Is Djokovic greater than Federer and Nadal?

[Shady_Sawyer]

Considering his NCYGS, his superior H2H against rivals Nadal, Federer, Murray and the way dismantled Federer in Wimbledon in 2014 and 2015 (Fed's supposedly favourite surface) and defeated Nadal on his favourite surface in 2015 .....I think he is superior to Federer in the GOAT debate in every way. Right now the title vs runner up stats is Djokovic 12-8, Nadal 14-6 and Federer 17-10 These 10 runner up trophies are mostly gifts from Nadal and Djokovic who are superior to Federer. To me Djokovic at this point is superior to Nadal given his NYCGS and various other records like WTF and world no.1 and everything else. Djokovic is highly discredited and not given his due because he comes from a second world communist country which does not fit the pro Federer and pro Nadal media.

 

[davced1]

I don't know really. When Federer and Nadal were at their best Djokovic was always number 3. He was always better than Murray. Now we see what happens when Nadal and Federer are not at their best anymore, then Djokovic prosper. It would have been nice if all three of them were still at their best though.

However if Djokovic does go on and beat Federers slam record it is another situation.

 

[tennis_pro]

Yes, beating Berdych and Bautista-Agut is very impressive.