Mind Boggling Stat : From 05 till 14 RG - in BO5 Nadal was 11-3 vs Federer and 10-3 vs Djokovic, a total of 21-6 in H2H vs them...

and what about Nadal bringing down Federer? Lets give some credit to Nadal too? Why only credit to Djokovic for battling others? Nadal beat Fed at W08 and AO09, those had a big role in ruining Federer's mental peace, trust me.
I just matter of fact mentioned some real data! I forgot to mention every single fact under the sun!
 
23-13 slams margin is not the right comparison, 2020-23 cannot be clubbed with 2011-19 because Federer stopped being a factor after 2019. So 2020-23 can be the era where Novak has full control of Tennis, even Nadal is not a big factor in this, not before.

2010-19 they win 15 slams and 13 slams respectively
After Fed played his last GS Final, Nadal also was on fumes, Djokovic won like 8 slams in that period when Rafa won 3, that is Novak's equivalent of Federer's 04-07,

04-07 ---> Federer 11 slams, Nadal 3 slams, Safin 1 slam, Gaudio 1 slam ---> Federer's era
08-19 ---> Nadal 16 Slams, Djokovic 16 Slams, Federer 8 Slams ----> Big 3 era
20-23 ---> Djokovic 8 slams, Nadal 3 slams, Med 1, Thiem 1, Alcaraz 1 ----> Djokovic's era where he covered gap and became slams leader

I see it like this, Nadal not having his era is fine, eras are actually very weak periods, even @Hitman agreed that 08-19 was big 3 phase, seems reasonable to me.

I don't see any issues with 08-19 being considered the big 3 phase.
 
HAHAHA! In '22, Nadal saw an opportunity to capture 3 slams, except he captured a career-ending injury instead!

I beg your pardon, the same field showed in all slams in '21-23, except the best player was disqualified from two slams in '22!

What are you even trying to accomplish here? Everyone else is having a perfectly reasonable discussion and you’re out here dropping the IQ level into room temperature zones.
 
Correct. But only one of them had reached their peak for the first time by 2008 and it definitely was not Novak. You have seen the MWP I showed you to categorically prove the vast improvement from 08-10 to 11-16 for Novak. And you’ve seen Rafa was very consistent 08-14 with one exception in 13.

And from 11-22, (I’ll even take 23 off because Rafa wasn’t a force in majors again after 22) Novak won 20 majors to Rafa’s 13 which is still J-Mac’s career of majors ahead.

Fed no longer being in the picture was actually a much bigger issue for Rafa at that stage. Novak didn’t lose to Fed in a major after 2012. Whilst Rafa lost to Fed in majors in 2017 and 2019. Furthermore Rafa won 2 majors as late as 2022, so the fact he didn’t win more majors from 20-22 is only on Rafa and nobody else. Losing to Novak on his favourite court in 21 cost him big time.


No it’s not in bad faith at all. Rafa won 2 majors in 22. I even took 2023 off and that still leaves a huge 7 major gap from 11-22 from Novak to Rafa.

Man, Rafa winning 2 majors in 22 was pure vulture behavior, he was a shadow of himself. At that point he was like 9 years post prime and his movement was severely hampered relative to his peak/prime. If there hadn’t been a 14 year long vacuum of tier 1-3 great talent, none of the big 3 would have accumulated the resumes they did post 16, let alone what Nadal and especially Djokovic accumulated post 2019. And it’s ok, life is life, it happened like it happened, but there’s not much of interest to glean from a big 3 vs big 3 perspective from that except that Djokovic had the latest starting peak and the best health at that stage.
 
What are you even trying to accomplish here? Everyone else is having a perfectly reasonable discussion and you’re out here dropping the IQ level into room temperature zones.
Get the hell out of here! What I said was certified true!

Federer won 13 slams that were easy, while Djokovic won 6 slams that were easy! You could see the fact that Federer defeated Rodenwitt 22 times, while Djokovic defeated Zedmedpas 11 times!
 
Man, Rafa winning 2 majors in 22 was pure vulture behavior, he was a shadow of himself. At that point he was like 9 years post prime and his movement was severely hampered relative to his peak/prime.
The problem with using this vulture theory is you can actually apply it to the vast majority of Rafa slams if your only basis for argument is Big 3 peak levels:

(In brackets are MWP excluding big 3 matches)

2005-2006: Djokovic not even a factor
2007-2010: Djokovic significantly below peak form (2007-2010 84%) (2011-2016 92%)
2010: IW-USO Federer significantly below 2004-2007 peak form (2004-2007 95%) (2010 IW-USO 81%)
2013: Federer had worst season of his major winning period (72.6%)
2017: Djokovic has worst season of his major winning period (2011-2016 92% 2017 80%)
2020-2022: No Federer to contend with
2022: Djokovic can’t compete in Australia

I’d count that as least 16/22 of Rafa’s majors where there was a level of “vulturing” going on in regards to either or both Roger and Novak being very significantly below their peak level.

Now I personally choose to credit the players for winning majors when they were not at their peak, but if you are going to apply a vulturing logic, you should apply it consistently with the same fairness to all 3 players, else it’s tainted by bias.

If there hadn’t been a 14 year long vacuum of tier 1-3 great talent, none of the big 3 would have accumulated the resumes they did post 16,
Impossible to say who wins what and how many they win though as is always the case with hypotheticals. Djokovic kept Sinner and Alcaraz at bay in terms of still being dominant until 2024. Djokovic was capable of beating very good versions of Fed and peak Nadal repeatedly so realistically, it’s impossible to estimate the slam impact of any new mythical elite player.

And in regards to the Djokovic v Nadal competition specifically it makes zero difference in terms of a biological advantage as they are a less than a year apart.

let alone what Nadal and especially Djokovic accumulated post 2019. And it’s ok, life is life, it happened like it happened, but there’s not much of interest to glean from a big 3 vs big 3 perspective from that except that Djokovic had the latest starting peak and the best health at that stage.
I refer you back to my original answer regarding health and form. Ultimately, my response would be that Rafa was just as effective as he was from 17-22 in majors than he was at any point in his career.

17-22 Slam MWP - 90.2%
Peak 08-14 Slam MWP - 90.9%
 
I just matter of fact mentioned some real data! I forgot to mention every single fact under the sun!
Nadal had his share of patsies on RG.

Since you like mentioning facts, the patsies on clay that you are mentioning as probably Djokovic and Federer themselves, they were so useless vs prime Nadal at RG. Novak had to beat up some bad versions of Nadal at RG in 15 and 21 to collect some weak wins and Fed could not even do that.
 
Since you like mentioning facts, the patsies on clay that you are mentioning as probably Djokovic and Federer themselves, they were so useless vs prime Nadal at RG. Novak had to beat up some bad versions of Nadal at RG in 15 and 21 to collect some weak wins and Fed could not even do that.
Yeh, after '11, Djokovic was only 2-5 on RG! Should have been 3-4!

Don't give me that! Did you know that Nadal had the first break in the fourth set of '21 RG? Nadal was all gung-ho on evening the match!

Several months ago, it was all Federer vs Djokovic! Fedfans finally accepted Federer's fate! Now, it's all Nadal vs Djokovic! Rafans will accept Nadal's fate!
 
Last edited:
Since you like mentioning facts, the patsies on clay that you are mentioning as probably Djokovic and Federer themselves, they were so useless vs prime Nadal at RG. Novak had to beat up some bad versions of Nadal at RG in 15 and 21 to collect some weak wins and Fed could not even do that.
This actually ties into another valid point. Rafa fans constantly want to down play versions of Rafa whenever he lost but at the same time constantly want to over state versions of Novak whenever Novak was beaten by Rafa:-

Rafa on Clay (excluding Novak) in 2021:-
19-1 (95%)
Rafa on Clay (excluding Novak 2008-2014:-
174-7 (96%)

Novak on Hard (excluding Rafa) in 2010:-
43-10 (81%)
Novak on Hard (excluding Rafa) 2011-2016
284-30 (90%)


Although this is obviously not an exact science and there are caveats, it is a general indication that surface for surface, Novak was much further away from his peak effectiveness on hard courts in their 2010 US Open meeting, than Nadal was from his peak clay court effectiveness in their RG 2021 meeting.

But very few Nadal fans (if any) are ever willing to acknowledge this.
 
This actually ties into another valid point. Rafa fans constantly want to down play versions of Rafa whenever he lost but at the same time constantly want to over state versions of Novak whenever Novak was beaten by Rafa:-

Rafa on Clay (excluding Novak) in 2021:-
19-1 (95%)
Rafa on Clay (excluding Novak 2008-2014:-
174-7 (96%)

Novak on Hard (excluding Rafa) in 2010:-
43-10 (81%)
Novak on Hard (excluding Rafa) 2011-2016
284-30 (90%)


Although this is obviously not an exact science and there are caveats, it is a general indication that surface for surface, Novak was much further away from his peak effectiveness on hard courts in their 2010 US Open meeting, than Nadal was from his peak clay court effectiveness in their RG 2021 meeting.

But very few Nadal fans (if any) are ever willing to acknowledge this.
You mean that Nadal fans don't do paralysis through analysis like you do?
 
You mean that Nadal fans don't do paralysis through analysis like you do?
No, I just mean, it’s always about what Rafa did or how he peak he was, or how uninjured he was and never ever any credit to the opponent for just being a better player. You could be the first to break that trend if you so wish, I dare you.
 
No, I just mean, it’s always about what Rafa did or how he peak he was, or how uninjured he was and never ever any credit to the opponent for just being a better player. You could be the first to break that trend if you so wish, I dare you.
Eh? A match is a match. Nadal remains the best big match player in 21st century tennis.
 
Thanks for proving my point.
The truth being my point. It doesn't matter if a player is 100%, 90%, 50%, if they play the match. If you start the match, you are fit to play on that day, and the result is the result. It doesn't "take away" from anything if someone is injured.
 
The truth being my point. It doesn't matter if a player is 100%, 90%, 50%, if they play the match. If you start the match, you are fit to play on that day, and the result is the result. It doesn't "take away" from anything if someone is injured.
Well I’ll certainly give you credit for that, you’re the first Rafa fan I’ve heard say that.
 
Oh my bad, my grammar is as good as Nadal's hard-court record against Novak since 2013.

Since 2013 ? Then your Grammar should be good because in 2013 Nadal spanked Nole on Arthur Ashe and sent him to school (Becker School)...

So it should be since 2014, not since 2013 because 2013 is very significant...
 
Since 2013 ? Then your Grammar should be good because in 2013 Nadal spanked Nole on Arthur Ashe and sent him to school (Becker School)...

So it should be since 2014, not since 2013 because 2013 is very significant...
What he’s saying is it isn’t a thing to get hung up on because the main point is that Nadal went a long, long time without being anything remotely resembling a threat to Novak on HCs. Now, granted the record is slightly skewed by no 2017-2018 meetings but even after you account for that it’s still quite unimpressive as Djokovic wasn’t at his absolute best in a lot of those matches.
 
What he’s saying is it isn’t a thing to get hung up on because the main point is that Nadal went a long, long time without being anything remotely resembling a threat to Novak on HCs. Now, granted the record is slightly skewed by no 2017-2018 meetings but even after you account for that it’s still quite unimpressive as Djokovic wasn’t at his absolute best in a lot of those matches.

But why does Nadal have to be great on HCs too?

If Nadal is a great on HCs then there won't be any debate, he would be like 26-27 slams already, the reason we even debate is because Nadal on other surfaces is a bit short...

Nadal's greatness has always been connected to clay and a little bit outside it, he built his legacy around it and it is an eternal one, all these HC records and Grass records will be broken by kids in the future but nobody is touching clay

Versatility is highly overrated.
 
@Third Serve - I think Nadal has the best quality CGS if we pick 4 slams each from Big 3 and see cumulatively?

Nadal - 2009 Aus Open, 2008 French Open, 2008 Wimbledon, 2010 US Open
Federer - 2007 Aus Open, 2009 French Open, 2005 Wimbledon, 2004 US Open
Djoko - 2011 Aus Open, 2021 French Open, 2015 Wimbledon, 2011 US Open

So Nadal has been more versatile at the highest level before injuries took its toll ?

No wonder he had 21-6 record in BO5 vs Fed and Djoko combined in 2005-2014.
 
But why does Nadal have to be great on HCs too?

If Nadal is a great on HCs then there won't be any debate, he would be like 26-27 slams already, the reason we even debate is because Nadal on other surfaces is a bit short...

Nadal's greatness has always been connected to clay and a little bit outside it, he built his legacy around it and it is an eternal one, all these HC records and Grass records will be broken by kids in the future but nobody is touching clay

Versatility is highly overrated.
Well, given that Djokovic was far more of a threat to Nadal on clay than Nadal was to Djokovic on HCs during the same period it is undeniably a mark against Nadal. Sure, H2Hs can be a bit misleading but I think we have a big enough sample size here to make a pretty good conclusion.
 
But why does Nadal have to be great on HCs too?
He was great on hard court at times. Just not consistent enough given it’s by far the most prevalent surface they play on. This is why he couldn’t dominate the tour, the highest YE ranking points he got were in 2013 and that is due to his best ever year on the HC.
If Nadal is a great on HCs then there won't be any debate, he would be like 26-27 slams already, the reason we even debate is because Nadal on other surfaces is a bit short...
if Djokovic was good as Nadal on clay then he might have finished on 30-35 slams. But he wasn’t. And Nadal wasn’t as good on hard.
Versatility is highly overrated.
In your opinion. But, then you seem to always change your mind on that. Because you make threads about older players being more versatile compared to the big 3. And then you also repeatedly point out that homogenisation made it easier for the Big 3 compared to the 90’s. Well if versatility doesn’t matter to you, then homogenisation shouldn’t be an issue for you either.
 
if Djokovic was good as Nadal on clay then he might have finished on 30-35 slams. But he wasn’t. And Nadal wasn’t as good on hard.

Djokovic is lucky to even be in the conversation because there are 2 slams on HCs and also because there were no younger ATGs born until 14 years after him. If there was somebody born in 1994/1995 who was a great player then it would have been impossible for Djokovic to cross 15-16 slams, unlike him Nadal was less dependent on all this because he was already on something like 14 slams at age 28...

If the AO was on clay then what number of slams would Djokovic be on today? On 15-16 slams? What would Nadal be on? 30 slams?
 
Djokovic is lucky to even be in the conversation because there are 2 slams on HCs and also because there were no younger ATGs born until 14 years after him.
Again this is just a fallacy. There is zero luck involved. It’s such a lazy line to roll out. There have been 2 HC majors since 1988. The big 3 were children and barely born. They all knew which the most prevalent surface was for slams and big titles.

If any one was going to be classed as lucky, it would be Rafa for not having 3 grass and 1 clay like it used to be. But in reality none of the big 3 were lucky or unlucky.

If there was somebody born in 1994/1995 who was a great player then it would have been impossible for Djokovic to cross 15-16 slams, unlike him Nadal was less dependent on all this because he was already on something like 14 slams at age 28...
These types hypotheticals don’t actually mean anything when debating their achievements.. They don’t carry any weight because anyone can pick an opposite hypothetical. Let’s say Djokovic is born 4 years earlier, than maybe Rafa wins nothing outside of Clay and maybe even Rafa wins less at RG. Either way as another hypothetical, it has no significance.
If the AO was on clay then where would Djokovic be today? On 15-16 slams?
If Roland Garros was on indoor hard, then where would Rafa be? 8 slams? This is why these types of hypotheticals have no value.
 
Again this is just a fallacy. There is zero luck involved. It’s such a lazy line to roll out. There have been 2 HC majors since 1988. The big 3 were children and barely born. They all knew which the most prevalent surface was for slams and big titles.

If any one was going to be classed as lucky, it would be Rafa for not having 3 grass and 1 clay like it used to be. But in reality none of the big 3 were lucky or unlucky.


These types hypotheticals don’t actually mean anything when debating their achievements.. They don’t carry any weight because anyone can pick an opposite hypothetical. Let’s say Djokovic is born 4 years earlier, than maybe Rafa wins nothing outside of Clay and maybe even Rafa wins less at RG. Either way as another hypothetical, it has no significance.

If Roland Garros was on indoor hard, then where would Rafa be? 8 slams? This is why these types of hypotheticals have no value.

Roland Garros is not indoors for a good reason, clay can never be indoors ... the dust will make it hard for audience to breathe making it an environmental hazard... stop giving weird logics to defend Djokovic.

if Djokovic is born 4 years earlier then he would be at a physicality disadvantage to Nadal and also gets spanked more. Do you know why? The 2011 Djokovic had experience of playing Rafa and losing against him from 2006 till 2010, without those 4-5 years experience of how to handle Rafa he would never even have a 2011 season like success vs Nadal if you make him 4 years older

Get this : Djokovic and Federer were the slow learners and the guys who matured slowly physically, putting them older to Rafa by 3-4 years is only going to make it super hard for them since Rafa would mature earlier and cause problems. Nadal was a problem for everyone on tour given how unique he is.
 
Roland Garros is not indoors for a good reason, clay can never be indoors ... the dust will make it hard for audience to breathe making it an environmental hazard... stop giving weird logics to defend Djokovic.

if Djokovic is born 4 years earlier then he would be at a physicality disadvantage to Nadal and also gets spanked more. Do you know why? The 2011 Djokovic had experience of playing Rafa and losing against him from 2006 till 2010, without those 4-5 years experience of how to handle Rafa he would never even have a 2011 season like success vs Nadal if you make him 4 years older

Get this : Djokovic and Federer were the slow learners and the guys who matured slowly physically, putting them older to Rafa by 3-4 years is only going to make it super hard for them since Rafa would mature earlier and cause problems. Nadal was a problem for everyone on tour given how unique he is.
tennisgifs-tennis.gif⁠
tennisgifs-tennis.gif




bx4qj.gif
 
Roland Garros is not indoors for a good reason, clay can never be indoors ... the dust will make it hard for audience to breathe making it an environmental hazard... stop giving weird logics to defend Djokovic.
Lol, for actually taking that seriously. I’m not defending Djokovic at all, you’re missing the point. I’m not the one asking for AO to be turned to Clay. Nadal won an indoor title on clay by the way but that’s a moot point here. I don’t desire any of the majors to be changed, I was making the point that just as easily that one of the majors could have been changed to favour Nadal, then just as easily Roland Garros could have been changed to a different surface to really unfavour him with even more impact. Obviously this is extremely unlikely to happen but the principle still stands.

if Djokovic is born 4 years earlier then he would be at a physicality disadvantage to Nadal and also gets spanked more. Do you know why? The 2011 Djokovic had experience of playing Rafa and losing against him from 2006 till 2010, without those 4-5 years experience of how to handle Rafa he would never even have a 2011 season like success vs Nadal if you make him 4 years older
Again you’re continuing to deal in hypotheticals because you’re not content with the end outcome but worse than that, you are trying to pass off your prediction of a hypothetical as a fact. I could just no that wouldn’t happen and we’d be arguing about a something that’s never going to happen. It’s pointless.
Get this : Djokovic and Federer were the slow learners and the guys who matured slowly physically, putting them older to Rafa by 3-4 years is only going to make it super hard for them since Rafa would mature earlier and cause problems. Nadal was a problem for everyone on tour given how unique he is.
Rafa, despite his excellence on clay and general impressive record against Fed H-H wasn’t actually causing Federer’s slam lead to shrink until Fed went off the boil himself. When Rafa the quick learner won his first major at RG2005 he was 4-1 behind in slams. 5 years and 20 slams later, he was 16-7 behind in slams. He can thank Roger for dropping his form in 2010 so that Rafa could actually start closing the gap instead of it continuing to grow like it had been for 5 years after Rafa won his first.

2005 RG - Slam Lead 3
2006 RG - Slam Lead 5
2007 RG - Slam Lead 7
2008 RG - Slam Lead 8
2009 RG - Slam Lead 8
2010 RG - Slam Lead 9
 
Rafa, despite his excellence on clay and general impressive record against Fed H-H wasn’t actually causing Federer’s slam lead to shrink until Fed went off the boil himself. When Rafa the quick learner won his first major at RG2005 he was 4-1 behind in slams. 5 years and 20 slams later, he was 16-7 behind in slams. He can thank Roger for dropping his form in 2010 so that Rafa could actually start closing the gap instead of it continuing to grow like it had been for 5 years after Rafa won his first.

2005 RG - Slam Lead 3
2006 RG - Slam Lead 5
2007 RG - Slam Lead 7
2008 RG - Slam Lead 8
2009 RG - Slam Lead 8
2010 RG - Slam Lead 9

LOL @form in 2010 etc, Rafa reduced Federer to a crying beta in 2008-09 and kept him in his mental dungeons for a good decade .... Here is the fact... Federer was not masculine enough to handle Nadal, was slower in footspeed and was an inferior athlete even in his peak. No amount of gymnastics will change the fact that Federer is today 3rd in numbers, it is written in stone.

gq-features-090109-GQfeature24v.jpg
 
LOL @form in 2010 etc, Rafa reduced Federer to a crying beta in 2008-09 and kept him in his mental dungeons for a good decade
If you wish to think that’s what happened, then of course you can. Trying to make out a man isn’t a man just because he cries when he’s very upset is the stuff of a Neanderthal. Thinking you’re going to get an emotive reaction out of me by posting another picture of him crying is also foolish on your part.

Rafa beat Roger as early as 2004 on hard and in 2005 in a major. None of that stopped Roger piling on the majors and pulling further in the slam race.

Federer’s form lowered against none big 3 players after Australia 10 when he just won a major so clearly that was nothing to do with Rafa. Their H-H would only be a potential factor if he had to play Rafa again which it probably was in Australia 12 and 14. But form was a bigger factor. But 1 defeat on hard and 1 defeat on grass before Fed really dropped his form doesn’t mean anything conclusive at all about future meetings off Clay, if Fed played close to his best. Especially as even a none peak Roger continued to beat peak Rafa on hard in BO3 even after 09 Australia. And don’t forget Roger was able to routinely beat Rafa off clay after their Australia 14 meeting. And especially as peak Rafa still lost to Ferrer, Tsonga, Murrayx2, Del Potro, Darcis, Rosol, Wawrinka off Clay. Not to mention the 7 defeats in a row to Novak.

.... Here is the fact... Federer was not masculine enough to handle Nadal, was slower in footspeed and was an inferior athlete even in his peak. No amount of gymnastics will change the fact that Federer is today 3rd in numbers, it is written in stone.
lol, 3rd in the major and masters numbers but it depends which other numbers you’re talking about. He’s ahead of Rafa on plenty of numbers, and unlike Rafa, he had his own era for winning majors which Rafa played second fiddle to, and he was much better across his peak and career on 2/3 Bo5 surfaces and 3/4 Bo3 surfaces. Of course Rafa won more majors and more masters so obviously I can understand those that do place Rafa above Roger if that’s their reasoning.

You of all people, really shouldn’t be pointing at numbers though should you lol, when you rank Nadal above Djokovic which is simply unfathomable on the numbers, and then Sampras above Federer, which again on the numbers is just sheer lunacy. But then again, this is you, so we know logic and consistency are nowhere to be found.
 
If you wish to think that’s what happened, then of course you can. Trying to make out a man isn’t a man just because he cries when he’s very upset is the stuff of a Neanderthal. Thinking you’re going to get an emotive reaction out of me by posting another picture of him crying is also foolish on your part.

Rafa beat Roger as early as 2004 on hard and in 2005 in a major. None of that stopped Roger piling on the majors and pulling further in the slam race.

Federer’s form lowered against none big 3 players after Australia 10 when he just won a major so clearly that was nothing to do with Rafa. Their H-H would only be a potential factor if he had to play Rafa again which it probably was in Australia 12 and 14. But form was a bigger factor. But 1 defeat on hard and 1 defeat on grass before Fed really dropped his form doesn’t mean anything conclusive at all about future meetings off Clay, if Fed played close to his best. Especially as even a none peak Roger continued to beat peak Rafa on hard in BO3 even after 09 Australia. And don’t forget Roger was able to routinely beat Rafa off clay after their Australia 14 meeting. And especially as peak Rafa still lost to Ferrer, Tsonga, Murrayx2, Del Potro, Darcis, Rosol, Wawrinka off Clay. Not to mention the 7 defeats in a row to Novak.


lol, 3rd in the major and masters numbers but it depends which other numbers you’re talking about. He’s ahead of Rafa on plenty of numbers, and unlike Rafa, he had his own era for winning majors which Rafa played second fiddle to, and he was much better across his peak and career on 2/3 Bo5 surfaces and 3/4 Bo3 surfaces. Of course Rafa won more majors and more masters so obviously I can understand those that do place Rafa above Roger if that’s their reasoning.

You of all people, really shouldn’t be pointing at numbers though should you lol, when you rank Nadal above Djokovic which is simply unfathomable on the numbers, and then Sampras above Federer, which again on the numbers is just sheer lunacy. But then again, this is you, so we know logic and consistency are nowhere to be found.

Federer remains the 3rd wheel and a failure today when compared to his 2 more successful rivals, the joke is on you that you are defending him here by writing long essays, lol
 
Last edited:
Federer remains the 3rd wheel and a failure today
It’s so easy to get you to show your true colours lol and watch your bitterness shine through. Imagine calling someone with 20 slams and 6 more slams than a player you idolise and promote at every given opportunity a “failure”.
when compared to his 2 more successful rivals, the joke is on you that you are defending him here by writing long essays, lol
His record defends itself. As I’ve said before, I enjoy taking your ridiculous assertions about Federer and hypothetical nonsense about Nadal apart. And no doubt there’s plenty more of both to come ;)
 
It’s so easy to get you to show your true colours lol and watch your bitterness shine through. Imagine calling someone with 20 slams and 6 more slams than a player you idolise and promote at every given opportunity a “failure”.

His record defends itself. As I’ve said before, I enjoy taking your ridiculous assertions about Federer and hypothetical nonsense about Nadal apart. And no doubt there’s plenty more of both to come ;)

Federer is 3rd today and below Djokovic and Nadal in the hierarchy, there is no coming back from that. No matter how hard you try, this will remain forever written in stone. As far my true colors of being a Pete fan is concerned, don't worry, it is not very relevant here, we could put Pete at 4th and still Federer would remain 3rd of his own era while Pete was 1st of his era.
 
Federer is 3rd today and below Djokovic and Nadal in the hierarchy, there is no coming back from that. No matter how hard you try, this will remain forever written in stone. As far my true colors of being a Pete fan is concerned, don't worry, it is not very relevant here, we could put Pete at 4th and still Federer would remain 3rd of his own era while Pete was 1st of his era.
Federer fans in the past used the same metric as Djokovic fans use today. Federer fans now have to focus on his beautiful game or peak level, or the age factor, because Djokovic took so many records.

Nadal fans had slightly different metrics, and throughout Nadal's career. Those metrics still stand up in a lot of ways, like big match record, head-to-heads (including in the majors), some longevity records on top as well.
 
Federer is 3rd today and below Djokovic and Nadal in the hierarchy, there is no coming back from that. No matter how hard you try, this will remain forever written in stone.
There is nothing written in stone as you well know otherwise nobody would be having the debates that everyone has on here. If people want to place Djokovic and Nadal above Federer, there are statistical reasons to do so. But there are also plenty of reasons to place Federer above Nadal which is why many still do.

As far my true colors of being a Pete fan is concerned, don't worry, it is not very relevant here, we could put Pete at 4th and still Federer would remain 3rd of his own era while Pete was 1st of his era.
I wasn’t showing your true colours about being a Pete fan. Everyone can see your bitterness, your true colours are statements like, Federer being bad on clay and his whole career being a failure lol.
 
But there are also plenty of reasons to place Federer above Nadal which is why many still do.

I wasn’t showing your true colours about being a Pete fan. Everyone can see your bitterness, your true colours are statements like, Federer being bad on clay and his whole career being a failure lol.

What plenty of reasons? He is overall a worse player by numbers, his 237 weeks at 1 made in a vacuum, of his 8 wimbledons while having a 0-3 h2h in finals in the same venue vs Djokovic, streaks scored in a vacuum are not going to be rated more important than he having a lesser slam count and losing h2h vs his rivals, these things will stick out no matter who sees it. Federer is 3rd for eternity.

Federer fans in the past used the same metric as Djokovic fans use today. Federer fans now have to focus on his beautiful game or peak level, or the age factor, because Djokovic took so many records.

Nadal fans had slightly different metrics, and throughout Nadal's career. Those metrics still stand up in a lot of ways, like big match record, head-to-heads (including in the majors), some longevity records on top as well.

The only area where Federer is ahead of Djokovic and Nadal today is Money, popularity and clout on the tour, that certainly holds well but in a pure tennis discussion he trails to Djokovic and Nadal. You are right, in the past Fed fans had numbers as the metric but that metric was surpassed by both Djokovic and Nadal, so it has become other factors.
 
Last edited:
Federer fans in the past used the same metric as Djokovic fans use today. Federer fans now have to focus on his beautiful game or peak level, or the age factor, because Djokovic took so many records.
I still use the same metrics which is I now rate Djokovic as number 1.

Fed’s aesthetic beauty has zero relevance to a fair assessment his achievements.

Nadal fans had slightly different metrics, and throughout Nadal's career. Those metrics still stand up in a lot of ways, like big match record, head-to-heads (including in the majors), some longevity records on top as well.
This may be true for you, but it’s not true for Nadal fans in general. I’ve been on a few different forums to this one, and when Nadal was leading the slam race, that is pretty much all they crowed about which was understandable at the time. A lot of cockiness followed (no doubt like with some Fed fans of the past) and a lot of them thought it was a done deal after RG22 with COVID restrictions still possible for Novak in the future. For me personally, even if Nadal had finished above Djokovic in the slam race by a couple of slams, I’d still have him behind anyway for tour dominance and achievements on multiple surfaces factors.
 
For me personally, even if Nadal had finished above Djokovic in the slam race by a couple of slams, I’d still have him behind anyway for tour dominance and achievements on multiple surfaces factors.

If that is for you personally then why you are worried about who is rating Nadal ahead? I see you have a problem with Nadal fans rating him ahead based on slams h2h or clay dominance etc, why? Too hard to bother your own business and let others believe what they want?
 
Eh? A match is a match. Nadal remains the best big match player in 21st century tennis.
Except when he met Djokovic! Then he became timid!

LOL @form in 2010 etc, Rafa reduced Federer to a crying beta in 2008-09 and kept him in his mental dungeons for a good decade .... Here is the fact... Federer was not masculine enough to handle Nadal, was slower in footspeed and was an inferior athlete even in his peak. No amount of gymnastics will change the fact that Federer is today 3rd in numbers, it is written in stone.

gq-features-090109-GQfeature24v.jpg
A picture is worth a thousand words!

Fedfans used to say that Federer was a mismatch when it came down to Nadal. They should say the same thing when it came down to Djokovic, instead of blaming the whole thing on age.
 
What plenty of reasons? He is overall a worse player by numbers, his 237 weeks at 1 made in a vacuum, of his 8 wimbledons while having a 0-3 h2h in finals in the same venue vs Djokovic,
I love your style of asking me a question and then trying to answer yourself with your own opinion lol.

I rank Fed behind Djokovic and ahead of Nadal. And that’s because Fed had his own era of tour dominance that Nadal ever had and then his period of slam dominance was whilst Nadal was his world number 2 for the vast majority of 5 years. His own form dropped off after 10. But it still recovered enough less consistently again to be the dominant player on hard and grass again from 14 onwards were it not solely for Djokovic.

In terms of the metrics and reasons, you asked about for why he’s ahead of Nadal imo, that you asked for:-

-A 4 period Of Tour Dominance and a 6 year period of slam dominance. Nadal never had 2 consecutive seasons where he was the best player on tour.

-2 more years of career time in total as world number 1 and peak of tour dominance for 4 years where he stayed as number 1 for 100% of the time. Nadal never stayed world number 1 for more than 13 months.

-He leads Nadal at 3 out of the 4 majors for majors won and at Wimbledon and Australia they are by a ratio of 3:1 or greater.

-He defended a title at 3 different venues, 2 times in Australia, 4 times at Wimbledon, 4 times at the US. Nadal only defended a slam at RG.

-He has a better match win rate on 3 out of 4 tour surfaces including by far the most prevalent one and that includes career and and peaks.

Career

Outdoor Hard 83.6 - 81.8
Clay 76.1-90.5
Indoor Hard 85.1 - 68.6
Grass 86.9 - 79.2

-His peak was substantially better than Nadal’s and almost twice as dominant as Nadal in respect of being the worlds best player.

Federer W03 to AO10 v Nadal RG08 to RG14
Majors: 16 v 11
ATP Finals: 4 v 0
Masters+Olympics: 17 v 22
Time % as World Number 1: 78%-48%
Match Win% In Majors Overall: 94%-91%
And by slam:
Australia: 94.1 - 86.7
RG: 86.7 - 97.1
Wim: 96.2 - 83.3
US: 97.1 - 88.9

-Federer didn’t play second fiddle to anyone during his peak. Nadal played second fiddle in majors to Federer from W03 to AO10 and then to Djokovic from AO11 until he retired. And in his peak from RG08 to RG14, Federer was better than Nadal in 2009 Djokovic was better than Nadal from AO11 to RG14 which is 57% of Nadal’s peak alone, and that is why Nadal spent less than half the time of his own peak as world number 1.

streaks scored in a vacuum are not going to be rated more important than he having a lesser slam count and losing h2h vs his rivals, these things will stick out no matter who sees it. Federer is 3rd for eternity.
You don’t speak for everyone just as I don’t. As you’ve seen on here, plenty of people have Fed (none Fed fans) rated higher than Nadal and it’s for the many reasons I’ve listed above.

The only area where Federer is ahead of Djokovic and Nadal today is Money, popularity and clout on the tour, that certainly holds well but in a pure tennis discussion he trails to Djokovic and Nadal.
It’s clearly not the only area Federer is ahead of Nadal, there’s plenty of them as I’ve very explicitly demonstrated. But as you are a casua fan who in your own words “only watches the second week of majors” you wouldn’t have the ability to comprehend this.
 
If that is for you personally then why you are worried about who is rating Nadal ahead? I see you have a problem with Nadal fans rating him ahead based on slams h2h or clay dominance etc, why? Too hard to bother your own business and let others believe what they want?
It’s called a debate, which is exactly what everyone does on here every day.
 
I love your style of asking me a question and then trying to answer yourself with your own opinion lol.

I rank Fed behind Djokovic and ahead of Nadal. And that’s because Fed had his own era of tour dominance that Nadal ever had and then his period of slam dominance was whilst Nadal was his world number 2 for the vast majority of 5 years. His own form dropped off after 10. But it still recovered enough less consistently again to be the dominant player on hard and grass again from 14 onwards were it not solely for Djokovic.

In terms of the metrics and reasons, you asked about for why he’s ahead of Nadal imo, that you asked for:-

-A 4 period Of Tour Dominance and a 6 year period of slam dominance. Nadal never had 2 consecutive seasons where he was the best player on tour.

-2 more years of career time in total as world number 1 and peak of tour dominance for 4 years where he stayed as number 1 for 100% of the time. Nadal never stayed world number 1 for more than 13 months.

-He leads Nadal at 3 out of the 4 majors for majors won and at Wimbledon and Australia they are by a ratio of 3:1 or greater.

-He defended a title at 3 different venues, 2 times in Australia, 4 times at Wimbledon, 4 times at the US. Nadal only defended a slam at RG.

-He has a better match win rate on 3 out of 4 tour surfaces including by far the most prevalent one and that includes career and and peaks.

Career

Outdoor Hard 83.6 - 81.8
Clay 76.1-90.5
Indoor Hard 85.1 - 68.6
Grass 86.9 - 79.2

-His peak was substantially better than Nadal’s.

Federer W03 to AO10 v Nadal RG08 to RG14
Majors: 16 v 11
ATP Finals: 4 v 0
Masters+Olympics: 17 v 22
Time % as World Number 1: 78%-48%
Match Win% In Majors Overall: 94%-91%
And by slam:
Australia: 94.1 - 86.7
RG: 86.7 - 97.1
Wim: 96.2 - 83.3
US: 97.1 - 88.9

-Federer didn’t play second fiddle to anyone during his peak. Nadal played second fiddle in majors to Federer from W03 to AO10 and then to Djokovic from AO11 until he retired. And in his peak from RG08 to RG14, Federer was better than Nadal in 2009 Djokovic was better than Nadal from AO11 to RG14 which is 57% of Nadal’s peak alone, and that is why Nadal spent less than half the time of his own peak as world number 1.


You don’t speak for everyone just as I don’t. As you’ve seen on here, plenty of people have Fed (none Fed fans) rated higher than Nadal and it’s for the many reasons I’ve listed above.


It’s clearly not the only area Federer is ahead of Nadal, there’s plenty of them as I’ve very explicitly demonstrated. But as you are a casua fan who in your own words “only watches the second week of majors” you wouldn’t have the ability to comprehend this.

Federer's peak was a vacuum, thats why 237 weeks could happen. The sweet spot of 01-07 was created because no ATG between Sampras and Rafael's DOB was born. Hewitt and some non ATGs were swapping rank 1 spots like a game of muscial chairs in 00-03 before Federer took it to control it and still vacuum was there until the second ATG hit his peak in 2008 i.e Nadal.

Obviously Nadal cannot have 237 weeks because his peak years have actual competition unlike Federer's.

Nadal and Djokovic actually fought against each in the actual competitive era for rank 1 positions and thats why they both have 5 year end 1s in 2008-2019, your agenda to show Nadal as a man who could not compete for rank 1s fails because 08-19 is the actual Big 3 era where Nadal is par with Djokovic in YE1.

2020-2023 is where Djokovic added 3 more YE1 in a phase without Federer and with a more declined Nadal, an actual vacuum where there are no Murrays or Stans, just Medvedevs and Zverevs and T-pas along with Kyrgios, Berretini etc...

So in the actual good era i.e the Big 3 era Nadal was toe to toe with Djokovic at 5 YE1 each and in the strong era of 08-13 it was Nadal who shined brighter than everyone

Does it finally register why Nadal was such a big player and not limited to clay ? 5 year end 1s dont come in a phase where your own heroes could not do any better despite being more versatile.
 
Except when he met Djokovic! Then he became timid!


A picture is worth a thousand words!

Fedfans used to say that Federer was a mismatch when it came down to Nadal. They should say the same thing when it came down to Djokovic, instead of blaming the whole thing on age.

Sonny I agree with you about the picture telling a 1000 words, but you must also agree that Fed and Nadal matchup was indeed a matchup mismatch for Federer but not in the case of Djokovic-Federer, their H2H was pretty even and their matchup progressed as it should have with the older guy having an edge for some years with the younger guy gaining edge later.

Federer could have converted a few of those defeats to wins if he was more courageous and clutch, that is true... but still the matchup was somewhat even.
 
Federer's peak was a vacuum, thats why 237 weeks could happen. The sweet spot of 01-07 was created because no ATG between Sampras and Rafael's DOB was born. Hewitt and some non ATGs were swapping rank 1 spots like a game of muscial chairs in 00-03 before Federer took it to control it and still vacuum was there until the second ATG hit his peak in 2008 i.e Nadal.
You asked for the metrics and reasons, and I gave you them. If you want to just point blank ignore them, that’s on you. Rafa won a major at 19, he was world number 2 for the best part of 5 years to Federer. They are the facts. And if you want further proof that subsequent events were a lot less down to Nadal becoming a lot better, and more due to Fed worsening, Nadal was very soon back to being number 2 for the vast majority of the next 12 years from 2011 onwards once Djokovic reached a similar level to Fed on hard and grass.

Obviously Nadal cannot have 237 weeks because his peak years have actual competition unlike Federer's.
He was the competition to Federer as his number 2 for the bulk of W03 to AO10 when Federer won 16 majors to Nadal 6. And 12 majors to 5 from after RG05 to AO10.

Nadal and Djokovic actually fought against each in the actual competitive era for rank 1 positions and thats why they both have 5 year end 1s in 2008-2019, your agenda to show Nadal as a man who could not compete for rank 1s fails because 08-19 is the actual Big 3 era where Nadal is par with Djokovic in YE1.
No that’s not actually accurate. Nadal was trying to fight with Federer from 2005-2010. In that period Federe has 4 YE1 and Nadal had 2 YE1. In that period, Nadal finished YE2 4 times. And Fed finished YE2 2 times. That’s bombproof evidence they were fighting each other for YE1 in that period.

From 11 onwards Nadal was fighting with Djokovic until 22. In that period Djokovic had 8YE1 and Nadal had 3 YE1. Again further proof, Nadal’s career was mainly playing second fiddle to the slam and tour dominance of either Federer or Djokovic.

2020-2023 is where Djokovic added 3 more YE1 in a phase without Federer and with a more declined Nadal, an actual vacuum where there are no Murrays or Stans, just Medvedevs and Zverevs and T-pas along with Kyrgios, Berretini etc...
Nadal won 3 majors in 2020-2022. And 2 as late as 2022 which is the joint second best tally of his career. He gets no passes for not being able to add as many as Djokovic. Don’t forget he added 9 majors to 1 before Djokovic hit his peak. There is less than a year between them. Nadal was a much better player than Djokovic as 19-22 year olds. Djokovic was then better player after that age for age with less of a gap back to Nadal but over a much longer period.

So in the actual good era i.e the Big 3 era Nadal was toe to toe with Djokovic at 5 YE1 each and in the strong era of 08-13 it was Nadal who shined brighter than everyone
All the metrics point to Djokovic not reaching his prime until 2011. In fact 2010 was Djokovic worst season since 2007. And 2010 overall was a very weak season of Federer and Djokovic combined compared to pretty much any other year from 2007 to 2019. 1 major final between them is the lowest they reached in that entire period, with them both also having their lowest MWP from 2007-2012.
Does it finally register why Nadal was such a big player and not limited to clay ? 5 year end 1s dont come in a phase where your own heroes could not do any better despite being more versatile.
I have never stated he’s limited to Clay. It’s actually you who often suggests this by repeatedly claiming versatility is overrated. I always commend Rafa for his achievements off Clay in terms of majors won. It’s just unfortunate for him. that there were two players in his era who far better than him on the other three surfaces, both across their careers and in all their respective peaks.
 
You asked for the metrics and reasons, and I gave you them. If you want to just point blank ignore them, that’s on you. Rafa won a major at 19, he was world number 2 for the best part of 5 years to Federer. They are the facts. And if you want further proof that subsequent events were a lot less down to Nadal becoming a lot better, and more due to Fed worsening, Nadal was very soon back to being number 2 for the vast majority of the next 12 years from 2011 onwards once Djokovic reached a similar level to Fed on hard and grass.


He was the competition to Federer as his number 2 for the bulk of W03 to AO10 when Federer won 16 majors to Nadal 6. And 12 majors to 5 from after RG05 to AO10.


No that’s not actually accurate. Nadal was trying to fight with Federer from 2005-2010. In that period Federe has 4 YE1 and Nadal had 2 YE1. In that period, Nadal finished YE2 4 times. And Fed finished YE2 2 times. That’s bombproof evidence they were fighting each other for YE1 in that period.

From 11 onwards Nadal was fighting with Djokovic until 22. In that period Djokovic had 8YE1 and Nadal had 3 YE1. Again further proof, Nadal’s career was mainly playing second fiddle to the slam and tour dominance of either Federer or Djokovic.


Nadal won 3 majors in 2020-2022. And 2 as late as 2022 which is the joint second best tally of his career. He gets no passes for not being able to add as many as Djokovic. Don’t forget he added 9 majors to 1 before Djokovic hit his peak. There is less than a year between them. Nadal was a much better player than Djokovic as 19-22 year olds. Djokovic was then better player after that age for age with less of a gap back to Nadal but over a much longer period.


All the metrics point to Djokovic not reaching his prime until 2011. In fact 2010 was Djokovic worst season since 2007. And 2010 overall was a very weak season of Federer and Djokovic combined compared to pretty much any other year from 2007 to 2019. 1 major final between them is the lowest they reached in that entire period, with them both also having their lowest MWP from 2007-2012.

I have never stated he’s limited to Clay. It’s actually you who often suggests this by repeatedly claiming versatility is overrated. I always commend Rafa for his achievements off Clay in terms of majors won. It’s just unfortunate for him. that there were two players in his era who far better than him on the other three surfaces, both across their careers and in all their respective peaks.

Rafa should not have been rank 2, a teenager like him and an old senior citizen (in tennis terms) like Agasi were forced to do the heavylifting by being Fedeer's best rival in 04-07 because others from Federer's age segment were not good enough. It is the vacuum which enabled Nadal to become rank 2 at 19, the same vacuum which gave Federer 237 weeks.
 
Rafa should not have been rank 2, a teenager like him and an old senior citizen (in tennis terms) like Agasi were forced to do the heavylifting by being Fedeer's best rival in 04-07 because others from Federer's age segment were not good enough. It is the vacuum which enabled Nadal to become rank 2 at 19, the same vacuum which gave Federer 237 weeks.
Lol, so vacuum exists for Federer for to be 237 weeks as number 1 but no vacuum existed on Clay for Nadal to win 14 majors in 18 seasons. Top class inconsistency and bias yet again. Just maybe both were just down to how good Federer was on hard and grass, and how good Nadal was on clay. Let’s not forget Nadal was 81 matches unbeaten on clay as an 18 to 20 year old. Which he never managed again albeit but purely for Djokovic, Nadal would have managed 61 unbeaten on clay between 2010 and 2012.

If you are good enough, you are old enough. Borg won a major at barely turned and 18 and by 21 was good enough to dominate the tour. But now I suppose you are going to say he was in a vaccuum as well lol.

Nadal was one of the best teenagers of the open era, trying to devalue how good he was to suit an agenda is fairly see through. Federer and Djokovic simply improved a lot more than Nadal did from 22-23 and both achieved significantly more than him as 23 to 30 year olds.

Federer 14 majors
Djokovic 11 majors
Nadal 8 majors
 
Sonny I agree with you about the picture telling a 1000 words, but you must also agree that Fed and Nadal matchup was indeed a matchup mismatch for Federer but not in the case of Djokovic-Federer, their H2H was pretty even and their matchup progressed as it should have with the older guy having an edge for some years with the younger guy gaining edge later.

Federer could have converted a few of those defeats to wins if he was more courageous and clutch, that is true... but still the matchup was somewhat even.
If Federer had his newly found BH from the beginning, then his match up with Nadal would be pretty much even!

If Federer had been courageous, then his match up with Djokovic would be even!
 
Back
Top