Is it fair to say that Roger Federer remains the Gold standard for Longevity at the highest level in Tennis ?

Is it fair to say that Roger Federer remains the Gold standard for Longevity at the highest level ??


  • Total voters
    91
I think i was one of very few people, perhaps even the only one, who years ago did say Federer's 5 W's and USO's in a row and consecutive weeks at no.1 would always, once recency bias faded, keep Federer in the GOAT discussion.
W2019 may well ultimately as time passes mean Federer gets the nod over Nadal and Djokovic overall. Lest we forget he beat Nadal there at 38 years of age and then took Djokovic to 5 sets. Back to back. Rafa and Novak at the same age would not have a prayer of doing that with Sinner and Alcaraz back to back, and neither are Nadal and Djokovic levels. Indeed Djokovic has been utterly routined by both at slams and he is younger than Federer in 2019.
There is no question Federer set a new benchmark for longevity. It is undeniably fact.
That's why he's my GOAT.
 
Of Federer's 5 straight WB's, the most & only important opponent was Nadal @ '07 WB. At that time, Federer was 26, no. 1 in the world and on his favorite surface, he was supposed to beat no. 2, who hadn't won any non-RG! He was supposed to win, the earth shook twelve months later when Nadal won! Of course, he was successful against Roddick three times at WB, who was a lesser version of Medvedev!

Of his 5 straight US's, frankly none was impressive. Agassi was 11 years his elder. Djokovic and Murray were at the time were 20 and 21. None could be classified in the various Federer-Djokovic and Nadal-Djokovic battles, for instance!
 
Last edited:
Nah, you guys aren't playing that card.

Federer got injured at Indian Wells that year vs Ivan Dodig and was dealing with that injury from then onwards, so he was fine at AO, and it was about as close to a five-set thrashing as one could get. He was hanging on for dear life in that match and Murray had his way with him.

Murray also did well to carry that form into the first couple sets in the final vs Novak. He was the better player and the only player to carve up break points in the first two sets. He did fumble a 0-40 and lost his marbles after the feather incident at 2-2 in the second set tiebreak, but the blisters on his foot had nothing to do with his loss. Novak raised his level and took the match to him and Murray couldn't keep up.

So it works both ways - Federer's back was fine vs Murray and Murray's feet were relatively fine as well vs Novak. Neither 'injury' can be attributed to their respective losses. But Murray stomped on Federer in the AO semis, that year, and should have wrapped it up in straights, four max. You're not playing the 'poor Federer' card for that match. No chance.
Fed was pretty poor for his standards though. Barely got past Tsonga where he’d only served 6 aces.
 
Djokovic's longevity was better. Federer won 0 Slams between 31-35 and didn't get back to #1 during that time except for fall 2012. He was 35.5 when he won another Slam and right after that became #1 again. Djokovic won many Slams between 31-35, and probably spent close to 200 weeks at #1 and had 3 YE #1's.
 
Djokovic's longevity was better. Federer won 0 Slams between 31-35 and didn't get back to #1 during that time. He was 35.5 when he won another Slam and right after that became #1. Djokovic won many Slams between 31-35 and probably spent close to 200 weeks at #1.
Djoko won more than half of his slams when his 2 greatest rivals were on the decline. I don't mind crediting him when it comes to longevity but saying it matters more BECAUSE he was winning slams AFTER 31 is crazy.
 
Djoko won more than half of his slams when his 2 greatest rivals were on the decline. I don't mind crediting him when it comes to longevity but saying it matters more BECAUSE he was winning slams AFTER 31 is crazy.
It matters a lot because he maintained a high level for a very long time, and was the best player in the game for well over a decade. He wasn't losing to players like Seppi, Stakhovsky, Robredo, etc. in Slams at 32-34.
 
It matters a lot because he maintained a high level for a very long time, and was the best player in the game for well over a decade. He wasn't losing to players like Seppi, Stakhovsky, Robredo, etc. in Slams at 32-34.
True, he was beating people like Anderson, Thiem, Kyrgios, Tsitsipas and Berretini lol
 
True, he was beating people like Anderson, Thiem, Kyrgios, Tsitsipas and Berretini lol
That's better than losing to them, and Thiem is wayyy better than Seppi and Gulbis on hardcourt and clay. They don't even belong in the same sentence. Berretini and Anderson are better than Stakhovsky on grass.
 
Last edited:
That's better than losing to them, and Thiem is wayyy better than Seppi and Gulbis on hardcourt and clay. They don't even belong in the same sentence.

Don't let the door hit you on the way out

4bUV7Ls.gif
 
Djokovic's longevity was better. Federer won 0 Slams between 31-35 and didn't get back to #1 during that time except for fall 2012. He was 35.5 when he won another Slam and right after that became #1 again. Djokovic won many Slams between 31-35, and probably spent close to 200 weeks at #1 and had 3 YE #1's.
That’s not related to longevity, just circumstances.
 
Yeah, Djokovic did it in a Weakest Era of All Time(WEAT)
You can keep repeating that if it makes you feel better. Lol. The game wasn't strong at all from 1998-2003 either. Agassi won two pretty weak AO titles during that time but no one really cares because we know he was the best there regardless.
 
Nah, you guys aren't playing that card.
I speak for no one but myself, cut the you guys crap.

Federer got injured at Indian Wells that year vs Ivan Dodig and was dealing with that injury from then onwards, so he was fine at AO, and it was about as close to a five-set thrashing as one could get. He was hanging on for dear life in that match and Murray had his way with him.

Murray also did well to carry that form into the first couple sets in the final vs Novak. He was the better player and the only player to carve up break points in the first two sets. He did fumble a 0-40 and lost his marbles after the feather incident at 2-2 in the second set tiebreak, but the blisters on his foot had nothing to do with his loss. Novak raised his level and took the match to him and Murray couldn't keep up.

So it works both ways - Federer's back was fine vs Murray and Murray's feet were relatively fine as well vs Novak. Neither 'injury' can be attributed to their respective losses. But Murray stomped on Federer in the AO semis, that year, and should have wrapped it up in straights, four max. You're not playing the 'poor Federer' card for that match. No chance.

Federer was barely serving any aces in 2013 AO (on a HC) and had to wear compression shirt in several matches which he does when his back is bothering him.

As I said, 2013 was one of Fed's worst seasons. It would be akin to using 2015 losses for Nadal or 2017 for Novak against them.

Nothing you or anyone else writes on this matter will change my mind on this one in the slightest.
 
Fed was pretty poor for his standards though. Barely got past Tsonga where he’d only served 6 aces.

Fed was terrible for the whole of 2013. Murary vultured a slam win against him at AO and Nadal did so at Cinci (but ducked him in 2015 of course) and WTF.

When Fed and Murray met in slams when both were in form, Fed usually won in straights. Even 2012 Wimbledon final didn't go 5.
 
I mean there are guys who could trouble even peak Fed depends on the surface/conditions.

Murray just ain't one of them, not in slams when it's business time for Fed and his attacking game is functioning like a well-oiled machine.

Yeah, Murray is not Del Potro or Safin to trouble Federer.

he is peer with rafa (and muzza) how could he be born in exactly perfect time but not rafa who is born less than a year before? fed is born in ATG vacuum. no other ATG was born in 5 years before or after him! that is the timing!

nole was injured at the end of 2016 but muzza won it fair and square. he probable paid high price and it could be even worse. he took YE#1 in the very last match of the year saving MP vs milos in the SF, the match before. so it was so close that he paid that high price for nothing (or for 1 week no1 because the points from WTF does not drops after 52 weeks, as other tournaments - after tournament, but before it so that atp list equals race list).

Federer had Nadal for many years even in the 2000s, so the vacuum that you talk about was not that much of a vacuum. Plus vacuum ior not Federer's level of play was very high and far beyond any Muzza...you respect Muza because he beat Djokovic, but sadly vs Fed and Nadal this Muzza was nothing.
 
04. Federer held MPs in the Wimbledon final at close to 38 while Djokovic is unable to do that.
ROFLMFAO this is an argument??? :-D

About the other ones, sure, but I'd like to remind you that Djokovic has not yet retired. And after all, you are still doubting him. And you will again be surprised.​
 
Of Federer's 5 straight WB's, the most & only important opponent was Nadal @ '07 WB. At that time, Federer was 26, no. 1 in the world and on his favorite surface, he was supposed to beat no. 2, who hadn't won any non-RG! He was supposed to win, the earth shook twelve months later when Nadal won! Of course, he was successful against Roddick three times at WB, who was a lesser version of Medvedev!

Of his 5 straight US's, frankly none was impressive.
Agassi was 11 years his elder. Djokovic and Murray were at the time were 20 and 21. None could be classified in the various Federer-Djokovic and Nadal-Djokovic battles, for instance!
Roddick a lesser version of Medvedev ON GRASS, lmfao :-D:-D

As if you would not have posted endlessly over the years about a slam final in which Djokovic served up two bagel sets. :sneaky:
 
That's why he's my GOAT.

I think i was one of very few people, perhaps even the only one, who years ago did say Federer's 5 W's and USO's in a row and consecutive weeks at no.1 would always, once recency bias faded, keep Federer in the GOAT discussion.
W2019 may well ultimately as time passes mean Federer gets the nod over Nadal and Djokovic overall. Lest we forget he beat Nadal there at 38 years of age and then took Djokovic to 5 sets. Back to back. Rafa and Novak at the same age would not have a prayer of doing that with Sinner and Alcaraz back to back, and neither are Nadal and Djokovic levels. Indeed Djokovic has been utterly routined by both at slams and he is younger than Federer in 2019.
There is no question Federer set a new benchmark for longevity. It is undeniably fact.
1. nole is 15-16 years older than sinneras not 6 as fed is older than him.

2. nole has not negative record vs them not even in slams while fed has negative record vs both nole and rafa both overall and even worse in slams. in fact, fed had very weak record vs rafa even in his peak years in his own era (04-09)!

nole vs sinner: 4-4 (2-1 in slams)
nole vs raz: 5-3 (2-2 in slams)
he was 4-2 vs sinner (2-0 at slams) and 3-2 vs ras (1-1 at slams) in his 2nd era (W18-23)

fed vs nole: 23-27+WO (6-11 in slams)
fed vs rafa: 16+WO-24 (4-10 in slams)
fed vs rafa in his own era (04-09): 7-13 (2-6 in slams)

3. nole won vs sinner and raz b2b in 5th most prestigious tournament WTF23 in SF and F in 4 easy sets (6-3, 6-2 and 6-3, 6-3)!

fed won only once vs nole and rafa at the same tournament. at WTF10 before nole reach his peak and on indoor HC that is rafas worst condition.
nole won 5 times vs fed and rafa: can07 (+ rodick so all top3 players), IW11, USO11, WTF13 and WTF15.
 
Last edited:
You mentioned Muzza again and again but Muzza was never a threat to Federer in Grand Slams. He was winning in BO3 and Federer was okay with those wins, the moment Muzza started to face him in Slams Federer started taking him seriously in the match and beat him everytime except the AO in 2013 which was in Fed's bad year anyway.

Muzza was nothing against Federer, he was always a pigeon to Federer. Muzza is very lucky he was born in 1980-1981, otherwise his H2H vs Federer would be something like 2-20 or 3-22 types.

Muzza would be on 0 slams today if born in 1980-81. :)
Yeah this Murray-Fed H2H is blown way out of proportion. Very happy that Fed turned it around in later years and corrected that atrocity. He always dominates Murray at slams. 5–1 and even way past prime he beat Muzz.
 
Djoko won more than half of his slams when his 2 greatest rivals were on the decline. I don't mind crediting him when it comes to longevity but saying it matters more BECAUSE he was winning slams AFTER 31 is crazy.
why did rafa decline so "soon"? he is peer with nole. and he won 2 slams so late as 2022.

on the contrary, there was fed and rafa that did their colossal superhuman comeback in 17-18 when nole was away due injury and surgery. and rafa won his ultra great 2nd CGS when nole was deported for strictly political reasons!

on the other hand nole won 7 consecutive big finals vs absolute peak rafa in the middle of his "mini-era", 10-13. 10 and 13 was his 2 greatest seasons and 11 would be his THE greatest season if not for nole.
 
Last edited:
Tough to say as we first have to define what longevity entails. Is it most cumulated success after a certain age (like x slams after 30)? Biggest stand-alone success at the oldest age? Oldest player with a certain level? What if a guy wins 8 slams between 30 and 35 and then doesn’t win anything more after it? What if a player doesn’t win anything after 30 but then at 38 wins a slam? What if a player never wins a slam after 30 but still plays a very high level and even strolls within the top ten at age 45? Mac was done winning slams pretty early but given the level he still plays at 66 we can still say he has great longevity.
 
Tough to say as we first have to define what longevity entails. Is it most cumulated success after a certain age (like x slams after 30)? Biggest stand-alone success at the oldest age? Oldest player with a certain level? What if a guy wins 8 slams between 30 and 35 and then doesn’t win anything more after it? What if a player doesn’t win anything after 30 but then at 38 wins a slam? What if a player never wins a slam after 30 but still plays a very high level and even strolls within the top ten at age 45? Mac was done winning slams pretty early but given the level he still plays at 66 we can still say he has great longevity.
As things stand, the best achievement at oldest age belongs to Fed. Coming close to winning Wimbledon at age almost 38. Let’s see if Djokovic can match it this year.
 
Federer was tired after the match with JMDP, plus it was not a wimbledon final.

We all saw what Federer did to Murray in 2015 in the semis, it was a 1 sided destruction. That is what they are against each, Murray is not in Federer's league on Grass

Federer and Sampras are tier 1 in ability
Djokovic is Tier 2
Murray is probably tier 3 or tier 4.



Federer had no problem with crushing Murray, at that time in slams Murray was nothing vs Federer. Murray is a hewitt level player, nothing more.
Murray beat Fed at slams first time in 2013 when Fed had a very bad year. Djokovic beat Fed already in 2008. Nadal on the other hand lost to Murray already in 2008 and again in 2010 both before he lost first to Djokovic in 2011. Whoever rigged those draws must have been pretty stupid. No way Federer needs protection from Murray.
 
Tough to say as we first have to define what longevity entails. Is it most cumulated success after a certain age (like x slams after 30)? Biggest stand-alone success at the oldest age? Oldest player with a certain level? What if a guy wins 8 slams between 30 and 35 and then doesn’t win anything more after it? What if a player doesn’t win anything after 30 but then at 38 wins a slam? What if a player never wins a slam after 30 but still plays a very high level and even strolls within the top ten at age 45? Mac was done winning slams pretty early but given the level he still plays at 66 we can still say he has great longevity.
As things stand, the best achievement at oldest age belongs to Fed. Coming close to winning Wimbledon at age almost 38. Let’s see if Djokovic can match it this year.
He’ll have to beat both Sinner and Alcaraz to even come close
 
He’ll have to beat both Sinner and Alcaraz to even come close
Debatable. Both are way younger than Djoko and Nadal in 2019. Also Fed in the end didn’t beat both. On the other hand of course Raz and Sinner are overall not Djokodal level. It’s moot anyways because I don’t think Djoko will reach the Wimbledon final. Even if he did, a quarterfinal at 40 I can’t see.
 
Debatable. Both are way younger than Djoko and Nadal in 2019. Also Fed in the end didn’t beat both. On the other hand of course Raz and Sinner are overall not Djokodal level. It’s moot anyways because I don’t think Djoko will reach the Wimbledon final. Even if he did, a quarterfinal at 40 I can’t see.
He didn’t beat both, but he came closer than everyone from the last 3 gens
 
Don’t think Raz and Sinner have sown a higher level so far than Djokodal at those ages
The other poster said Nadal or Djokovic wouldn’t come close to beating Raz and Sinner at the age of 38. I mean we don’t know how Sinner and Raz would do at 31/32, maybe they will be completely shot.
 
why did rafa decline so "soon"? he is peer with nole. and he won 2 slams so late as 2022.

on the contrary, there was fed and rafa that did their colossal superhuman comeback in 17-18 when nole was away due injury and surgery. and rafa won his ultra great 2nd CGS when nole was deported for strictly political reasons!

on the other hand nole won 7 consecutive big finals vs absolute peak rafa in the middle of his "mini-era", 10-13. 10 and 13 was his 2 greatest seasons and 11 would be his THE greatest season if not for nole.
Djokovic was in the draw of each slam that Federer won in 2017 and 2018.
 
Roddick a lesser version of Medvedev ON GRASS, lmfao :-D:-D

As if you would not have posted endlessly over the years about a slam final in which Djokovic served up two bagel sets. :sneaky:
Medvedev defeated Alcaraz in the slams! Who did Roddick defeat in the slams, in the prime of his life?
 
the season they turning 31

the season they turned313233343536373839
fed1 slam, 3 masters YE#2//
YE#6
2 masters
YE#2
1 master
YE#3
//
YE#16
2 slams, 3 masters
YE#2
1 slam
YE#3
1 master
YE#3
//*
YE#5*
nole2 slams, 2 masters
YE#1
2 slams, 2 masters
YE#2
1 slam, 2 masters
YE#1
3 slams, 1 master
YE#1
1 slam, WTF, 1 M
YE#5*
3 slams, WTF, 2 M*
YE#1
OG
YE#7
????
greaternolenolenolenolenolenolefed????
2020*: 6 masters and W not held
2021*: shanghai not held
2022*: AO deportation, USO IW, miami, can, cinci bans, shanghai not held, W22 points not counted
2023*:bans IW, miami
 
1. nole is 15-16 years older than sinneras not 6 as fed is older than him.

2. nole has not negative record vs them not even in slams while fed has negative record vs both nole and rafa both overall and even worse in slams. in fact, fed had very weak record vs rafa even in his peak years in his own era (04-09)!

nole vs sinner: 4-4 (2-1 in slams)
nole vs raz: 5-3 (2-2 in slams)
he was 4-2 vs sinner (2-0 at slams) and 3-2 vs ras (1-1 at slams) in his 2nd era (W18-23)

fed vs nole: 23-27+WO (6-11 in slams)
fed vs rafa: 16+WO-24 (4-10 in slams)
fed vs rafa in his own era (04-09): 7-13 (2-6 in slams)

3. nole won vs sinner and raz b2b in 5th most prestigious tournament WTF23 in SF and F in 4 easy sets (6-3, 6-2 and 6-3, 6-3)!

fed won only once vs nole and rafa at the same tournament. at WTF10 before nole reach his peak and on indoor HC that is rafas worst condition.
nole won 5 times vs fed and rafa: can07 (+ rodick so all top3 players), IW11, USO11, WTF13 and WTF15.
Djokovic at this rate will have negative h2hs against both Sinner and Alcaraz at the slams, that is kinda the point
 
Federer's level at an advanced age is more impressive than Novak's. Here's my philosophico-methodological breakdown:

Federer nearly won Wimbledon aged 37 (almost 38) beating Nadal and Djokovic back to back. A 37 years old Mr. Djokovic won the Olympic Gold beating a much younger (16 years younger) Alcaraz who was at his absolute physical and skills prime.

38 years old Federer beat Djokovic at the ATP finals. 37 and a half years old Novak beat Carlos at the AO.

I'm picking Federer here, if only because Nadovic >>>>> Raz. Nearly beating Nadovic back to back >>>>>>> beating Raz. Carlos will never be in the BIg 3 tier.
Could we simplify to "because Djokovic is superior to Nadal, so I do not like him"?
 
Another argument he has that i think once recency bias has gone may well become very relevant is that 20 Majors plus the record at the most prestigious slam marks him out as the Greatest.
I think his peak/prime years- that consistency in those mid-20s, exactly when he should have been consistently winning, is a big deal.

Not to mention just his Rogerness.

(I know Novak fans will love his "Rogerness" being a metric.)

#RoklexAds
#Perpetual
 
Yeah, 5 consecutive at both Wimbledon and USO is really impressive, one of the historically unique feats in tennis. It's not as rock solid as Rafa's FO record but I have to say, I don't expect to see anyone repeat 5x in a row at USO and Wimbledon in my lifetime either.

Fed will always have a case for GOAT, just because of peak play and dominance, he had probably the best 4 year run ever. He did have some bouts of really impressive in his old (tennis) age as well but was marred by inconsistency, some if caused by injuries in 2013 and 2016. You can see that he's still relevant just by the fact that even in this forum, people still talk about Fed all the time (whether fans or detractors) despite him being retired for 3 years now.

Nadal and Novak have their claims too of course, with Novak's IMO still being the strongest despite everything. Nole slam, won literally every big tourney in tennis there is, Slam and weeks and YE#1 records. Yeah he had a few weaker gens which made it easier for him to be so dominant at 30+ but still, that can't take all the shine of his ridiculously complete career, it's damn near perfect CV.
Great post. I see the Big 3 in tennis a bit like in snooker comparing the Big 3 in snooker (in my county the world champs are going on) Davis Hendry and O'sullivan. You can make arguments for all 3, ultimately it depends on what criteria is being used to determine The Greatest. In Snooker it is more set as the Triple Crown events seems the yardstick. In tennis the problem is the yardstick always moves depending who has the upperhand. It was based on the slams only, but nowadays suddenly m1000 events have become as big as slams. I dont have an issue with that personally, what i have an issue with is the lack of consistency in tennis as to what defines being the Greatest. Snooker is great as the yardstick is universally agreed.
 
Back
Top