i had the same problem but the other way around. i was stringing my racquet with psgd at 58 and it feels good, nice feel and ball pocketing, but i wanted a little less power, so i string it at 60. now is very different. its feels nothing like it used to, feels like hitting with a board, and i dont like that at all, so im gonna go back to string at 58.
To answer your question, yes you have to string softer strings at high tensions, just like polys have to be string at low tension because of its high stifness. i suggest you string it at 57 or 58 next time, cause if you string too high you might lose feel.