How does Roger Federer do it after all these years?

Haven't checked the entire thread but wondered if VB has come in and raised doping allegations LOL. Only a matter of time.:)
 
Do you expect him to keep quiet if he is injured? You seem to b upset anytime the "unbeatable when healthy" facade could possibly be explained, but are more than willing to defend the "only loses because he's old" whenever Fed loses. Your "old" narrative is far more conveniant than that of Nadal's "injured" narrative.

Federer being "old" doesn't render his losses invalid, what it does is move them out of the scope of peak/prime discussions, whichever is relevant. E.g. Nadal and Djokovic don't become better Wimbledon players than Federer by virtue of beating him in a Wimbledon final, or Djokovic doesn't become a better USO player than Federer because he's 3-0 H2H there since 2010, and any attempt to construe them as such (if only not for weak era / injuries, oh boy!) is plainly insulting. I don't need to give Federer hypothetical titles or superiority - the accolades speak for themselves. Yes, there are Fedfans who want to go all the way here - I don't, Federer's career is self-justifying.

It's important in comparing specific player H2Hs/matches only. Like, for an obvious example, it would be stupid to criticise Murray for not beating Djokovic at AO when Istomin could do it, since Murray faced a better Djokovic (although he could've done better still). In the context of weighing careers, it's not too significant.
 
Fed had a crappy serving day in that final. The pressure of having to maintain his level in other areas without the backup of his serve got to him by the 5th set, I believe. Hence the crumbling in the 5th set with a string of UEs.
He did play well in the rallies and return well in that final.
But remember the two games I told you about in set 3. Twice leading 0/40 towards the end of the set. I forget it if was two game in a row or two out of three, but even with that he got to the TB. Then won the next set.

So he already had the 2nd set in the bag. This issue in set 3 was not his serve. He could not buy a BP to sell his soul, and by the time he made it to the TB, he was rattled.

Perhaps it was the slower court surface that made things so different, but to my eyes it looked like Nadal by that point in his career was simply in his head, not that his overall game was in any way weak, at least that day.
 
Federer being "old" doesn't render his losses invalid, what it does is move them out of the scope of peak/prime discussions, whichever is relevant. E.g. Nadal and Djokovic don't become better Wimbledon players than Federer by virtue of beating him in a Wimbledon final, or Djokovic doesn't become a better USO player than Federer because he's 3-0 H2H there since 2010, and any attempt to construe them as such (if only not for weak era / injuries, oh boy!) is plainly insulting. I don't need to give Federer hypothetical titles or superiority - the accolades speak for themselves. Yes, there are Fedfans who want to go all the way here - I don't, Federer's career is self-justifying.

It's important in comparing specific player H2Hs/matches only. Like, for an obvious example, it would be stupid to criticise Murray for not beating Djokovic at AO when Istomin could do it, since Murray faced a better Djokovic (although he could've done better still). In the context of weighing careers, it's not too significant.
Exact same logic can be used for injuries. An injured player is not playing closer to their peak than an "old" player. Also, this logic is way too convenient as it basically nulls any loss your player faces for the past 10 years, but wait, if he wins it counts double because he's old and he's facing young opposition. So in Federer's 20-year career, he was too "young" for 5 years and too old for 10 years. So basically we can only count the 5 years he was in his "prime." That's 25% of his career that only then we can count losses. The last 50% it doesn't count cuz he's old but the wins count though.
 
Nadal losing early on grass starting from 26 = Fed skipping clay at near 36.

Fed has made an RG semi and two quarters since Nadal last reached the Wimby quarters and Federer is 5 years older. The last time Federer lost before the 4th round of the French was 14 years ago. Stick to talking about Nadal when arguing for Nadal.
I understand your disappointment with Nadal's underperformance at Wimbledon in recent years, especially considering it comes after his triumph over Federer in 2008. Who knows, maybe this year he'll do better?
 
9-3 : A clay king who missed a lot of dates at Fed’s best HC venues in Fed’s prime. While Fed made it to the dance on Nadal’s venue with a lot more consistency.

I.e. Fed get’s penalized for being better on clay than Nadal is on HC and grass.
On the other hand, part of the reason he has 19 slams is because he didn't have to play Nadal more often in slam finals. It's a blessing in disguise for Fed.
 
Federer being "old" doesn't render his losses invalid, what it does is move them out of the scope of peak/prime discussions, whichever is relevant. E.g. Nadal and Djokovic don't become better Wimbledon players than Federer by virtue of beating him in a Wimbledon final, or Djokovic doesn't become a better USO player than Federer because he's 3-0 H2H there since 2010, and any attempt to construe them as such (if only not for weak era / injuries, oh boy!) is plainly insulting. I don't need to give Federer hypothetical titles or superiority - the accolades speak for themselves. Yes, there are Fedfans who want to go all the way here - I don't, Federer's career is self-justifying.

It's important in comparing specific player H2Hs/matches only. Like, for an obvious example, it would be stupid to criticise Murray for not beating Djokovic at AO when Istomin could do it, since Murray faced a better Djokovic (although he could've done better still). In the context of weighing careers, it's not too significant.
Then when it comes to Nadal you're unwilling to use the same logic. All of his losses count simply because he was in the "prime" age range but everyone knows a lot of these losses were the direct result of injuries. Oh wait, but all the losses to Federer count because he's younger than him! Even if Nadal is out of form, injured, and old these losses count because he is "less older" than Federer. Let me tell you something. Age doesn't really matter, form does. Judging a players wins and losses based on age is stupid, at least when that player has been riddled with injuries. What matters is when 2 players are playing their best tennis and in the final they square off, no excuses of age or all that BS, if they are in the final and have dominated previous opponents like in WIMB 2014, 2015. Age then does not matter, especially with someone like Federer who's style does not rely on a young age at all. If Federer had a style like Novak or Nadal you'd actually have more of a point because the decline would be much greater. But here we are in 2017/2018 and Federer is playing some of the best tennis of his career but the losses dont count cuz he's facing younger opponents but the wins do count. No. If an in-form players faces an in-form player, there are no excuses. That's what matters
 
He used to run into dangerous grasscourt journeymen in early Wimbledon rounds before (every top player does more or less), he just beat them every time. To make a shift from that to losing to them all the time can't be down to luck even considering how small margins can be in tennis.

I think it may be just as simple as losing a step, make Nadal fraction of a second late to hit a passing shot on faster 1st week grass and he suddenly becomes a lot more beatable. Of course that loss in physicality also affects his mental strength but that is really one aspect of the game that should never be viewed in isolation, especially when we're talking about ATGs (who by their nature have to be very mentally strong to achieve what they did, regardless of their immense talent).
Yes, I didn't mean that his luck has turned against him recently. Maybe there is no luck involved at all, although certainly I have rationalized it that way at times. It's probably a combination of manythings (not the least the fact that all these losses have set a precedent, and now any player believes he can beat Nadal on the surface.)
 
On the other hand, part of the reason he has 19 slams is because he didn't have to play Nadal more often in slam finals. It's a blessing in disguise for Fed.

you've already been owned on this.

For this to happen, Nadal's prime on HC would have to be earlier , that means he'd take his losses to federer as well in HC slams.
Federer would make up for those 1-2 slams later, given his longevity.
How about Nadal ? more unlikely.

in slam finals outside of clay, their h2h is 3-2 in favour of federer.

in finals outside of clay, the h2h is 8-3 in favour of federer. :oops:
 
you've already been owned on this.

For this to happen, Nadal's prime on HC would have to be earlier , that means he'd take his losses to federer as well in HC slams.
Federer would make up for those 1-2 slams later, given his longevity.
How about Nadal ? more unlikely.

in slam finals outside of clay, their h2h is 3-2 in favour of federer.

in finals outside of clay, the h2h is 8-3 in favour of federer. :oops:
It doesn't need to be slam finals. The fact is Nadal has a positive H2H in HC slams against Fed. It really doesn't matter, though. The H2H is only of secondary importance. Especially after last year. :D
 
Ive never shied away from the truth of Federer choking, it's his biggest bane and why he lost so many big matches to opponent who didn't play better than him (i.e. equal or actually he was slightly better).
Just to make the point clear, your point and mine is not the same.

Fedfans concentrate on losses. Fans of other players do the same thing.

I don't totally trust these stats because who knows who is counting, and how many things are screwed up. But lets accept for the moment that they are at least ball park:

http://www.atpworldtour.com/en/stats/break-points-saved/all/all/all/

There are the top servers again, not in aces, but in being absolutely horrible to break.

Note the places of Nadal and Fed. Djokovic is lower.

Not surprisingly Novak is very high in 2011.

Look at Fed and Novak in 2015.

Check out Nadal, career, clay.

Now, check out profiles:

http://www.atpworldtour.com/en/players/rafael-nadal/n409/player-stats

http://www.atpworldtour.com/en/players/roger-federer/f324/player-stats

Check career, year, surface.

If you check BPs saved against total service points won, total service points will be close but on average a point or two higher. This will go up and down by season, but it is close.

Now check BPs converted against return points won. In general this will be the same or slightly higher for BPs won.

Why is it usually a point or two lower for service, a point or two higher for returns?

I don't know. But if you check 100 or so people, when you add BPs saved to BPs converted, the total will be very close to service points won and return points won.

For Fed, career, 67+41 vs 69+40.

For Nadal, career, 66+45 vs 67+42

Do you see how close those both are?

Djokovic
65+44
67+42

This time dead on, with the same slight deficit on BPs saved and slight bonus on BPs converted.

You can expect more points on service for Fed, fewer on return, which is in line with the way they all win games.

Fedfans cherry pick matches he had poor BP conversions in, which is understandable, but we don't (unfortunately) had any way to compare how BPs are handled between early rounds in majors and later rounds. If there is a weakness that's where it will show up, and we know, from the fact that Sampras was an absolute beast at Wimbledon in the last three rounds, that IF we had those stats for him, those BP stat would be higher than usual, in comparison to other players - meaning that in final rounds, compared to himself, on grass, he was especially clutch on BPs.
I'm pointing out that Nadal has also become a choker (check his five-set record since 2012, for instance), and that isn't directly age-related either, he's just not that confident when he can't rely on his physical attributes so much under duress, so the idea of Nadal possessing titanic innate mental strength is an illusion.
That part is right. Novak was titanic in 2011 and in 2015-2016 (during his slam run), primarily on HCs, especially on slow HCs. Nadal was a total beast during his winning years, and pretty much every year on clay.

To see how closely BPs are based on all points, check this out:

http://www.atpworldtour.com/en/players/roger-federer/f324/player-stats

50% of points won on return, 52% of BPs.

66% of service points won, 65% of BPs.

Note how close those number are, how the sums are within one point.

Those number will diverge a lot for matches, and for short periods. But for long periods the are very predictable.

Compare with Nadal on grass, career. Again adding up points and BPs, the difference is one percent.

Most of this "choking" is just about a player with an edge playing one he knows he has an edge over, and is that really choking? We don't say the opposite when the players we are rooting for win. We just say they are winning matches they are supposed to win.

The two players who most frequently got into Fed's head were Nadal and Djokovic, and it shows.

Now we'll see who is in the heads of the others this year, which will be a huge part of this season coming up.

Who's on top mentally? How much of that is due to changes in physical dominance, mostly about injuries now.
 
Fedfans cherry pick matches he had poor BP conversions in, which is understandable, but we don't (unfortunately) had any way to compare how BPs are handled between early rounds in majors and later rounds. If there is a weakness that's where it will show up, and we know, from the fact that Sampras was an absolute beast at Wimbledon in the last three rounds, that IF we had those stats for him, those BP stat would be higher than usual, in comparison to other players - meaning that in final rounds, compared to himself, on grass, he was especially clutch on BPs.

That part is right. Novak was titanic in 2011 and in 2015-2016 (during his slam run), primarily on HCs, especially on slow HCs. Nadal was a total beast during his winning years, and pretty much every year on clay.

Yes, you have to add up manually from TA stats - very reliable for BPs, by the way, I've yet to find an error other than an obvious glitch, e.g. "-2/6" is obviously wrong (minus 2 BPs saved, eh?), but 4/8 is 4/8 and not 3/7 or 4/10, you can be sure of that. BP stuff is a field of analysis yet to be explored in detail.
 
It doesn't need to be slam finals. The fact is Nadal has a positive H2H in HC slams against Fed.

not according to you ...;)

"On the other hand, part of the reason he has 19 slams is because he didn't have to play Nadal more often in slam finals."

It really doesn't matter, though. The H2H is only of secondary importance. Especially after last year. :D

oh yeah, the one against Djokovic became of secondary importance after 2015-16, when Djoko overtook Nadal in the h2h.
Now after 2017, its of secondary importance vs Federer as well :D
 
I was at his practice session today and had to laugh about all the people in the opposite court's grandstand who were all standing up and turning around to watch Federer instead of the actual match they'd been spectating.
 
Fed’s play at his age has been remarkable. We have to go back to Rosewall to find a player that played as well in his mid-30’s. I believe that his versatility and very good serving is what keeps him competitive.
 
Fed’s play at his age has been remarkable. We have to go back to Rosewall to find a player that played as well in his mid-30’s. I believe that his versatility and very good serving is what keeps him competitive.

I believe that we’ll have a much clearer picture as to which player is the best of this century in 5 years. Right now, Federer has a massive lead, IMHO.

The most important stats to me in no particular order are:

Weeks at #1
wins vs top 5 for a career
# of slam trophies
#of World Tour Finals trophies

Djokovic to me appeared to be on pace to pass Federer if his peak lasted through the end of this year. If he would have had 320 weeks at #1, 15 slam titles, 7 World Tour Finals trophies, while passing Fed in wins vs the top 5, then that would have been enough to pass him. Granted, he would have been 2 slam titles behind Fed. But his other records would have been enough to pass Fed, IMHO.

But Djokovic slowed down while Fed added to his stats.

But now, he still trails Fed in all of those categories by quite a bit, except for WTF titles.

Nadal is odd in that he has a bunch of losses to scrubs early in slams. But once he gets to the 2nd week, he is nearly unbeatable.
 
On the other hand, part of the reason he has 19 slams is because he didn't have to play Nadal more often in slam finals. It's a blessing in disguise for Fed.

Dude, I have no idea how you can say that when Fed-Nadal hold the record for most slam final meetings in the open era. NOBODY has played Nadal more often in slam finals. Fed has 19 Slams IN SPITE of his lopsided h2h with Nadal in Slams. Nadal has done a great job of preventing Fed from winning Slams, especially at RG and maybe even AO. What more could Rafa have done? He could have prevented 2009 RG, but he lost to Soderling. You can't count on him to prevent Fed winning Wimbledon because he always goes down to scrubs in the first week. He could have and SHOULD have prevented AO 2017, but lost despite having a 10 year long Slam win streak.
 
On the other hand, part of the reason he has 19 slams is because he didn't have to play Nadal more often in slam finals. It's a blessing in disguise for Fed.

Dude, I have no idea how you can say that when Fed-Nadal hold the record for most slam final meetings in the open era. NOBODY has played Nadal more often in slam finals. Fed has 19 Slams IN SPITE of his lopsided h2h with Nadal in Slams. Nadal has done a great job of preventing Fed from winning Slams, especially at RG and maybe even AO. What more could Rafa have done? He could have prevented 2009 RG, but he lost to Soderling. You can't count on him to prevent Fed winning Wimbledon because he always goes down to scrubs in the first week. He could have and SHOULD have prevented AO 2017, but lost despite having a 10 year long Slam win streak.
 
Paul Annacone made an interesting point recently that Federer loves the same things that other players hate. Things like travel and the nomadic life, organising hitting partners, having to live out of hotel rooms which other pros dread, Federer seems to thrive on. And he has a huge amount of assistance in organising all these tasks. Annacone said he has never seen another player with this fascination and attention to detail with the most mundane daily tasks.

He loves the lifestyle but, more importantly, he has so much money and resources that he can really buffer the harshness of the nomadic existence of the travelling pro . This is one of the main reasons that he can stay fresh and and be successful.

Another key is the fact that he is resting so much of the season now because his winning percentage is so high he can afford to take massive amounts of time off and just relax while everyone else is grinding away and just focus on his strengths. It's been quite a while since he has played a full calendar and that is a huge, huge advantage to have over the majority of the field. It's a big privilege to essentially be able to bypass the most gruelling part of the season. Very fortunate and a big, big advantage that Federer is using very cleverly.
 
Last edited:
Then when it comes to Nadal you're unwilling to use the same logic. All of his losses count simply because he was in the "prime" age range but everyone knows a lot of these losses were the direct result of injuries. Oh wait, but all the losses to Federer count because he's younger than him! Even if Nadal is out of form, injured, and old these losses count because he is "less older" than Federer. Let me tell you something. Age doesn't really matter, form does. Judging a players wins and losses based on age is stupid, at least when that player has been riddled with injuries. What matters is when 2 players are playing their best tennis and in the final they square off, no excuses of age or all that BS, if they are in the final and have dominated previous opponents like in WIMB 2014, 2015. Age then does not matter, especially with someone like Federer who's style does not rely on a young age at all. If Federer had a style like Novak or Nadal you'd actually have more of a point because the decline would be much greater. But here we are in 2017/2018 and Federer is playing some of the best tennis of his career but the losses dont count cuz he's facing younger opponents but the wins do count. No. If an in-form players faces an in-form player, there are no excuses. That's what matters
I guess Fed really is better than Nadal then.

4-0 versus a world #1 level “in-form” Rafa in 2017.
 
Exact same logic can be used for injuries. An injured player is not playing closer to their peak than an "old" player. Also, this logic is way too convenient as it basically nulls any loss your player faces for the past 10 years, but wait, if he wins it counts double because he's old and he's facing young opposition. So in Federer's 20-year career, he was too "young" for 5 years and too old for 10 years. So basically we can only count the 5 years he was in his "prime." That's 25% of his career that only then we can count losses. The last 50% it doesn't count cuz he's old but the wins count though.
A players prime is usually 5 years or less.

Federer is playing GOATERER past prime level at 36. Which is better than just about everyone else in their prime. But that’s what GOATS do. Fed’s been World #2 or better for at least a part of every year since 2003.

But He’s not been in his personal prime since probably 2007, it’s just that he’s too GOATERER to stop winning at 36.
 
Last edited:
Then when it comes to Nadal you're unwilling to use the same logic. All of his losses count simply because he was in the "prime" age range but everyone knows a lot of these losses were the direct result of injuries. Oh wait, but all the losses to Federer count because he's younger than him! Even if Nadal is out of form, injured, and old these losses count because he is "less older" than Federer. Let me tell you something. Age doesn't really matter, form does. Judging a players wins and losses based on age is stupid, at least when that player has been riddled with injuries. What matters is when 2 players are playing their best tennis and in the final they square off, no excuses of age or all that BS, if they are in the final and have dominated previous opponents like in WIMB 2014, 2015. Age then does not matter, especially with someone like Federer who's style does not rely on a young age at all. If Federer had a style like Novak or Nadal you'd actually have more of a point because the decline would be much greater. But here we are in 2017/2018 and Federer is playing some of the best tennis of his career but the losses dont count cuz he's facing younger opponents but the wins do count. No. If an in-form players faces an in-form player, there are no excuses. That's what matters
But dude, age does matter when you're comparing 2 ATG's. It doesn't matter how well Fed does against the Murray's and Wawrinka's, they are not ATG and Fed has always done well against them anyway.

So you're telling me that Federer at age 34 was supposed to beat a peak Novak having his best period ever? You're delusional if you really believe that. Why did Nadal fail to win a single match against a 35-36 year old (including a slam final) last year when he was playing well? 30-31 year old failed against his only ATG opponent who was 35-36, but 33-34 year old Fed was supposed to beat an ATG who was actually younger than him and at his peak. Yeah, sure thing bro.....Imagine Nadal going up against 2015 Djokovic last year. He would have been lucky to win even half of what he did.

Of course, all wins count regardless of age. Nobody is ignoring Federer's losses. He lost fair and square. The problem comes when you try to extrapolate from those losses and say "oh, Djokovic is better than Fed, Fed is a weak era mug, Fed has a losing record against his rivals, so he sucks" without looking at the full picture. In that case, sorry, you can't disregard age just to throw mud at Federer. It's ok to say that all losses count, but it's not ok to say that age has no factor whatsoever in comparing Fed with Novak and Rafa.
 
Unfortunately though he never had the makings of being a big match player against his biggest rivals.

Biggest rivals were reduced to trash 2004 - 2007. Youre talking about novak and rafa? They shouldnt be feds rivals its actually bad on novaks and nads legacy that gramps has been beating them. Nads and novaks inability to stop fed from being a rival is not good for their legacies. Fed shouldnt be a foctor to these guys and certainly should not be beating them in grandslams as he has been doing
 
Last edited:
Biggest rivals were reduced to trash 2004 - 2007. Youre talking about novak and rafa? They shouldnt be feds rivals its actually bad on novaks and nads legacy that gramps has been beating them. Nads and novaks inability to stop fed from being a rival is not good for their legacies
THIS THIS, A THOUSAND TIMES THIS

Fed’s detractors so often gloss over this.

Nadal should be KILLING Fed by now. EVERYWHERE.

Novak’s H2H w Fed should not even be close. It’s practically a dead heat.
 
But how can his age only be a problem when he loses? He gets to a lot of these finals pretty convincly a lot of the time and as RF-18 pointed out, he also has home crowd support most of the time. Even last year he is constantly getting to finals and able to beat the field in straight sets at Wimbledon. Age doesn't seem to be much of a problem for him when he's winning.
Well yeah, Djokovic and Federer fans do because they couldn't handle him. Notice how Nadal doesn't really need to do that with Federer on grass or Djokovic on hard. He has handled himself just fine against them in slams.

Becuase he is that good that a declined level of him is good enough to make peak version of any player who is not an ATG look like a complete mug. It must be pretty disheartening for a professional tennis player to play theyre very best and still be tossed around by a grandpa fed or even a injured fed. Fed could probably beat most of the tour as a 40 year old.

Against an ATG it is not that simple. Yes even in a declined state he often routinely beats a peak Nadal or Djokovic but he obviously isn't going to do it that often. Just as Nadal and Djoker have themselves lost to fed and the other guy FIFTY TIMES (and in Nadals case its even worse as he has a bad record against non ATG's and even journey men and mugs in a way federer and djokovic simply dont)... because its not that simple

It doesnt make sense to hold fed to this standard also apart from because u think he is thag great and he makes tennis look so easy. Nadal cant even dominate a single full year, djokovic does a 2011 and then goes in hiding. He had another good year and then once again becomes irrelevant (he is much more consistent than nadal though and overall very consistent) yet fed did what the others did in their whole careers basically in one non stop strech 2004-2007 and then multiple times again. Nadal etc cant even do that for 1 year. Even in this field, nads did ok last year and will not dominate 2018 virtually 99% guaranteed. Yet you expect fed to do more than 2004-2007? Lol, let Nadal dominate just one full year and novak do 2 years and lets talk then.

Feds 2004-2007 is enough for him to be GOAT just based on that (obviously he didnt just do that though) Yet as he is that good and he makes tennis look that easy you have basically set such a high standard that you dont for e.g. nadal who cant even dominate a full year ever and makes tennis look lkke a brutal hard sport
 
Last edited:
Back
Top