Is Carlos a top 5 teenage player of all time?

Is Carlos a top 5 teenage player of all time?


  • Total voters
    79

Entername

Professional
Insane development by Carlos this year, I never thought we'd see another teen win a major but Carlitos should changed that narrative fast. He's currently 19 years and 4 months old with one major, 6 titles (2 Masters), and the youngest ever to be world number one. Some of the other candidates are:

- Nadal had 1 major and 16 titles (6 Masters) before turning 20
- Borg had 2 majors and 15 titles (1 Masters) before turning 20
- Becker had 2 majors and 12 titles (5 Masters) before turning 20
- Chang had 1 major and 6 titles (1 Masters) before turning 20
- Wilander had 2 majors and 14 titles (3 Masters) before turning 20
- Sampras had 1 major and 6 titles (1 GS Cup) before turning 20
- Edberg had 1 major and 5 titles before turning 20
 
Sampras, Edberg, Chang all better at this point. That said, the year is not out, and Carlitos may be able to pile up a few stats before turning 20.
 
Sampras/Chang actually beat real people to win their majors (namely decent albeit post prime versions of Lendl). Edberg I guess only won AO vs Lendl/Wilander on grass, I'd still say that's more impressive. Agassi is clearly above Alcaraz, finished #3 in a decent era at 18, made two major semis, did decently in them, and won a bunch of small titles. Obviously would have looked like a world beater against this year's USO (or hell even RG) field. No one can deny that.

Also teenage Hewitt/Roddick in 00/01 could have coasted to some joke tournament like this year's USO and in far more impressive fashion to boot. Mac also made two major semis as a teenager and would have done more if he didn't go to college.
 
Sampras/Chang actually beat real people to win their majors (namely decent albeit post prime versions of Lendl). Edberg I guess only won AO vs Lendl/Wilander on grass, I'd still say that's more impressive. Agassi is clearly above Alcaraz, finished #3 in a decent era at 18, made two major semis, did decently in them, and won a bunch of small titles. Obviously would have looked like a world beater against this year's USO (or hell even RG) field. No one can deny that.

Also teenage Hewitt/Roddick in 00/01 could have coasted to some joke tournament like this year's USO and in far more impressive fashion to boot. Mac also made two major semis as a teenager and would have done more if he didn't go to college.

Don't trust teenage Agassi's mentality to close the deal in a slam, unlike Alcaraz.
Sinner of this USO is roughly Blake's level IMO. Agassi of USO 05 just beat Blake.
Agassi actually played better in the RG 88 semi than in USO 88 semi tho'. Some wild aggressive tennis with so many net approaches. Only tired out in a 5th vs Wilander. He'd actually take out Nadal of this year unless maybe its the QF or nerves set in in a final.

Hewitt USO 00 could certainly take this year's USO.
Roddick ended 2001 as #14. Not sure of his mental strength to take it as much as Hewitt's. But then throw in home crowd support factor. that gives Roddick a boost
 
Last edited:
Don't trust teenage Agassi's mentality to close the deal in a slam, unlike Alcaraz.
Sinner of this USO is roughly Blake's level IMO. Agassi of USO 05 just beat Blake.
Agassi actually played better in the RG 88 semi than in USO 88 semi tho'. Some wild aggressive tennis with so many net approaches. Only tired out in a 5th vs Wilander. He'd actually take out Nadal of this year unless maybe its the QF or nerves set in in a final.

Hewitt USO 00 could certainly take this year's USO.
Roddick ended 2001 as #14. Not sure of his mental strength to take it as much as Hewitt's. But then throw in home crowd support factor. that gives Roddick a boost
But can you trust ruud's or sinner's mentality to close a slam against agassi? Agassi's mentality against Lendl or Courier or Pete or a seasoned reliable player like Gomez doesn't mean he wouldn't run over a bunch of young mugs equally as mentally immature if not moreso but significantly less talented.

I don't think Sinner is at Blake's level, not even close. Blake is significantly better at everything besides standstill BH. Blake with just raw tools and no refinement was able to credibly compete against Federer and not make a fool of himself, Sinner would be embarrassed. I don't think Sinner, Tiafoe, or Ruud played better than 05 Ginepri, they are around that level, not at Blake or Agassi.

01 Roddick suffered a bit of a breakdown late against Hewitt but before that was playing very well. Could easily beat this slate of mugs without even needing a 5th set.
 
But can you trust ruud's or sinner's mentality to close a slam against agassi? Agassi's mentality against Lendl or Courier or Pete or a seasoned reliable player like Gomez doesn't mean he wouldn't run over a bunch of young mugs equally as mentally immature if not moreso but significantly less talented.

I don't trust them either. So there'd be nerves both sides.

I don't think Sinner is at Blake's level, not even close. Blake is significantly better at everything besides standstill BH. Blake with just raw tools and no refinement was able to credibly compete against Federer and not make a fool of himself, Sinner would be embarrassed. I don't think Sinner, Tiafoe, or Ruud played better than 05 Ginepri, they are around that level, not at Blake or Agassi.

I didn't mention Tiafoe/Ruud though. Only Sinner. You are under-rating Sinner IMO. the only thing Blake is significantly better at is footspeed.
FH, he has the edge, but not big one. return and serve, same ballpark. (serve - 1st serve Sinner, 2nd serve Blake)

I'd pick Blake over Sinner, but its not a big edge.

01 Roddick suffered a bit of a breakdown late against Hewitt but before that was playing very well. Could easily beat this slate of mugs without even needing a 5th set.

not a guarantee for a teenager mentally.
 
I don't trust them either. So there'd be nerves both sides.



I didn't mention Tiafoe/Ruud though. Only Sinner. You are under-rating Sinner IMO. the only thing Blake is significantly better at is footspeed.
FH, he has the edge, but not big one. return and serve, same ballpark. (serve - 1st serve Sinner, 2nd serve Blake)

I'd pick Blake over Sinner, but its not a big edge.



not a guarantee for a teenager mentally.
Blake has much higher peaks on serve/return. I haven't seen much of Sinner but he seems pretty mediocre in terms of anything beyond standstill hitting. Poor man's Berdych.
 
Blake has much higher peaks on serve/return. I haven't seen much of Sinner but he seems pretty mediocre in terms of anything beyond standstill hitting. Poor man's Berdych.

Sinner's improved his returning signficantly this year.
nothing like last year or 2020 from what I've seen.

He absorbs pace fine as well - the only thing he's better at than Berdych tho'

Blake's serve wasn't really that great to be put as much better. 2nd serve better than Sinner yes, but not 1st serve IMO.
 
I was so close to having the 88 Agassi > 22 Alcaraz propaganda live forever. So close. Although I still believe RG ‘88 Wilander beats every teen except for Nadal and Borg and USO ‘88 Lendl beats every teen except maaaaybe Sampras. Many of the teens do worse than Agassi did as well.So it is what it is.

This take is spot on imo
Nadal, Borg, Wilander, Becker are unequivocal top 4 in any order.
Closer with Sampras, Chang, Edberg. We'll see.
 
Sinner's improved his returning signficantly this year.
nothing like last year or 2020 from what I've seen.

He absorbs pace fine as well - the only thing he's better at than Berdych tho'

Blake's serve wasn't really that great to be put as much better. 2nd serve better than Sinner yes, but not 1st serve IMO.
Blake's first serve was a bit inconsistent but he definitely had some good patches with it in both 05 and 06. 05 vs Agassi, in 3 sets it was pretty good and vs Nadal his first serve game was pretty strong.

Against Fed in 06, tough for anything but an elite server to hold easily against that kind of Fed.
 
Insane development by Carlos this year, I never thought we'd see another teen win a major but Carlitos should changed that narrative fast. He's currently 19 years and 4 months old with one major, 6 titles (2 Masters), and the youngest ever to be world number one. Some of the other candidates are:

- Nadal had 1 major and 16 titles (6 Masters) before turning 20
- Borg had 2 majors and 15 titles (1 Masters) before turning 20
- Becker had 2 majors and 12 titles (5 Masters) before turning 20
- Chang had 1 major and 6 titles (1 Masters) before turning 20
- Wilander had 2 majors and 14 titles (3 Masters) before turning 20
- Sampras had 1 major and 6 titles (1 GS Cup) before turning 20
- Edberg had 1 major and 5 titles before turning 20
Good list, thanks. Could you add Alcaraz vurrent stats as well?
 
Let's not forget Becker. He played some tough opponents to bag some of those titles.

Here are some examples:
beat peak #1 Lendl on carpet in the Chicago final. Lendl once reeled off 66 straight wins on carpet, a record for the surface and 2nd most on any surface(Nadal did 81 straight on clay)
beat peak #1 Lendl in the Wimbledon final(I know, that was by far Lendl's weakest surface)
beat #6 Edberg at the Montreal final
beat peak #1 Lendl at the sydney hardcourt final
beat #4 Edberg at the Tokyo final(carpet_
beat #2 Edberg at the Indian Wells final
beat #7 Connors at the Qheens final

The guy was 10-6 vs top-10 guys in finals alone!
He was 11-5 vs top 10 in the semis
He was 4-1 vs top 10 in the quarters

I.e, as a teenager, he was 25-12 vs top 10 players during the quarters, semis, and finals of tourneys.

Becker is a strong candidate for #1
 
Process of elimination, definitely below Nadal, Borg, Becker and Wilander. So that leaves 1 spot.

Sampras, Edberg, Chang. Going with Sampras at least. So not Top 5.
 
Let's not forget Becker. He played some tough opponents to bag some of those titles.

Here are some examples:
beat peak #1 Lendl on carpet in the Chicago final. Lendl once reeled off 66 straight wins on carpet, a record for the surface and 2nd most on any surface(Nadal did 81 straight on clay)
beat peak #1 Lendl in the Wimbledon final(I know, that was by far Lendl's weakest surface)
beat #6 Edberg at the Montreal final
beat peak #1 Lendl at the sydney hardcourt final
beat #4 Edberg at the Tokyo final(carpet_
beat #2 Edberg at the Indian Wells final
beat #7 Connors at the Qheens final

The guy was 10-6 vs top-10 guys in finals alone!
He was 11-5 vs top 10 in the semis
He was 4-1 vs top 10 in the quarters

I.e, as a teenager, he was 25-12 vs top 10 players during the quarters, semis, and finals of tourneys.

Becker is a strong candidate for #1

well you have strong arguments for Becker as well as Wilander, Borg, Nadal.
Those are definitely top 4 in some order.
The only question is who is 5th.
 
Insane development by Carlos this year, I never thought we'd see another teen win a major but Carlitos should changed that narrative fast. He's currently 19 years and 4 months old with one major, 6 titles (2 Masters), and the youngest ever to be world number one. Some of the other candidates are:

- Nadal had 1 major and 16 titles (6 Masters) before turning 20
- Borg had 2 majors and 15 titles (1 Masters) before turning 20
- Becker had 2 majors and 12 titles (5 Masters) before turning 20
- Chang had 1 major and 6 titles (1 Masters) before turning 20
- Wilander had 2 majors and 14 titles (3 Masters) before turning 20
- Sampras had 1 major and 6 titles (1 GS Cup) before turning 20
- Edberg had 1 major and 5 titles before turning 20

and Rafa turned 20 the same week he won his second major. He was still 19 when FO2006 started.
 
Agassi is clearly above Alcaraz, finished #3 in a decent era at 18, made two major semis, did decently in them, and won a bunch of small titles. Obviously would have looked like a world beater against this year's USO (or hell even RG) field. No one can deny that.

The year isn't over.

Alcaraz could end up winning the YEC and finishing the year #1, in addition to winning a Slam and 5 other titles. Not to mention all the Finals he went to.
 
All the numbskulls that are so desperate to hastily apply ATG status to the next big thing are:

a) setting yourselves up for disappointment, because
b) there will be so much pressure on the focus of your attention, combined with
c) unrealistic, way-too-early expectations of said person,

which will likely doom the success of that person, and your personal wishes.

Enjoy!
 
All the numbskulls that are so desperate to hastily apply ATG status to the next big thing are:

a) setting yourselves up for disappointment, because
b) there will be so much pressure on the focus of your attention, combined with
c) unrealistic, way-too-early expectations of said person,

which will likely doom the success of that person, and your personal wishes.

Enjoy!

Except this isn’t about what will be. It is about what already has happened. We can answer this question without hypotheticals right now. We aren’t saying he will win 10 slams. We’re saying he has won a slam, master tournaments, and is already #1 at 19 and that puts him on par with the achievements of a select group of individuals before they turned 20.
 
I think he sneaks into the top 5 as well. GOAT teens in men's tennis in no order:

- Rafa
- Borg
- Wilander
- Becker
- Carlitos

Tiny Carlos still has one more major, 5 Masters, a WTF, and a YEN1 up for grabs until he turns 20 as well
Over sampras? He had very strong competition going through muster, lendl, McEnroe and Agassi.
 
ROFLMAO he’s not even top 20. Hewitt would run circles around him and Roddick would serve 150mph bombs into his face.
 
@The Blond Blur please do your job
23ahfi.jpg
 
Sampras/Chang actually beat real people to win their majors (namely decent albeit post prime versions of Lendl). Edberg I guess only won AO vs Lendl/Wilander on grass, I'd still say that's more impressive. Agassi is clearly above Alcaraz, finished #3 in a decent era at 18, made two major semis, did decently in them, and won a bunch of small titles. Obviously would have looked like a world beater against this year's USO (or hell even RG) field. No one can deny that.

Also teenage Hewitt/Roddick in 00/01 could have coasted to some joke tournament like this year's USO and in far more impressive fashion to boot. Mac also made two major semis as a teenager and would have done more if he didn't go to college.

i agree with everything except roddick and hewitt. i think alcaraz of today is better than roddick/hewitt of 2000-2001. safin of 2000 on the other hand was more talented and had a better game than alcaraz. alcaraz is much physically fitter and faster than safin of 2000.
 
Let's not forget Becker. He played some tough opponents to bag some of those titles.

Here are some examples:
beat peak #1 Lendl on carpet in the Chicago final. Lendl once reeled off 66 straight wins on carpet, a record for the surface and 2nd most on any surface(Nadal did 81 straight on clay)
beat peak #1 Lendl in the Wimbledon final(I know, that was by far Lendl's weakest surface)
beat #6 Edberg at the Montreal final
beat peak #1 Lendl at the sydney hardcourt final
beat #4 Edberg at the Tokyo final(carpet_
beat #2 Edberg at the Indian Wells final
beat #7 Connors at the Qheens final

The guy was 10-6 vs top-10 guys in finals alone!
He was 11-5 vs top 10 in the semis
He was 4-1 vs top 10 in the quarters

I.e, as a teenager, he was 25-12 vs top 10 players during the quarters, semis, and finals of tourneys.

Becker is a strong candidate for #1
I’m so glad you put some context to this discussion. Becker was outta this world as a teen, and we’re talking even younger than Carlos is now. Becker was doing this at 17 and 18 years of age

Wilander beat Lendl (who was on a tear in ‘82 of non slam tourneys), Guerilitas, and Vilas to win the French in’82…at age 17. Then won 8 or 9 tourneys in ‘83, including the Aussie Open on grass by beating near peak-level McEnroe in the semis and Lendl in the Finals. Oh and also got to another French Final, losing only to an inspired Yannick Noah

so many times in this era of sports fandom, cumulative stats are posted without context breaking them down
 
i agree with everything except roddick and hewitt. i think alcaraz of today is better than roddick/hewitt of 2000-2001
Absolutely not. Outta here with this recency bias, come on. Tiny Carlos would never get past either guy in a grand slam.


he's a much better shotmaker than roddick at the very least. all roddick has over carlos is his serve. carlos has better hands at net, better touch, equally powerful groundstrokes as roddick, and hits with more precision than roddick. and definitely has more speed and athleticism than roddick
 
he's a much better shotmaker than roddick at the very least. all roddick has over carlos is his serve. carlos has better hands at net, better touch, equally powerful groundstrokes as roddick, and hits with more precision than roddick. and definitely has more speed and athleticism than roddick


Tiny Carlos has never once beaten a player of that caliber. Even at the US Open where on paper he had huge advantages, much lesser players took him deep and gave him fits.

Tiafoe has an absolute meatball serve and carlitos was unable to punish it at all. Just sat back. Imagine him trying to deal with 140mph bombs from Roddick. Fuggetaboutit. Even nadal took bruises.

 
Tiny Carlos has never once beaten a player of that caliber. Even at the US Open where on paper he had huge advantages, much lesser players took him deep and gave him fits.

Tiafoe has an absolute meatball serve and carlitos was unable to punish it at all. Just sat back. Imagine him trying to deal with 140mph bombs from Roddick. Fuggetaboutit. Even nadal took bruises.


he handled bombs from marin cilic. and lesser players have taken great players to five sets and given them fits. santoro is not that great, but his game style gave safin fits. tipsarevic took federer to five etc
 
he handled bombs from marin cilic. and lesser players have taken great players to five sets and given them fits. santoro is not that great, but his game style gave safin fits. tipsarevic took federer to five etc

Washed Cilic is nowhere near the level of the guys in question. Safin would have crushed Tiny Carlos, too. Maybe even worse than Roddick. Entirely different level of tennis compared to what we're seeing now.
 
he's a much better shotmaker than roddick at the very least. all roddick has over carlos is his serve. carlos has better hands at net, better touch, equally powerful groundstrokes as roddick, and hits with more precision than roddick. and definitely has more speed and athleticism than roddick

Alcaraz being a better shotmaker than Roddick doesn't matter if he keeps getting broken while Roddick keeps holding.
the serve of Roddick is a massive advantage. that serve+fh means he keeps holding at USO.

over the year, I'd take Alcaraz 22 over Roddick 01, but at USO, I might actually go with Roddick in a one on one.

Hewitt USO 00 vs Alcaraz USO 22 is close.
Hewitt's clearly better returner and steadier while Alcaraz is the better shotmaker.
Year wise, also it's close.
 
he handled bombs from marin cilic. and lesser players have taken great players to five sets and given them fits. santoro is not that great, but his game style gave safin fits. tipsarevic took federer to five etc

Thing is Alcaraz went 5 vs 3 different players. He could have avoided vs Cilic/Tiafoe at the very least.
 
Rosewall won 2 slams in 1953, the Aussie and the French, halfway to the grand slam, he was seeded number 1 at Wimbledon that year….he was 18 years old at the time…..
 
Back
Top