Hall of Fame
Honestly, lets stop keeping UO 2011 in that list. He wasn't few points or games away from winning title there but a whole match plus one point away. And match too where he wouldn't have been favorite to win.Yes he underperformed.. age did play a big part in fedal & fedovic matchups, but still there are so many losses which were the case when roger defeated himself (particularly against djok).
He let 9 slams slip under his belt by choking on some of the most important tennis points in the history of sports..
Here are all of them, it's upon you to judge
AO 2005 (bullsh*t swiss)
UO 2011 (bullsh*t swiss)
Wim 2019 (bullsh*t swiss)
I know he should have won that SF against Djokovic but considering the phase his rivalry with Nadal was in, he was not likely to win a BO5 grand slam final against Nadal. As a Nadal fan I was wishing so much for Fed to win that match.