How many more titles could have Sinner won without getting disrupted by his team's negligence?

So how many more titles could he have won this year without getting burdened?

  • 4+

    Votes: 2 7.7%
  • 4

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 3

    Votes: 4 15.4%
  • 2

    Votes: 2 7.7%
  • 1

    Votes: 1 3.8%
  • 0

    Votes: 17 65.4%

  • Total voters
    26

Rovesciarete

Hall of Fame
The world is full of wild fancies but the ITIA report states Sinner was contaminated without fault or negligence. CAS will look into the appeal of WADA, which wants to clarify if there is some negligence on the part of the player. Obviously, no relevant body accuses the number 1 of doping, given the simple facts of the case. Still, a great deal of mental harm and stress were inflicted on the dominant player of the tour and illnesses are often linked to that kind of psychological damage.

Given that there is no doubt that Sinner was thus disadvantaged, it is remarkable how close he came to winning MC and the two five-setters. His resilience in the face of adversity has been outstanding and understandably widely acknowledged by his peers. In both slam matches he won no less points than the opposition, despite suffering from a lack of preparation and illness. So another slam title was certainly possible.

This begs naturally the question of how much he could have won without that great handicap.
 

nolefam_2024

Bionic Poster
Don't buy the excuse that the testing had such an impact that he lost titles because of it. So zero.

Rewatch the rg semis. His body still has issues. He hits so hard and raz was so fast that it became tiring very fast.

Then same thing in IW.

MC without umpire mistake he probably takes tsitsipas down anyway. But that is not related to the doping test.

Madrid he injured himself.

Olympics is probably only one where he possibly skipped due to doping test. No idea. I don't buy the tonsillitis excuse much.
 

Winner Sinner

Hall of Fame
Always very clear in his analyses @Rovesciarete

Oh yes, regardless of what the frustrated haters say, the case of the positivities with consequent procedural protocols would have put the nerves of any self-respecting human being to the test, and obviously Sinner was not immune from a similar sword of Damocles that for months hung and still hangs over his head.

The same hip problem suffered during the clay season may have been conditioned by the strong stress suffered in that phase where he had received the notification due to the positive results a few days ago.
More stress = weaker immune system.

Having said that, the personal regret of a great fan like myself, as Sinner and Vagnozzi themselves admitted, concerns Wimbledon.
That match with Medvedev was strongly influenced by the sleepless night before the match with the Russian.
He was ready to win Wimbledon too.

So I would say at least one more major (Wimbledon) and a masters 1000 to choose between Madrid, Rome and Montreal.
 

adil1972

Hall of Fame
How many more titles could have Sinner won without current top10

In our region there is saying something like this

Very big restaurant (shop) but useless food (service)
 

Winner Sinner

Hall of Fame
How many more titles could have Sinner won without current top10

In our region there is saying something like this

Very big restaurant (shop) but useless food (service)
Never was a metaphor more incorrect.

Sinner's father is a great chef and Italian cuisine is the best in the world.
Change metaphor.
 

adil1972

Hall of Fame
Never was a metaphor more incorrect.

Sinner's father is a great chef and Italian cuisine is the best in the world.
Change metaphor.

I had no idea about sinner father or italian cuisine.

Only thing i know is that i love pizza which orginated from italy.

What i mean among other things is that some players dont live upto hype
 
Last edited:

Drighiz

Rookie
Don't buy the excuse that the testing had such an impact that he lost titles because of it. So zero.

Rewatch the rg semis. His body still has issues. He hits so hard and raz was so fast that it became tiring very fast.

Then same thing in IW.

MC without umpire mistake he probably takes tsitsipas down anyway. But that is not related to the doping test.

Madrid he injured himself.

Olympics is probably only one where he possibly skipped due to doping test. No idea. I don't buy the tonsillitis excuse much.
Consider though that he lost by such a small margins that surely a few nights of better sleep could have made some difference. He was having a panic attack in the quarter final against Medvedev and hadn't slept the night before.
 

Winner Sinner

Hall of Fame
Consider though that he lost by such a small margins that surely a few nights of better sleep could have made some difference. He was having a panic attack in the quarter final against Medvedev and hadn't slept the night before.
The paradox of those who belittle the problem is that they are all people who, in Sinner's place, would have already fallen into depression, rather than continuing to maintain a pace of excellence.

It's too easy to minimize the problems behind a keyboard.
Please play for months with the fear of a disqualification or with the fear of how the world might react once it becomes aware of the positive results.

This modus operandi of minimizing the problem is just hypocrisy.
 

Winner Sinner

Hall of Fame
Among other things, precisely because the news could not be disclosed publicly for months, Sinner was able to confide in a very limited circle of people, ergo, he could not even vent to some colleagues.
 

Rovesciarete

Hall of Fame
Consider though that he lost by such a small margins that surely a few nights of better sleep could have made some difference. He was having a panic attack in the quarter final against Medvedev and hadn't slept the night before.

Basic logic indeed. His handicap is not quantifiable, as @nolefam_2024 rightly points out, but it was there - even for one of the strongest under pressure!

In short his performance curve was shifted to the left through no fault of his. So how many more points, games, sets, matches or titles would he won?

Absolutely more points, certainly more games, likely more sets, probably more matches and maybe more titles....
 

vokazu

Legend
Sorry, how can you say you don't know Italian cuisine?

It would be like saying I don't know what water is.

When I grew up in my hometown there was literally no Italian restaurants at all.

I'm sure there are places around the world (especially remote places) which have no Italian restaurant.
 

Krish872007

Talk Tennis Guru
Maybe 1 more title - Monte Carlo was winnable and would have meant titles on almost surfaces.
Other than that he pretty much maxed out for the year, no one is infallible every single day of the season - he would have still had his off days and minor injury niggles. I will not comment further on being burdened or unburdened by what has been
 

GoatNo1

Hall of Fame

He would probable won many less titles without "getting disrupted by his team's negligence"?​

 
Last edited:

1H-Backhand

Rookie
When I grew up in my hometown there was literally no Italian restaurants at all.

I'm sure there are places around the world (especially remote places) which have no Italian restaurant.
When I grew up, in my hometown nobody spoke English.

But I KNEW what the English language was AND that it was the most spoken in the world...
 

1H-Backhand

Rookie
The world is full of wild fancies but the ITIA report states Sinner was contaminated without fault or negligence. CAS will look into the appeal of WADA, which wants to clarify if there is some negligence on the part of the player. Obviously, no relevant body accuses the number 1 of doping, given the simple facts of the case. Still, a great deal of mental harm and stress were inflicted on the dominant player of the tour and illnesses are often linked to that kind of psychological damage.

Given that there is no doubt that Sinner was thus disadvantaged, it is remarkable how close he came to winning MC and the two five-setters. His resilience in the face of adversity has been outstanding and understandably widely acknowledged by his peers. In both slam matches he won no less points than the opposition, despite suffering from a lack of preparation and illness. So another slam title was certainly possible.

This begs naturally the question of how much he could have won without that great handicap.
Good chance he could have achieved the CYGS
 

tennis3

Hall of Fame
I assume the premise of the thread is that his team was negligent in him getting caught testing positive. The question I guess is, if he continued to take clostebol like normal, how many more titles. Probably several I bet
 

Sudacafan

Bionic Poster
I assume the premise of the thread is that his team was negligent in him getting caught testing positive. The question I guess is, if he continued to take clostebol like normal, how many more titles. Probably several I bet
Correct. His team was fired not because of doping him, but because of negligence in not preventing him from getting caught when doping.
 
Last edited:

dking68

Legend
I
The world is full of wild fancies but the ITIA report states Sinner was contaminated without fault or negligence. CAS will look into the appeal of WADA, which wants to clarify if there is some negligence on the part of the player. Obviously, no relevant body accuses the number 1 of doping, given the simple facts of the case. Still, a great deal of mental harm and stress were inflicted on the dominant player of the tour and illnesses are often linked to that kind of psychological damage.

Given that there is no doubt that Sinner was thus disadvantaged, it is remarkable how close he came to winning MC and the two five-setters. His resilience in the face of adversity has been outstanding and understandably widely acknowledged by his peers. In both slam matches he won no less points than the opposition, despite suffering from a lack of preparation and illness. So another slam title was certainly possible.

This begs naturally the question of how much he could have won without that great handicap.

I think he would've won Beijing and also Wimbledon. Especially Beijing. Right? @Winner Sinner , they reappealed during the Beijing tournament and he was dropping sets like crazy
 

norcal

Legend

How many more titles could have Sinner won if he told his staff not to bring PED's into the locker room?​

 

Rovesciarete

Hall of Fame
I think he would've won Beijing and also Wimbledon. Especially Beijing. Right? @Winner Sinner , they reappealed during the Beijing tournament and he was dropping sets like crazy

He certainly had a bad start in Beijing. As I have written before, it is impossible to be sure that he would or wouldn’t have won this or that tournament.

However, this thread confirms again nicely it isn't easy to grasp the implications of simple concepts such that tennis is a sport of fine margins. Imagine you have a player twice winning more points than his opponent in a five-set battle despite a reduction of performance potential of x through physical and mental struggles induced partly by event c. It is pretty likely that even just a slightly smaller x-factor could have resulted in this player winning both matches.

All in all I find it just fascinating that some can post endless insinuations in one direction but are unable to process the consequences of harm into the other one.
 
Last edited:
Top