Something I have been thinking about lately everytime I read a GOAT thread on here. Imagine this: A player comes out of no where and for 1 calender year wins everything. Doesnt drop a set or a game. Bagels everyone. Winning a point against this guy is a struggle. Doesnt make an unforced error throughout the year. Hits 3-4 winners per game. 100% first serves for the whole year. you get the idea. Now, the above player that I have described is a tennis superman. LOL. Now, Imagine, he dies in a car crash. He would end up with 4 majors, 9 Masters and few other tournaments. Would go like 100-0 for the whole year. IS HE YOUR GOAT? If not, please elaborate why. For me, he is because he reached a level of tennis that has never been reached before and played at that level for a year. Looking forward to some interesting replies.