Fans of the big four, how many of you will accept this scenario?

[Deleted member 77403]

Federer wins Wimbledon to get his 19th slam and hold the outright record at SW19 with 8 slam and breaking the tie with Pete. However he does not win USO, WTF or end the year as world number one.

Djokovic wins USO, marking his return to the winner's circle, having seven straight seasons of winning at least one slam. Winning a 3rd USO title to better balance his HC slam distribution and also. Does not win WTF, or end year number one.

Nadal wins the WTF and completes the trophy cabinet of big trophies, and becoming the only active player to hold the super slam, all four slams, SOG and WTF. Ends the year world number one, equals Djokovic with 4 year end number ones.

Murray finally wins the AO in January on his sixth final, and now has won slams at three different events. Loses number one ranking along the way to Nadal.

 

[joekapa]

Nope. Would like Djokovic to beat Federer @ Wimby. Keeping his idols (Sampras), record in tact. Doesn't bother me if he wins it or not.

Would like him to win USO and WTF, which I think he can.

 

[Backspin1183]

Nadal winning WTF while others win a Grand Slam title each? Lol not acceptable scenario for Nadal fans.
No sir, we prefer another US Open title.

 

[Jonas78]

Just hand Federer that 8th Wimbledon and I'll be fine with everything! (As long as noone else wins more than 19 slams of course)

 

[Deleted member 77403]

Getting the exact responses I thought I would get.

 

[NatF]

I will only be satisfied by another 3 slam season for Fedr and a glorious ascent to #1 at the end of year.

 

[Deleted member 733170]

I would be very happy with such a scenario.

 

[Tennis_Hands]

Looks good to me.

It is also well thought out as there are no players ranked in the hundreds at the WTF or anyone called Muller.

 

[Jonas78]

Nadal winning WTF while others win a Grand Slam title each? Lol not acceptable scenario for Nadal fans.
No sir, we prefer another US Open title.

The battle for that USO title could be tougher than for several years. With Djoker and Murray on their way back, you could have all big4 playing on a decent level, which we havent seen sinse 2011/2012.

 

[Deleted member 77403]

OK. Lets change a little bit.

Federer wins Wimbledon.
Djokovic wins USO
Nadal wins AO
Murray wins RG

How do Nadal fans feel now?

Murray fans, would you rather he won RG or AO if you could only pick one?

 

[NatF]

OK. Lets change a little bit.

Federer wins Wimbledon.
Djokovic wins USO
Nadal wins AO
Murray wins RG

How do Nadal fans feel now?

lol no.

Who gets YE #1 in this scenario?

 

[Deleted member 77403]

lol no.

Who gets YE #1 in this scenario?

Federer gets it in this scenario, since he has multi slam year. Nadals double career slam to compensate for that in January.

 

[Deleted member 77403]

Federer gets it in this scenario, since he has multi slam year. Nadals double career slam to compensate for that in January.

Oh and Djokovic completes the Masters set by winning Cincy.

 

[vive le beau jeu !]

the nadal winning nothing... can i order that ?

 

[ChrisRF]

I would be happy with Federer „only“ winning Wimbledon until the end of the season. But the thing is, if I’d accept the scenario, I would know it beforehand that his season would be literally over in 5 days. So I wouldn’t do it. I like the tension and the feeling that he always has a chance to win, even though I’m not shocked if he finally doesn’t.

 

[NatF]

@Hitman ask us again on Sunday

 

[Deleted member 77403]

@Hitman ask us again on Sunday

I will.

 

[Paul Harman]

Murray fans, would you rather he won RG or AO if you could only pick one? Murray fans? Hello? Anyone there?

AO

 

[SpinToWin]

I will accept reality

 

[TennisATP]

It's unfair to give Federer a slam if he's going to skip the French Open again next year. The others are playing 4 out of 4, he's going to play 3 out of 4.

So if we want to give only 1 win for everyone, I'd say:

Wimbledon: Murray
US Open: Nadal
WTF: Federer
Australian Open: Djokovic
French Open: Wawrinka

 

[joekapa]

Being a Djokovic fan, I will say this. I want Cilic to win Wimby this year, and beat Djokovic to do it. Cilic has received a lot of flack about his abilities. I regard him as the best "big man" in this sport, and think he deserves another slam.

 

[Deleted member 77403]

It's unfair to give Federer a slam if he's going to skip the French Open again next year. The others are playing 4 out of 4, he's going to play 3 out of 4.

So if we want to give only 1 win for everyone, I'd say:

Wimbledon: Murray
US Open: Nadal
WTF: Federer
Australian Open: Djokovic
French Open: Wawrinka

No. In my scenario, Federer plays RG and full clay season next year.

 

[Deleted member 77403]

Being a Djokovic fan, I will say this. I want Cilic to win Wimby this year, and beat Djokovic to do it. Cilic has received a lot of flack about his abilities. I regard him as the best "big man" in this sport, and think he deserves another slam.

I can understand this. I don't mind Cilic winning Wimbledon, he will more than likely need to beat back to back Wimbledon champions to do it.

 

[MasturB]

If Fed wins Wimb and USO i don't care if he never wins another tournament again. 250 500 1000 or Slam.

20 slams is a sexy number and Nadal or Nole likely never touch it.

 

[moonballs]

I am already very happy with Fed's 18. Even if he doesn't win Wimbledon.

 

[TheGhostOfAgassi]

OK. Lets change a little bit.

Federer wins Wimbledon.
Djokovic wins USO
Nadal wins AO
Murray wins RG

How do Nadal fans feel now?

Murray fans, would you rather he won RG or AO if you could only pick one?

This one is perfect to me

 

[Jackuar]

Fed wins WO
Fed wins USO
Fed wins Cincy
Fed wins WTF
Murray wins AO
Fed wins RG
Nadal wins WO
Murray wins USO
Djoko can have a load of masters meanwhile.

 

[junior74]

the nadal winning nothing... can i order that ?

Spoiler: Sadness inside

 

[Centre Court]

Federer winning a final Wimbledon would be fitting, so I'd take that option regardless

 

[tennisaddict]

As long as Fed wins one of Wimb or USO, I am fine with it. If he is losing anywhere hopefully it is not a heart breaker and not against mugs. Only acceptable loss is to Djok.

1 major to each of the big 4 in the next 4 majors sounds very fair.

 

[AustinTx24]

Federer wins Wimbledon to get his 19th slam and hold the outright record at SW19 with 8 slam and breaking the tie with Pete. However he does not win USO, WTF or end the year as world number one.

Djokovic wins USO, marking his return to the winner's circle, having seven straight seasons of winning at least one slam. Winning a 3rd USO title to better balance his HC slam distribution and also. Does not win WTF, or end year number one.

Nadal wins the WTF and completes the trophy cabinet of big trophies, and becoming the only active player to hold the super slam, all four slams, SOG and WTF. Ends the year world number one, equals Djokovic with 4 year end number ones.

Murray finally wins the AO in January on his sixth final, and now has won slams at three different events. Loses number one ranking along the way to Nadal.

Sounds good to me...sign me up!

Only one thing though, 19 is an odd number so Federer would need to win 20 at the US Open 2018! I don't like odd numbers!

 

[EdSWright]

Nadal winning WTF while others win a Grand Slam title each? Lol not acceptable scenario for Nadal fans.
No sir, we prefer another US Open title.

O2 Arena has large doorframes. I like his chances.

 

[merwy]

Fine with me. Although it sounds a bit too much like the typical American happy ending where everyone gets to complete his resume. But if Fed wins this, I don't need him to win anything else in the rest of the season.

 

[Steve0904]

I'd take it easily. I only had to read as far "Federer wins Wimbledon...." Don't give a damn about anything else.

 

[Phoenix1983]

Being a Djokovic fan, I will say this. I want Cilic to win Wimby this year, and beat Djokovic to do it. Cilic has received a lot of flack about his abilities. I regard him as the best "big man" in this sport, and think he deserves another slam.

I regard him as a doper.

 

[Shaolin]

I'll accept only Federer winning Wimbledon or USO and WTF, preferably all 3.

 

[JMR]

Only one thing though, 19 is an odd number so Federer would need to win 20 at the US Open 2018! I don't like odd numbers!

But 19 is also one of the prime numbers, which are relatively rare compared to the set of all whole numbers. How glorious to have a prime slam count! Sampras couldn't do it.

 

[swordtennis]

I would be happy for all for of them. Especially Nadal. The Big Lug.

 

[joekapa]

I regard him as a doper.

Yeah, yeah.......he is the only one. Give me a break.

 

[Sentinel]

Nadal winning WTF while others win a Grand Slam title each? Lol not acceptable scenario for Nadal fans.
No sir, we prefer another US Open title.

Nadal just won RG, or does that not count as a slam any more ?

 

[Sentinel]

Federer wins Wimbledon to get his 19th slam and hold the outright record at SW19 with 8 slam and breaking the tie with Pete. However he does not win USO, WTF or end the year as world number one.

Djokovic wins USO, marking his return to the winner's circle, having seven straight seasons of winning at least one slam. Winning a 3rd USO title to better balance his HC slam distribution and also. Does not win WTF, or end year number one.

Nadal wins the WTF and completes the trophy cabinet of big trophies, and becoming the only active player to hold the super slam, all four slams, SOG and WTF. Ends the year world number one, equals Djokovic with 4 year end number ones.

Murray finally wins the AO in January on his sixth final, and now has won slams at three different events. Loses number one ranking along the way to Nadal.

Fine with me, good Sir.

 

[Djokovic2011]

Je n'accepterais pas. Even the thought of Nadal winning the WTF or Federer winning another Wimbledon makes me feel queasy.

 

[Deleted member 688153]

Federer winning another Wimbledon makes me feel queasy.

A testament to how many he's won already, I guess.

 

[Sentinel]

Federer wins Wimbledon to get his 19th slam

If he does, BIG IF, its highly unlikely he'll go through the rest of the season without winning anything else.

 

[Deleted member 688153]

As for your scenario, OP, I think it sounds fantastic. I would love for that all to happen.

 

[Sentinel]

I regard him as a doper.

That was accidental.

 

[Djokovic2011]

A testament to how many he's won already, I guess.

Nah, more like a testament to how some of his fans treated Djokovic like the devil for having the temerity to beat their idol in two successive finals.

 

[Semidios]

OK. Lets change a little bit.

Federer wins Wimbledon.
Djokovic wins USO
Nadal wins AO
Murray wins RG

How do Nadal fans feel now?

Murray fans, would you rather he won RG or AO if you could only pick one?

FO of course.He already won a hard court slam, now he needs one one clay.

 

[Rafa the King]

Rafa to win of the next 2 plus RG 2018, now that would satisfy me.

 

[Deleted member 688153]

Nah, more like a testament to how some of his fans treated Djokovic like the devil for having the temerity to beat their idol in two successive finals.

I can understand that, but that's not Federer's fault though. He doesn't deserve ill wishes for the action of a few haters.