21-2 and Andy rarely even took a set, even in some of his 'high peak' performances vs. Federer. 2009 WB was the only time he even pushed Roger to 5, and in pretty much every final even in Masters he just bent over, like clockwork, every single damn time.
I'm not one of the weak era theorists bc I really do respect Andy's talent but it wasn't even that Roger was playing GOATing peak level tennis all the time. That's the maddening part. Roddick never believed in his soul that he could do anything against Federer. He fired his coaches and tried to change his entire game because of it. We make fun of NextGen but he was such a mentally weak player when it came to Roger - like if he existed today he would be called the most mentally fragile mug on tour.
I'm not saying Roger didn't deserve to win, but ffs. Win at least once against him Andy. He didn't kill American tennis, but he was the only one who could have saved it, and he failed spectacularly in all honesty. H2H over Novak be damned, he had a failed career and I hate him for it because he had the talent to be so, so much more.