It seems to me that Andy had a fairly easy draw, but when he is put to the test, he chokes or doesn't perform like a #2 seed. On the other hand, Federer had problems with Aggasi, but like most #1 player or champions, he knows how to win when it counts. That just makes me think that Roddick hasn't really secures his #2 position. What should he really ranked? #3, #4?