Jan Silva back in USA

C

chalkflewup

Hall of Fame
MarTennis said:
If you have advanced degrees, education, high income (nevermind if you have free cash flow), you have to create the conditions of deprivation that manifest hunger to have a world class junior. Period. Ready to argue on this point.
Click to expand...

Was Federer poverty stricken or deprived? What about McEnroe? Sampras? Querrey?
 
Last edited:
MarTennis

MarTennis

Semi-Pro
Deprivation as motivation

GRANITECHIEF said:
All of this despite that fact that many of the top players didn't experience any of said conditions.
Click to expand...

Definitely arguing this as the state of play going forward. Also, I think we assume to players come from rich backgrounds. Fed, Gulbis, maybe Nadal, Murray. Who else is rich?
 
MarTennis

MarTennis

Semi-Pro
The Serbs aren't rich and deprivation during the bombing was no deterrent to their development.
 
Last edited:
C

chalkflewup

Hall of Fame
IMO, if deprivation is the key ingredient in the development of a world class athlete, then the United States would be the doormat of the Olympic games.
 
B

BMC9670

Hall of Fame
MarTennis said:
Definitely arguing this as the state of play going forward. Also, I think we assume to players come from rich backgrounds. Fed, Gulbis, maybe Nadal, Murray. Who else is rich?
Click to expand...

There is a big difference in being rich vs middle class vs poor, in motivation and in resources. Look through the bios of the top 100 ATP players and you'll find most come from middle to upper middle class families. Sure, there are rags to riches stories, but not many - they just get all the publicity.

The things is, being poor and hungry just isn't enough in tennis. This isn't basketball - you can't hone your skills for free on the playground with tons of high-quality built-in competition, get world-class coaching and training for free in college, and get drafted and at a minimum ride the pine for $500k per year all expenses paid.
 
T

tball2day

Semi-Pro
BMC9670 said:
There is a big difference in being rich vs middle class vs poor, in motivation and in resources. Look through the bios of the top 100 ATP players and you'll find most come from middle to upper middle class families. Sure, there are rags to riches stories, but not many - they just get all the publicity.

The things is, being poor and hungry just isn't enough in tennis. This isn't basketball - you can't hone your skills for free on the playground with tons of high-quality built-in competition, get world-class coaching and training for free in college, and get drafted and at a minimum ride the pine for $500k per year all expenses paid.
Click to expand...

Exactly....
 
C

chalkflewup

Hall of Fame
BMC9670 said:
There is a big difference in being rich vs middle class vs poor, in motivation and in resources. Look through the bios of the top 100 ATP players and you'll find most come from middle to upper middle class families. Sure, there are rags to riches stories, but not many - they just get all the publicity.

The things is, being poor and hungry just isn't enough in tennis. This isn't basketball - you can't hone your skills for free on the playground with tons of high-quality built-in competition, get world-class coaching and training for free in college, and get drafted and at a minimum ride the pine for $500k per year all expenses paid.
Click to expand...

Right on. Plus, our media does a "sensational" job adding plenty of frosting to the rags to riches stories. Don't get me started on some of these tennis commentators.
 
C

Chemist

Rookie
Is he 12 yet? Looks pretty good on video, but may lack real match experience. TRN showed he played one B12 match in CA in September 2011 and lost to a kid, who may be 2-3 years older, but ranked almost 700.
 
N

Number1Coach

Banned
i will be getting in touch with Scott Silva soon to see how he and Jan are doing would be nice to hear from them . Scott you can run but you cant hide old friend I am coming see you and Jan to encourage you guy with lots of love and hugs !!!
 
Last edited:
T

TennisCoachIN

Rookie
Jan strokes look really nice. He still looks so young.

What happened this afternoon. Seen Number 1 got banned and TCF erased all his posts again???
 
A

andfor

Legend
smoledman said:
So Jan fizzled out? Another cautionary tale?
Click to expand...
http://www.tennisrecruiting.net/player/activity.asp?id=786907
http://www.universaltennis.com/members/Memberdashboard.aspx?view=playerprofile&playerid=127817
I also saw a report that the family moved to Finland, but can't substantiate it. From his record he appears to be a good player, far the top of his age group. His father used to post here.
For me I'd call it cautionary from the standpoint that over-hyping a child is just wrong. Kids can't process and understand the exposure.
 
lgbalfa

lgbalfa

Professional
any news on jan silva?

i think he is a sophomore now in high school?

just curious how this prodigy is now doing.

thanks
 
lgbalfa

lgbalfa

Professional
What's the latest on him?

Nothing to report on with tennisrecruiting.com

Is he even a legitimate high level D1 player?

Thanks
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Tchocky
5 Year Old Tennis Prodigy
2 3
Replies
132
Views
9K
johnathan smith
J
B
Can anyone stop Nadal?-Article
Replies
32
Views
2K
bolo
B
JohnnyMac Fan!
Nadal to Reporters: "I need something else, will try to find (it)"
2
Replies
65
Views
4K
sredna42
sredna42
C
Long Lost Hero
Replies
16
Views
1K
kiki
kiki
T
Just spotted Jan Silva in the crowd
Replies
13
Views
2K
TennisandMusic
T
Top