Federer Doha 2005 vs Djokovic Doha 2016

Who wins?


  • Total voters
    23
  • Poll closed .
D

Deleted member 77403

Guest
Djokovic would win IMO, that was his absolute Earth's Mightiest Warrior form.

Federer IMO wasn't in his true God Form in that Doha 05 match.
 

KINGROGER

G.O.A.T.
Federer if he brought his peak HC level e.g 03-04 YEC, 05 Cincy, 06 USO.

Those two versions either guy in 3, lean towards Djokovic he was unreal that tournament.
 

Backspin1183

Talk Tennis Guru
Nadal said he's never seen someone play better than Djokovic Doha 2016.

And he saw Federer play in 2005.

I'd also not seen Nadal make so many errors and unable to string 5-6 shots together like he did that match against Djokovic.
 

metsman

G.O.A.T.
Nadal said he's never seen someone play better than Djokovic Doha 2016.

And he saw Federer play in 2005.
It is well established that 2005 Nadal is an inexperienced tennis rookie. How do you expect him to properly assess Federer's level in 2005, even if he saw him?
 

robthai

Hall of Fame
I dont remember how Fed played in Doha. Technology was crap back then compared to now, it was hard to have access to replays in higher quality where the ball is actually visible.
 

JoelSandwich

Hall of Fame
Djokovic would win IMO, that was his absolute Earth's Mightiest Warrior form.

Federer IMO wasn't in his true God Form in that Doha 05 match.
I’m talking about form throughout the entire tournament
I only used that match because that’s like all I could find lol
 
Top