Higher USO peak?

[RS]

Who wins and versions can be included too as well as the difference in court speeds in certain additions (you might say Fed wins on faster court and Djoko on a slower one)

 

[Standaa]

PETE and it's not even close.

 

[mike danny]

I'd say Fed. The matches themselves attest to this.

 

[StrongRule]

Is this a serious question?

 

[Third Serve]

Fed by some margin. I'd be curious to hear about any opposing arguments since even the H2H which so many cling to tends to favor Fed slightly.

 

[Start da Game]

fraud 2004 - 2006

 

[ABCD]

Easy. That match was played in 2015.

 

[Third Serve]

Fed by some margin. I'd be curious to hear about any opposing arguments since even the H2H which so many cling to tends to favor Fed slightly.

Easy. That match was played in 2015.

Never mind

 

[NoleFam]

Who cares about peak to peak? Djokovic beat Federer and 20,000 of his fans singlehandedly. #onemanshow #noassistancerequired

 

[Yugram]

Djokovic by significant margin.

 

[Third Serve]

Who cares about peak to peak? Djokovic beat Federer and 20,000 of his fans singlehandedly. #onemanshow #noassistancerequired

Avatar ignore prevents me from seeing this image.

 

[NoleFam]

Avatar ignore prevents me from seeing this image.

You better turn it back on

 

[OldschoolKIaus]

Edberg 1992

 

[Bamoos]

Peak for peak : Federer
Peak Pushovic against old man choking no FH no ground game mentally weak 2015 Fed : Djokovic

 

[MeatTornado]

Fed fans say Fred. Novak fans plus some Ned fans say Djoker.

See y'all at the next one.

 

[BackhandDTL]

2010 Nadal at the USO was the highest peak ever seen, followed closely by 04-06 Fed

 

[OldschoolKIaus]

2010 Nadal at the USO was the highest peak ever seen, followed closely by 04-06 Fed

2003 Roddick > 2010 Nadal

 

[RS]

Who cares about peak to peak? Djokovic beat Federer and 20,000 of his fans singlehandedly. #onemanshow #noassistancerequired

Federer is not my main guy so IDC that he lost and it was quality tennis from both which is what matters to me when these two play

 

[TheNachoMan]

2010 and 2011 answered that question

 

[Third Serve]

Peak for peak : Federer
Peak Pushovic against old man choking no FH no ground game mentally weak 2015 Fed : Djokovic

well that was a mouthful

 

[StrongRule]

Djokovic by significant margin.

How did you come back so fast?

 

[BackhandDTL]

even if Fed is at a marginally higher level he’s not beating Djokovic 2011 or Nadal 2010, simply because he’s not the same big game player.

 

[Bamoos]

2010 and 2011 answered that question

They did indeed

post prime spraying 2011 Fed with 2-0 and double MP against peak Djokovic

peak fearhand 06 Fed with peak defence, movement powerful serve etc in straight sets, or 4 if his concentration dips for a set.

 

[StrongRule]

2010 and 2011 answered that question

Exactly. Peak Djokovic in 2011 only won because past prime Federer choked like crazy. Now imagine what peak Federer would do to him then.

 

[Bamoos]

even if Fed is at a marginally higher level he’s not beating Djokovic 2011 or Nadal 2010, simply because he’s not the same big game player.

11/16 slams won during peak years says otherwise. Most prolific player ever. Most slams won while peak. The other two vultures not on same level bud.

 

[Krish872007]

Nadl.

 

[NoleFam]

Federer is not my main guy so IDC that he lost and it was quality tennis from both which is that matters when these two play

Oh I know you don't care if he loses. You just enjoy the show when you create threads like this. Lol.

 

[BackhandDTL]

2003 Roddick > 2010 Nadal

Yes one dimensional Roddick beats peak Nadal. Good thinking.

Nadal spams that backhand until Roddick is spun out of the court

 

[Nadalgaenger]

Fed by some margin. I'd be curious to hear about any opposing arguments since even the H2H which so many cling to tends to favor Fed slightly.

I voted for Fed BUT we have to remember that 2007 Djokovic caused Fed significant problems in 2007. He really could have won first two sets.
Fed easily could have won 2011 against best version of Djokovic...He wins one of those service points and this conversation becomes a joke!
The problem will always be that peak Fed never faced peak Nole...

 

[Third Serve]

Yes one dimensional Roddick beats peak Nadal. Good thinking.

Nadal spams that backhand until Roddick is spun out of the court

ooh, sensitive!

 

[BackhandDTL]

ooh, sensitive!

Where do I sound sensitive? Quite rich coming from Fed fans.

 

[mike danny]

Oh I know you don't care if he loses. You just enjoy the show when you create threads like this. Lol.

 

[The Blond Blur]

Fed fans say Fred. Novak fans plus some Ned fans say Djoker.

See y'all at the next one.

Laughs in @The Blond Blur

Spoiler

 

[edberg volleys]

Who cares about peak to peak? Djokovic beat Federer and 20,000 of his fans singlehandedly. #onemanshow #noassistancerequired

Federer is not my main guy so IDC that he lost and it was quality tennis from both which is what matters to me when these two play

CYGS likes this. Most objective poster I've ever seen. Boy, he/she is really something else!!

 

[NoleFam]

No one:
RS: Yes

Lol.

 

[edberg volleys]

Fed 2004 US highest peak

 

[Backspin1183]

Where do I sound sensitive? Quite rich coming from Fed fans.

OMG! Can't believe how sensitive some Nadal fans are.

 

[Backspin1183]

ooh, sensitive!

OMG! Can't believe how sensitive some Federer fans are.

 

[BackhandDTL]

OMG! Can't believe how sensitive some Nadal fans are.

bamos

 

[bhpower]

Federer was higher, his attacking style was amazing, but courts were faster by then (2004-2007).
That helped him a little.

 

[Backspin1183]

Who cares about peak to peak? Djokovic beat Federer and 20,000 of his fans singlehandedly. #onemanshow #noassistancerequired

OMG! Can't believe how sensitive some Djokovic fans are.

 

[Third Serve]

OMG! Can't believe how sensitive some Nadal fans are.

OMG! Can't believe how sensitive some Federer fans are.

OMG! Can't believe how sensitive some Djokovic fans are.

i has confuse

 

[BeatlesFan]

PETE and it's not even close.

You took the words out of my mouth. Peak Pete at USO (1995, I'd say) is better than any version of Roger or Djokovic at the USO, particularly Djokovic.

 

[BeatlesFan]

Yes one dimensional Roddick beats peak Nadal. Good thinking.

How'd a "one dimensional player" ever manage to reach the #1 ranking? Never mind that Roddick beat Nadal three times on HC.

 

[NoleFam]

OMG! Can't believe how sensitive some Djokovic fans are.

LOL.

I know you're secretly grinning at this though. Epic!

 

[BackhandDTL]

How'd a "one dimensional player" ever manage to reach the #1 ranking? Never mind that Roddick beat Nadal three times on HC.

2003 was a comparatively weak era that allowed guys like Hewitt and Roddick to take the big titles. I wonder how they’d do with prime Federer/Nadal or Djokovic in the mix?

And young Murray beat prime Federer almost every time in the masters. How’d they fare in slams?

You can look at Nadals results against Roddick at 500s like Dubai or one of Nadal’s worst masters —Miami— to build your argument but it won’t be very credible.

 

[NatF]

Fed in 4.

 

[RS]

Oh I know you don't care if he loses. You just enjoy the show when you create threads like this. Lol.

Looking at the comments while rewatching the RG 05 final. Thread could get more heated in the next couple day would not say i am enjoying the show yet

 

[mike danny]

The problem will always be that peak Fed never faced peak Nole...

Right back at you.

 

[NoleFam]

Looking at the comments while rewatching the RG 05 final. Thread could get more heated in the next couple day would not say i am enjoying the show yet

Such an instigator.