sandiegoman
Rookie
With his win against Milos, do you think he'll come out of retirement? He was playing much more aggressively, less slicing and great forehand shots.
Do you think Roddick will come out of retirement with the win?
- Thread starter sandiegoman
- Start date
Fee
Legend
THIS THREAD SUCKS BECAUSE: (Place X where applies)
[_] This topic did not need a separate thread
[_] Fake/duplicate account
[_] It asks when and/or will Nadal become #1 in the world
[_] It is a Nadal v Federer thread where making sense is prohibited
[_] It assumes Federer will forever be on top of the tennis world
[_] It is a lame troll attempt
[_] It is a “Threaten to leave” thread
[_] It over hypes players that don’t deserve it
[_] Original Poster's grammar makes me suspect the post was written by 4 year old
[_] It claims Player X career is over after 1 bad loss
[_] It tries to determine the best player ever (on any surface) for the 200th time
[_] It compares Graf and Seles, in any way.
[_] It asks when or if a young player will ever reach their potential after a totally expected loss
[_] It is a serious discussion of a exhibition match
[_] It proclaims a 16-18 year old's career is finished after a couple of first round losses
[_] It has the word Gilbert in the subject line
[_] It discusses doubles when its not a Davis Cup weekend
[_] It is a serious discussion of a clay clown's chances at a clay event or in an individual match against a competent clay player
[_] It is the annual thread where people complain about clay courters not showing up and embarrassing themselves on grass
[_] It is the annual thread where people complain about Americans not showing up in Monte Carlo
[_] It speculates whether player X is on dope without any evidence
[_] It asks/assumes Safin is finished in tennis after a totally expected few first round loss to the local baker in the first round of small tournament X
[_] Use the damn search engine
[_] It accuses the loser of choking when he did nothing of the sort
[_] It talks about fake injuries and/or fake injury time outs
[_] Cramp are called an injury
[_] BROKEN CAPS LOCK
[_] It claims females can be competitive with males in any form of tennis
[_] Wrong forum, eejit.
[_] It was created by a 13 year old desperate for attention
[_] It contains advice to a top ten pro player from a 3.0 with a losing record
[_] It predicts the winner of a tournament final based on a 'feeling'
[_] It's a 'Hey I'm back' thread after a) you were banned for a damn good reason or b) no one noticed you were gone or missed you.
[_] It's a duplicate thread started by someone who can't scroll one inch down the first page.
[XX] It is a serious discussion of a result from an off season exhibition match (bonus points for discussing a retired player coming out of retirement)
[_] This topic did not need a separate thread
[_] Fake/duplicate account
[_] It asks when and/or will Nadal become #1 in the world
[_] It is a Nadal v Federer thread where making sense is prohibited
[_] It assumes Federer will forever be on top of the tennis world
[_] It is a lame troll attempt
[_] It is a “Threaten to leave” thread
[_] It over hypes players that don’t deserve it
[_] Original Poster's grammar makes me suspect the post was written by 4 year old
[_] It claims Player X career is over after 1 bad loss
[_] It tries to determine the best player ever (on any surface) for the 200th time
[_] It compares Graf and Seles, in any way.
[_] It asks when or if a young player will ever reach their potential after a totally expected loss
[_] It is a serious discussion of a exhibition match
[_] It proclaims a 16-18 year old's career is finished after a couple of first round losses
[_] It has the word Gilbert in the subject line
[_] It discusses doubles when its not a Davis Cup weekend
[_] It is a serious discussion of a clay clown's chances at a clay event or in an individual match against a competent clay player
[_] It is the annual thread where people complain about clay courters not showing up and embarrassing themselves on grass
[_] It is the annual thread where people complain about Americans not showing up in Monte Carlo
[_] It speculates whether player X is on dope without any evidence
[_] It asks/assumes Safin is finished in tennis after a totally expected few first round loss to the local baker in the first round of small tournament X
[_] Use the damn search engine
[_] It accuses the loser of choking when he did nothing of the sort
[_] It talks about fake injuries and/or fake injury time outs
[_] Cramp are called an injury
[_] BROKEN CAPS LOCK
[_] It claims females can be competitive with males in any form of tennis
[_] Wrong forum, eejit.
[_] It was created by a 13 year old desperate for attention
[_] It contains advice to a top ten pro player from a 3.0 with a losing record
[_] It predicts the winner of a tournament final based on a 'feeling'
[_] It's a 'Hey I'm back' thread after a) you were banned for a damn good reason or b) no one noticed you were gone or missed you.
[_] It's a duplicate thread started by someone who can't scroll one inch down the first page.
[XX] It is a serious discussion of a result from an off season exhibition match (bonus points for discussing a retired player coming out of retirement)
Fee
Legend
Full disclosure, I stole it from mens tennis forums dot com years ago and started a thread here. Forgot about it for years, but this thread inspired the memory in me. Had to add the bit about exos, for some reason it didn't make it over to this forum.
Here's the original thread if you want to bump it and suggest new edits. http://tt.tennis-warehouse.com/showthread.php?t=132982
Last edited:
N
NadalAgassi
Guest
No. Winning a one match exhibition vs someone who isnt even a top player himself in no way compares to week to week tournament tennis.
kimbahpnam
Hall of Fame
by this logic Kuerten should come back after beating Djokovic!!!
http://espn.go.com/tennis/story/_/i...ten-edges-novak-djokovic-exhibition-match-rio
http://espn.go.com/tennis/story/_/i...ten-edges-novak-djokovic-exhibition-match-rio
Yep, and Sampras was world #1 again after beating Fed a few years ago.
For one match on a fast court set up to give Sampras the best chance to win -- Yeah, maybe he was.
Which is pretty impressive. However, past that - No.
(As I said at the time, there have been guys who were retired who came back to play Davis Cup and turned in great one-shot performances, so who knows.)
Which is pretty impressive. However, past that - No.
(As I said at the time, there have been guys who were retired who came back to play Davis Cup and turned in great one-shot performances, so who knows.)
3fees
G.O.A.T.
Probably not
Federer20042006
Banned
I think Roddick should be a commentator. If they let him say what he wanted, it could be awesome.
boredone3456
G.O.A.T.
Yes, and by virtue of this win he is now the favorite to win the Australian Open as well
Did I mention I'm the Queen of England?
Did I mention I'm the Queen of England?
DolgoSantoro
Professional
I'd love it if Roddick became a commentator, he usually has something interesting to say. But he isn't coming out of retirement. He didn't retire because he couldn't play well occasionally, he reached the 4th round of his last tournament. He retired because he couldn't consistently play well and trying to do so was just physically and mentally exhausting him.
Qubax
Professional
I wish.
At the beginning of Raonic match, Roddick was bad.
His serve was pretty bad, or should I say 15-20 MPH slower for the majority of the match. He went for a couple of big ones in the 3rd set and by big I mean 115mph(yikes)
As the match wore on he got a little more competent hitting groundies, and showed that he still has an underated net game(even in retirement)
But Roddick wanted to win waaaaay more then Milos. It was good to see Roddick actually kind of fighting for the match toward the end of it...but it was sad to know that it was just a one of Exo.
I wish Roddick would have taken NOT retired, but instead taken like 3 months off to rest, recover, rehabilitate the hamburger helper shoulder and then make a calculated slow come back with about 6-8 weeks of training leading into the Aussie Open.
I believe HAD Roddick taken the 3 months off to heal, without announcing his retirement, he could have come back and been a bit more rejuvenated Physically and mentally. The fact is though that Roddick has instead just been eating fried food, getting fat and living the good life. I think a part of him missed the competition and would love to compete again...but the commitment....it's too much....
...and to come back from doing jack squat for 3 months would taken some serious leg work. It's a shame he isn't hungry enough to try...
signed - grieving Roddick fan....
At the beginning of Raonic match, Roddick was bad.
His serve was pretty bad, or should I say 15-20 MPH slower for the majority of the match. He went for a couple of big ones in the 3rd set and by big I mean 115mph(yikes)
As the match wore on he got a little more competent hitting groundies, and showed that he still has an underated net game(even in retirement)
But Roddick wanted to win waaaaay more then Milos. It was good to see Roddick actually kind of fighting for the match toward the end of it...but it was sad to know that it was just a one of Exo.
I wish Roddick would have taken NOT retired, but instead taken like 3 months off to rest, recover, rehabilitate the hamburger helper shoulder and then make a calculated slow come back with about 6-8 weeks of training leading into the Aussie Open.
I believe HAD Roddick taken the 3 months off to heal, without announcing his retirement, he could have come back and been a bit more rejuvenated Physically and mentally. The fact is though that Roddick has instead just been eating fried food, getting fat and living the good life. I think a part of him missed the competition and would love to compete again...but the commitment....it's too much....
...and to come back from doing jack squat for 3 months would taken some serious leg work. It's a shame he isn't hungry enough to try...
signed - grieving Roddick fan....
President
Legend
I think Roddick just realized that winning a major or even Masters title was a long shot at this point. Yeah he hadn't had any major injuries, but his ground game was never the best and was only going to get worse with time and he lost some explosiveness on the serve. The current top 4 is too strong for someone like Andy to win big titles and he has had a successful enough career that he was never going to be happy for long winning Memphis or Atlanta and calling it a good season.
Let him go
He's had a good career. There are so many players who are around Roddick's level that never won a slam. Nalbandian and Haas for example. I will always remember his rivalry with Federer. Although it was very one-sided, you always felt that (especially in those wimbly finals) Roddick had a chance, but never managed to take it. He also has a very likable personality. I liked watching Roddick's interviews more than anyone else's. Even his on court antics (racquet breaking, the petty arguments with the umpires) were very amusing to me because he just acts how he wants to. It's a nice change up from the other players who act how they are supposed to act.
And to be honest, the last 3 years or so, his groundstrokes just weren't good enough to keep it up with the rest of the top players, so maybe it's better that he quit now.
Mainad
Bionic Poster
Roddick hasn't played at anything like his old level since he won 2010 Miami. It's been steadily downhill ever since. He once said that he would quit if his ranking drifted too far outside the top ten. He was #39 when he decided to call it a day.
I'm sure he could have carried on for a few more years, like Hewitt, even winning one or two more small titles but generally struggling, like Hewitt, to get past the early rounds of the big tournaments. Once he realised that he was never again going to be able to compete for top titles and had no chance of regaining his top ten ranking, it was the end for him. I guess he is just one of those guys who can't get motivated unless he can mix it with the best!
He's achieved things that 99% of players can only dream of and his place in tennis history is assured. I'm sure we will continue to see him at various exhos and eventually the Seniors Tour.
But yes, I will miss him too.
I'm sure he could have carried on for a few more years, like Hewitt, even winning one or two more small titles but generally struggling, like Hewitt, to get past the early rounds of the big tournaments. Once he realised that he was never again going to be able to compete for top titles and had no chance of regaining his top ten ranking, it was the end for him. I guess he is just one of those guys who can't get motivated unless he can mix it with the best!
He's achieved things that 99% of players can only dream of and his place in tennis history is assured. I'm sure we will continue to see him at various exhos and eventually the Seniors Tour.
But yes, I will miss him too.
Last edited:
N
NadalAgassi
Guest
I agree with all that and I perfectly understand how reaching that point for a former #1 and 5 time slam finalist is too much to want to keep going. In fact I often wonder how someone like Hewitt manages himself to keep going, but it admirable I suppose that he is able to. I dont think if I were in his situation I would be able to motivate myself to work so hard each day knowing where I once was, and where I am now, already being in my 30s.
PhrygianDominant
Hall of Fame
Rock Strongo
Legend
Yes obviously. Against a guy ranked 13 in the world.
Yes? His ground game is junior level tennis.
I agree totally.
AnotherTennisProdigy
Professional
Then how does he win and reach #13 in the world? The serve only helps for half of the games he plays.
The Moonballer
New User
The win doesn't say much. Milos is a giraffe and can't really return well. His ground game is pretty horrible as well.
Dick has a much better chance commentating
Dick has a much better chance commentating
Rock Strongo
Legend
I'd worry though that his unretirement would be rather short given that his shoulder has finally decided to call it a day (surprised this just happened now). He'd probably be forced to resort to pure serve and volley, and while that's a style he's unexpectedly good at, it's what happens after the first volley that's usually a bit suspect.
Would probably have been the best thing ever for him to play one more Wimbledon final as a wild card and win. Now when did that happen before?
Mainad
Bionic Poster
I'm assuming (or at least hoping) that Murray wasn't taking this match at all seriously!
Cup8489
G.O.A.T.
I watched a bit of this match. Murray was not hitting ANY, and I mean ANY, first serves over 123. He was spinning it in, and I saw quite a few second serves not even make it to 80 mph, and not have much direction or placement. His second serve was honestly not a whole lot better than some first serves I've seen. He was pushing in that match... it was obvious.
Roddick should stay retired; he's not going to be beating these guys in majors.
Roddick should stay retired; he's not going to be beating these guys in majors.
If Roddick took a long time off and got his shoulder back together he might be able to make a run if he just focused on one or two big tournaments for the year. That being said, he's not that type of person, and would want to compete every tournament, which would of course hurt his shoulder big time.
Qubax
Professional
Did it look like Roddick was trying? Like he wanted it?
That's how it looked at times in the Raonic exo...
batz
G.O.A.T.
Well, he was grinning from ear to ear when they went to net at the end
Andy M didn't look to be trying on serve and there wasn't a whole lot on his groundies - ARod was having his usual exho laughs but looked much sharper and more up for it.
Mainad
Bionic Poster
In his post-match interview after beating Murray in Miami, Roddick made these comments:
"If we had gone three sets I would've had a full body cramp and it would've been awkward for all of you," said Roddick, who kept a running dialogue with the crowd. "There's no comeback (to tennis for me).
"Andy was nice to me tonight."
Roddick has put on almost two kilograms (four pounds) since retiring following the U.S. Open. He says he's content in retirement and is playing a lot of golf.
"I don't miss the travel at all," Roddick said. "It's nice coming here and seeing familiar faces. I still enjoy hitting tennis balls, but I haven't lost that part of it. I haven't lost any of the innocent parts of tennis. I just do it in front of less people."
http://bleacherreport.com/tb/d94c5?utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=tennis
So no thoughts of making a comeback. Just enjoying his retirement.
"If we had gone three sets I would've had a full body cramp and it would've been awkward for all of you," said Roddick, who kept a running dialogue with the crowd. "There's no comeback (to tennis for me).
"Andy was nice to me tonight."
Roddick has put on almost two kilograms (four pounds) since retiring following the U.S. Open. He says he's content in retirement and is playing a lot of golf.
"I don't miss the travel at all," Roddick said. "It's nice coming here and seeing familiar faces. I still enjoy hitting tennis balls, but I haven't lost that part of it. I haven't lost any of the innocent parts of tennis. I just do it in front of less people."
http://bleacherreport.com/tb/d94c5?utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=tennis
So no thoughts of making a comeback. Just enjoying his retirement.
D
Deleted member 307496
Guest
Roddick made a smart move by retiring, his career was hitting the "downward spiral" stage anyway, losing his footing in the top ten, eventually falling out of the top 20, ect.
Similar threads
- Poll
