How strong was 2004 Roddick relative to the Sampras era?

I'll tell you guys one thing, if Nadal was Roddicks main rival instead of Federer, Roddick would win 5-7 hardcourt slams for sure. Roddick loved playing those baseline spaniards and argentinians: Ferrero, Nadal, Nalbandian, Coria, Moya etc
 
Roddick loved playing those baseline spaniards and argentinians: Ferrero, Nadal, Nalbandian, Coria, Moya etc

He loved playing them on his favorite surface, and their not-so-favorite surface :-)

However, Roddick's favorite surface is also one of Fed's favorite surfaces (and Sampras), and therein lies your quandry with Roddick only having 1 slam to his name.

Can't win GS on clay. Can't win GS on grass due to Fed (or Sampras in earlier era). That only leaves 2 slams per year where he can hope to compete. Add onto that a relatively short career and a GOAT hardcourt/grass competitor such as Fed or Sampras and you get 1 slam.
 
He loved playing them on his favorite surface, and their not-so-favorite surface :)

However, Roddick's favorite surface is also one of Fed's favorite surfaces (and Sampras), and therein lies your quandry with Roddick only having 1 slam to his name.

Can't win GS on clay. Can't win GS on grass due to Fed (or Sampras in earlier era). That only leaves 2 slams per year where he can hope to compete. Add onto that a relatively short career and a GOAT hardcourt/grass competitor such as Fed or Sampras and you get 1 slam.

Ferreros favourite surface, according to himself, was hardcourt. I think Nalbandian too. You don't know how Sampras vs prime Roddick matches up in Wimbledon or the hardcourt slams for that matter.
 
Last edited:
Anybody disbelieving that Roddick had an all-time great forehand can watch this. I have never seen a more vicious display of forehands.

 
You don't know how Sampras vs prime Roddick matches up in Wimbledon

Sampras and Fed are similarly dominant at Wimbledon, IMHO. If anything, one could make the argument that Sampras was even more dominant, as he won higher % of Wimbledons that he entered (Fed = 8 championships in 19 years = 42%, Sampras 7 championships in 14 years = 50%)

So, if Fed leads Roddick 4-0 at Wimbledon, it's safe to say that Sampras would similarly dominate Roddick on grass.
 
Sampras and Fed are similarly dominant at Wimbledon, IMHO. If anything, one could make the argument that Sampras was even more dominant, as he won higher % of Wimbledons that he entered (Fed = 8 championships in 19 years = 42%, Sampras 7 championships in 14 years = 50%)

So, if Fed leads Roddick 4-0 at Wimbledon, it's safe to say that Sampras would similarly dominate Roddick on grass.

I don't think that's safe to say at all. Sampras is a significantly weaker player than Federer, and Federer could have easily won two more Wimbledon. He had a toss-upp match against Djokovic and also a big match against Nadal that was a 5 set toss-upp.
 
Sampras is a significantly weaker player than Federer

Not on grass. Please cite some statistics which would support Sampras being "significantly weaker player" than Fed on grass.

I cited Sampras 50% win for Wimbledons entered, versus Fed's 42% win, which would suggest that Sampras is actually more dominant on grass than Fed. In my mind they are equals on grass. Sampras certainly not "significantly weaker player" on grass compared to Fed.
 
Not on grass. Please cite some statistics which would support Sampras being "significantly weaker player" than Fed on grass.

I cited Sampras 50% win for Wimbledons entered, versus Fed's 42% win, which would suggest that Sampras is actually more dominant on grass than Fed. In my mind they are equals on grass. Sampras certainly not "significantly weaker player" on grass compared to Fed.

Equal on grass? Federers highest level of play is higher than Sampras. He has more tools on the court. Better offense, better defensive, much better returns, comparable serve. Better than average volley. Better ground strokes. More solid. Etc
 
Roddick had quite a very deep return position, generally he hung back deep behind the baseline so he could blast his forehand.
This is a non-starter when playing on 1990s grass and indoor, and even decoturf.

This kind of return would give Sampras and Co even more time to close the net, especially if they target Roddick's BH.
 
Last edited:
OK, let's think about exactly where those 5 hardcourt slams would come from.
Let's say Sampras era is 1990's (he first won USO in 1990).
Roddick's career was basically 7 years of competitive tennis (2003-2009)

USO champions:
1990 - Sampras
1991/92 - Edberg
1993 - Sampras
1994 - Agassi
1995/96 - Sampras
1997/98 - Rafter
1999 - Agassi

AO champions:
1990 - Lendl
1991 - Becker
1992/93 - Courier
1994 - Sampras
1995 - Agassi
1996 - Becker
1997 - Sampras
1998 - Korda
1999 - Kafelnikov

I'll spot you the 1998 Australian Open. But tell me where he gets the other 4 championships in his 7 year career?
1999 AO also
 
Djokovic would smoke Sampras with any racket
Djokovic would not pass the first week for at least over half of his career if playing on 1990s grass. Nadal? He might have ended up joining the clay cohorts who normally skipped Wimbledon.

Worse, less developed nutrition science means that Djokovic might have forever remained pre-2011 Djokovic.
 
Djokovic would not pass the first week for at least over half of his career if playing on 1990s grass. Nadal? He might have ended up joining the clay cohorts who normally skipped Wimbledon.

Worse, less developed nutrition science means that Djokovic might have forever remained pre-2011 Djokovic.

Djokovic is certainly a physical weakling but if we are discussing pure playing skills, I am confident that peak Djoko beats peak Sampras routinely.
 
Djokovic is certainly a physical weakling but if we are discussing pure playing skills, I am confident that peak Djoko beats peak Sampras routinely.
Except for the BH and maybe return (One thing that most folks out there tend to ignore is that Sampras, OTOH, had excellent slice return), then nope.
 
Except for the BH and maybe return (One thing that most folks out there tend to ignore is that Sampras, OTOH, had excellent slice return), then nope.

Djokovic is one the greatest returners of all time. Sampras game matches up horribly. Pistol Petes weapons will be neutralised by a super fast counter puncher.
 
Roddick was able step into the court as well with his returns.
Yes, but not on 1st serves and still far less effective. His forehands, like the vast majority of the so-called "modern forehand", require huge takeback and thus need more time to hit effectively than a classic Eastern/Extreme Eastern forehands of the 1990s.

He cannot really block serves, which means he would give the S&V players weak sitting ducks instead of Agassi's rockets. Look at Wimbledon 2003 as an example, the majority of Federer's 1st serve point won were aces/service winners/unreturnables of all kinds because Roddick's returns suck.
 
Djokovic is one the greatest returners of all time. Sampras game matches up horribly. Pistol Petes weapons will be neutralised by a super fast counter puncher.

Agassi also one of greatest returners ever, super fast counter-puncher, hit on rise to take time away from opponent, etc. Yet, Sampras 20-14 lifetime against Agassi, 3 of Agassi's wins being on clay.
 
Look at Wimbledon 2004. That Roddick would have probably beat most players in history. Federer was not deterred, but most would have been.
That Roddick wouldn't have been able to really use his non-serve weapons (well, only a powerful but big-swing forehand - a typical "modern forehand") on 1990s fast grass against a serve-and-volleyer.

Agassi also one of greatest returners ever, super fast counter-puncher, hit on rise to take time away from opponent
Using the word "counter puncher" with Agassi is not so right since he actually attacked the serves.
 
Last edited:
Agassi also one of greatest returners ever, super fast counter-puncher, hit on rise to take time away from opponent, etc. Yet, Sampras 20-14 lifetime against Agassi, 3 of Agassi's wins being on clay.

Agassi was a great returner of serve, but he was nowhere near the mover of a Djokovic and Nadal.
 
Agassi was a great returner of serve, but he was nowhere near the mover of a Djokovic and Nadal.

But you were just saying that Nadal wasn't in the same league of "mover" as Joker?

Regardless, against Pete, return of serve was more critical than movement. Usually you got a look at the serve, and if you didn't return it well (assuming you could get a racket on it), point was over. At nearly 90% service games won, many sets he didn't get broken, and just needed 1 break to take the set.

I can assure you that Pete's advantage over Agassi wasn't due to Agassi's movement (or supposed lack thereof).
 
That Roddick would have been able to really use his weapons on 1990s fast grass against a serve-and-volleyer.

Federer served and volleyed quite a bit and Roddick has some nice passers on the back hand side. The BH was really indicative of Roddicks form. When Roddicks game was "on" , the backhand was producing winners, when his game was off, it was mostly a neutral stroke. You see the same pattern in Wimbledon 09. Lots of BH winners down the line. But Roddicks big forehand was long sense gone by then.
 
But you were just saying that Nadal wasn't in the same league of "mover" as Joker?

Regardless, against Pete, return of serve was more critical than movement. Usually you got a look at the serve, and if you didn't return it well (assuming you could get a racket on it), point was over. At nearly 90% service games won, many sets he didn't get broken, and just needed 1 break to take the set.

I can assure you that Pete's advantage over Agassi wasn't due to Agassi's movement (or supposed lack thereof).

I am not comparing their sprint records. Djokovics transition game was far superior to Agassi, who wasn't a grinder like Djokovic. Djokovic could also dictate the points from his ground stroke, so he was not a one dimensional player by any means.
 
Using the word "counter puncher" with Agassi is not so right since he actually attacked the serves.

Agassi was definitely a counter puncher. He had some incredible passing shots and offensive lobs, in his day he faced an onslaught of agressive net rushers (Sampras, Becker, Edberg, Rafter, Goran). They would often rush the net on return games as well, therefore the counter-punch.
 
Agassi was definitely a counter puncher. He had some incredible passing shots and offensive lobs, in his day he faced an onslaught of agressive net rushers (Sampras, Becker, Edberg, Rafter, Goran). They would often rush the net on return games as well, therefore the counter-punch.

Not on the level of Djokovic or Nadal.
 
he was nowhere near the mover of a Djokovic and Nadal.
His style allowed him to reach the ball as quick as a fast mover despite not moving much.

Federer served and volleyed quite a bit and Roddick has some nice passers on the back hand side
Actually, the 2003 "S&V mode" Federer served way more towards the corner points than he did in 2004 (as he had to serve like that), i.e. he went more on his serves in 2003.
But, if playing in the 1990s, Roddick would have to face guys who served better/bigger AND volleyed better than Federer (Sampras/Becker/Stich/Krajicek).

it was mostly a neutral stroke

I am not comparing their sprint records. Djokovics transition game was far superior to Agassi, who wasn't a grinder like Djokovic. Djokovic could also dictate the points from his ground stroke, so he was not a one dimensional player by any means.
On the bad-bouncing old grass, he wouldn't be able to hit ground strokes like he does today. There would be loads of mishits.

Besides, against a S&V players on fast grass, ROS is more important than the ability to chase down volleys.

There was a reason why S&V game dominated grass back then, and it was a fact.

Not on the level of Djokovic or Nadal he wasn't.
Counter-punchers can't hit from the baseline and have clean strokes?

Because he was still a baseline attacker in nature.
 
Chang and Hewitt (if late career counts)

I would call Chang more of a junkballer/pusher/defender. But our ideas of baseliner/counter-puncher/all-courter might be different since I identify more with the 1980's/1990's and I think you're more familiar with the 2000/2010 era.
 
I am not saying Djokovic was a counter puncher stylistically. Peak Djokovic was a universal, non volleyer. He just happened to be a fantastic counter puncher among one of many traits.
 
Djokovic is one the greatest returners of all time. Sampras game matches up horribly. Pistol Petes weapons will be neutralised by a super fast counter puncher.

actually Djokovic is unsettled by lack of rhythm - see vs Karlovic, some of the matches vs Isner, some of the matches vs federer when he was servebotting.
DJoko would be struggling vs Sampras on medium-fast to fast surfaces , but would have the edge on the slower surfaces.
 
Oh yes, Sampras is definately the greater player. But Sampras had bad periods whuch guys like Roddick could capitalize. Roger Federer won 6-0.7-6-6-0 against Lleyton Hewitt. Hewitt made easy work of Sampras in 2001. If Federers game was on, he was impossible. Roddick also didn't have to worry about the return game as much. Sampras return game was such and such. Federer was a top 2 returner at his peak. This was the worst possible match-up for Roddick.
Hewitt played much better than he did in the 04 final to beat Sampras by that scoreline.

Also beat him easily as a teenager at the Masters Cup in 2000. Queens in 2000. Pushed him to three sets multiple times as a teenager and during Sampras' later prime (1998-1999).

And to top it off, Hewitt was simply a better tennis player than Roddick. Roddick had the advantage on grass, yes, but elsewhere Hewitt held the advantage until he was riddled by injuries.

This is what Hewitt could do to Roddick during the supposed "2004" period (and Lleyton himself said he thought he was the second best player of 2004).

 
actually Djokovic is unsettled by lack of rhythm - see vs Karlovic, some of the matches vs Isner, some of the matches vs federer when he was servebotting.
DJoko would be struggling vs Sampras on medium-fast to fast surfaces , but would have the edge on the slower surfaces.

Karlovic has the world best first serve. Playing him is a nightmare for anyone looking for rhythm. Sampras and Karlovic serves are not comparable. The angles and heights Karlovic produces are second to none.
 
I would call Chang more of a junkballer/pusher/defender. But our ideas of baseliner/counter-puncher/all-courter might be different since I identify more with the 1980's/1990's and I think you're more familiar with the 2000/2010 era.

Chang was a counter-puncher. Agassi was an aggressive baseliner.
Nothing to do with the era you identify with more in this case.
 
Karlovic has the world best first serve. Playing him is a nightmare for anyone looking for rhythm. Sampras and Karlovic serves are not comparable. The angles and heights Karlovic produces are second to none.

and yet federer is 13-1 vs Karlovic
Nadal is 5-0 vs Karlovic
Murray is 7-0 vs Karlovic

Djokovic is 1-2 vs Karlovic.

My point is djokovic has struggled with lack of rhythm quite a few times. and I included the example of federer servebotting, whose serve while excellent, is not as good as Sampras'.
 
Hewitt played much better than he did in the 04 final to beat Sampras by that scoreline.

Also beat him easily as a teenager at the Masters Cup in 2000. Queens in 2000. Pushed him to three sets multiple times as a teenager and during Sampras' later prime (1998-1999).

And to top it off, Hewitt was simply a better tennis player than Roddick. Roddick had the advantage on grass, yes, but elsewhere Hewitt held the advantage until he was riddled by injuries.

This is what Hewitt could do to Roddick during the supposed "2004" period (and Lleyton himself said he thought he was the second best player of 2004).


If Roddick serve and volleys to a counter puncher like Hewitt, he SHOULD lose badly. Roddick was never even a decent volleyer.

The Kamikaze strategy employed by A-Rod in that match does not tell us anything.
 
Of course they can, and Agassi was by no means weak at it. He was not on the same planet as Djokovic and Nadal, however.

not as good as them consistency wise for sure, but when playing well, he's up there with both of them (minus Nadal on clay of course)
 
If Roddick serve and volleys to a counter puncher like Hewitt, he SHOULD lose badly. Roddick was never even a decent volleyer.

The Kamikaze strategy employed by A-Rod in that match does not tell us anything.
Roddick was getting pushed to the brink even by Hewitt when he had many surgeries, was ranked outside the top 100 and Roddick was still a top ten player and much closer to his playing prime.

The fact is that Roddick was not as good a player as Hewitt and not as talented as Safin, so he couldn't figure out a strategy that would work against players like Lleyton and Roger who had great returns to counter his serve.
 
Roddick was getting pushed to the brink even by Hewitt when he had many surgeries, was ranked outside the top 100 and Roddick was still a top ten player and much closer to his playing prime.

The fact is that Roddick was not as good a player as Hewitt and not as talented as Safin, so he couldn't figure out a strategy that would work against players like Lleyton and Roger who had great returns to counter his serve.

Roddick was in his prime in that clip having beaten Safin... Why nobody informed Roddick that his net game sucked and should be avoided at all costs is beyond me. His net game sucked on more than one level.
 
Last edited:
Equal on grass? Federers highest level of play is higher than Sampras. He has more tools on the court. Better offense, better defensive, much better returns, comparable serve. Better than average volley. Better ground strokes. More solid. Etc


If Federer is better at everything else, then their serves are certainly not comparable.
 
Back
Top