Hardest ATP draw for any title winner?

After watching Shapovalov (ranked 54 at the time) beat...

R32 Miomir Kecmanovic (Ranked 56)
R16 Taylor Fritz (Ranked 4)
QF Tomas Machac (Ranked 24)
SF Tommy Paul (Ranked 9)
F Casper Ruud (Ranked 5)

...on his way to the 500 Dallas Open title I started to think, "what is the hardest draw faced by a player who WON the title in ANY ATP event?" I think in my opinion it would have to be Nalbandian's 2007 Madrid Masters Title where he beat...

R1 (5-7, 6-2, 6-4) Arnaud Clement
R2 (4-6, 6-4, 7-6) Tomas Berdych (9 seed)
R3 (6-2, 6-4) Juan Martin Del Potro
QF (6-1, 6-2) Rafael Nadal (2 seed)
SF (6-4, 7-6) Novak Djokovic (3 seed)
F (1-6, 6-3, 6-3) Roger Federer (1 seed)

What do you all think? If you think it's another/different title run make sure to include the draw they went through as well!
 
Last edited:

ibbi

G.O.A.T.
I think it is hard to argue with Nalbandian, tbh, love the mention of Nadal 2013 RG too, not facing anyone outside the top 60. Some others I love (and feel like I mention a lot), though less based on seeding.

Kuerten, RG97
beats Muster (RG95 champion), Kafelnikov (RG96 champion), Bruguera (RG93 & 94 champion), also Medvedev (Hamburg '97 champion).

Borg, RG78
Tanner (#9) - 6-2, 6-4, 7-6 (no sets dropped in first 3 rounds)
Ramirez (#6) - 6-3, 6-3, 6-0 (no sets dropped in first 4 rounds, Monte Carlo champ)
Barazzutti (#7) - 6-0, 6-1, 6-0
Vilas (#2) - 6-1, 6-1, 6-3 (Hamburg champ, defending champ)
 
Last edited:

ibbi

G.O.A.T.
Nalbandian's Paris Bercy win, while nothing compared to the Madrid one, is also damn impressive. The guy beat 5 (FIVE) top 15 players in a row - Moya, Federer, Ferrer, Gasquet, Nadal. Ferrer the only one to get a set off of him.

Federer's 2017 Aussie Open with his 4 top 10 wins coming back from knee surgery, including (admittedly, his pigeon, but also the US Open champion) Wawrinka, and his daddy Rafa (3-0 at the AO) is also surely up there too.
 
Last edited:

nolefam_2024

Bionic Poster
Does UTS have a hardest draw based on ELO list?
Yes :)




 

Moose Malloy

G.O.A.T.
Yes :)




thanks! Certainly wasn't expecting to see Brian Gottfried on the list.

His 1976 Los Angles win wasn't too shabby.
Dibbs
Connors
Nastase
Ashe
 

buscemi

Legend
Tsonga at the 2014 Canadian Open is often mentioned alongside Nalbandian at Madrid in 2007 as the other toughest Masters Series draw ever:

1R: Roger-Vasselin​
R32: Chardy​
R16: Djokovic​
QF: Murray​
SF: Dimitrov​
F: Federer​

I think Nalbandian's draw was a bit tougher from top to bottom, but both of these were terrific efforts.
 

Cabeza del Demonio

Professional
After watching Shapovalov (ranked 54 at the time) beat...

R32 Miomir Kecmanovic (Ranked 56)
R16 Taylor Fritz (Ranked 4)
QF Tomas Machac (Ranked 24)
SF Tommy Paul (Ranked 9)
F Casper Ruud (Ranked 5)

...on his way to the 500 Dallas Open title I started to think, "what is the hardest draw faced by a player who WON the title in ANY ATP event?" I think in my opinion it would have to be Nalbandian's 2007 Madrid Masters Title where he beat...

R1 (5-7, 6-2, 6-4) Arnaud Clement
R2 (4-6, 6-4, 7-6) Tomas Berdych (9 seed)
R3 (6-2, 6-4) Juan Martin Del Potro
QF (6-1, 6-2) Rafael Nadal (2 seed)
SF (6-4, 7-6) Novak Djokovic (3 seed)
F (1-6, 6-3, 6-3) Roger Federer (1 seed)

What do you all think? If you think it's another/different title run make sure to include the draw they went through as well!
Can't go without mentioning the legendary 2001 Wimbledon run by Goran Ivanišević:
1R: Jonsson (Qualifier, only easy match)
2R: Moyá (Major champ, former #1)
3R: Roddick (Major champ, future #1)
4R: Rusedski (Major finalist)
QF: Safin (Major champ, former #1)
SF: Henman (#4 seed and longtime contender)
F: Rafter (Major champ, former #1)
 

Turning Pro

Hall of Fame
Fed Ao 2004

Bogomolov
Hewitt
Nalbandian
Ferrero
Safin

Nadal 2011

Isner
Andujar
Ljubicic
Soderling (2 time finalist)
Murray (1 time finalist and many semis)
Fed (5 time finalist and 1 time winner)
 

buscemi

Legend
First three rounds

Goldie
Lundgren - Federer's coach, RIP.
Hlasek
Pretty solid first three rounds for Sampras. Goldie reached a career-high #27 in 1989, Hlasek reached a career-high #7 in 1989, and Lundgren came into the U.S. Open on the heels of making the finals of the RCA Championships, beating Agassi before losing to Becker.
 

Hitman

Bionic Poster
Pretty solid first three rounds for Sampras. Goldie reached a career-high #27 in 1989, Hlasek reached a career-high #7 in 1989, and Lundgren came into the U.S. Open on the heels of making the finals of the RCA Championships, beating Agassi before losing to Becker.

Agree. Incredible run.
 
Goran Wimbledon 2001.

R1: Jonsson
R2: Moya

R3: Roddick
R4: Rusedski
QF: Safin
SF: Henman

F: Rafter
Can't go without mentioning the legendary 2001 Wimbledon run by Goran Ivanišević:
1R: Jonsson (Qualifier, only easy match)
2R: Moyá (Major champ, former #1)
3R: Roddick (Major champ, future #1)
4R: Rusedski (Major finalist)
QF: Safin (Major champ, former #1)
SF: Henman (#4 seed and longtime contender)
F: Rafter (Major champ, former #1)
Looks good on paper but Moyá and Safin weren’t good on grass (besides in the strong era), Rusedski vultured grass tournaments in Nottingham and at the Hall of Fame but didn’t do much elsewhere and Roddick was young and injured
 

Third Serve

Talk Tennis Guru
They weren’t unusual for the tournaments themselves since they could afford playing the big four and other top players with many title runs being more impressive than a good chunk of masters runs.
Agree that those 500s tended to attract strong draws, but even with that consideration those two draws were uniquely difficult.
 
Top