lightning in a bottle, make a bit of a run. Felt great in practice that week, went out 2nd round. Novak was someone who I had a decent record against at that point and he beat me like a drum. I was like a child on the court and I didn't play that bad. I lost two and two on grass. I walked off the court and thought I'm going to go out tomorrow and feel like I'm playing well. He just beat me like a drum and that was one of the first times where I thought this game is getting a little bit different than what I've been used to, these guys are from another planet right now. That one kind of hit home for me. The way he was playing in that moment was eye opening."
Because he didn't face them enough!

Check Zverev, Thiem and Tsitsipas on Federer's side! Federer's Terror 3!

If you guys were so anxious about them, then make your own list. Stop complaining! This reminds me of when I was differentiating legit and trivial slams!

The point was, of the guys they faced often, Djokovic would come out ahead. That should not be a surprise to any of us!
 
Last edited:
Three points is lucky circumstances which is what you’re arguing against the original post.

It seems kind of strange that the player who had the age advantage, for the majority of the rivalry, has the racket technology advantage, for the entire rivalry, had the stroke advantage, for the entire rivalry could not win more than half the points against Federer and the most lopsided wins between the two belong to the person who had the age disadvantage, the racket technology, disadvantage, and the stroke disadvantage.
it seems kind of strange that a player who everyone voted for GOAT was surpassed by not 1 but 2 players.
And now finding some comfort in pointing out that favourite plàyer won more point.
Federer service was world class so he got many free points and could attack other player service game.
Rafa Novak are not that elite server who had to work hard for every point.
Regarding Federer Novak rivalry you need to rewatch 40 15 triology and you will get your answer.
Those 3 matches will tell you why Novak is slam leader and Roger is not.
 
Back
Top