French Open Final: [1] Rafa Nadal vs [7] Dominic Thiem

How’s it go?

  • Thieminator in 3

    Votes: 10 6.1%
  • Thiem’s time is now in 4

    Votes: 22 13.4%
  • Domi shows supreme mental strength in 5

    Votes: 12 7.3%
  • Bull rushes to victory in 3

    Votes: 60 36.6%
  • Rafa crushes puny ball basher in 4

    Votes: 41 25.0%
  • Rafa trolls Fed fans in 5

    Votes: 2 1.2%
  • Rain ruins another match

    Votes: 4 2.4%
  • Mury GOAT

    Votes: 1 0.6%
  • Just get this over with so we can get the grass season started!

    Votes: 6 3.7%
  • Anyone but Zverev

    Votes: 6 3.7%

  • Total voters
    164

Mike Sams

G.O.A.T.
i think that is his best slam outside of RG. I would doubt he would win it, but a SF would be nice. Either way, he has a great chance to win RG in the future.
He could've made the QF if he had beaten Del Potro which he likely should've. And Federer looked injured against Del Potro so who knows? Maybe Thiem would've made the SF.
 

Fedole

Semi-Pro
No he'll never amount to anything because he's mentally weak and has no variety, as evidenced today.
Nobody expected him to win today, but people expected him to win at least one set and give Rafa a run for his money.
He folded like a deck chair after going 0-30 down at 5-4. After that, the outcome was inevitable.
As for lack of variety, his second serve out wide was abysmal, the obvious thing to do was to change it up or take the pace off his first serve- he did neither.
People thought he would win a set and then realised how ****ing good Nadal is on this court despite Thiem throwing everything at him for an hour. As for folding like a deck chair, you must have missed Delpo the other day.

If you judge everything on matches against Nadal at the French Open, you must think everyone is useless!
 
T

Tiki-Taka

Guest
What we have seen happening in tennis over the last 20 years or so proves categorically that past results and patterns have no bearing on future successes. And that's applicable to any aspect of life.
What's next? As far as Slam counts go, it remains very interesting. For the rest of the field, there's still some soul-searching to do. Federer and Nadal continue to hold up the old Big 4 fort, splitting the past 6 Slams between them!

And by the way, good to see you using a conventional font nowadays :D
I abandoned it at the beginning of this year. After several complaints it felt like I would be truly annoying if I just ignored them all. :p
 

merwy

G.O.A.T.
Lol, you need to watch more clay court tennis. Thiem is #2 in the field.
I'm sick of hearing this. Thiem is #7 of the world right now, period. No number 2 on clay or whatever. Cut the crap. Let him win a clay m1000 before calling him that. Pretty sure Zedbot will gain in on him soon anyway so he won't be seeing a lot of RG finals in his career.
 

marc45

G.O.A.T.
David Ferrer‏Verified account @DavidFerrer87 2h2 hours ago

DfV3f0uXkAE8J4T.jpg
 

tennis_pro

Bionic Poster
Because it's ttw and people predict things based on who the last Gs winner was. Remember the 2015 threads: Djokovic will win 20 slams?
yes and I mocked that concept several times at the time

If I didn't have to freeze my money for 10 years I would've bet a lot of cash on Federer ending up with more majors than Djokovic, the odds were even around early 2016 IIRC.
 

World Beater

Hall of Fame
Federer is no lock at Wimbledon.

Whereas Nadal looks extremely strong out there - solid, and consistent with little dips. he may surprise at Wimbledon with a run, and will be strong at the usopen. someone will have to outplay him there..who? Delpo? Shapovalov?

Federer still can blow hot and cold, and is much more vulnerable...

Nadal's defense alone will beat most guys on tour these days even on the faster surfaces.
 

Steve0904

Talk Tennis Guru
Steve ... get over it or take some anti-depressants man! When Federer won Wimbledon last year beating a bunch of worthless players, you didn't say a f*ucking thing about the next generation being cra*p. yet Nadal wins a slam and you write a half-page essay about it?

By the way, I'm in full agreement with your point though :)

Why did you think I was angry? I've been saying that Nadal would win RG since at least April after I saw his first couple matches in MC. I'm not depressed about anything. I even mentioned in this thread that I was partly enjoying watching Thiem get the crap kicked out of him.
 

DreddyTennis45

Hall of Fame
People thought he would win a set and then realised how ****ing good Nadal is on this court despite Thiem throwing everything at him for an hour. As for folding like a deck chair, you must have missed Delpo the other day.

If you judge everything on matches against Nadal at the French Open, you must think everyone is useless!

That's true but outside of the french open he's never reached a slam QF or won a single Masters 1000 despite three of them being on his favourite suface lmfao.
Nobody is denying Nadal's greatness on clay but Outside of clay thiem is a top 50 player at best.
 

Fedole

Semi-Pro
I'm sick of hearing this. Thiem is #7 of the world right now, period. No number 2 on clay or whatever. Cut the crap. Let him win a clay m1000 before calling him that. Pretty sure Zedbot will gain in on him soon anyway so he won't be seeing a lot of RG finals in his career.
Zedbot was miles away in the QF's, he will always be out-moved by Thiem on this court. As for the #7 thing... cut the crap, bro.
 

Mike Sams

G.O.A.T.
Federer is no lock at Wimbledon.

Whereas Nadal looks extremely strong out there - solid, and consistent with little dips. he may surprise at Wimbledon with a run, and will be strong at the usopen. someone will have to outplay him there..who? Delpo? Shapovalov?

Federer still can blow hot and cold, and is much more vulnerable...

Nadal's defense alone will beat most guys on tour these days even on the faster surfaces.
Nadal may have blown his full load in the clay season as he tends to do. And won't be ready to go hard until US Open. Although it will be likely a bigger task this time around. Nadal isn't known for defending Slams successfully off clay.
 

Fedole

Semi-Pro
That's true but outside of the french open he's never reached a slam QF or won a single Masters 1000 despite three of them being on his favourite suface lmfao.
Nobody is denying Nadal's greatness on clay but Outside of clay thiem is a top 50 player at best.
You've done it there man. I can't respond to that!
 

George Turner

Hall of Fame
Well guys i missed the whole match because of real life. Doesn't sound like i missed anything, i'll watch the highlights at some point.

I think Thiem does deserve criticism, he may be nicknamed the prince of clay but what use is that title if he's unable to do any better against Nadal at the French than Bolelli, Haase, Marterer or Schwartzman.

They've had three matches at RG now and Thiem has won a combined 23 games without even reaching 5 games in a set. These are not good contests.
 

Mike Sams

G.O.A.T.
Well guys i missed the whole match because of real life. Doesn't sound like i missed anything, i'll watch the highlights at some point.

I think Thiem does deserve criticism, he may be nicknamed the prince of clay but what use is that title if he's unable to do any better against Nadal at the French than Bolelli, Haase, Marterer or Schwartzman.

They've had three matches at RG now and Thiem has won a combined 23 games without even reaching 5 games in a set. These are not good contests.
Let's see them play on wet clay and blue clay instead of sunny, bouncy clay.
 

clout

Hall of Fame
Just think about it. Borg has 11 majors. Djokovic 12. Nadal has 11 French Open’s alone.
That's actually ridiculous. If u exclude what nadal has done OFF clay, he'll still have the same amount of slams as the great Bjorn Borg. And if u exclude what he's done ON clay, he'll still have the same amount of slams as other past tennis legends such as Boris Becker and Stefan edberg. He's surely gotta be at least a top 2/3 player of all time by now even if he decides to retire at this very moment.
 
Last edited:

Nostradamus

Bionic Poster
Wait a minute.... James Blake just said super Quick conditions actually Favor Thiem......like at Madrid. so does this mean if it was Hot Sunny day today for the final,, thiem had better chance of winning ????
 

cucio

Legend
Nadal has likely broken clay court tennis forever for those who care about titles and stats, he has knocked the ball way out of the park. When he retires, even the future Gugas or Musters, which will be mighty giants on their own, will look like flashes in a pan. Winning just a measly 3-4 RG's? Meh.
 
Last edited:

ACE of Hearts

Bionic Poster
Thiem’s style is perfect for nadal. He seems to handle guys with the one handed in clay without much issues. Nadal played well in this match i felt especially on his serve.
 

TheGhostOfAgassi

Talk Tennis Guru
Well guys i missed the whole match because of real life. Doesn't sound like i missed anything, i'll watch the highlights at some point.

I think Thiem does deserve criticism, he may be nicknamed the prince of clay but what use is that title if he's unable to do any better against Nadal at the French than Bolelli, Haase, Marterer or Schwartzman.

They've had three matches at RG now and Thiem has won a combined 23 games without even reaching 5 games in a set. These are not good contests.
BUT he reached the final!!!
That is something new. His first ever GS final. Its a BIG deal!! And good experience.
 

George Turner

Hall of Fame
BUT he reached the final!!!
That is something new. His first ever GS final. Its a BIG deal!! And good experience.

Yes but lets face it, if he was in Nadals half he would never have got to the final :p

It is a good experience, hopefully for him next time Nadal isn't the opponent. He's already proven he can beat anyone else in the field but i'm disappointed the "prince" cannot do better against Nadal than early round journeymen.
 

Mainad

Bionic Poster
So Rafa completes La Undécima with 11 titles at Roland Garros, 11 at Monte Carlo and 11 at Barcelona. The milestones just keep coming and going. At this rate, who would dare bet against La Duodécima in 2019??

Thiem is the 7th different opponent Nadal has faced in finals at RG (others being Puerta, Federer, Söderling, Djokovic, Ferrer and Wawrinka) and, like them, ultimately came up short. At least he managed more games (9) than did Ferrer in 2013 (8) or Wawrinka last year (6).
 

The_Order

G.O.A.T.
Nadal had cramps in his hand and could barely play, yet managed to win the set 6-2 lmfao how do people still rate Thiem

You obviously didn't watch. Even though Nadal was in pain, he was still capable of playing so to say he could barely play is absolute rubbish.

And yeah, smart people will still rate Thiem. He's obviously not the calibre of Nadal on clay, but he is still a pretty damn good clay courter who will no doubt win RG one day.
 

World Beater

Hall of Fame
Federer still remains the closest who took took rafa into the 5th set in a rg final...(i.e. breaker in the 4th set).

Rafa may not be as fast as 2005 but his game is much more refined on clay. he has it all.

can thiem improve his net game, court sense, drop shots etc...seems like a really tall order...don't think he can beat this rafa...he will have to wait for nadal's level to come down...
 

mightyjeditribble

Hall of Fame
So happy for today's victory but that Ao loss still hurts after so much time... It would've been 19-18 now.
And if Fed had won Wimbledon 2008, it might have been 21-17 ... As Rafa said after that match, he had won some close ones also against Roger. Can't have them all - let's just be happy & amazed at what they both achieved.

Sent from my Moto G (5) using Tapatalk
 

Meles

Bionic Poster
Thiem didn’t even really try any new tactics. I mean even the weekend warriors on this message board are saying to take the serve out wide.
That is what Thiem has been doing all tournament and Nadal was camped out wide for return so Thiem went down the tee. He actually played a decent match and altered his serving in the 2nd to get his first percentage up. This was a big, big improvement from last year when he was out of the match early in the 2nd.:confused: I would have liked to have seen more drop shots, but not exactly a go to shot with Nadal.:confused:
 

Meles

Bionic Poster
Federer still remains the closest who took took rafa into the 5th set in a rg final...(i.e. breaker in the 4th set).

Rafa may not be as fast as 2005 but his game is much more refined on clay. he has it all.

can thiem improve his net game, court sense, drop shots etc...seems like a really tall order...don't think he can beat this rafa...he will have to wait for nadal's level to come down...
This is pretty much it. Thiem is at his speed peak this year. He may add a bit to his serve game and stamina, but don't see that getting him over the line against this Nadal. Would have been interesting if the conditions were even heavier.:oops:
 

Mike Sams

G.O.A.T.
Nadal has likely broken clay court tennis forever for those who care about titles and stats, he has knocked the ball way out of the park. When he retires, even the future Gugas or Musters, which will be mighty giants on their own, will look like flashes in a pan. Winning just a measly 3-4 RG's? Meh.
What about the future Nadals? A lot of kids are emulating Nadal's style coming up, and they're building their game for clay. Who knows what we'll see in the next few generations? Maybe the future Nadal will come right from Nadal's own tennis academy.
 

Mainad

Bionic Poster
lol ken roswell rubbing salt in the wounds did anyone notice?

I did and was a bit startled to hear him say it. I thought it was a bit tactless to say the least especially as the cameras immediately swung to focus on Thiem's forelorn face after he said it. Not Kenny's finest moment but he's 83 and an ATG so I guess we should cut him some slack!
 

Meles

Bionic Poster
And Rosewall, French Open champion from 1953 and 1968 who was called upon to present the trophy, could not help but criticise Thiem’s performance.

“Like everybody we would like to have seen a few more sets but that’s what happens in tennis,” Rosewall said on court.

“Rafa was a little bit too good and Dominic was a bit disappointing with his own game.”

https://www.express.co.uk/sport/ten...sappointing-French-Open-champion-Ken-Rosewall

@tennisaddict : that's an accurate assessment. Why would Rosewall be bitter ?
LOL. I'd love to see him laying it down on Fraud at a couple trophy ceremonies. You guys would have a fit.:rolleyes:
 

abmk

Bionic Poster
LOL. I'd love to see him laying it down on Fraud at a couple trophy ceremonies. You guys would have a fit.:rolleyes:

Nope, not at all. I wouldn't mind anyone laying into Federer for RG 08 final perf. for example. In fact, given a chance, I'd do it myself. :D
 
Top