How do you rank Alcaraz's 2025 Year Compare to the best Years of Federer/Nadal/Djokovic?

[McEnroeisanartist]

How does Alcaraz's 2025 Year Compared to the best Years of Federer/Nadal/Djokovic?

Alcaraz
2025 - 5 titles from 7 finals at the Big Tournaments (Grand Slams, ATP Tour Finals, and Masters 1000)

Federer
2004 - 7 titles from 7 finals
2005 - 6 titles from 7 finals
2006 - 8 titles from 11 finals
2007 - 6 titles from 10 finals
2017 - 5 titles from 6 finals

Nadal
2008 - 6 titles from 7 finals
2010 - 6 titles from 7 finals
2013 - 7 titles from 9 finals

Djokovic
2011 - 8 titles from 9 finals
2014 - 6 titles from 7 finals *note won just one Grand Slam
2015 - 10 titles from 13 finals
2016 - 6 titles from 9 finals
2023 - 6 titles from 7 finals
2021* - 4 titles from 6 finals, but won 3 Grand Slams

Sinner
2024 - 6 titles from 6 finals
2025 - 4 titles from 8 finals

 

[rUDin 21]

Fed in 2017 had same number of titles and still finished year no.2
So much about weak era.

 

[smoledman]

Alcaraz in 2025 had his first ATG level year, let's see if he can add a few more.

 

[jackson vile]

How does Alcaraz's 2025 Year Compared to the best Years of Federer/Nadal/Djokovic?

Alcaraz
2025 - 5 titles from 6 finals at the Big Tournaments (Grand Slams, ATP Tour Finals, and Masters 1000)

Federer
2004 - 7 titles from 7 finals
2005 - 6 titles from 7 finals
2006 - 8 titles from 11 finals
2007 - 6 titles from 10 finals
2017 - 5 titles from 6 finals

Nadal
2008 - 6 titles from 7 finals
2010 - 6 titles from 7 finals
2013 - 7 titles from 9 finals

Djokovic
2011 - 8 titles from 9 finals
2014 - 6 titles from 7 finals *note won just one Grand Slam
2015 - 10 titles from 13 finals
2016 - 6 titles from 9 finals
2023 - 6 titles from 7 finals
2021* - 4 titles from 6 finals, but won 3 Grand Slams

Sinner
2024 - 6 titles from 6 finals
2025 - 4 titles from 8 finals

Novak is crazy!

 

[mehdimike]

How does Alcaraz's 2025 Year Compared to the best Years of Federer/Nadal/Djokovic?

Alcaraz
2025 - 5 titles from 6 finals at the Big Tournaments (Grand Slams, ATP Tour Finals, and Masters 1000)

Federer
2004 - 7 titles from 7 finals
2005 - 6 titles from 7 finals
2006 - 8 titles from 11 finals
2007 - 6 titles from 10 finals
2017 - 5 titles from 6 finals

Nadal
2008 - 6 titles from 7 finals
2010 - 6 titles from 7 finals
2013 - 7 titles from 9 finals

Djokovic
2011 - 8 titles from 9 finals
2014 - 6 titles from 7 finals *note won just one Grand Slam
2015 - 10 titles from 13 finals
2016 - 6 titles from 9 finals
2023 - 6 titles from 7 finals
2021* - 4 titles from 6 finals, but won 3 Grand Slams

Sinner
2024 - 6 titles from 6 finals
2025 - 4 titles from 8 finals

Alcaraz 5 out of 6?!
Shouldn't it be 5 out of 7? Off the top of my head, he lost at Wimb and YEC.

 

[N01E]

It would have been #12 on their overall seasons ranking. Not as good as Rafa's 2008/2013 and Roger's 2005, but better than Rafa's 2017/2019, Roger's 2009 and Novak's 2018 (comparing to other 2 slams YE#1 seasons, achievement wise only).

 

[Bardland]

Don't forget Murray's 2016 season.
6 titles from 10 big finals
Overall 9 titles from 13(!) finals
Wimbledon, Olympic Gold (only player in history to win two singles Olympic Golds), ATP Finals winner.
YE No.1 (Had more points than 2025 Alcaraz and that's under the old system where you got fewer points for finishing runner up)