If Federer, Nadal and Djokovic were all born in 1981 (but had same injury timeline)

[jl809]

Year	Aussie Open	RG	Wimbledon	US Open
2000		2005dal (#1)
2001		2006dal (#2)	Goran def 2006dal (debatable)	2007ovic (#1)
2002	2008ovic (#2)	2007dal (#3)	2007dal (#4)
2003	2003gassi def 2008dal (debatable)	2008dal (#5)	2003erer def 2008dal (#1)	2008ovic (#3)
2004	2009dal (no dasco SF) def 2004erer (debatable) (#6)		2004erer(#2)	2004erer(#3)
2005	2011ovic (#4)	2010dal (#7)	2005erer def 2010dal (debatable) (#4)	2010dal (#8)
2006	2006erer def 2012ovic (debatable) (#6)	2011dal (#9)	2006erer def 2011dal (#7)	2011dal def 2006erer (debatable) (#10)
2007	2007erer def 2013ovic (debatable) (#8)	2012dal (#11)	2007erer (#9)	2013ovic (no stan semi) def 2007erer (#5) (debatable)
2008	2014ovic (#6)	2013dal (#12)	2008erer (#10)	2013dal (#13)
2009	2015ovic (#7)	2014dal (#14)	2015ovic (#8)	2015ovic (#9)
2010	2016ovic (#10)	2016ovic (#11)		2010erer (#11)
2011	2011erer (#12)	2011erer(#13)		2011erer (#14)
2012	2012erer (#15)	2017dal (#15)	2012erer (#16)	2018ovic def 2017dal (debatable) (#12)
2013	2019ovic (#13)	2018dal (#16)	2018dal def 2019ovic (#17)	some mug
2014	2020ovic (#14)	2019dal (#17)	2014erer (#17)	2019dal (#18)
2015	2021ovic (#15)	2020dal (#19)	2015erer (#18)	2015erer (#19)
2016	no data for 2022ovic	no data yet	no data yet	no data yet
2017	probably 2017erer (#20)	no data yet	probably 2017erer (#21)	no data yet
2018	posssibly 2018erer (#22)???	no data yet	no data yet	no data yet
2019	no data yet	no data yet	probably 2019erer (#23)	no data yet

Points to take away:
- Federer probably highest slam count depending on how Nadal continues at RG
- Djokovic is a Wimbledon fraud in the real timeline
- Fed and Djok both end up with CGS because of 15-16dal
Debatable:
- Goran defeating 2006dal at W
- the battles between prime Fed and Djoker at the AO
- Nadal winning ANY Aussie Opens is debatable, leaning with him beating Federer in 04 because of the matchup issue (no tiring Dasco semi, forehand to weak backhand with Fed's tiny racket)
- 2018ovic beating 2017dal at the USO
- 2018dal beats 2019ovic at Wimbledon (2019ovic was worse than in 2018)
- 2013ovic (with no Stan semi) winning the US Open over 2007erer

 

[jl809]

lol I can't delete this but posted accidentally before I finished it
EDIT: done

 

[MichaelNadal]

lol I can't delete this but posted accidentally before I finished it

 

[spottishwood]

lol I can't delete this but posted accidentally before I finished it

Tag TW staff and ask them to delete it.

 

[AnOctorokForDinner]

Just edit the post to completion, man.

 

[jl809]

Year	Aussie Open	RG	Wimbledon	US Open
2000	Agassi	2005dal (#1)	PETE	Safin!
2001	Agassi	2006dal (#2)	Goran def 2006dal (debatable)	2007ovic (#1)
2002	2008ovic (#2)	2007dal (#3)	2007dal (#4)	PETE
2003	2003gassi def 2008dal (debatable)	2008dal (#5)	2003erer def 2008dal (#1)	2009ovic (#3)
2004	2009dal (no dasco SF) def 2004erer (debatable) (#6)	Gaudio smh	2004erer(#2)	2004erer(#3)
2005	2011ovic (#4)	2010dal (#7)	2005erer def 2010dal (#4)	2010dal (#8)
2006	2006erer def 2012ovic (debatable) (#5)	2011dal (#9)	2006erer def 2011dal (#6)	2006erer def 2011dal (#7)
2007	2007erer def 2013ovic (debatable) (#8)	2012dal (#10)	2007erer (#9)	2007erer (#10) def 2013ovic (no Stan SF) (debatable)
2008	2014ovic (#6)	2013dal (#11)	2008erer (#11)	2013dal (#12)
2009	2015ovic (#7)	2014dal (#13)	2015ovic (#8)	2015ovic (#9)
2010	2016ovic (#10)	2016ovic (#11)	Berdych!	2010erer (#12)
2011	2011erer (#13)	2011erer(#14)	Tsonga!	2011erer (#15)
2012	2012erer (#16)	2017dal (#14)	2012erer (#17)	2018ovic def 2017dal (debatable) (#12)
2013	2019ovic (#13)	2018dal (#15)	2018dal def 2019ovic (#16)	some mug unless Nadal injects his knee
2014	2020ovic (#14)	2019dal (#17)	2014erer (#18)	2019dal (#18)
2015	2021ovic (#15)	2020dal (#19)	2015erer (#19)	2015erer (#20)
2016	not putting one - can't speculate on 2022ovic w/o covid	2021dal (#20)	Lendlray!	Stan!
2017	2023ovic (#16)	2022dal (#21)	2017erer (#21)	2023ovic (#17)

Thought I'd update this. It got closer than I was expecting tbh

 

[Third Serve]

I can’t read but looks like Fred is on top so have an upvote.

 

[jl809]

New tallies are
- Fed: 4 AOs, 1 RG, 10 WBs, 6 USOs
- Ned: 1 AO, 15 RGs, 1 WB, 3 USOs
- Djoker: 9 AOs, 1 RG, 1 W, 5 USOs

 

[fedfan24]

I’d give 2006 AO to 2013ovic and 2008 USO to 2008erer but great effort with the thread

 

[nolefam_2024]

Hypotheticals are not real

 

[jackson vile]

Nadal win almost all RG, Novak wins almost all AO, Federer gets the short stick with reduced Wim and USO shared with Novak and Nadal.

 

[Holmes]

Djokovic and Nadal as same aged rivals, both who played top 10 tennis at younger ages, instead of Roddick, Hewitt and Fish? This does not end well for the Maestro.

 

[Matrix968]

Year	Aussie Open	RG	Wimbledon	US Open
2000	Agassi	2005dal (#1)	PETE	Safin!
2001	Agassi	2006dal (#2)	Goran def 2006dal (debatable)	2007ovic (#1)
2002	2008ovic (#2)	2007dal (#3)	2007dal (#4)	PETE
2003	2003gassi def 2008dal (debatable)	2008dal (#5)	2003erer def 2008dal (#1)	2009ovic (#3)
2004	2009dal (no dasco SF) def 2004erer (debatable) (#6)	Gaudio smh	2004erer(#2)	2004erer(#3)
2005	2011ovic (#4)	2010dal (#7)	2005erer def 2010dal (#4)	2010dal (#8)
2006	2006erer def 2012ovic (debatable) (#5)	2011dal (#9)	2006erer def 2011dal (#6)	2006erer def 2011dal (#7)
2007	2007erer def 2013ovic (debatable) (#8)	2012dal (#10)	2007erer (#9)	2007erer (#10) def 2013ovic (no Stan SF) (debatable)
2008	2014ovic (#6)	2013dal (#11)	2008erer (#11)	2013dal (#12)
2009	2015ovic (#7)	2014dal (#13)	2015ovic (#8)	2015ovic (#9)
2010	2016ovic (#10)	2016ovic (#11)	Berdych!	2010erer (#12)
2011	2011erer (#13)	2011erer(#14)	Tsonga!	2011erer (#15)
2012	2012erer (#16)	2017dal (#14)	2012erer (#17)	2018ovic def 2017dal (debatable) (#12)
2013	2019ovic (#13)	2018dal (#15)	2018dal def 2019ovic (#16)	some mug unless Nadal injects his knee
2014	2020ovic (#14)	2019dal (#17)	2014erer (#18)	2019dal (#18)
2015	2021ovic (#15)	2020dal (#19)	2015erer (#19)	2015erer (#20)
2016	not putting one - can't speculate on 2022ovic w/o covid	2021dal (#20)	Lendlray!	Stan!
2017	2023ovic (#16)	2022dal (#21)	2017erer (#21)	2023ovic (#17)

Thought I'd update this. It got closer than I was expecting tbh

That's what I'm calling the top SF, even Spielberg will bow before such masterpiece