Federer was not masculine enough to handle Nadal's speed and forehand, his forehand was weak and he cried because deep down he was weak without control of his emotions too which is evident from him crying after wins, losses and everything. Now don't try to hide this by saying ohh that is neanderthal or cavemen talk, everyone knows that Federer lacked control of his emotions and his urge to cry profusely.
It is precisely that, Neanderthal and Caveman talk. Do you remember Nadal getting very emotional and crying when Federer was doing his farewell at the Laver Cup. Is he less of a man for doing that in your opinion?
The H-H was nothing to do masculinity. It’s a simple match up thing allied to Nadal being an incredible player concerning point by point focus. Federer struggled to handle Nadal’s FH into his high BH, and it was more of an issue on higher bouncing surfaces. We same ample evidence of that post 2014 when Federer was able to counter the same strategy with a more aggressive BH, that didn’t allow the points to develop in the same manner off the clay.
But if you wish to believe it was all about masculinity lol, then of course that is your prerogative.
Notice how his urge to cry reduced as he entered his 30s? Even now during Interviews one feels like he could start crying but the tendency is lesser than it was in his 20s when while speaking after a win his sound would tells us that he will cry now, with age he is learning to control his urges more but a tad too late.
I didn’t know you had lived with Federer for the last 20 years to give us such an insight into how often Fed cried in his 20’s and 30’s lol.
Do remember : Nadal took Federer's soul by beating him at Wimbledon 2008 and Aus Open 2009, a younger rival who is gaining ground on you taking these slams.... no wonder after Nadl returned from injury in 2010, Federer won only 1 slam (wimbledon 2012) in 7 long years.... whatever advantage he had of winning many slams in a vacuum was nullified in those 7 years when he won just 1.
LOL trying to rewrite history with your imagination and just ignoring the facts again.
Nadal took Federer soul after Wimbledon 2008 and Aus 09 did he?
So much so that Fed completed the career grand slam in his very next tournament.
So what happened from RG09 to AO10. You clearly haven’t remembered have you, so I’ll remind you that Nadal was present in 3 of those majors:-
RG09: Federer wins the title by beating Soderling who beat Nadal.
WO9:- Federer wins Wimbledon. Nadal doesn’t turn up and fails to defend a slam away from RG. Something he doesn’t manage across his entire career.
US09:- Del Potro wins it by beating Federer in a close 5 setter, after demolishing Nadal in straight sets in just over 2 hours.
AO10:- Federer wins Australia. Nadal is a set and 3-0 down to Murray before throwing the towel in a major match. Something Nadal does on multiple occasions in his career, and something the “non masculine” Federer never does in his career.
So immediately after “Nadal took Federer’s soul” in the next 4 majors:-
Federer completes the CGS and wins 3 out of the next 4 majors and makes all 4 finals.
Nadal wins 0 majors and is beaten by Soderling and demolished by Del Potro and is on the way a heavy defeat by Murray before he throws the towel in.
Full credit for Nadal for going on to win the next 3 majors in fine style and completing his own CGS, but quite clearly it was zero to do with Federer “losing his soul” after Wimbledon 08 and Australia 09. But we saw more evidence that Nadal hadn’t suddenly gone to a new unplayable level when Djokovic beat peak Nadal (who had just won 3 majors in a row for the only time in his career) 7 times in a row on all 3 surfaces from the start of the very next season. And became far better on hard and grass than Nadal, just like Fed had previously been.
Trying to rewrite history with your imagination won’t work with those who have the requisite knowledge of the facts.