Female Clay Court GOAT

  • Thread starter Thread starter NadalAgassi
  • Start date Start date
After Chris's 125 match streak was broken (In a third set tiebreak, by Tracey Austin), she went back and won another 72 in a row, broken by Hana Mandlikova 7-5 6-4

125 was not enough. That Austin loss must not stand as a symbol of hope for the tour. It should to be surrounded, drowned in a flood of wins in both directions

So we have 197 wins- 1 loss over an 8 year span.

I guess that should do.
 
Last edited:
i would Seles not rank this way on clay
i dont know exatly how would i rank her, but not this way for sure
just my opinion
 
CHATGpt:

,,How I would “rank” Seles​


Instead of just counting titles:


  • Peak dominance: One of the top 3 women ever (Graf, Navratilova, Seles).
  • Impact on the game: Massive — she popularized aggressive baseline play and two-handed strokes on both sides.
  • Career total potential: Had she not been stabbed, she might have been the greatest women’s player of the 1990s.

So in terms of talent, peak dominance, and influence, I’d rank Seles above the 8-title label, maybe even in the very top tier of all-time women’s tennis, regardless of actual GS numbers."

this is one reason i like CHATGpt
 
CHATGpt:

,,How I would “rank” Seles​


Instead of just counting titles:


  • Peak dominance: One of the top 3 women ever (Graf, Navratilova, Seles).
  • Impact on the game: Massive — she popularized aggressive baseline play and two-handed strokes on both sides.
  • Career total potential: Had she not been stabbed, she might have been the greatest women’s player of the 1990s.

So in terms of talent, peak dominance, and influence, I’d rank Seles above the 8-title label, maybe even in the very top tier of all-time women’s tennis, regardless of actual GS numbers."

this is one reason i like CHATGpt
Its always soo hard with these Uber-intense baseline players because without a natural length career with a normal bell shaped curve, you have no idea how long that red hot competitive intensity could sustain those early win patterns. We do not know whether her career would have looked more like Connors or more like Wilander ,more like Evert or more like Jaeger. Its the same problem with Austin. Borg chose to quit because he knew he couldn't.
 
Its always soo hard with these Uber-intense baseline players because without a natural length career with a normal bell shaped curve, you have no idea how long that red hot competitive intensity could sustain those early win patterns. We do not know whether her career would have looked more like Connors or more like Wilander ,more like Evert or more like Jaeger. Its the same problem with Austin. Borg chose to quit because he knew he couldn't.
yes, we cant know ,,IF" ...
but i mean STABBING DOES NOT BELONG TO THE SPORT and stabbing was the reason Seles has only 8 (or 9?) GS title
so if you would not like to estimate ,,IF" ... she is not even rankable, she was stabbed what does not belong to the sport
(i myself would estimate her at least 8-10 GS title more ,,IF"..)
 
yes, we cant know ,,IF" ...
but i mean STABBING DOES NOT BELONG TO THE SPORT and stabbing was the reason Seles has only 8 (or 9?) GS title
so if you would not like to estimate ,,IF" ... she is not even rankable, she was stabbed what does not belong to the sport
(i myself would estimate her at least 8-10 GS title more ,,IF"..)
It has zero to do with 'in the sport', or 'out of the sport'. We can't read tea leaves. We don't know how long she would have maintained the same intensity and passion, had she not been stabbed. We also don't know how Austin's career would have turned out absent the back injuries. Some of these players maintain that intensity and competitive drive throughout a normal career, and some do not. We don't know if she would have had joint problems or injuries like Bueno, or Graf, or Mandlikova or burnout like Jaeger. Heck she might have become a party animal like McEnroe or Wilander or Hingis. these answers are going to affect the hardware collection.
 
Last edited:
The frustrating thing with Seles are all the what ifs.

-Would she have become the best ever without the stabbing? Possible but not certain, nobody will ever know.
-Would she have become the best clay courter ever without the stabbing? Possible but not certain, nobody will ever know.
-Would she have become the best overall hard court player ever without the stabbing. Possible, but not certain, nobody will ever know.
-Would she have become the best rebound ace player ever without the stabbing? Quite likely considering she is even in contention for that as it, but still impossible to know for certain.
-Given she had won 3 straight YEC at such a young age, might she have even challenged/overtaken Navratilova's status as the carpet GOAT? Possible but not certain, nobody will ever know.

That is the most frustrating thing though. As a Seles fan I would rather her not be stabbed, and the worst case scenario results possible occur, say getting only 12 or 13 slams total, only a few more than she has, and achieving none of the above things. Basically doing far more than even her lower end guesstimates would guess. Atleast then there are no unknowns, we all know, she knows, and she wasn't robbed of the chance of what she may have done, and fans weren't robbed of learning the answer, and instead having to wonder forever, especialy those who followed her career closely. It is the frustration for her and all of tennis, and even someone like Graf who I am sure would like to have had the challenge of trying to attain her numbers naturally with nothing happening to Seles. The frustration of the permanent series of unknowns created by Gunther Parche, who is now hopefully rotting somewhere in hell if it exists, and if not rotting in the ground and forgotten likely even by his own family, is good enough.
 
The frustrating thing with Seles are all the what ifs.

-Would she have become the best ever without the stabbing? Possible but not certain, nobody will ever know.
-Would she have become the best clay courter ever without the stabbing? Possible but not certain, nobody will ever know.
-Would she have become the best overall hard court player ever without the stabbing. Possible, but not certain, nobody will ever know.
-Would she have become the best rebound ace player ever without the stabbing? Quite likely considering she is even in contention for that as it, but still impossible to know for certain.
-Given she had won 3 straight YEC at such a young age, might she have even challenged/overtaken Navratilova's status as the carpet GOAT? Possible but not certain, nobody will ever know.

That is the most frustrating thing though. As a Seles fan I would rather her not be stabbed, and the worst case scenario results possible occur, say getting only 12 or 13 slams total, only a few more than she has, and achieving none of the above things. Basically doing far more than even her lower end guesstimates would guess. Atleast then there are no unknowns, we all know, she knows, and she wasn't robbed of the chance of what she may have done, and fans weren't robbed of learning the answer, and instead having to wonder forever, especialy those who followed her career closely. It is the frustration for her and all of tennis, and even someone like Graf who I am sure would like to have had the challenge of trying to attain her numbers naturally with nothing happening to Seles. The frustration of the permanent series of unknowns created by Gunther Parche, who is now hopefully rotting somewhere in hell if it exists, and if not rotting in the ground and forgotten likely even by his own family, is good enough.
I doubt that she would have beat any records of Martina's records on carpet, the carpet tour was beginning its decline not that long after Martina departed. The volume of the 'hardwear' was going to dry up.
 
I doubt that she would have beat any records of Martina's records on carpet, the carpet tour was beginning its decline not that long after Martina departed. The 'hardwear' was going to dry up.

In fairness I do agree that is unlikely BUT 3 YEC titles (in a row) by only age 18, still makes you wonder what she may have achieved on that particular surface.

You have a great point on the carpet tour though. Carpet itself was already going the way of the dinosaur by the late 90s, and virtually extinct by the early 2000s. Which I personally find ridiculous as I think it is a key element of the game and adding variety to it, both in the mens and womens game, and in fact seems less prone to injury than almost any other surface as well, but that is what the ITF wanted I guess.

It is funny to think there was a time wood was even a very significant surface, atleast in the mens "pro" game.
 
Injuries and burn outs belong to the sport
Stabbing not.
I see this differs Seles to the other big youngstars.
This is why i find the ranking of the OP incorrect.
 
After Chris's 125 match streak was broken (In a third set tiebreak, by Tracey Austin), she went back and won another 72 in a row, broken by Hana Mandlikova 7-5 6-4
Wow!! I didn’t realize that she reeled off another 72 straight. So if I’m reading this correctly, she went 197-1 on clay across a 198-match stretch.

That is absolutely obscene.
 
Sabatini beat Martina 7-6, 6-1 at Rome that year. I actually think Sabatini would have won that hypothetical final but it is pretty much a 50-50 call. Either way I agree the pressure on Graf would have rose further had she lost that match.

Graf always seemed to have a HUGE chip on her shoulder when playing Sabatini though, despite getting the better of their rivalry by a long ways. I think she viewed Sabatini's talents and abilities as far beneath her own and resented that Gaby could have challenge her and beat her as many times as she did. When Sabatini briefly dominated their head to head from mid 1990-mid 1992, that was the most miserable I saw Graf look on the tennis court in general (also around the same time Seles began dominating the game too of course). What is ironic is she seemed to respect Sanchez Vicario infinitely more despite that Aranxta IMO was a less talented player than Sabatini.
IF Steffi resented Sabatini, it probably was because Gabriella was more popular and much better looking than she was. Sabatini's main problem was mental, as she had an excellent all-court game.
 
IF Steffi resented Sabatini, it probably was because Gabriella was more popular and much better looking than she was. Sabatini's main problem was mental, as she had an excellent all-court game.

Sabatini was more popular than everyone. Graf was still more popular than most of her rivals, outside of Sabatini, so it is not like she was unpopular, Sabatini was just possibly the most popular player ever in her prime. She even had a $20, 000 doll in one country that outsold the cheap $5 dollar or so barbie dolls at the height of Barbie's popularity. Atleast until the stabbing the crowds rooted for Graf in every single match vs Seles, whether she was favored or not (granted part of that is also just how unpopular Seles was until the stabbing, probably the most hated #1 ever at that point); and even after the stabbing they seemed to be rooting for Graf in their 99 RG and 99 Australian Open matches, particularly the RG match. They also almost always rooted for her against Sanchez Vicario. Outside of the US they rooted for Graf when she played Capriati. Crowds just rooted for Sabatini against everyone, they even were rooting for her in her Canadian Open semi final vs Seles when Seles was just coming back from the stabbing and showered with love from the crowds. She was just insanely popular.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PDJ
I think Wills should be higher at 5. Otherwise no quibbles
I doubt Lenglen ever lost a match on clay. She only has 2 French titles because the French was not open to foreigners until 1925. She did win 4 World Hard Court titles, on clay in Paris, before 25. Wills probably only lost once, to Lenglen, the only time they played against each other.
 
This is my list of the top female clay courters of all time:


1. Chris Evert
2. Steffi Graf
3. Suzanne Lenglen
4. Justine Henin
5. Monica Seles
6. Margaret Court
7. Helen Wills Moody
8. Maureen Connolly
9. Aranxta Sanchez Vicario
10. Hilde Krahwinkel Sperling
11. Martina Navratilova
12. Gabriela Sabatini
13. Doris Hart
13. Conchita Martinez
14. Ann Haydon Jones
15. Nancy Richey
16. Lesley Turner
17. Margaret Osborne Du Pont
18. Mary Pierce
19. Martina Hingis
20. Evonne Goolagong
21. Hana Mandlikova
22. Angela Mortimer
23. Simone Mathieu
24. Margaret Scriven Vivian
25. Svetlana Kuznetsova
26. Shirley Fry
27. Althea Gibson
28. Serena Williams
29. Jennifer Capriati
30. Venus Williams



What would yours be.
Henin is too high and Wills too low, but otherwise this is about perfect. I would probably outright switch Wills and Henin, dropping Henin to 7th from 4th, and rising Wills to 4th from 7th.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PDJ
Sabatini was more popular than everyone. Graf was still more popular than most of her rivals, outside of Sabatini, so it is not like she was unpopular, Sabatini was just possibly the most popular player ever in her prime. She even had a $20, 000 doll in one country that outsold the cheap $5 dollar or so barbie dolls at the height of Barbie's popularity. Atleast until the stabbing the crowds rooted for Graf in every single match vs Seles, whether she was favored or not (granted part of that is also just how unpopular Seles was until the stabbing, probably the most hated #1 ever at that point); and even after the stabbing they seemed to be rooting for Graf in their 99 RG and 99 Australian Open matches, particularly the RG match. They also almost always rooted for her against Sanchez Vicario. Outside of the US they rooted for Graf when she played Capriati. Crowds just rooted for Sabatini against everyone, they even were rooting for her in her Canadian Open semi final vs Seles when Seles was just coming back from the stabbing and showered with love from the crowds. She was just insanely popular.
One place where Graf was not popular, was in Italy, which is why she hardly ever played there.
 
One place where Graf was not popular, was in Italy, which is why she hardly ever played there.

Yes that is true, 100% agree there. I saw the event once when she was there and the crowds hated her there. I bet they would have even rooted for pre stabbing Seles over her there. It is kind of ironic since her sort of disgusting nose is pretty classic Italian in a way, I would have thought that might win her some favor. :-D
 
Yes that is true, 100% agree there. I saw the event once when she was there and the crowds hated her there. I bet they would have even rooted for pre stabbing Seles over her there. It is kind of ironic since her sort of disgusting nose is pretty classic Italian in a way, I would have thought that might win her some favor. :-D
why did the Italians dislike her so much?
 
Purely my guess, but I would guess Italians probably did not like Graf since they liked emotional people and players and Graf was the complete opposite of that. She showed no emotion ever, other than sometimes celebrations after winning, did her job with her briefcase in determined fashion trying to win, then left. Atleast at this stage, she finally began showing more emotion in 95-99.

Sabatini wasn't the most emotive person either (still much moreso than Graf atleast) but she was so incredibly beautiful, charismatic, and just beloved it didn't matter.
 
Purely my guess, but I would guess Italians probably did not like Graf since they liked emotional people and players and Graf was the complete opposite of that. She showed no emotion ever, other than sometimes celebrations after winning, did her job with her briefcase in determined fashion trying to win, then left. Atleast at this stage, she finally began showing more emotion in 95-99.

Sabatini wasn't the most emotive person either (still much moreso than Graf atleast) but she was so incredibly beautiful, charismatic, and just beloved it didn't matter.
IMy guess is that they like 'beautiful play' with lots of variety, lots of touch, shot construction, graceful movement... They admire the art of tennis more than the science. They appreciate creativity more than power. I would never think Graf would be their favorite cup of tea. Players like Bueno, Goolagong, Sabatini, Hingis yes!
 
IMy guess is that they like 'beautiful play' with lots of variety, lots of touch, shot construction, graceful movement... They admire the art of tennis more than the science. They appreciate creativity more than power. I would never think Graf would be their favorite cup of tea. Players like Bueno, Goolagong, Sabatini, Hingis yes!
Actually that makes much more sense than my original guesstimation. I think it is that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PDJ
I doubt that she would have beat any records of Martina's records on carpet, the carpet tour was beginning its decline not that long after Martina departed. The volume of the 'hardwear' was going to dry up.
I think Martina won 48 consecutive matches on carpet.

Seles was halfway there at 24 when she was stabbed, going undefeated from November 11, 1991-February 1993.

Navratilova also won the WTA Finals four straight years: 1983-1986. Seles had won 3 straight years -- 1990-1992 -- when she was stabbed.

I could see Seles toppling both of those records if she's not stabbed.
 
IMy guess is that they like 'beautiful play' with lots of variety, lots of touch, shot construction, graceful movement... They admire the art of tennis more than the science. They appreciate creativity more than power. I would never think Graf would be their favorite cup of tea. Players like Bueno, Goolagong, Sabatini, Hingis yes!
I can confirm, 100%, that the Italians adored Maria Bueno. She told me herself that she was the only woman who played on the show court when both men and women played. The love was mutual. She much preferred Rome to Paris and, in her day, it was considered more prestigious.
 
I think Martina won 48 consecutive matches on carpet.

Seles was halfway there at 24 when she was stabbed, going undefeated from November 11, 1991-February 1993.

Navratilova also won the WTA Finals four straight years: 1983-1986. Seles had won 3 straight years -- 1990-1992 -- when she was stabbed.

I could see Seles toppling both of those records if she's not stabbed.

I think Graf would be a tough opponent for Seles if they ever met at the YEC. Not saying Seles could not have won or win, but she never beat Graf on a surface faster than clay (I believe rebound ace was considered slower than clay at the time). And when Seles won those 3 YEC she did not meet Graf in any of them. Granted the counter to that is Graf may have preserved her streak of only losing to Seles on slower courts, by no reaching any big fast court finals, minus Wimbledon, in the early 90s (which is where I laugh at the Seles fans who insist Graf was at her all time peak in the early 90s when Seles was dominant, but that is a whole other topic). So whether Seles got to 5 YEC in a row to beat the record would depend largely what happens if she plays Graf in 93 and 94, which would be interesting. I know Graf lost to Pierce in 94 but now with a whole new draw there is no saying this happens anymore. And as you know well I hate Graf, probably dislike her even more than Seles (who I also admitedly am not a fan of) so that isn't bias on my part, but an objective observation.
 
I think Graf would be a tough opponent for Seles if they ever met at the YEC. Not saying Seles could not have won or win, but she never beat Graf on a surface faster than clay (I believe rebound ace was considered slower than clay at the time). And when Seles won those 3 YEC she did not meet Graf in any of them. Granted the counter to that is Graf may have preserved her streak of only losing to Seles on slower courts, by no reaching any big fast court finals, minus Wimbledon, in the early 90s (which is where I laugh at the Seles fans who insist Graf was at her all time peak in the early 90s when Seles was dominant, but that is a whole other topic). So whether Seles got to 5 YEC in a row to beat the record would depend largely what happens if she plays Graf in 93 and 94, which would be interesting. I know Graf lost to Pierce in 94 but now with a whole new draw there is no saying this happens anymore. And as you know well I hate Graf, probably dislike her even more than Seles (who I also admitedly am not a fan of) so that isn't bias on my part, but an objective observation.
Yeah, I just don't think Graf looked great at the WTA Finals in either 1993 or 1994. As you noted, there was the straight set loss to Pierce in 1994 when Graf was clearly less than 100% with her back injury. And, in 1993, I don't think Graf was that good in either the SF (against Huber) or the final (against ASV).

I actually think Seles's game worked really well on indoor carpet, where the angles she created on both sides worked to her benefit. The bounce being truer and a bit higher than on grass helped her as compared to at Wimbledon. And with her serve and net game improving, she would have been tough to beat on the surface. Steffi starting in 1995 would have been a tall order, but I like Monica's odds in 1993 and 1994.
 
Yeah, I just don't think Graf looked great at the WTA Finals in either 1993 or 1994. As you noted, there was the straight set loss to Pierce in 1994 when Graf was clearly less than 100% with her back injury. And, in 1993, I don't think Graf was that good in either the SF (against Huber) or the final (against ASV).

I actually think Seles's game worked really well on indoor carpet, where the angles she created on both sides worked to her benefit. The bounce being truer and a bit higher than on grass helped her as compared to at Wimbledon. And with her serve and net game improving, she would have been tough to beat on the surface. Steffi starting in 1995 would have been a tall order, but I like Monica's odds in 1993 and 1994.

I think Graf also got pretty unmotivated by 94, as she was bored without anyone pushing her enough, and it is also one reason she was not battle tested enough when she came up against some unexpectedly inspired opponents in slams that year too. I think the entire dynamic changes if the Seles stabbing does not occur, but I doubt Graf is as lackluster as she was most of 94, and even some of 93 after the stabbing, especialy as she was beginning to play better herself most of the year before the Seles stabbing and working on new things with her coach Heinz to combat both Seles and Sabatini (who she had been having a lot of losses to).

Anyway I could see Seles possibly getting the record, I just don't think it is even close to a slam dunk. If Seles were able to get the record by beating Graf at the 93 and 94 YEC it would really trump Navratilova, as Graf is definitely a superior carpet player to Evert, and the carpet field in Seles's time, surprisingly given the time, was stronger than Navratilova's time. You would think in Navratilova's time it would be stronger as the tour in general was more fast court oriented, but players at that time seemed to focus more on grass (one reason both Navratilova and Evert on her worst surface Wimbledon records are so impressive) than carpet.

Now as for the most consecutive wins on carpet, I would agree she would have had a great shot at that, except didn't that streak already end with her loss to Navratilova in early 93? Or was that an indoor hard court and not carpet, in which case the chance would still be on. I think starting up a whole new streak and surpassing the 36 would be tough given the limited number of carpet events on tour even by then, and I don't think she is going unbeaten for years more on carpet, but if she were still at the 18 it was possible, although might require winning the 93 YEC.
 
Last edited:
I think Graf also got pretty unmotivated by 94, as she was bored without anyone pushing her enough, and it is also one reason she was not battle tested enough when she came up against some unexpectedly inspired opponents in slams that year too. I think the entire dynamic changes if the Seles stabbing does not occur, but I doubt Graf is as lackluster as she was most of 94, and even some of 93 after the stabbing, especialy as she was beginning to play better herself most of the year before the Seles stabbing and working on new things with her coach Heinz to combat both Seles and Sabatini (who she had been having a lot of losses to).
1993 seems so pivotal for me if Seles isn't stabbed. If Seles wins the French Open and the U.S. Open, followed by Graf having her physical struggles the following year, I'm just not sure Steffi ever gets off the mat and is able to elevate her game in 1995 like she did. But, if Graf is able to win the French Open or, likelier, the U.S. Open in addition to Wimbledon in 1993, I think it's game on in 1994 and beyond.
 
It has zero to do with 'in the sport', or 'out of the sport'. We can't read tea leaves. We don't know how long she would have maintained the same intensity and passion, had she not been stabbed. We also don't know how Austin's career would have turned out absent the back injuries. Some of these players maintain that intensity and competitive drive throughout a normal career, and some do not. We don't know if she would have had joint problems or injuries like Bueno, or Graf, or Mandlikova or burnout like Jaeger. Heck she might have become a party animal like McEnroe or Wilander or Hingis. these answers are going to affect the hardware collection.
We DO know that she had one of the greatest peaks in tennis history, outplaying Steffi Graf when they were both in their primes.
 
125 was not enough. That Austin loss must not stand as a symbol of hope for the tour. It should to be surrounded, drowned in a flood of wins in both directions

So we have 197 wins- 1 loss over an 8 year span.

I guess that should do.
Evert wanted to drown that defeat so deep, most would forget it ever even happened. :laughing:
 
Back
Top