I have not tried any of them. I am sure they would fit my narrow feet, however, as I just pointed out, I have another problem. On clay I am like Bambi on ice: I easily slip away. I need the best profile I can get, something like that Asics profile.
I am no expert on clay shoes, so in my humble opinion, you would be best to get one of the shoes specifically made "for clay", like the Babolat Team Clay or Adidas CC Feather. They have unique tread patterns made for exactly that: improved grip on clay. If you notice the CC's have a unique tread, with all the little pointed "spike-like" nubs. I rarely rarely play on clay, but did so a few times this past summer (har-tru), and felt more confident/sure-footed using the CC's on clay as compared to my herringbone hard-court shoes. The Babolat Clay shoe uses a michelin compound outsole which is also very 'grippy'. The Asics look good too, as many players use herringbone on clay as well, so these could all be great options.
Hopefully someone with more clay experience can sort this out, as I play on har-tru only 2-3x a year, but that's my 2 cents.
