junkieballer
Legend
We know Djokovic leads 27-23 the h2h with Federer, but Fed fans say it was just due to lucky circumstances. So let's also see the h2h against players they both faced 10+ times:
vs Nadal = Djokovic 31-29 (51.7% win rate) > Federer 16-24 (40.0%)
vs Murray = Djokovic 25-11 (69.4%) > Federer 14-11 (56.0%)
vs Berdych = Djokovic 25-3 (89.3%) > Federer 20-6 (76.9%)
vs Wawrinka = Federer 23-3 (88.5%) > Djokovic 21-6 (77.8%)
vs Tsonga = Djokovic 17-6 (73.9%) > Federer 12-6 (66.7%)
vs Cilic = Djokovic 20-2 (90.9%) > Federer 10-1 (90.9%) - same win percentage but Nole has more wins
vs Nishikori = Djokovic 18-2 (90.0%) > Federer 8-3 (72.7%)
vs Ferrer = Federer 17-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 16-5 (76.2%)
vs Del Potro = Djokovic 16-4 (80.0%) > Federer 18-7 (72.0%)
vs Monfils = Djokovic 20-0 (100.0%) > Federer 10-4 (71.4%)
vs Gasquet = Djokovic 13-1 (92.9%) > Federer 19-2 (90.5%)
vs Stepanek = Djokovic 13-1 (92.9%) > Federer 14-2 (87.5%)
vs Kohlschreiber = Federer 14-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 12-2 (85.7%)
vs Raonic = Djokovic 12-0 (100.0%) > Federer 11-3 (78.6%)
vs Seppi = Djokovic 12-0 (100.0%) > Federer 14-1 (93.3%)
vs Youzhny = Federer 17-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 7-3 (70.0%)
vs Lopez = Federer 13-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 9-1 (90.0%)
So out of 17 opponents that both played 10+ times, Djokovic has better h2h than Federer against 12 of them. Add to that the actual h2h between the two, and Djokovic has better h2h in 13 out of 18.
total head to head against players both faced 10+ times including the h2h between them:
Djokovic 314-99 (76.03%)
Federer 273-100 (73.19%)
As you can see, the h2h between Djokovic and Federer is not just about circumstances, Nole also performed better against the opponents they both faced.
vs Nadal = Djokovic 31-29 (51.7% win rate) > Federer 16-24 (40.0%)
vs Murray = Djokovic 25-11 (69.4%) > Federer 14-11 (56.0%)
vs Berdych = Djokovic 25-3 (89.3%) > Federer 20-6 (76.9%)
vs Wawrinka = Federer 23-3 (88.5%) > Djokovic 21-6 (77.8%)
vs Tsonga = Djokovic 17-6 (73.9%) > Federer 12-6 (66.7%)
vs Cilic = Djokovic 20-2 (90.9%) > Federer 10-1 (90.9%) - same win percentage but Nole has more wins
vs Nishikori = Djokovic 18-2 (90.0%) > Federer 8-3 (72.7%)
vs Ferrer = Federer 17-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 16-5 (76.2%)
vs Del Potro = Djokovic 16-4 (80.0%) > Federer 18-7 (72.0%)
vs Monfils = Djokovic 20-0 (100.0%) > Federer 10-4 (71.4%)
vs Gasquet = Djokovic 13-1 (92.9%) > Federer 19-2 (90.5%)
vs Stepanek = Djokovic 13-1 (92.9%) > Federer 14-2 (87.5%)
vs Kohlschreiber = Federer 14-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 12-2 (85.7%)
vs Raonic = Djokovic 12-0 (100.0%) > Federer 11-3 (78.6%)
vs Seppi = Djokovic 12-0 (100.0%) > Federer 14-1 (93.3%)
vs Youzhny = Federer 17-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 7-3 (70.0%)
vs Lopez = Federer 13-0 (100.0%) > Djokovic 9-1 (90.0%)
So out of 17 opponents that both played 10+ times, Djokovic has better h2h than Federer against 12 of them. Add to that the actual h2h between the two, and Djokovic has better h2h in 13 out of 18.
total head to head against players both faced 10+ times including the h2h between them:
Djokovic 314-99 (76.03%)
Federer 273-100 (73.19%)
As you can see, the h2h between Djokovic and Federer is not just about circumstances, Nole also performed better against the opponents they both faced.