The ball seems to curl off to the side. In other words, it's traveling from Nadal in the ad court toward Federer in the ad court, but at the bounce it curls off toward the deuce court. And that's how it seems to have passed Federer's racquet: not over or under, but past the extreme edge of the racquet.I agree. I don't think it really a terrible bounce in which you could really expect a player to totally miss the ball. You would expect him to get a piece of the ball at least. Makes you wonder how some players today would adapted to the truly awful grass and really bad bounces at the old Forest Hills courts.
I saw the match on television and I've looked at the bounce numerous times and I still can't believe he missed it totally. Let's face it, no one would expect Federer to missed that type of bounce totally. It was shocking.
Or does the ball curl back that way because Federer deflected it slightly with the edge of the racquet? I've seen many such shots like that while taking stats: where the racquet edge just barely grazes the ball, barely changing its trajectory (although, the shots I'm talking about are difficult shots on the run, barely reached).
While I agree it was shocking, whiffs always are. I'm sure I've seen some in taking all the stats I have.
Borg whiffed on one of Laver's serves at Hilton Head. I put that down as an ace for Laver.