D
Deleted member 716271
Guest
I think Roger Federer is undoubtedly one of the greatest players ever, and will go down as an absolute legend to be sure. But one area where it has become increasingly clear that he lacks is mental fortitude in tight matches. We all know his 5 set record is not up to the par of all the other greats...
In fact, most of his 5 set wins record I would imagine is comprised against lower opposition in early rounds of slams, like his escapes against Falla, Bennetau, Del Potro etc.
Against really top opposition (say top few in the world, or threats to win slams on that particular surface), he has an unbelievably poor record.
Off the top of my head, I can recall 10 5 set losses that were all rather striking...these date back to when Federer was young and rising as well as his laters, so I don't think you can say "well he's old, a lesser player wouldn't even push the other guy to 5 sets" It's a long time pattern, and while he should be commended for playing so great to force 5th sets now, the fact that he more often than not ends up on the wrong side of them is puzzling, especially when fitness doesn't seem to be an issue. Without further ado...
Safin AO '05 (blows match point on serve in 4th set tiebreak, fights hard to save 6 mp in 5th, but eventually loses)
Nalbandian TMC '05 (loses from 2 sets up)
Nadal Rome '06 (Trying to get elusive 5 set clay win over Nadal before FO to gain momentum...loses after being up 15-40 4-5 with 2 MP on Nadal's serve and then again loses 4 points in a row after being up 5-3 in final set tiebreak)
Wimbledon '08 (fights valiantly to tie it up, holds a BP midway thru 5th set, goes on to lose in "Greatest Match of all Time)
AO ' 09 (loses another 5 setter to Nadal, again off clay, this time folds in the 5th, seeming mentally fragile and gets broken twice in the decider)
USO '09 (loses an odd 5 setter to Del Potro, seemingly outplaying him and in control, and then again buckles in the 5th, again losing by a double break in the decider)
USO' 10 (loses to Djokovic, Djokovic saves 2 MP on serve, Federer gets mentally frustrated and gets broken the next game)
USO '11 (Eery repeat of last year, except this one is worse...up 2 sets to love...up 5-3 40-15 in the 5th...Djokovic hits epic forehand, but Fed then mentally folds, double faults in this game...then gets broken at 15 in his next service game and again loses 7-5 in the 5th vs. Djokovic)
AO '13 (Folds in the 5th against Murray, he is well over 30 at this point, but still issues do not seem fitness related, this one is more understandable as he was slightly outplayed the whole match, yet again plays great at the end of the 4th, and then oddly folds in the 5th, again losing by a double break)
Wimby '14 (Almost 33, but yet is on his best surface and Djokovic's supposed worse, still plays fantastic, especially for age and pushes Djoko to the brink, but again blinks in the 5th after coming back from 5-2 in the 4th and seemingly having the momentum. Much like Wimby '08, Federer can't convert a BP midway thru the 5th)
Just imagine if Federer has converted a few of these. I really think he is mentally weaker than most of the other GOAT candidates when it comes to tight matches and pressure situations.
In fact, most of his 5 set wins record I would imagine is comprised against lower opposition in early rounds of slams, like his escapes against Falla, Bennetau, Del Potro etc.
Against really top opposition (say top few in the world, or threats to win slams on that particular surface), he has an unbelievably poor record.
Off the top of my head, I can recall 10 5 set losses that were all rather striking...these date back to when Federer was young and rising as well as his laters, so I don't think you can say "well he's old, a lesser player wouldn't even push the other guy to 5 sets" It's a long time pattern, and while he should be commended for playing so great to force 5th sets now, the fact that he more often than not ends up on the wrong side of them is puzzling, especially when fitness doesn't seem to be an issue. Without further ado...
Safin AO '05 (blows match point on serve in 4th set tiebreak, fights hard to save 6 mp in 5th, but eventually loses)
Nalbandian TMC '05 (loses from 2 sets up)
Nadal Rome '06 (Trying to get elusive 5 set clay win over Nadal before FO to gain momentum...loses after being up 15-40 4-5 with 2 MP on Nadal's serve and then again loses 4 points in a row after being up 5-3 in final set tiebreak)
Wimbledon '08 (fights valiantly to tie it up, holds a BP midway thru 5th set, goes on to lose in "Greatest Match of all Time)
AO ' 09 (loses another 5 setter to Nadal, again off clay, this time folds in the 5th, seeming mentally fragile and gets broken twice in the decider)
USO '09 (loses an odd 5 setter to Del Potro, seemingly outplaying him and in control, and then again buckles in the 5th, again losing by a double break in the decider)
USO' 10 (loses to Djokovic, Djokovic saves 2 MP on serve, Federer gets mentally frustrated and gets broken the next game)
USO '11 (Eery repeat of last year, except this one is worse...up 2 sets to love...up 5-3 40-15 in the 5th...Djokovic hits epic forehand, but Fed then mentally folds, double faults in this game...then gets broken at 15 in his next service game and again loses 7-5 in the 5th vs. Djokovic)
AO '13 (Folds in the 5th against Murray, he is well over 30 at this point, but still issues do not seem fitness related, this one is more understandable as he was slightly outplayed the whole match, yet again plays great at the end of the 4th, and then oddly folds in the 5th, again losing by a double break)
Wimby '14 (Almost 33, but yet is on his best surface and Djokovic's supposed worse, still plays fantastic, especially for age and pushes Djoko to the brink, but again blinks in the 5th after coming back from 5-2 in the 4th and seemingly having the momentum. Much like Wimby '08, Federer can't convert a BP midway thru the 5th)
Just imagine if Federer has converted a few of these. I really think he is mentally weaker than most of the other GOAT candidates when it comes to tight matches and pressure situations.