Early tennis tournaments in France open to foreign players

newmark401

Professional
By Mark Ryan


One of the enduring myths about French tennis is that the French Closed Championships, or French National Championships, were the precursor to the modern-day French Open. In reality, nothing could be further from the truth. After all, the French Closed Championships were, as their title indicates, closed, meaning that only French players and overseas players registered with French clubs could take part in them.

The French Closed Championships began in 1891 with a men’s singles event and continued for many years, with a women’s singles event being added in 1897. By 1914 there were also men’s, women’s and mixed doubles event at this tournament. By 1914 the French Closed Championships also had a permanent home, on the clay courts of the Racing Club de France in Paris. The original venue(s) and surface(s) for this tournament remain obscure. However, it is clear that clay was the surface used, if not at the very beginning, then soon afterwards.

In 1891, when the first French Closed Championships took place, tennis, or lawn tennis as it was then known, was still very much in its infancy, although growing increasingly popular, not just in the British Isles, but on the Continent and elsewhere. As its popularity increased, so did the number of tournaments. Nowadays, most tournaments tend to take place over one week and to begin on the Monday and end on the Sunday. However, when tennis was still young this was not always the case, especially in France, where a tournament could begin mid-week and end on the following Monday and where Sunday play was not uncommon.

In addition, a “tournament” often meant just a men’s singles event with very few competitors, with “byes” sometimes being awarded in more than just the first round. A men’s doubles event would usually be added at some point, followed by a mixed doubles event and a handicap singles event for women (there was often also a handicap singles event for men) and, later on, a non-handicap women’s singles event and, still later, a women’s doubles event. Handicap doubles and mixed events were not uncommon too. This pattern began in the British Isles and spread to the Continent and elsewhere.

The French, inventors of jeu de paume, a precursor of tennis, embraced its more modern form as enthusiastically as any other nation. The French even tried to embrace grass courts, but these proved impossible to maintain due to the climate in France, so a switch was made early on to clay courts. In his book “Tennis: A Cultural History”, Heiner Gillmeister writes that tennis clubs were being established in France as early as 1877, the year of the first Wimbledon tournament, when the Decimal Club of Paris was founded by ten Englishmen, lawn tennis being very much an English import brought over by English tourists or popularised by English people living in France. Hence its early popularity in north-west coastal towns such as Le Havre, Boulogne-sur-Mer and Dinard (the Tennis Club de Dinard was founded circa 1879).

Heiner Gillmeister also notes the founding of other clubs in the Paris region, including the Racing Club de France, a multi-sports club founded in 1882, which adopted lawn tennis into its programme in 1885 and had a number of courts in the Bois de Boulogne. The Stade Français was founded in 1883 and, in the beginning, was also a racing club. Its first tennis courts were built in 1889, indoors, on wood (the first wooden courts ever built in France). In 1899, the Stade Français acquired a large area in Saint-Cloud Park, where a number of hard (clay) courts were built, and it was here that the first World Hard Court Championships would take place in 1912.

Another important early Parisian club was the Cercle des Sports de l’Ile de Puteaux, founded in 1886 by Count Léon de Janzé. This club initially had ten courts (Heiner Gillmeister calls them “sand courts laid out on a bed of rubble”). Finally, there was, and still is, the Tennis Club de Paris, founded in 1895 by a number of benefactors, including Armand Masson, a French Canadian based in Paris and husband of the tennis champion (Françoise) Adine Masson, who was also French-Canadian.

The Tennis Club de Paris was originally located at 91 Boulevard Exelmans in the Auteuil district of the capital. This club was, and still is, wholly devoted to tennis. When it was first founded it had four indoor (wood) courts and five exterior clay courts. As early as 1895, the year of its founding, the Tennis Club de Paris arranged an open tournament on its indoor courts. However, the dates, 22-27 November, were not propitious and few overseas players took part (the first winners of the singles events were André Vacherot and Adine Masson). It was therefore decided to hold the tournament at a more favourable time, namely over the Easter weekend. This tournament became known as the French Covered Courts Championships but, interestingly, was also referred to simply as the French Championships.

Its new position in the calendar did attract more overseas players to the French Covered Courts Championships, with subsequent winners of the men’s singles event including Manliffe Goodbody of Ireland, the Englishmen George Simond and Major Josiah Ritchie, and the New-Zealander Tony Wilding. The women’s singles event was dominated by French players, although the Englishwoman Gladys Eastlake-Smith won the title in 1907.

In 1900, five years after the inauguration of the French Covered Courts Championships at the Tennis Club de Paris, the aforementioned Cercle des Sports de l’Ile de Puteaux club started its own tennis tournament, which was to become known as the Paris Championships. This tournament was played on the club’s clay courts. According to R.B. Hough, writing in the chapter entitled “Play in France and Switzerland” in the book “Lawn Tennis at Home and Abroad” (1903): “At Puteaux there is an Annual Summer Meeting, at which the championships of Paris are played, and a very enjoyable tournament it is from a social point of view. The Comte de Janzé is President of the club, and the meeting is under his management, consequently it is well looked after. R. F. Doherty carried all before him there in 1902.”

The fact that Reggie Doherty, the elder of the two great English tennis-playing brothers, won the men’s singles at this event in 1902 makes it clear beyond doubt that this tournament was indeed open to overseas players. However, in its early years it appears to have suffered from a lack of participation by foreign players because its place in the calendar – at the end of June/beginning of July – clashed with a number of tournaments being held at the same time in Great Britain.

In the chapter from “Lawn Tennis at Home and Abroad” quoted from above, R.B. Hough goes on to write that, “In the provinces, Dinard, Nice, and Cannes are the most important tournaments.” As already indicated, the Tennis Club de Dinard was founded circa 1879. The first tennis tournament took place there circa 1890; it was open to overseas players and was held on clay. Early winners of the men’s singles event included the Englishman Arthur Wentworth Gore and Harold Mahony of Ireland. The unheralded Englishwoman Ivy Arbuthnot won the women’s singles title several times in the 1890s; her compatriots Dorothea Douglass and Hilda Lane won it in later years.

At least one tennis tournament was inaugurated in Cannes around the beginning of the 1890s. According to the website www.cannes.com, in the early 1880s the English Renshaw twins, William and Ernest, had several courts built on the site of the future Beau Site Hotel in Cannes. It is clear that the Renshaws helped to popularise the sport of tennis in the south of France at this time, when they moved there in the winter to practise and play in a more favourable climate. However, it should not be forgotten that tennis was also growing in popularity in other parts of the country at the same time, especially, as already indicated, along the north-west coast.

By the turn of the nineteenth century, the tournament held at the Beau Site Hotel in Cannes was a fixed feature of the tennis and social calendar in the south of France. This tournament, known as the Championships of Cannes, attracted many of the top French and overseas players, and was won several times by Laurie Doherty, who was just coming into his own circa 1900. Both the men’s singles and women’s singles events at the Championships of Cannes would be dominated by overseas players for many years.

So would the singles events at the South of France Championships, held further up the coast in Nice. This tournament was inaugurated circa 1894. Laurie Doherty won it many times; Reggie Doherty also won the singles title, as did Tony Wilding. The German player Countess Clara von der Schulenburg and the Englishwoman Blanche Hillyard were among the early winners of the women’s singles title in Nice.

The fact that all of these tournaments were open not just to French but also to overseas players, makes a mockery of any claim that the French Closed Championships tournament was the precursor of the modern French Open. The real international tournaments were these open ones, and it was the desire to create a major clay court tournament on a par with Wimbledon and open to players of all nations which led to the holding of the first World Hard Courts Championships in Paris in 1912. But that is another story.
-----
 
Last edited:
Excellent

Couldn't agree more.

That is why I say the World Hardcourt Championship played on clay (starting in 1912) is the true precursor to the French Open.

In fact tournament winners of the WHCC should be regarded as major winners in my book. After all it was regarded by the international tennis federation as a 'World Championship' (along with the World Covered Court and Wimbledon) - hence a major. Hence, Bill Tilden should be credited with 11 Majors not 10 because he won the WHCC in 1921.
 
This is just an appendix to the above article on early tennis tournaments in France open to foreign players.
-----

Appendix I

How they struck a contemporary

An unnamed correspondent sent the following reports on the Riviera tournaments to the London “Times” in 1908 and 1909. They provide an interesting insight into the history, administration and general quality of the four tournaments in question. By 1908, the Monte Carlo tournament came first in the calendar.
-----

The Monte Carlo Cup, Condamine, Monte Carlo, Monaco

From the “Times”, 3 March 1909

“The first of the series of international lawn tennis tournaments on the Riviera began at Monte Carlo on 22 February. The new courts near the casino are unfortunately not yet finished, so the four old ones in the Motor Boats Exhibition enclosure on the Condamine were again used. Glorious sunshine favoured the opening day, but afterwards the weather became thoroughly bad and never gave much hope of improvement. There was no rain to speak of, but it always looked threatening. It was bitterly cold, too, and a strong wind blew across the courts.

“This year the tournament attracted a record number of entries, 84 names in all being sent in, and it was gratifying that the ‘class’ of the entries was much above that of the last three years. There is no doubt that the present courts at Monte Carlo are most difficult to play on. It was remarked by one competitor that lawn tennis on them was more a penance than a pleasure. The light is atrocious, the courts are slippery, and the ball flies out at the slightest touch. Consequently the only game for most people to play with any success is the ‘safety’ game, that is for the player to wait for his opponent’s mistakes and not to try to win by his own good shots. Nearly everyone seemed put off by the change of surroundings and therefore did not quite play up to their true form…”
-----

The Riviera Championships, Mentone Lawn Tennis Club, Mentone, France

From the “Times”, 14 March 1908

“Nowhere on the Riviera is it possible to enjoy a lawn tennis tournament in more picturesque and comfortable conditions than at Mentone, and although the weather was rather unfavourable, the meeting, which was brought to a close on Monday 9 March, was a success in every way. The courts, three in number, always played well, and the rain had no effect on them; but the new stand, which had only been completed the week before at a cost of £100, was hardly patronized to the extent that had been hoped.”
--

From the “Times”, 10 March 1909

“The Mentone Lawn Tennis Club held their eight annual tournament on Monday 1 March and the following days… There were three courts at the disposal of Mr Madge, the referee. They may easily be said to be the fastest on the Riviera and take a great deal of getting used to. However, they are a distinct improvement on the slippery courts at Monte Carlo. The light in the morning is excellent, but later in the day shadows come right across the courts, and on the worst of the sides it is a matter of luck to get a ‘sight’ of the ball at all. Perhaps the lawn tennis at Mentone is taken less seriously than at Monte Carlo, Nice or Cannes. Nevertheless there was an excellent entry…”
-----

The South of France Championships, Place Mozart, Nice, France

From the “Times”, 23 March 1909

“The 15th international lawn tennis tournament at Nice on the courts of the Place Mozart was delayed owing to incessant rain. The tournament was advertised to start on Monday 8 March. No play, however, was possible on that day or on Tuesday. A few odd matches were with difficulty waded through on the next two days during bright intervals. However, there was a delightful change for the better on Friday, and a full programme was able to be carried out in perfect weather. The courts were kept going from 8.30 a.m. until 5 p.m. The president of the club, Mr G.H. Brandt, returned from Portugal in order to be present.

“This year the committee decided not to make use of the services of a paid referee but to take the burden of management on their shoulders. There were very unfortunately only two courts at their disposal. A large stand was erected on a ‘doubtful’ spare court and thus the work of the committee was made doubler hard. The entries were large and the open events, coupled with various handicap events, had to be ‘got through’ in a fixed time. There are limits even to the handicap players’ willingness to turn out early in the morning or late afternoon. Great interest is taken in lawn tennis at Nice. The crowds are most enthusiastic and certainly larger than at other at the other Riviera meetings. The courts ‘played’ extremely well…”
-----

The Championships of Cannes, Beau Site courts, Cannes, France

From the “Times”, 31 March 1909

“The 20th annual lawn tennis tournament held at Cannes on the famous courts of the Beau Site hotel was able to be begun on 21 March. The date fixed for the start was 17 March, but on that day most of the competitors were playing off matches in the Nice tournament, and on the following day rain prevented any play. However, after two days’ weary waiting, competitors were rewarded by a week of glorious tropical sunshine. This season the tournament on the Beau Site courts was easily voted the most enjoyable of the series. At the former tournaments there was always some atmospheric difficulty to contend with, but the Cannes week, when at last it was ‘under way’, turned out a most delightful one in all respects and everyone enjoyed it thoroughly.

“The Beau Site courts, under the management of the well-known professional Tom Flemming, have long been recognized as the home of tennis on the Riviera. The Renshaws were the first to come out to Cannes and start the lawn tennis and the tournaments there. Their excellent example has been taken up by their successors, especially perhaps, by the Dohertys, who seldom fail to put in an appearance at the Beau Site. Terraces round the principal court make an ideal ‘grand stand’, and they are crowded with people each day watching the play.

“Mr G.M. Simond, after a successful fortnight’s lawn tennis, once more took upon himself the more serious duties of the referee. He was backed up by a committee of five, consisting of H.L. Doherty, Mr Ritchie, Mr Alexander, Mr Godfree and Mr Wallis Myers. The courts, of which there are three, are in perfect condition. They are fast, and it is possible to drive with more power and accuracy on them than on other Riviera courts. The light and background are first rate…”
-----
 
Wasn't the French Championship played at the Ile de Puteaux ?

By Mark Ryan


One of the enduring myths about French tennis is that the French Closed Championships, or French National Championships, were the precursor to the modern-day French Open. In reality, nothing could be further from the truth. After all, the French Closed Championships were, as their title indicates, closed, meaning that only French players and overseas players registered with French clubs could take part in them.

The French Closed Championships began in 1891 with a men’s singles event and continued for many years, with a women’s singles event being added in 1897. By 1914 there were also men’s, women’s and mixed doubles event at this tournament. By 1914 the French Closed Championships also had a permanent home, on the clay courts of the Racing Club de France in Paris. The original venue(s) and surface(s) for this tournament remain obscure. However, it is clear that clay was the surface used, if not at the very beginning, then soon afterwards.

In 1891, when the first French Closed Championships took place, tennis, or lawn tennis as it was then known, was still very much in its infancy, although growing increasingly popular, not just in the British Isles, but on the Continent and elsewhere. As its popularity increased, so did the number of tournaments. Nowadays, most tournaments tend to take place over one week and to begin on the Monday and end on the Sunday. However, when tennis was still young this was not always the case, especially in France, where a tournament could begin mid-week and end on the following Monday and where Sunday play was not uncommon.

In addition, a “tournament” often meant just a men’s singles event with very few competitors, with “byes” sometimes being awarded in more than just the first round. A men’s doubles event would usually be added at some point, followed by a mixed doubles event and a handicap singles event for women (there was often also a handicap singles event for men) and, later on, a non-handicap women’s singles event and, still later, a women’s doubles event. Handicap doubles and mixed events were not uncommon too. This pattern began in the British Isles and spread to the Continent and elsewhere.

The French, inventors of jeu de paume, a precursor of tennis, embraced its more modern form as enthusiastically as any other nation. The French even tried to embrace grass courts, but these proved impossible to maintain due to the climate in France, so a switch was made early on to clay courts. In his book “Tennis: A Cultural History”, Heiner Gillmeister writes that tennis clubs were being established in France as early as 1877, the year of the first Wimbledon tournament, when the Decimal Club of Paris was founded by ten Englishmen, lawn tennis being very much an English import brought over by English tourists or popularised by English people living in France. Hence its early popularity in north-west coastal towns such as Le Havre, Boulogne-sur-Mer and Dinard (the Tennis Club de Dinard was founded circa 1879).

Heiner Gillmeister also notes the founding of other clubs in the Paris region, including the Racing Club de France, a multi-sports club founded in 1882, which adopted lawn tennis into its programme in 1885 and had a number of courts in the Bois de Boulogne. The Stade Français was founded in 1883 and, in the beginning, was also a racing club. Its first tennis courts were built in 1889, indoors, on wood (the first wooden courts ever built in France). In 1899, the Stade Français acquired a large area in Saint-Cloud Park, where a number of hard (clay) courts were built, and it was here that the first World Hard Court Championships would take place in 1912.

Another important early Parisian club was the Cercle des Sports de l’Ile de Puteaux, founded in 1886 by Count Léon de Janzé. This club initially had ten courts (Heiner Gillmeister calls them “sand courts laid out on a bed of rubble”). Finally, there was, and still is, the Tennis Club de Paris, founded in 1895 by a number of benefactors, including Armand Masson, a French Canadian based in Paris and husband of the tennis champion (Françoise) Adine Masson, who was also French-Canadian.

The Tennis Club de Paris was originally located at 91 Boulevard Exelmans in the Auteuil district of the capital. This club was, and still is, wholly devoted to tennis. When it was first founded it had four indoor (wood) courts and five exterior clay courts. As early as 1895, the year of its founding, the Tennis Club de Paris arranged an open tournament on its indoor courts. However, the dates, 22-27 November, were not propitious and few overseas players took part (the first winners of the singles events were André Vacherot and Adine Masson). It was therefore decided to hold the tournament at a more favourable time, namely over the Easter weekend. This tournament became known as the French Covered Courts Championships but, interestingly, was also referred to simply as the French Championships.

Its new position in the calendar did attract more overseas players to the French Covered Courts Championships, with subsequent winners of the men’s singles event including Manliffe Goodbody of Ireland, the Englishmen George Simond and Major Josiah Ritchie, and the New-Zealander Tony Wilding. The women’s singles event was dominated by French players, although the Englishwoman Gladys Eastlake-Smith won the title in 1907.

In 1900, five years after the inauguration of the French Covered Courts Championships at the Tennis Club de Paris, the aforementioned Cercle des Sports de l’Ile de Puteaux club started its own tennis tournament, which was to become known as the Paris Championships. This tournament was played on the club’s clay courts. According to R.B. Hough, writing in the chapter entitled “Play in France and Switzerland” in the book “Lawn Tennis at Home and Abroad” (1903): “At Puteaux there is an Annual Summer Meeting, at which the championships of Paris are played, and a very enjoyable tournament it is from a social point of view. The Comte de Janzé is President of the club, and the meeting is under his management, consequently it is well looked after. R. F. Doherty carried all before him there in 1902.”

The fact that Reggie Doherty, the elder of the two great English tennis-playing brothers, won the men’s singles at this event in 1902 makes it clear beyond doubt that this tournament was indeed open to overseas players. However, in its early years it appears to have suffered from a lack of participation by foreign players because its place in the calendar – at the end of June/beginning of July – clashed with a number of tournaments being held at the same time in Great Britain.

In the chapter from “Lawn Tennis at Home and Abroad” quoted from above, R.B. Hough goes on to write that, “In the provinces, Dinard, Nice, and Cannes are the most important tournaments.” As already indicated, the Tennis Club de Dinard was founded circa 1879. The first tennis tournament took place there circa 1890; it was open to overseas players and was held on clay. Early winners of the men’s singles event included the Englishman Arthur Wentworth Gore and Harold Mahony of Ireland. The unheralded Englishwoman Ivy Arbuthnot won the women’s singles title several times in the 1890s; her compatriots Dorothea Douglass and Hilda Lane won it in later years.

At least one tennis tournament was inaugurated in Cannes around the beginning of the 1890s. According to the website www.cannes.com, in the early 1880s the English Renshaw twins, William and Ernest, had several courts built on the site of the future Beau Site Hotel in Cannes. It is clear that the Renshaws helped to popularise the sport of tennis in the south of France at this time, when they moved there in the winter to practise and play in a more favourable climate. However, it should not be forgotten that tennis was also growing in popularity in other parts of the country at the same time, especially, as already indicated, along the north-west coast.

By the turn of the nineteenth century, the tournament held at the Beau Site Hotel in Cannes was a fixed feature of the tennis and social calendar in the south of France. This tournament, known as the Championships of Cannes, attracted many of the top French and overseas players, and was won several times by Laurie Doherty, who was just coming into his own circa 1900. Both the men’s singles and women’s singles events at the Championships of Cannes would be dominated by overseas players for many years.

So would the singles events at the South of France Championships, held further up the coast in Nice. This tournament was inaugurated circa 1894. Laurie Doherty won it many times; Reggie Doherty also won the singles title, as did Tony Wilding. The German player Countess Clara von der Schulenburg and the Englishwoman Blanche Hillyard were among the early winners of the women’s singles title in Nice.

The fact that all of these tournaments were open not just to French but also to overseas players, makes a mockery of any claim that the French Closed Championships tournament was the precursor of the modern French Open. The real international tournaments were these open ones, and it was the desire to create a major clay court tournament on a par with Wimbledon and open to players of all nations which led to the holding of the first World Hard Courts Championships in Paris in 1912. But that is another story.
-----

Wasn't the French Closed Championship played at Ile de Puteaux the odd years from 1891 to 1907 ? It would seem odd that the had the 'Paris Championship' only a month or so later on the same courts? (See passage highlighted in Red). Or perhaps it is not odd. Sounds like the Paris Championships were an open to all countries affair.
 
Wasn't the French Closed Championship played at Ile de Puteaux the odd years from 1891 to 1907 ? It would seem odd that the had the 'Paris Championship' only a month or so later on the same courts? (See passage highlighted in Red). Or perhaps it is not odd. Sounds like the Paris Championships were an open to all countries affair.

In my original piece I should have written that the tournament inaugurated at the Ile de Puteaux club in 1900 was open to both French and overseas players.

I don't know much about the early years of the obscure French Closed Championships, which is only worth remembering because the top French players of the time tended to play there.
 
Same Club?

In my original piece I should have written that the tournament inaugurated at the Ile de Puteaux club in 1900 was open to both French and overseas players.

I don't know much about the early years of the obscure French Closed Championships, which is only worth remembering because the top French players of the time tended to play there.

Yes I understood, thanks, that the Paris tournament was open to overseas players. I just was wanting confirmation that it was played at exactly the same club as the French Closed Championships (in the odd years from 1891 to 1907). There is information in these forums that point in that direction.

BTW, I had a look on google maps satellite view and you can still see the tennis courts on the Ile de Puteaux (an island in the Seine river to the West of Central Paris). I stayed at the camp ground a couple of times on the East side of the river opposite the Southern most point of the Ile de Puteaux. (The Camp ground is between the Bois de Boulogne and the Seine River).
 
Yes I understood, thanks, that the Paris tournament was open to overseas players. I just was wanting confirmation that it was played at exactly the same club as the French Closed Championships (in the odd years from 1891 to 1907). There is information in these forums that point in that direction.

BTW, I had a look on google maps satellite view and you can still see the tennis courts on the Ile de Puteaux (an island in the Seine river to the West of Central Paris). I stayed at the camp ground a couple of times on the East side of the river opposite the Southern most point of the Ile de Puteaux. (The Camp ground is between the Bois de Boulogne and the Seine River).

I forget, now, exactly where I got that original information according to which the French Closed Championships tournament was played at alternate clubs from 1891 to 1908 before a one-off sojourn in Bordeaux in 1909, followed by a permanent move back to the Racing Club de France, where it was still being held as late as 1924.

Contemporary English- (and German-) language sources almost never reported on this tournament. I suppose the best place to look for information on it would be contemporary French sources, but these are extremely difficult to come by.

Almost all of the information, results, etc. I have found from the period 1877 to 1945 come from sources like "The Field", " Lawn Tennis and Croquet"/"Lawn Tennis and Badminton", "Lawn-Tennis und Golf", "Sport und Spiel", etc. The only French sources I've seen are two of the sports almanacks from the end of the nineteenth/beginning of the twentieth century, which are interesting though not hugely helpful...

Anyway, as you know, a lot of related information can be found in the following thread, created last year: http://tt.tennis-warehouse.com/showthread.php?t=280425
 
Last edited:
Back
Top