How strong was 2004 Roddick relative to the Sampras era?


Sampras led the tour in holding rate 7 out of 8 years in the 90's, was broken 4 times in 7 Wimbledon finals, and had a higher % of service games won in majors, with a massive edge in service statistics against the top 5 and top 10 over Federer, in an era where the tour-wide hold rate was much lower than it is today.

If Federer is outright better in all of the things you mentioned (and I regard Federer as the superior player), then Sampras has the better serve outright.
 
Chang was a counter-puncher. Agassi was an aggressive baseliner.
Nothing to do with the era you identify with more in this case.

Can you name another 1990's counter-puncher besides Chang? (who borders on pure defense in some of his matches)

I would put Courier, Muster, and Lendl more in the aggressive baseliner category. Courier especially, looking to put away a big forehand set up by his serve.

Agassi could use the opponent's shots against them more, due to standing far forward in the court and hitting on the rise. Particularly when he played against S&V. Agassi-Edberg in the early 1990's is good example of Agassi's counter-punching abilities. Would hardly call that style against Edberg aggressive baseliner, when the rallies were so short on average.
 
Sampras led the tour in holding rate 7 out of 8 years in the 90's, was broken 4 times in 7 Wimbledon finals, and had a higher % of service games won in majors, with a massive edge against the top 5 and against the top 10 over Federer, in an era where the tour-wide hold rate was much lower than it is today.

If Federer is outright better in all of the things you mentioned (which I concede, and I regard Federer as the superior player), then Sampras has the better serve outright.

Comparing stats from different eras is misleading. Federers serv stats was superior in their one Wimbledon encounter, and Sampras serve only got better with age (as did Feds).
 
Can you name another 1990's counter-puncher besides Chang? (who borders on pure defense in some of his matches)

I would put Courier, Muster, and Lendl more in the aggressive baseliner category. Courier especially, looking to put away a big forehand set up by his serve.

Agassi could use the opponent's shots against them more, due to standing far forward in the court and hitting on the rise. Particularly when he played against S&V. Agassi-Edberg in the early 1990's is good example of Agassi's counter-punching abilities. Would hardly call that style against Edberg aggressive baseliner, when the rallies were so short on average.

Rios and Santoro could counter-punch quite a bit.

Taking it so early on the rise is being aggressive.
Counter-punching is countering the punch of the opponent (in big part by using their own pace against them). Too many of Agassi's returns/groundstrokes were hit hard by themselves for Agassi to be called a counter-puncher.

Lendl was more defensive than Agassi, esp. considering his play on clay, though he was an aggressive baseliner himself in general.
 
Comparing stats from different eras is misleading.


How?

If it's misleading, why bother comparing them at all? If anything, it would be misleading in favour of Federer to believe that their serves are close, considering how high hold rates are today (attributable to poly strings).

But anyways, Pete's serving stats are superior to Federer's even w/o factoring in era differences. He still won a higher % of service games, and a much higher % of service games won against top 5/10 opponents, and posted higher ace rates every year and higher unreturnable rates in the matches charted for them.

This is despite him, as you say, having a much inferior supporting game. If he's inferior in every other respect, why is he still ahead on serve?


Federers serv stats was superior in their one Wimbledon encounter,


Federer's serve stats were inferior that one time he played that one match against ____.

Against the entire field, and over a heftier sample size, no, their serve's as standalone shots aren't comparable, by your standards, because the difference between their serves is about the same as the difference between the other facets of their games.


and Sampras serve only got better with time (as did Feds), so age is irrelevant to that equation.

Pete's serve stats were similar pretty much every year from 1993-2000, so no.
 
Last edited:
Yes, but not on 1st serves and still far less effective. His forehands, like the vast majority of the so-called "modern forehand", require huge takeback and thus need more time to hit effectively than a classic Eastern/Extreme Eastern forehands of the 1990s.

He cannot really block serves, which means he would give the S&V players weak sitting ducks instead of Agassi's rockets. Look at Wimbledon 2003 as an example, the majority of Federer's 1st serve point won were aces/service winners/unreturnables of all kinds because Roddick's returns suck.

Roddick's returning was fine in Wim 03 semi.
In 2003 Wim SF, 34 out of 84 service points (40.48%) of Federer's serves were unreturned.
No DFs for federer, so that means Roddick returned 50 of the 84 Federer serves. (59.52%)
 
Last edited:
"If it's misleading, why bother comparing them at all?"

I don't think you should compare them at all from a numbers perspective. Simply look at their respective game. All the available footage indicates to me that 2004 Roddick vs prime Sampras would have been a competitive rivalry. I don't believe Sampras vs 05, 06, 07 Federer would be competitive however. I can envision Federer easily dominate Sampras like he did Roddick.
 
Sampras did not start playing in 1993, so yes. Young Pete's second serve was not as strong originally. Young Federers serve was good but not as good as later.

So how about we compare their serves once they became dominant players? Why would we compare their serves when they weren't even top 3 players? You brought up prime Sampras, after all.

Sampras' serve from 1993-2000 is much better than Federer's serve ever was, at any point. If Federer is better from the ground/on the return, and defensively, then Sampras is the better server. It can't be that the first three are clearly in Federer's favour but the fourth is somehow comparable.
 
"If it's misleading, why bother comparing them at all?"

I don't think you should compare them at all from a numbers perspective. Simply look at their respective game. All the available footage indicates to me that 2004 Roddick vs prime Sampras would have been a competitive rivalry. I don't believe Sampras vs 05, 06, 07 Federer would be competitive however. I can envision Federer easily dominate Sampras like he did Roddick.

Okay, simply look at their respective serves. Sampras' serve is clearly better.
 
So how about we compare their serves once they became dominant players?

Sampras' serve from 1993-2000 is much better than Federer's serve ever was, at any point. If Federer is better from the ground/on the return, and defensively, then Sampras is the better server. It can't be that the first three are clearly in Federer's favour but the fourth is somehow comparable.

Again, you can't compare stats from two different eras. Different players, different conditions, different game etc. Sampras volley was better than Federers, and Sampras was a serve and volleyer.
 
Again, you can't compare stats from two different eras. Different players, different conditions, different game etc. Sampras volley was better than Federers, and Sampras was a serve and volleyer.

Alright.

No two players can ever be compared.

Can't compare Sampras to Roddick for those very reasons: different players, different conditions (Sampras wasn't the same after '99), different game, etc. Can't say Connors had a better return than Karlovic; different eras, different players, different conditions.

Can't compare anything in tennis, ever, until all the variables are accounted for. Which will never happen.

So, we can't compare anything, and your thread no longer makes much sense.
 
Alright.

No two players can ever be compared.

Can't compare Sampras to Roddick for that very reason -- different players, different conditions (Sampras wasn't the same after '99), different game, etc.

Can't compare anything in tennis, ever, until all the variables are accounted for. Which will never happen.

So, can't compare anything.

I am saying you cant compare STATS between two different eras. You can still compare the players to each other. Peak Sampras probably beats an inconsistent, not fully realised Federer in 03 and early 04, in four or five sets. That's the most generous I can be to pistol Pete. After that, It's all Federer.... And yes, grass included.
 
I am saying you cant compare STATS between two different eras. You can still compare the players to each other. Peak Sampras probably beats an inconsistent, not fully realised Federer in 03 and early 04, in four or five sets. That's the most generous I can be to pistol Pete. After that, It's all Federer.... And yes, grass included.


Of course you can, but you wouldn't even need statistics to confirm that Sampras has the better serve if one were to watch them over a long enough period of time. It's clearly better, and was the class of the tour for 7 of 8 years. If you can't compare the statistics with some degree of confidence then you also can't compare them as players, because Sampras didn't play with poly strings. Federer played with poly post spring of '02 (I believe), obviously augmenting his game to some degree.

It's unreal that in 2018, with reams of footage/data/anecdotal evidence/player testimony at our disposal, that somebody can't concede a point as simple as Sampras having a much better serve than Federer.

The rest I won't bother to speculate on, because I was strictly talking about their serves. I do believe that Federer would edge Sampras in a hypothetical h2h series.
 
Last edited:
I don't think you should compare them at all from a numbers perspective. Simply look at their respective game. All the available footage indicates to me that 2004 Roddick vs prime Sampras would have been a competitive rivalry. I don't believe Sampras vs 05, 06, 07 Federer would be competitive however. I can envision Federer easily dominate Sampras like he did Roddick.

You don't even know how good Sampras was at his prime.
Sampras at his prime > Roddick at his prime and its not even close. Roddick would win some matches, but Sampras would have the clear edge.

prime fed vs prime sampras would be competitive anywhere except on clay
 
You wouldn't even need statistics to confirm that Sampras has the better serve if one were to watch them over a long enough period of time. It's clearly better, and was the class of the tour for 7 of 8 years.

It's unreal that in 2018, with reams of footage/data/anecdotal evidence/player testimony at our disposal, that somebody can't concede a point as simple as Sampras having a much better serve than Federer.

The rest I won't bother to speculate on, because I was strictly talking about their serves.

How can it be established that Sampras has a superior serve when the conditions, including balls (lighter) and playing surfaces are not the same?
 
How can it be established that Sampras has a superior serve when the conditions, including balls (lighter) and playing surfaces are not the same?

Because his serve was better DESPITE the conditions; it was better, even to the naked eye, despite playing w/o poly and with a smaller raqcuet. The balls being lighter and the surfaces being quicker are more than offset by poly when it comes to serve stats, which is reflected by how vast the difference is between tour-wide hold rates then and now.
 
Because his serve was better DESPITE the conditions; it was better, even to the naked eye, despite playing w/o poly and with a smaller raqcuet. The balls being lighter and the surfaces being quicker are more than offset by poly when it comes to serve stats, which is reflected by how vast the difference is between tour-wide hold rates then and now.

The extrapoled, inferrred serve superiority of which you speak is NOT reflected in their one and only encounter. And Sampras played very well in that match, so the numbers are hardly skewed.
 
The extrapoled, inferrred serve superiority of which you speak is NOT reflected in their one and only encounter. And Sampras played very well in that match, so the numbers are hardly skewed.

Okay, their one match trumps all intuition, common sense and decades/thousands of matches worth of data, fine.
 
Okay, their one match trumps all intuition, common sense and decades/thousands of matches worth of data, fine.

Okay, so let's go through it. Sampras fastest serves were faster than Feds. Their average first serve speed was about the same. Sampras serve was characteristically difficult to read. Federers serve is characteristically impossible to read. Sampras average ace count per match was 11, Fed's is 7.7. It looks like they are indeed comparable.
 
Okay, so let's go through it. Sampras fastest serves were faster than Feds. Their average first serve speed was about the same. Sampras serve was characteristically difficult to read. Federers serve is characteristically impossible to read. Sampras average ace count per match was 11, Fed's is 7.7. It looks like they are indeed comparable.


Sampras had the pacier serve. Even in their one match that you value so heavily, it was about 7-10mph faster on both serves (I reckon a wiz like @abmk would have those stats handy). The radar guns were notoriously juiced after in the early to mid 2000s. I do remember that Fed's average first serve that day was clocked in at around 115 mph--about in line with what you get today (I say this as somebody who's been following his serve speeds for over a decade), so no, that can't be ascribed to his youthfulness.

Pete's serve was also notoriously heavy and had more RPMs than Federer's serves; while his ace rates were indeed high (and a 3.4 ace difference is quite big, it's much more than the difference between Djokovic and Federer yet nobody would call their serves comparable), his unreturned serve rates, from the matches that have been charted, are up there with the Isner's and Raonic's of the world. He's regularly approached/exceeded 50% unreturned serves, whereas Federer has only done so on a few of the matches of his that have been charted.

All of this
despite playing with natural gut. You scoff at the idea of comparing stats because the conditions are different from era to era (true, no doubt), but that very same premise makes any comparison of their games problematic, because improved equipment adds to the potency of their strokes and thus makes said strokes look better. So the eye test you champion when comparing Sampras and Roddick must be deemed inadmissible.

But again, even with Federer's serve being made to look better with poly, it still isn't as good as Pete's serve playing with natural gut.
 
Last edited:
Sampras had the pacier serve. Even in their one match, it was about 7-10mph faster on both serves (I reckon a wiz like @abmk would have those stats handy). The radar guns were notoriously juiced after in the early to mid 2000s. I do remember that Fed's average first serve clocked in at around 115 mph--about in line with what you get today (I say this as somebody who's been following his serve speeds for over a decade), so no, that can't be ascribed to his precociousness.

Both his first and second serves were also notoriously heavy and had more RPMs than Federer's serves; while his ace rates were indeed high (and a 3.4 ace difference is quite big, it's much more than the difference between Djokovic and Federer yet nobody would call their serves comparable), his unreturned serve rates, from the matches that have been charted, are up there with the Isner's and Raonic's of the world. He's regularly approached/exceeded 50% unreturned serves, whereas Federer has only done so on a few of the matches of his that have been charted.

All of this
despite playing with natural gut. You scoff at the idea of comparing stats because the conditions are different from era to era (true, no doubt), but that very same premise makes any comparison of their games problematic, because improved equipment adds to the potency of their strokes and thus makes said strokes look better. So the eye test you champion when comparing Sampras and Roddick must be deemed inadmissible.

But again, even with Federer's serve being made to look better with Poly, it still isn't as good as Pete's serve playing with natural gut.

Sampras serve is better, never denied that. Is it better enough to actually make a difference against Federer? Well, 70% first serves is an outstanding percentage , and Sampras got broken several times (3) in a match he played well in...against an unrefined, erratic Roger Federer. That does not bode well for Sampras in these hypothethicals.
 
Last edited:
Anyone who is so ignorant to say federer and Sampras had on an average similar 1st serve speed and continues to talk like he knows sh*t about sampas should be banned about a 100 times from this forum, LOL .
 
Sampras serve is better, never denied that. Is it better enough to actually make a difference against Federer? Well, 70% first serves is an outstanding percentage , and Sampras got broken several times, in a match he played well in...against an unrefined, erratic Roger Federer. That does not bode well for Sampras in these hypothethicals.

You never affirmed it in our back-and-forth either, until now.

My point is that Sampras a better serve, full-stop. To flatly state that Federer is better at X Y and Z and then say that their serves are comparable isn't even-handed at all. Sampras' serve is better than Fed's probably by the same (or maybe even greater) margin than Fed's fh is greater than Pete's fh. I could be cynical and say things like 'Sock's forehand is comparable to Nadal's' etc etc, but despite being technically true (hey, they're both good forehands after all!), I wouldn't be arguing in good faith.
 
You never affirmed it in our back-and-forth either, until now.

My point is that Sampras a better serve, full-stop. To say that Federer is better at X Y and Z and then say that their serves are comparable isn't even-handed at all. Sampras' serve is better than Fed's probably by the same (or maybe even greater) margin than Fed's fh is greater than Pete's fh. I could be cynical and say things like 'Sock's forehand is comparable to Nadal's' etc etc, but despite being technically true (hey, they're both good forehands after all!), I wouldn't be arguing in good faith.

This serving stat from Fed against Agassi is very comparable to Sampras-Agassi matches. Federers serve is awesome. https://www.atpworldtour.com/en/scores/2005/580/MS004/match-stats
 
This serving stat from Fed against Agassi is very comparable to Sampras-Agassi matches. Federers serve is awesome. https://www.atpworldtour.com/en/scores/2005/580/MS004/match-stats


And here are their career stats against Agassi:

http://www.tennisabstract.com/cgi-bin/player.cgi?p=RogerFederer&f=ACareerqq&q=AndreAgassi

http://www.tennisabstract.com/cgi-bin/player.cgi?p=PeteSampras&f=ACareerqq&q=AndreAgassi

Sampras, despite having the inferior supporting game and playing Agassi more times in his prime than Federer did, edges Fed in ace% and % of service games won, all while playing with a full gut string set-up in every single one of those matches.

Why you continue to limit these comparisons to single matches or single match-ups, however, is beyond me.

No doubt that Federer has a great serve, though, that was never in question.
 
Last edited:
And that's on the slow rebound ace surface Federer aces Agassi 22 times....


...and Sampras aced Agassi 37 times in their 2000 match, on the same court, with a higher ace rate (23.7%-22.2%).

This is despite contesting the fifth set with a torn hip flexor.

The fact that you eschew long-term data sets in favour of cherry-picked matches is telling.
 
Sampras serve is better, never denied that. Is it better enough to actually make a difference against Federer? Well, 70% first serves is an outstanding percentage , and Sampras got broken several times (3) in a match he played well in...against an unrefined, erratic Roger Federer. That does not bode well for Sampras in these hypothethicals.

Sampras held in 26 of 29 service games in that match (89.66%). In which la la land, is that not good ?
Federer returned pretty well in that match. He played well beyond his years in that match. Sampras though past his prime, also played well.

Did you even watch any matches before 03 ?
I suggest you do before you make such foolish statements.
 
Sampras held in 26 of 29 service games in that match (89.66%). In which la la land, is that not good ?
Federer returned pretty well in that match. He played well beyond his years in that match. Sampras though past his prime, also played well.

Did you even watch any matches before 03 ?
I suggest you do before you make such foolish statements.

The ones living in la la lind are guys like Mcenroe who thinks peak Sampras beats peak Federer on grass 6 or 7 times out of 10, and bases that around Sampras serve.
 
Sampras held in 26 of 29 service games in that match (89.66%). In which la la land, is that not good ?
He served well but did not do other things well. For example, in volleying, Henman in the QF volleyed way better than Sampras in that match.

Roddick's returning was fine in Wim 03 semi.
In 2003 Wim SF, 34 out of 84 service points (40.48%) of Federer's serves were unreturned.
No DFs for federer, so that means Roddick returned 50 of the 84 Federer serves. (59.52%)
You should also take into account sitting duck returns.

Sampras serve only got better with age
Go watch Sampras acing Lendl in US Open 1990 pls.
 
He served well but did not do other things well. For example, in volleying, Henman in the QF volleyed way better than Sampras in that match.

he volleyed fine, though not great. Henman was anyways a better volleyer than Sampras.


You should also take into account sitting duck returns.

That'd be there for every returner.
I did the stats for this match a few months ago and trust me, Roddick returned fine in this match. Federer was really serving and playing very well in general (arguably his greatest grass court match)

https://tt.tennis-warehouse.com/index.php?threads/federer-roddick-wimbledon-2003-semi-stats.597325/

The only problem with his game was getting a lower than usual % of 1st serves in.
 
Last edited:
The ones living in la la lind are guys like Mcenroe who thinks peak Sampras beats peak Federer on grass 6 or 7 times out of 10, and bases that around Sampras serve.

I don't agree with it, but lets see whether you are even qualified to make such a judgement : "Sampras' first serve speed on an average was about the same as Federer's" ?
Ok, you are disqualified.
 
This is a non-starter when playing on 1990s grass and indoor, and even decoturf.

This kind of return would give Sampras and Co even more time to close the net, especially if they target Roddick's BH.

The times when Roddick did play a S&V player he stood closer to the baseline on the return, it was mostly against other baseliners that he dropped back. Against Henman at the USO in 2003 he was alot closer to the baseline on the return than against Ferrero. He also scored wins on grass over Ancic in hot form in the summer of 2004

I wouldn't back Roddick to do much of anything indoors BTW. On grass I think he'd probably play quite differently in the 90's as well. On HC I expect he'd do well, only Sampras and then Rafter for a couple of years were elite S&V's in that 93-98 timeframe on HC. I wouldn't back guys like Martin, Rusedski etc...over Roddick.
 
he volleyed fine, though not great. Henman was anyways a better volleyer than Sampras.




That'd be there for every returner.
I did the stats for this match a few months ago and trust me, Roddick returned fine in this match. Federer was really serving and playing very well in general (arguably his greatest grass court match)

https://tt.tennis-warehouse.com/index.php?threads/federer-roddick-wimbledon-2003-semi-stats.597325/

The only problem with his game was getting a lower than usual % of 1st serves in.

That's interesting. You were the one thinking Roddicks return game would prove his downfall against Sampras. Are you finally coming to grips with the fact that peak Roddick would do okey enough returning?
 
Ehm, what? Young Roddick would have been a beast indoors. I'm gonna check his record.

Roddick didn't do much indoors across his career. He played some good matches as you'd expect but I doubt he'd be contending for the biggest events regularly - to put it mildy.

TBH the amount of misinformation in this thread from you and Iowa it's hard to know how much to weigh in, this is despite me being a big fan of Arod.
 
Roddick didn't do much indoors across his career. He played some good matches as you'd expect but I doubt he'd be contending for the biggest events regularly - to put it mildy.

TBH the amount of misinformation in this thread from you and Iowa it's hard to know how much to weigh in, this is despite me being a big fan of Arod.

Roddicks 03 indoor hardcourt record was 8-2. 1 semifinal, 1 final. 04 Roddick was 14-3 (including two DC wins) , 1 final.

Roddick didn't play much matches on it, but the stats still show he did well.
 
Roddicks 03 indoor hardcourt record was 8-2. 1 semifinal, 1 final. 04 Roddick was 14-3 (including two DC wins) , 1 final.

Roddick didn't play much matches on it, but the stats still show he did well.

Nothing spectacular. He was definitely better on outdoor HC.

He actually won San Jose in 2004 which was an indoor tournament - the final is on my channel. He beat Mardy Fish in pretty good quality contest. His win over James Blake in Memphis was a great match too back in 2002. But these aren't huge wins.
 
That'd be there for every returner.
I did the stats for this match a few months ago and trust me, Roddick returned fine in this match. Federer was really serving and playing very well in general (arguably his greatest grass court match)

https://tt.tennis-warehouse.com/index.php?threads/federer-roddick-wimbledon-2003-semi-stats.597325/

The only problem with his game was getting a lower than usual % of 1st serves in.

Roddicks best grass court match is surely the 04 final, not the 03 semis. He did have set point in 03 but that's about it.
 
I find it hard to believe that anyone in Sampras era had a better volley, since this is what Sampras relied on if the serve didn't get the jobe done, and he had 14 slams compared to Henmans 0.
 
I find it hard to believe that anyone in Sampras era had a better volley, since this is what Sampras relied on if the serve didn't get the jobe done, and he had 14 slams compared to Henmans 0.

You should just stop talking about Sampras now. Guy was an incredible athlete and great off the ground.

Sampras was better in every department compared to Henman except probably the volleys. You don't win 14 slams and a plethora of other titles if you can only serve and volley.
 
You should just stop talking about Sampras now. Guy was an incredible athlete and great off the ground.

Sampras was better in every department compared to Henman except probably the volleys. You don't win 14 slams and a plethora of other titles if you can only serve and volley.

Sampras was a serve and volleyer. This is what he did he majority of the time. Or did that somehow escape you?
 
Last edited:
Sampras was a serve and volleyer. This is what he did he majority of the time. Or did that somehow escape you?

He was only pure S&V in his later career (and grass and indoors throughout). He often hung back on second serves and even firsts in his earlier career.
 
I find it hard to believe that anyone in Sampras era had a better volley, since this is what Sampras relied on if the serve didn't get the jobe done, and he had 14 slams compared to Henmans 0.

Edberg and Rafter had better volleys.

Sampras was a good volleyer, but generally had easier volleys do deal with, since his 1st (and 2nd) serves were so beastly. Lot of his volleys were easy put-aways.

Edberg and Rafter, OTOH, had slower, spinnier serves and relied more on their volley/overhead skills (and both super athletic like Sampras) to put away points. Edberg also rushed the net like a mad man on return of service games as well, more than Sampras who sometimes seemed content just to bang from the baseline on return of service games. Edberg is acutually #17 all-time for % return games won!

How much 1990's tennis have you watched?
 
Edberg and Rafter had better volleys.

Sampras was a good volleyer, but generally had easier volleys do deal with, since his 1st (and 2nd) serves were so beastly. Lot of his volleys were easy put-aways.

Edberg and Rafter, OTOH, had slower, spinnier serves and relied more on their volley/overhead skills (and both super athletic like Sampras) to put away points.

How much 1990's tennis have you watched?

Sampras defensive, "digging" volleys on the recieving end of returns right on his feet by the likes of Agassi should count for something. Sampras got amazing balls back and was solid on both wings. I argue his volley under pressure was superior to Federer, even though Federer has a nice volley too.
 
Back
Top