I think this is an interesting topic and good to see it back on page 1, of the odds and ends forum.
I think rating your own city can be related how you feel about your life at a particular point in time but can also relate to experiences you have had living in other places. Also you will get different opinions from people who have visited or recently moved into your city from overseas or interstate.
As of June 2024 Australia is going through some inflationary times and the price of real estate in the capital cities has soared to unattainable levels. From an internal migration perspective there has been a flow of people from Victoria and Sydney to the Gold Coast, Brisbane and Sunshine Coast. People who have left Sydney have done so because the cost of living is too high whereas those who have left Melbourne have done so due to economic and political reasons.
Those who have always lived in Brisbane, GC and SC are starting to feel the affects of the influx of the southerners and are looking to more regional areas.
Meanwhile the city that to some extent has flown under the radar is Adelaide, which is a beautiful place but always underrated by the other states. Adelaide has a median property price less than half of Sydney. Meanwhile Perth after being in decline for over a decade has had a bit of a run in the last 3 years but due to its perceived one industry economic driver has a bit of an uncertain feel to it plus it’s a long way for the east coasters to move there. Canberra also had run in the last 4 years becoming the second most expensive city in Australia but as of June 2024 has slipped back to 3rd with Brisbane for the first time in history hitting 2nd and Melbourne is now 4th. Canberra is the only capital inland city in Australia, is close to the snowy mountains, so it gets very cold ( for Australian expectations ) and has always had a sterile feel to it with its man made lake, non period architecture and government feel to it, but I think it has its pluses.
Hobart is a city that sits still for decades and then goes on a rapid run in property prices and this happened from 2013 to 2020, which was unusually long and is now on the slide. The population in Hobart is only around 220k so a 5k influx of people from the mainland will spike property prices. Darwin, you don’t hear much about the place but it has a young population, is very humid and is prone to tropical cyclones.
I think the ideal city or region to live is a place where property values are reasonable, incomes are relatively high in proportion to property prices , an equitable climate and low-ish population density with some beauty in environment such as water or mountains.