Hypothetical Federer/Nadal meetings

[dandelion_smiley]

What would the outcome of their matches be had they played in:

The Australian Open 2004-2010 (except 2009)
The French Open 2004 and 2009-2010
Wimbledon 2004-2005, 2009-2010
The US Open 2004-2010

The ones that I'm really curious about are: AO 2008, AO 2010, French 2009, Wimbly 2009, US Open 2008, US Open 2010

 

[Eternally_damned]

Federer would have won all of them except most of the FOs.

 

[dandelion_smiley]

Federer would have won all of them except most of the FOs.

Federer would've probably won all the HC meetings in 2004-2007 (2006 AO is Nadal's biggest chance), I'd go for Nadal in AO/UO 2008, FO 2009 (even tho Nadal wasn't at his best, I don't see Fed beating Nadal at the French no matter how badly Nadal is playing), 2009 W goes to Fed, 2009 UO definately Fed, 2010 Australian Fed has the slight advantage, French and Wimbledon this year Nadal, US Open 50/50

 

[Starfury]

The fact that Federer made most of these finals and Nadal didn't pretty clearly makes Federer the favorite.
Accordingly, Nadal would have to be the favorite in the last three majors.

 

[Blinkism]

Ah, the off-season.